Best Steakhouses in Fox Point

We were very happy with the overall experience at Five O’clock Steakhouse. The staff was very pleasant and provided great service. The ambiance was classic supper club with a fine dining feel. The only thing that prevented us from giving it 5 stars was due to lack of flavor in the steak. We got a porterhouse and a rib eye, both medium rare. They were cooked perfectly and were very tender with a beautiful char. So when we took our initial bites and were met with steak very obviously lacking in salt, it was disappointing. The gravy under the steak was fabulous. When I reheated my leftovers and added a generous sprinkle of salt, I finally felt all the flavors come together as they should. Given that this place is a steakhouse, I wish the steaks met that expectation we had because there’s very clearly so much potential there. The Thai buffalo shrimp and tiramisu were outstanding! I’d come back just for those items!

Hands down the best steakhouse in Milwaukee. The service was phenomenal and the food was just incredible. Will absolutely be coming here again

Steaks were excellent. Caesar salad at $15 was not special.

I was celebrating my birthday at Mr B’s with my family. Arnold and Vinny made it so special for us with their exceptional service and attention to every detail during our stay there. Food was splendid from appetizers to desserts. What made it even more joyful was Arnold’s jokes and stories that he shared during our visit. Manager David also made it a very special night by being attentive and making sure that nothing was missing. Lastly, bartender Adam was great as always. It was the best decision to be there twice in 10 days!!!

The food was awesome and our waitress was top shelf