Best Restaurants with Private Rooms in Shelter Island / San Diego Bay

My wife and I celebrate our 15th weeding anniversary they made it really special the food was great the service was great

Food is outstanding, service is great, has an authentic vibe to it. I have celiac disease they staff is very knowledgeable

We started out by sharing the calamari and crab cake. Both were out of this world delicious. The calamari were cooked to perfection. My husband ordered his usual rib eye steak with a side of mashed potatoes and I tried the Chilean bass with mushroom risotto. Let’s just say, I had to block his fork from my plate. He wanted to steal my food it was that good. His ribeye was perfect, but my fish was absolute heaven. Sara came over to the table to wish us a Happy Anniversary & send over a delicious limoncello slice of cake. She’s the sweetest! Our night couldn’t have gone any better!

Great food and friendly service across the street from the Hotel Del Coronado at a reasonable price compared to onsite.

What a great experience! The servers were very attentive, friendly and helpful. The place looks tiny from the outside, but once you go inside it is bigger than you think. The decor is very chic and beautiful, airy with a touch of romanticism. The food was amazing. Everything was fresh, flavorful and cooked spot-on. We ordered chips, salsa and guacamole. The red salsa is where its at. It had the perfect amount of light spice with a lot of flavor. I ordered the stuffed squash blossoms which were fried to perfection, stuffed with a great combo of flavors, sitting on a bed of refried beans. My friend ordered the machaca wagyu tostada which had the meat cooked two ways and layered for a burst of flavor in each bite.