Best Italian Restaurants in Soulard / Benton Park

Price: Moderate (58)Price: Expensive (26)Price: Very Expensive (12)

18 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Eleven Eleven Mississippi restaurant

1. Eleven Eleven Mississippi

4.6

Exceptional(4463)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • St. Louis

Booked 13 times today

Eleven Eleven Mississippi, located in St. Louis, is highly praised for its exceptional take on traditional Italian cuisine. Interior design of the restaurant adds to experience with its charming ambiance. Their food is meticulously prepared as described by numerous reviews: grilled salmon, spinach salad with cranberries, pecans, orange segments, and goat cheese with shallot vinaigrette were declared "perfect" and "the best ever". Housemade focaccia, complemented with herb and parm olive oil, is noted as "amazing". The wine list is extensive, with a large Italian selection, impressing even the wine connoisseurs. Various reviews highlight the superb services provided by the friendly staff. Both first-time visitors and frequent customers highly recommend Eleven Eleven Mississippi for its consistently good experience.

A photo of Charlie Gitto's 'On the Hill' restaurant

2. Charlie Gitto's 'On the Hill'

4.8

Exceptional(6936)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • The Hill

Booked 73 times today

Renowned for offering an authentic culinary experience, Charlie Gitto's 'On the Hill' is celebrated as the epitome of Italian cuisine. The restaurant is praised for its old school Italian meals, with guests commending its "authentic taste," as reflected in the reviews. The toasted ravioli, arancini, Fettucine Alfredo, steak, and risotto have been singled out for their exceptional flavor. Reviewers also highlight the restaurant's exceptional service and the knowledgeable, attentive staff. The ambiance is described as classy, and the restaurant maintains this high standard consistently, proving that they've mastered the art of good dining over the years. Most reviewers look forward to returning, considering it the best Italian they've ever had, with phrases such as "a great reminder of what Italian food is supposed to taste like" being commonplace in reviews.

A photo of Edera Italian Eatery restaurant

3. Edera Italian Eatery

4.6

Exceptional(22)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Central West End

Booked 14 times today

Edera Italian Eatery is focused on serving simple, refined food in a more casual, come-as-you-are atmosphere. Chef Andrew Simon offers a fresh interpretation, sourcing the highest quality ingredients from Italy to Missouri. The menu features premium Neapolitan pizzas, signature pastas and premium entrees. Edera’s cuisine – featuring sauces, pastas and baked goods made fresh daily in the restaurant – are elevated enough for a special night out, while also being approachable enough for everyday fare. Concepted by the Koplar family in consultation with renowned Chef Mike Randolph, Edera has quickly become a fixture in St. Louis’s iconic Central West End neighborhood. We invite you to experience our newly renovated dining room or dine alfresco alongside towering ivy walls in our Italian style courtyard. We look forward to serving you!

A photo of Guido's Pizza and Tapas restaurant

4. Guido's Pizza and Tapas

4.6

Exceptional(636)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • The Hill

Booked 19 times today

Guido's Pizza and Tapas comes highly recommended for its authentic and delicious Italian cuisine. Patrons have praised the restaurant's exceptional food and service, stating it's "not your typical Italian in the states - it's the real deal." It's applauded for its wide range of offerings from incredible pizzas, pastas, to salads, with every dish seemingly outcompeting the last. A customer has even claimed it has "the best Italian food around" and has given it a 10-star rating. Guido's Pizza and Tapas is also recognized for its outstanding service and warm, welcoming ambiance, ensuring a memorable dining experience.

A photo of Lorenzo's Trattoria restaurant

5. Lorenzo's Trattoria

4.7

Exceptional(2249)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • The Hill

Booked 14 times today

Lorenzo's Trattoria, located in the heart of 'The Hill' in St. Louis, consistently delights with its delicious and authentic Italian cuisine. The delightful house salad and Italian sausage pizza are highly recommended as a 'perfect light meal' during hot weather. The quality and taste of their food have been compared to the cozy neighborhood and family setting you would find in Northern Italy, with one reviewer stating that eating at Lorenzo's was like visiting their Italian aunt who was a phenomenal cook. The staff are noted as being personable and attentive, ensuring their customers always leave satisfied. Many customers have sworn to return to Lorenzo's any time they visit St. Louis, praising it as one of the best in the city, if not 'the best Italian food on the hill BY FAR'.

A photo of Bar Italia Ristorante restaurant

6. Bar Italia Ristorante

4.3

Awesome(969)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Central West End

Booked 10 times today

Bar Italia Ristorante, located in the Central West End of St. Louis, is renowned for its authentic Italian cuisine. The charming outdoor patio is a consistent favorite amongst patrons who consider it to be the nicest in the city. The restaurant's ambiance offers the feeling of dining in a small town in Italy, enhancing the overall dining experience. The restaurant's remarkable service, combined with a delectable Italian menu, has been consistently praised by customers. The testimonies from countless satisfied diners, ranging from praising their exquisite food to their exceptional service and enchanting setting, solidify Bar Italia Ristorante's status as a top dining spot for those seeking an authentic Italian culinary experience.

A photo of Dominic's on the Hill restaurant

7. Dominic's on the Hill

4.6

Exceptional(1076)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • The Hill

Booked 1 time today

Dominic's on the Hill has long established itself as a bastion of fine Italian cuisine in St. Louis. Hailed as 'great' and 'traditional', it has garnered enthusiastic reviews. A customer remarked, "Dominic’s Italian cuisine is fine, mighty fine... For those not familiar with St Louis I’d give the Italian a day in court with the best of New York, Philadelphia and Chicago." The service is widely lauded as 'superb' and 'friendly', with Dominic making a personal effort to check on guests. Dining experiences are 'memorable' and 'authentic', with patrons relishing in the 'old fashioned Italian feel'. The personal touch seems to be the cherry on top, solidifying Dominic's on the Hill as a must-visit for Italian cuisine enthusiasts.

8. Rigazzis

new

5.0

Exceptional(3)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • The Hill

Booked 1 time today

At Rigazzi’s, our mission is simple – to consistently deliver an authentic taste of Italy in a warm, welcoming atmosphere. We are dedicated to preserving the rich culinary traditions of Historic Hill, striving to be the premier destination for genuine Italian-American dining in St. Louis. We aim to create memorable dining experiences, where each visit to Rigazzi’s is a journey through timeless flavors. We invite you to join us on this culinary adventure, as we continue to be a cornerstone of Historic Hill, offering the simple pleasures of good food and good company.

9. Al's Restaurant

4.6

Exceptional(523)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Downtown St. Louis

Booked 1 time today

Al's Restaurant is a highly-revered Steakhouse located in St. Louis, steeped in rich history and boasting an impressive 94-year tenure, creating a unique, unmatchable ambiance. Highly acclaimed by its loyal patrons, Al's stands out for its exclusive, verbal menu presentation, expert showmanship, and stinting service that makes patrons feel cherished. Distinct dishes like 'Steak Romano' and 'Al's Pasta' have garnered a reputation for being extraordinary, with portions large enough to justify their price. While its traditionally upscale environment and high-end cuts of meat liken Al's to renowned steakhouses like Chophouse 801 and Ruth's Chris, what sets Al's apart is its refusal to bend to modern aesthetics and insistence on preserving its captivating, old-school charm. Their unique method of presenting the cuts of meat directly to the table and preparing some dishes right there add to the exceptional dining experience.

A photo of Casa Don Alfonso - The Ritz-Carlton St. Louis restaurant

10. Casa Don Alfonso - The Ritz-Carlton St. Louis

4.5

Awesome(1189)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Clayton

Booked 27 times today

Casa Don Alfonso at The Ritz-Carlton in St. Louis is widely celebrated for its authentic Mediterranean cuisine. Reviewers echo a unanimous appreciation for its committed authenticity to Italian flavors, with dishes cooked by Italian chefs. Known for its unique menu items like 'meatballs with raisins and pine nuts' and 'lobster gnocchi,' the restaurant is praised for its variety and quality. Reviewers also note the freshness of ingredients and the restaurant's tendency to go 'above and beyond' in service. The perfect setup for a 'highly enjoyable date night', according to one review, the restaurant's gorgeous interior enhances the overall experience. The establishment's high regard for detail and customer satisfaction marks it as a top-notch Mediterranean dining destination.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

Soulard / Benton Park

Italian