Best Seafood Restaurants in Key Colony Beach

Price: Moderate (4)Price: Expensive (6)Price: Very Expensive (1)

10 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Florida Keys Steak & Lobster House restaurant

1. Florida Keys Steak & Lobster House

4.7

Exceptional(2945)

Price: Moderate

• Seafood • Marathon

Booked 30 times today

Florida Keys Steak & Lobster House, situated in the Marathon area, is an exceptional seafood cuisine restaurant that is worth visiting. Having received glowing reviews for its diverse dishes and exceptional service, it has created a warm and inviting ambience that many customers easily fall in love with. The seafood, whether part of the 'Surf and Turf' special, the Seafood Morocco, or the seafood platter, is always noted to be impeccably fresh and cooked to perfection. Furthermore, the combination of excellent service, led by servers like Bob and Alison, and the high-quality menu offerings make this restaurant truly stand out. The restaurant is also praised for its value, providing generously portioned and delicious dishes at a reasonable price, with many reviewers stating it was the 'best meal they've ever had.'

2. Brutus Seafood

4.3

Awesome(93)

Price: Moderate

• Seafood • Marathon

Brutus Seafood is a reputable restaurant renowned for its superb American cuisine. It emerges triumphant with its stellar menu featuring diverse dishes from Spinach Dip and Jalapeño Poppers to Tuna Tataki and Coconut Shrimp, to the praised lobster, fish sandwiches and shrimp peal and eat. Its commitment to quality and taste is emphasized in reviews, with patrons lauding the "excellent seafood" and "fresh fish," illustrating Brutus Seafood's commitment to bringing oceanic flavors to the American dining table. Furthermore, it's not just the food that is commendable - the ambience also receives rave reviews for its "casual keys atmosphere". Whether you're in the mood for "great food and great atmosphere" or a "laidback spot with great food," Brutus Seafood is the place to be.

3. Plaza Grill

5.0

Exceptional(79)

Price: Very Expensive

• Seafood • Marathon

Booked 2 times today

Located in Marathon, Plaza Grill provides a top-class Steakhouse experience as attested by numerous rave reviews. Patrons continuously praise its excellent food and service, with many hailing it as the best restaurant in Marathon. Key menu highlights include the perfectly cooked steaks, the expertly prepared seafood dishes, and the superbly crafted specialty drinks. Completing the experience are the outstanding team of staff, who serve with enthusiasm and expertise. The Plaza Grill's unique combination of ambiance, quality, and service make it a must-visit for both locals and visitors alike, and a beacon of Steakhouse cuisine.

4. Blu Bistro

4.1

Excellent(46)

Price: Moderate

• Seafood • Marathon

Blu Bistro is a notable choice for stellar Mediterranean cuisine. Despite low initial expectations due to quiet premises, numerous reviewers were pleasantly surprised with the excellent, varied food offered, served with charm. Gracing the edge of Slipjack Marina, the restaurant serves both delicious food and cocktails, appreciated by returning patrons. It is mentioned as a 'hidden gem', exuding a sophisticated, quiet luxury with a superb chef and staff. With rave reviews from guests, who commend the efficient service, fantastic music, and amazing octopus dish, Blu Bistro consistently delivers a excellent culinary experience in a pleasant atmosphere. The restaurant is renowned for creating a great vibe, making it a favorite among many.

A photo of Castaway Waterfront Restaurant & Sushi Bar restaurant

5. Castaway Waterfront Restaurant & Sushi Bar

4.6

Exceptional(2006)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Marathon

Castaway Waterfront Restaurant & Sushi Bar, located in the heart of Marathon, is one of the most beloved seafood restaurants in the region. Patrons rave about the restaurant's assortment of seafood dishes, including their popular tuna nachos and the Golden Tilefish, celebrating its freshness and flavor. Seafood lovers, including those with a taste for sushi, find the menu highly satisfying. Reviews also highlight the unique ambiance and friendly service, with special praises for servers such as Michelle, Casey, and Brian. The restaurant is highly recommended for both locals and tourists, promising a delightful culinary experience that is authentically Floridian.

6. Butterfly Café

4.5

Awesome(373)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Marathon

Booked 1 time today

Butterfly Café has developed a reputation as a top-notch provider of excellent American cuisine. Its diverse menu ranges from the quintessential All-American Cheeseburger to Caribbean Jerk Chicken, showcasing the wide array of flavors America has to offer. This culinary garnish is highlighted by reviews praising the "incredible" food and "excellent meals", with special mentions of the fresh Tomato & Mozzarella Salad and the delicious Snapper entrée. Rated as "the best fine dining restaurant in Marathon", customer experiences are enhanced by "great service", "exceptional service", and a "great atmosphere". Other highlights include the award-winning Key Lime Pie, a testament to their culinary prowess.

A photo of Lighthouse Kitchen + Bar restaurant

7. Lighthouse Kitchen + Bar

4.3

Awesome(1164)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Marathon

Booked 3 times today

The Lighthouse Grill at Faro Blanco Resort & Yacht Club has cemented itself as a top-tier destination for quintessential American cuisine. Rave reviews consistently highlight the excellent menu, with standout dishes including the short rib sandwich, scallops with risotto, and the Christmas special duck breast. Customers also praised the top-notch service, with servers like Georgiene, Simon, and Steven earning special mention for their attentiveness. The locale adds to the dining experience significantly, with stunning views of the Faro Blanco lighthouse and marina on the Gulf of Mexico framing every meal. A popular pick among locals and tourists alike, the Lighthouse Grill offers a dining experience that is "definitely fabulous", as one reviewer put it.

A photo of Sixty-One Prime at Hawks Cay restaurant

8. Sixty-One Prime at Hawks Cay

4.3

Awesome(411)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Duck Key

Booked 1 time today

Sixty-One Prime at Hawks Cay has earned its accolades as an excellent steakhouse, with customers raving about their high-quality steaks, fantastic service, and amazing atmosphere. As one reviewer mentioned, “The steaks and service were on par with the top steakhouses”. Another customer praised their wagyu strip steak and ribeye, going as far to say they were “out of this world.” Even the ambiance is appreciated, as one reviewer particularly enjoyed the “outdoor dining option overlooking the pool, lagoon and fire pit." The restaurant's prime location and consistent five-star reviews clearly mark Sixty-One Prime at Hawks Cay as a top destination for steak lovers.

A photo of Angler & Ale at Hawks Cay restaurant

9. Angler & Ale at Hawks Cay

4.3

Awesome(899)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Duck Key

Booked 6 times today

Angler & Ale at Hawks Cay is a must-visit for aficionados of contemporary American cuisine who appreciate excellent service, stunning views, and expertly presented dishes. Guest reviews consistently emphasize the high quality of the food and its presentation, underlining the unique flavors of dishes such as tuna nachos, coconut shrimp, yellowtail snapper, and crab cakes. The restaurant's setting offers a scenic panorama of a sea view, lagoon, and pool, enhancing the overall dining experience. With a carefully curated menu that caters to various palates, including vegetarian choices, Angler & Ale offers a memorable dining experience.

A photo of Porky's Bayside Restaurant and Marina restaurant

10. Porky's Bayside Restaurant and Marina

4.4

Awesome(106)

Price: Moderate

• Seafood • Marathon

Porky's Bayside Restaurant and Marina is a highly recommended dining spot for lovers of Barbecue cuisine. Renowned for their "Porky's Famous Smokehouse BBQ", the restaurant offers a variety of dishes, including Smoked BBQ Pulled Chicken, Beef Brisket, and North Carolina Pulled Pork. Other delicious options include their Smokehouse BBQ Sampler, which boasts an array of their finest barbecued meat. Reviews from satisfied customers validate the quality of their dishes and services. Phrases like "great drinks, great food, great atmosphere" and "service was efficient and food was really really good!" are common in the restaurant's testimonies. The restaurant has won the hearts of many with its attentive service and enchanting marina view.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

Key Colony Beach

Seafood