Best Italian Restaurants in Key West

Price: Moderate (19)Price: Expensive (18)Price: Very Expensive (11)

7 restaurants available nearby

1. Antonia's

4.9

Exceptional(2093)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Key West

Booked 25 times today

Antonia’s Restaurant, located in the heart of Old Town Key West has been delighting the palates of locals and visitors for almost 40 years. The menu at Antonia’s Restaurant offers an array of the freshest local seafood dishes and a variety of traditional meat dishes made from the freshest ingredients prepared daily by our Classically Northern Italian trained chefs. Feeling that dining is an experience to be savored, no culinary experience is complete without wine. In addition to an extensive wine list, full bar is also available.

2. Ocean Grill & Bar

4.7

Exceptional(994)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Key West

Booked 5 times today

Ocean Grill & Bar in Key West truly encapsulates the essence of Italian cuisine with its innovative seafood-inspired dishes. Celebrated Chef Lea, with over 20 years of culinary experience in Key West, masterfully blends local seafood flavors with traditional Italian techniques, creating standout dishes such as the Shrimp & Grits and the Lobster Benedict. The restaurant has garnered acclaim for its commitment to quality and authenticity, with one reviewer exclaiming, "Seared tuna with avocado was melt-in-your-mouth awesome. Grilled shrimp were super tender in fantastic 4-cheese grits" — a testament to the restaurant's prowess in delivering exceptional Italian fare. Whether you're a local or visiting, Ocean Grill & Bar promises a dining experience that's both authentically Italian and uniquely Key West.

A photo of New York Pasta Garden restaurant

3. New York Pasta Garden

4.2

Awesome(588)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Key West

Booked 2 times today

At New York Pasta Garden in Key West, seafood lovers can indulge in the essence of fresh, authentic flavors. Esteemed for its "delicious good size portions" of seafood, including a stellar Grouper and a "Fruit de mare that was great," this gem marries Italian culinary traditions with the bounty of the sea. Patrons rave about the "shrimp, scallop and lobster pasta," highlighting the quality and generous servings. The atmosphere is just as inviting, with a quaint garden setting that promises a memorable dining experience. The consistent praise for the "excellent" food and service ensures that New York Pasta Garden stands out as a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts.

A photo of La Trattoria Old Town restaurant

4. La Trattoria Old Town

4.7

Exceptional(2892)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Key West

Booked 21 times today

La Trattoria Old Town in Key West is a culinary gem renowned for its exceptional Steak cuisine. Nestled at 524 Duval Street, this flagship location offers an intimate bistro-type setting perfect for savoring their high-quality dishes. The restaurant prides itself on using only the freshest ingredients, ensuring each steak is cooked to perfection. Patrons rave about the authenticity and flavor of the dishes, describing the experience as "always a dining experience" and highlighting the Steak options as "cooked perfectly" with "excellent quality." Whether it's your first visit or you're a longtime fan, La Trattoria Old Town promises a memorable dining experience with every plate served.

5. Azur

4.9

Exceptional(2822)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Key West

Booked 2 times today

Azur, nestled in the charming heart of old Key West, is a beacon of Spanish cuisine that continues to delight both locals and visitors alike. With its inviting terrace and vibrant dining room, Azur offers a culinary journey with dishes that pay homage to authentic Spanish flavors. Patrons rave about the "out of this world" tilefish special and the "best octopus ever," highlighting the freshness and creativity of the menu. The consistent praise for their seafood dishes, like the highly recommended Key West Pink Shrimp and the flavorful branzino, underscores Azur's commitment to quality and authenticity. This gem in Key West is celebrated not just for its food but for its exceptional service and atmosphere, making every dining experience memorable. Azur remains a must-visit for anyone craving genuine Spanish delights in a cozy, welcoming setting.

6. Bel Mare

4.8

Exceptional(1185)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Key West

Booked 11 times today

Bel Mare in Key West offers a delightful twist on Modern Tuscan cuisine, melding coastal Italian flavors with a stunning marina backdrop. Diners rave about the authentic Tuscan dishes, describing them as "out of this world" and "the best I’ve ever had." The restaurant's dedication to quality is evident in their fresh, excellently prepared grouper and linguine with clams, which one guest claims is "the best sauce ever." The ambiance, enhanced by beautiful views of A&B Marina, complements the exquisite dining experience, making every meal memorable. Bel Mare's commitment to excellence makes it a must-visit for anyone seeking the best of Modern Tuscan cuisine in Key West.

A photo of La Trattoria Oceanside restaurant

7. La Trattoria Oceanside

4.8

Exceptional(2155)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Key West

Booked 11 times today

Nestled in the picturesque Key West, La Trattoria Oceanside offers a breathtaking ocean view alongside its authentic Italian cuisine. Patrons consistently rave about the "spot on" dishes such as the seafood ravioli and the carbolicious carbonara ravioli, with one diner exclaiming, the "key lime martini is AMAZING." The excellence extends beyond the food; the service is equally commendable with reviews highlighting the attentive and knowledgeable staff. This gem is described as the "go-to Key West restaurant for fine dining," making every meal a memorable experience against the stunning backdrop of the Atlantic Ocean. Whether celebrating a special occasion or enjoying a casual meal, La Trattoria Oceanside promises an "outstanding dining experience" that keeps guests returning.

How is content generated

Discover best Italian restaurants in Key West

Discover the charm of Italian cuisine in the vibrant and picturesque Key West, Florida Keys. This unique culinary destination offers a wide range of Italian eateries, each providing a distinct blend of traditional and innovative dishes that cater to every palate. From the freshest seafood-infused pasta to classic Italian desserts, these restaurants exemplify the rich flavors and culinary craftsmanship associated with Italy. Dining in Key West allows you to enjoy not only the delicious food but also the warm, inviting ambiance that these establishments are known for. Whether you're seeking a romantic dinner by the ocean or a cozy family meal, Key West's Italian dining scene promises an unforgettable experience. The consistent praise for exceptional service, high-quality ingredients, and creative cuisine highlights the area's commitment to authentic and satisfying dining. Explore Key West for an Italian culinary adventure that combines the serenity of the Florida Keys with the zest of Italy.

Explore OpenTable

Key West

Italian