Best Italian Restaurants in Fort Myers Beach

Price: Moderate (22)Price: Expensive (15)Price: Very Expensive (7)

14 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Terra Nostra Restaurant restaurant

1. Terra Nostra Restaurant

4.8

Exceptional(2009)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Fort Myers Beach

Booked 17 times today

Terra Nostra Restaurant near Fort Myers Beach delivers an exceptional seafood dining experience that consistently impresses both locals and visitors. Renowned for its "delicious" seafood offerings, guests rave about dishes like the succulent grouper, praised for its freshness and superb seasoning. The restaurant's location just minutes from Sanibel adds a charming allure, perfect for enjoying seafood fresh from the nearby waters. Patrons often highlight the excellent service, with comments such as "the food and service were amazing!" and "service was excellent." Terra Nostra's commitment to quality and an enchanting dining environment makes it a standout destination for seafood lovers seeking authenticity and excellence in Fort Myers.

A photo of Rae's Real Italian restaurant

2. Rae's Real Italian

4.5

Awesome(259)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Fort Myers

Booked 8 times today

Rae's Real Italian in Fort Myers Beach offers an authentic American dining experience that captures the essence of gourmet Italian cuisine with a unique American twist. Nestled within the scenic Pink Shell Beach Resort and Marina, Rae's provides a delightful fusion of traditional and contemporary flavors that cater to all ages. Guests rave about the "best meal we had all weekend" and praise the "unique and delicious" Key Lime Cannolis, highlighting the restaurant's commitment to quality and creativity. With its stunning Gulf of Mexico views and exceptional service, Rae's Real Italian is not just a meal; it's a culinary journey that resonates deeply with the American palate, making it a must-visit destination on Fort Myers Beach.

3. il Pomodoro

4.3

Awesome(346)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Fort Myers

Il Pomodoro in Fort Myers offers an authentic Sicilian dining experience that's been consistently lauded as one of the best in Southwest Florida. With a string of prestigious accolades including the Trip Advisor’s Traveler’s Choice Award and multiple News Press Restaurants of the Year rankings, diners are guaranteed a meal that transcends the ordinary. Guests rave about the "outstanding" Shrimp Fra Diavolo and the "amazing" rigatoni bolognese, emphasizing both the quality and the generous portion sizes. One reviewer exclaimed, "This is the best Italian I have EVER eaten!!" which is a testament to the restaurant's commitment to authenticity and excellence. Whether you're there for a cozy date night or a festive family gathering, Il Pomodoro promises an unforgettable culinary journey through the heart of Sicily.

A photo of Angelina's Ristorante restaurant

4. Angelina's Ristorante

4.8

Exceptional(5551)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Bonita Springs

Booked 32 times today

Angelina's Ristorante, widely recognized as one of the finest Italian restaurants in the Naples/Bonita Springs area, is the embodiment of excellent Italian cuisine. The restaurant earns high praise from diners, many of whom highlight the outstanding service, delectable menu options, and inviting ambiance as key elements of their exceptional dining experience. Patrons frequently commend the staff, like Marco and Danny, for their in-depth knowledge about the food and wine, enhancing the overall culinary journey. The restaurant is repeatedly lauded for its amazing food, specifically the homemade pasta, veal Marsala, and bolognese, that transport diners straight to Italy. Angelina’s Ristorante is consistently hailed as an establishment that never disappoints, delivering not just a meal, but a memorable event. Noting the quality, range, and creativity of their delightful offerings, it is easy to see why Angelina's Ristorante is considered the epitome of good Italian cuisine.

5. Mastello

4.8

Exceptional(416)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Fort Myers

Booked 8 times today

Mastello in Fort Myers is a gem for those seeking a premier steakhouse experience. Located conveniently near the Barbara B. Mann Theatre, this elegantly revamped venue is celebrated for its prime cuts and American Wagyu, ensuring a top-tier dining indulgence. Patrons rave about the "most delicious and well-seasoned filets" and the "perfectly prepared Wagyu top cut sirloin," highlighting the exceptional quality of the meats. With over 100 wine selections and a sophisticated cocktail bar, Mastello not only promises a delightful meal but a luxurious atmosphere perfect for any special occasion. As one diner put it, this is the place for "an upscale evening out," making every visit to Mastello a memorable feast of flavors and impeccable service.

A photo of La Fontanella Ristorante - Bonita Springs restaurant

6. La Fontanella Ristorante - Bonita Springs

4.7

Exceptional(440)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Bonita Springs

Booked 19 times today

La Fontanella Ristorante in Bonita Springs is a treasure for aficionados of fine cuts and authentic Italian cuisine. Praised for its "mouthwateringly good" veal osso buco and filet mignon, the restaurant excels in delivering meticulously prepared dishes that showcase the pinnacle of culinary craftsmanship. Visitors consistently laud the quality and authenticity of the meals, noting that even the pasta gorgonzola and veal dishes are "superb," and the carpaccio appetizer is "over the top." With glowing recommendations like, "Food is awesome," and "Fantastic meal! Service was excellent!" it's clear La Fontanella is a must-visit for anyone seeking exceptional fine cuts in a warm, inviting atmosphere.

7. 41 Bistro

4.7

Exceptional(204)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • San Carlos Park

Booked 3 times today

41 Bistro in San Carlos Park, Fort Myers, is a culinary haven for steak lovers. This exceptional dining spot combines Italian flair with the art of steak preparation, ensuring each dish is a masterpiece. Patrons rave about the quality, with one guest proclaiming the steak as "very good," highlighting its prominence alongside other Italian specialties. The restaurant's dedication to fine ingredients and skillful cooking shines through, making every steak dish a delectable journey of flavors. Whether it's a romantic dinner or a special gathering, 41 Bistro promises an unforgettable steak experience that keeps guests coming back for more. Celebrate your next steak dinner at 41 Bistro, where tradition meets excellence.

A photo of La Fontanella Ristorante - Fort Myers restaurant

8. La Fontanella Ristorante - Fort Myers

4.7

Exceptional(174)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • McGregor

Booked 19 times today

We're glad that you're here. We pride ourselves in serving you authentic, from-scratch Italian dishes made only from the freshest, highest quality ingredients. We provide a vast selection of fine wines and hand crafted cocktails to further culminate your meal, and fresh, from-scratch desserts to conclude. Along with our warm, inviting atmosphere and friendly professional service, you can be assured that we at La Fontanella strive to exceed your expectations each time that you join us for a meal. It is always our pleasure to serve you. We look forward to meeting you.

9. Trattoria Ciao

4.9

Exceptional(108)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Cape Coral

Booked 1 time today

Trattoria Ciao in Cape Coral is a haven for those seeking genuine Italian cuisine, where the aromas and flavors transport you straight to Italy. Praised for its "authentic Italian garlic bread" and described as a place where "everything was so so delicious," it's clear that Trattoria Ciao masters the art of Italian cooking. A patron raved about the "wild mushroom arancini" as "better than the ones I had in Italy," showcasing the restaurant's commitment to authentic and exquisitely prepared dishes. The cozy ambiance, complemented by live music, ensures a dining experience that's both "intimate" and "romantic," making every visit memorable. Whether it's the wood-fired pizzas or the "best shrimp piccata" ever tasted, Trattoria Ciao consistently exceeds expectations, making it a must-visit for anyone craving a taste of Italy in Florida.

10. Next Door

4.8

Exceptional(141)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Cape Coral

Booked 1 time today

Next Door in Cape Coral offers an exceptional dining experience that highlights the best of Contemporary American cuisine with a delightful modern twist. Patrons consistently rave about the unique and delicious flavor combinations, such as the "basil infused pasta" and the "wagyu carpaccio," underscoring the chef's skill in elevating traditional dishes. One reviewer exclaimed, "The chef nailed it with the unexpected & complimentary tasting of the asparagus puree with microgreens," emphasizing the creativity and quality that Next Door brings to every dish. Frequent guests appreciate not only the food but also the atmosphere, describing it as their "favorite date nightspot." With its commitment to freshness, evident in their daily handmade pastas, and a market for those who wish to bring a taste of Next Door home, this restaurant truly stands out in the Cape Coral culinary scene.

How is content generated

Discover best Italian restaurants in Fort Myers Beach

Discover the essence of Italian cuisine in Ft. Myers, Southwest Florida, and Fort Myers Beach, where a variety of Italian restaurants offer a slice of Italy right to your table. These dining establishments boast authentic Italian flavors, from traditional pasta dishes to innovative seafood creations that cater to both classic and contemporary tastes. Each restaurant focuses on creating a warm, inviting atmosphere, often enhanced by thoughtfully curated wine lists that complement the rich, flavorful dishes. The dining scene in this locale is vibrant and diverse, reflecting a strong appreciation for culinary craftsmanship and genuine hospitality. Visitors can expect top-notch service and an unforgettable dining experience that highlights both the simplicity and sophistication of Italian cooking. Whether you're a local or a visitor, these Italian restaurants in Southwest Florida provide a perfect backdrop for both casual outings and special occasions, promising an enjoyable and satisfying meal every time.

Explore OpenTable

Fort Myers Beach

Italian