Best Sicilian Restaurants in Little Italy

Price: Moderate (21)Price: Expensive (6)

25 restaurants available nearby

1. Lala

4.5

Awesome(101)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Little Italy

Booked 18 times today

"Lala" is a captivating blend of modern and classic Italian cuisine, paired with handcrafted cocktails in a cozy, sexy-chic ambiance. Our menu showcases timeless Italian flavors with a contemporary twist, from traditional Stuffed Shells to inventive loaded potato gnocchi. The intimate atmosphere, with dimmed lights and plush furnishings, sets the stage for romantic dinners or vibrant gatherings.Our bar is a haven of mixology artistry, featuring classic Negronis and signature creations like the "Lala Martini." Sustainability is a core value—we source responsibly and implement eco-friendly practices in both the kitchen and the bar. "Lala" isn't just a restaurant; it's a community that appreciates culinary excellence, inviting you to savor the extraordinary in every bite, sip, and moment. Join us for a celebration of Italian cuisine, crafted with contemporary flair, and served in an ambiance that exudes romance.

2. Barbusa

4.6

Exceptional(4216)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Little Italy

Booked 68 times today

Barbusa is a revered Italian restaurant that has garnered a glowing reputation from both local and visiting patrons. Nestled in the heart of Little Italy, San Diego, it boasts an inviting ambiance that perfectly marries modern decor with traditional Italian heritage. As noted in several reviews, the food at Barbusa is nothing short of exceptional; dishes like the ribeye, the rigatoni with eggplant, and the pesto gnocchi have been pointed out as exquisite highlights of the menu. Customers have also commended the exceptional and attentive service, making special mention of waiters like Paolo and Diego Silva, who elevate dining experiences through their passion and knowledge. One reviewer described a visit to Barbusa as an "unforgettable journey into the heart of Italy," which speaks volumes about the authenticity and quality of its culinary offerings. Overall, the combinative experience of the food, service, and ambiance make Barbusa a must-visit spot in San Diego for any lover of fine Italian cuisine.

A photo of Mimmo's Italian Village restaurant

3. Mimmo's Italian Village

4.4

Awesome(600)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • Little Italy

Booked 17 times today

Situated in the heart of Little Italy, San Diego, Mimmo's Italian Village is a gem for all Italian cuisine lovers. Its charm and authenticity have earned it high praises, including being hailed as one of the best Italian places in the area. Its service, ambiance, and food have been consistently praised for their excellence. The variety of the dishes, from linguini with shellfish to Bolognese with penne, has captivated the palates of locals and tourists alike. As a testament to its outstanding fare, one New York visitor wished for the restaurant's Bolognese to be air-shipped back home while a regular customer raved about the delectable Greek salad. Clearly, the unforgettable experiences at Mimmo's have made it a must-visit for Italian food enthusiasts.

4. Nonna

4.7

Exceptional(929)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Little Italy

Booked 15 times today

Nonna, located in the heart of Little Italy in San Diego, is an authentic Italian restaurant that never fails to impress its patrons. Hailed by Italian Americans from New York and Italian natives alike, Nonna is lauded for its high-quality, delicious food, exceptional service, and cozy ambiance. Reviewers on numerous occasions have noted Nonna's excellent eggplant dishes, generous portions, and outstanding authenticity, with some diners even stating it's the best Italian they've had since Italy itself! Whether you're craving their heavenly cannolis, exceptional espresso, or their succulent seafood special, you're in for an unforgettable dining experience at Nonna.

5. Vinarius

4.9

Exceptional(340)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Downtown

Booked 16 times today

Located in the heart of San Diego's vibrant Little Italy, Vinarius boasts an exceptional culinary journey through authentic Italian cuisine. The restaurant has received raving reviews from customers, all applauding the freshness, deliciousness, and authenticity of the food. The dishes are said to be "perfectly prepared," creating a fine dining experience that captures the essence of Italy. They are also lauded for their fabulous selection of Italian wines and top-notch espresso. The owner, Giuseppe, has been recognized for his affable demeanor and passionate dedication to the guests' satisfaction. The exceptionally friendly and attentive staff adds a warm touch to the overall dining experience, making Vinarius a must-visit destination for Italian food enthusiasts.

A photo of Isola Little Italy restaurant

6. Isola Little Italy

4.5

Awesome(739)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Little Italy

Booked 9 times today

Isola Little Italy, located in the heart of San Diego's Italian district, is consistently praised for its authentic and delicious Italian cuisine. Known for its incredible wood fired pizzas, outstanding lasagna, and superb prosciutto, customers claim it exceeds all other Italian restaurants they've tried in the city. Its Neopolitan pizzas have also been particularly complimented. The restaurant provides excellent service, a cozy ambiance, and great value for money. Visitors consistently praise its fresh and delicious food. Isola Little Italy's menu is reportedly made using fresh and authentic ingredients, confirming its allegiance to traditional Italian cooking. It's evidently a favorite for locals and tourists alike, being frequently revisited due to its consistently delicious and delightful dining experience.

A photo of Cori Pastificio Trattoria restaurant

7. Cori Pastificio Trattoria

4.8

Exceptional(568)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • North Park

Booked 27 times today

Cori Pastificio Trattoria, located in North Park, San Diego, is hailed as a standout for its authentic Italian cuisine. Customers often compare their food experience here to that in Southern Italy, evidencing its adherence to traditional Italian cooking. The restaurant gets high praise for its creative and unique menu, featuring dishes ranging from ricotta ravioli and short rib to a goat cheese infused pasta with meat sauce. Their offerings are described as "innovative", "fresh" and "delicious". The Caponata focaccia and Italian donuts were particularly highlighted in reviews as "absolutely to die for". The service is highly commended, with customers noting the accommodating and personable staff. This restaurant also features a sophisticated wine list and delightful cocktails, adding to its status as a must-visit for Italian cuisine lovers in San Diego.

8. Osteria Panevino

4.3

Awesome(1724)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Downtown

Booked 17 times today

Osteria Panevino, nestled in the lively Gas Lamp District of San Diego, is renowned for its authentic Italian cuisine. This restaurant consistently leaves its patrons delighted with its exquisite food and service, as reflected in numerous reviews. Diners rave about the homemade seafood pasta, Sicilian chicken, and an array of other dishes, all of which are beautifully presented. The food here is praised as some of the best Italian fare patrons have had anywhere. They commend the authenticity of the dishes, often attributing it to the Italian staff. The warm and professional service, particularly the friendly and attentive waitresses, add greatly to the overall dining experience. Reviewers also appreciate the restaurant's wonderful ambience, particularly the outdoor seating, which is a bonus in San Diego's summer.

A photo of Il Fornaio - Coronado restaurant

9. Il Fornaio - Coronado

4.6

Exceptional(5742)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Coronado

Booked 41 times today

Il Fornaio - Coronado is a cherished gem in San Diego that offers its clientele a delightful mix of authentic Italian cuisine and scenic waterfront views. The establishment is renowned for its high-quality service, with reviews praising the staff for their hospitality and menu recommendations. The menu boasts a wide variety of Italian dishes, from traditional pasta dishes like Rigatoni alla Vodka and Tagliatelle Bolognese to a unique Lemon Ravioli, all prepared with utmost attention to authenticity and taste. Guests have mentioned the food tastes 'like old fashioned quality home cooked Italian meals', reflecting the restaurant's commitment to culinary excellence. The scenic outdoor seating adds to the charm, providing stunning bay and city views, making Il Fornaio an acclaimed spot for quality Italian cuisine in San Diego.

A photo of Garage Buona Forchetta restaurant

10. Garage Buona Forchetta

4.7

Exceptional(817)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Coronado

Booked 35 times today

Garage Buona Forchetta, located in Coronado, stands out with its authentic Italian cuisine. Acknowledged as the 'next best thing to going to Italy', its lasagna, home-made pasta, and pizza receive glowing reviews. The gluten-free options such as potato gnocchi and almond cookies are highly appraised for their taste. Patrons frequently note the unique atmosphere, reminiscent of Italy, and the exceptional service. The signature 'Buona Forchetta' sauce receives particular praise and the restaurant offers a variety of Italian food items for purchase. Patrons often exclaim, 'Best Italian in Coronado!...very authentic. Amazing service too! Can't wait to go back!'.

How is content generated

Discover best Sicilian restaurants in Little Italy

Explore the rich flavors of Sicilian cuisine right in the heart of San Diego's Little Italy with our curated list of top restaurants. Each establishment featured on our page promises an authentic Sicilian dining experience, boasting a variety of traditional dishes from stone-fired oven pizzas to seafood delights, all prepared with fresh, quality ingredients. Little Italy itself is a vibrant culinary hub, renowned for its dynamic dining scene and strong Italian heritage, making it the perfect backdrop for these Sicilian culinary adventures. Whether you're a fan of hearty pastas or exquisite seafood, the restaurants in this locale cater to all palates, including options for those with dietary restrictions such as gluten-free and vegan choices. Diners consistently praise the exceptional service, the warm, inviting atmospheres, and the authentic flavors that transport them straight to Sicily. Discover why these spots are celebrated for blending traditional Sicilian recipes with modern culinary techniques, making each meal a memorable experience.

Explore OpenTable

Little Italy

Sicilian