Best American Restaurants in Siesta Key

Price: Moderate (44)Price: Expensive (48)Price: Very Expensive (3)

45 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Connors Steak & Seafood - Sarasota restaurant

1. Connors Steak & Seafood - Sarasota

4.7

Exceptional(8294)

Price: Expensive

• American • Siesta Key

Booked 77 times today

Connors Steak & Seafood in Sarasota is highly recommended for its exquisite Steakhouse cuisine. Numerous reviews attest to the "fantastic food", "great service", and "relaxed ambiance". Whether it's celebrating a special occasion or an informal lunch, customers continually praise the quality of both food and service. Patrons frequently recommend the steak as "best ever", and even compare the establishment favorably to well-known steakhouses like Mortons, Ruths Chris, and Hyde Park Steakhouse. The staff's attentiveness is remarked upon regularly in reviews, with guests appreciating the dedication to customer satisfaction. With 'delicious meals', 'great value', and exceptional customer service, Connors Steak & Seafood is described as a "true gem for Sarasota".

A photo of Libby's - Sarasota restaurant

2. Libby's - Sarasota

4.8

Exceptional(3894)

Price: Moderate

• American • Sarasota

Booked 22 times today

Libby's in Sarasota stands as a beacon of contemporary American cuisine, consistently lauded by patrons for its delicious dishes, diverse menu, and wonderful service. The eatery is known for serving favorites such as fried shrimp, fish and chips, and the Korean sticky ribs that exhilarate with their perfect blend of flavor and texture. The restaurant also accommodates vegetarians with selections like the cauliflower steak and impossible burger. This top-tier establishment not only offers high-quality dining experiences but also a delightful ambience, emphasized by its recent renovation. Customers routinely endorse the attentive staff and their commitment to ensuring each patron's satisfaction. Undoubtedly, Libby's has become a neighborhood gem that continues to exceed expectations.

A photo of Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse - Sarasota restaurant

3. Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse - Sarasota

4.6

Exceptional(2680)

Price: Expensive

• American • Sarasota

Booked 43 times today

Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse in Sarasota, Florida is a celebrated dining destination recognized for its delicious steakhouse cuisine. Patrons rave about the "consistently excellent" food and service, with many noting the freshness and quality of both the seafood and steak dishes. The restaurant's ambiance is equally hailed, praised for being a mix of homely comfort and luxury. Special occasions are celebrated with fervor, pairing sumptuous food like the infamous butter cake bananas foster and flavorful filet mignon with superior service. Drawing in the crowds with its unique offerings and unparalleled quality, Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse stakes its claim as a premier place for steakhouse cuisine.

4. Michael's On East

4.8

Exceptional(5515)

Price: Expensive

• American • Sarasota

Booked 20 times today

Michael's On East is a revered establishment in the Contemporary American cuisine scene. The restaurant is famous for creating extraordinary dining experiences with delightful fusion of flavors. Customers particularly praised the Moroccan special, porcini-rubbed flat iron steak, and vegetarian truffle risotto. The Moqueca, a Brazilian fish stew, and the Carved Porcini-Rubbed Flat Iron Steak were among the dishes highly recommended by satisfied guests. The extensive wine list and innovative monthly tasting menus keep regular patrons intrigued. The ambiance is elegant yet inviting, with a piano player adding to the charm. Michael's On East isn't just about food; it’s about the whole package of marvelous ambiance, amazing food, and exceptional service.

A photo of Ophelia's on the Bay restaurant

5. Ophelia's on the Bay

4.9

Exceptional(6200)

Price: Expensive

• American • Siesta Key

Booked 29 times today

Ophelia's on the Bay, located in the idyllic Lakewood Ranch neighborhood of Sarasota, is a premier destination for Contemporary American cuisine. Many reviews credit Ophelia's for providing an excellent blend of immaculate service, delectable dishes, and a breathtaking ambience. The menu, which changes daily, features fresh and creative meals including dishes like the American Waygu beef tartare and macadamia crusted red snapper. Complementing the food, customers felt taken care of by the knowledgeable and helpful staff. Fine dining paired with marvelous views of the bay, the restaurant has successfully created a compelling culinary experience that is loved by locals and tourists alike.

A photo of Tommy Bahama Restaurant & Bar - Sarasota restaurant

6. Tommy Bahama Restaurant & Bar - Sarasota

4.6

Exceptional(4385)

Price: Expensive

• American • Sarasota

Booked 28 times today

Tommy Bahama Restaurant & Bar in Sarasota is a well-loved spot that impresses with its stellar seafood cuisine. Reviews underscore the freshness of the seafood, with guests praising dishes from the crab bisque to the grilled salmon, and lauding the variety of seafood choices available. The restaurant's location is perfect, just a short stroll from Lido Beach, making it a popular choice for those looking to complement their meal with a beautiful sunset. Emphasis is also placed on the "scratch kitchen" attribute, testifying to the quality of the food. Moreover, guests appreciate the great ambiance, which is lively and trendy, yet relaxing. With excellent service and a well-rounded menu, Tommy Bahama Restaurant stands as a top spot for seafood lovers.

A photo of The Rosemary & Thyme restaurant

7. The Rosemary & Thyme

4.8

Exceptional(4304)

Price: Expensive

• American • Sarasota

Booked 22 times today

Rosemary & Thyme is highly praised for its exceptional American cuisine, weaving a classic and contemporary culinary narrative. Patrons consistently laud the restaurant for its diverse offerings, attentive service, and enticing specials that bring uniqueness to weekday dining. Customers are particularly captivated by the restaurant's theme nights, such as "Vivan los Vinos," where traditional Latin American flavors are artfully paired with fine wines. The "Out of Africa" dinner showcases a mastery of global cuisine, while the restaurant's "Gravy Date Night" and "Date Night" events are cherished fixtures. With comprehensive praise from guests, Rosemary & Thyme emerges as a must-visit destination for outstanding American cuisine.

A photo of Clayton's Siesta Grille restaurant

8. Clayton's Siesta Grille

4.8

Exceptional(2208)

Price: Moderate

• American • Sarasota

Booked 7 times today

Clayton's Siesta Grille stands out in American cuisine for its delectable mix of classic American fare and creative vegetarian dishes. Known for its attentive service and welcoming ambiance, Clayton's is consistently praised for its outstanding food and extensive drink offerings, from craft beers to specialty cocktails. Patrons highly recommend Clayton's for the quality and variety of their menu, including dishes like the perfectly prepared chicken, short rib beef, and the much-lauded cauliflower and garbanzo bean loaf. The restaurant is also noted for its seafood offerings, such as the grouper dish that has been hailed as the best by customers. Meals are served hot and the cocktails are noted for their creative twist. Exceptional service complements the overall dining experience, making Clayton's Siesta Grille a top-tier dining destination.

9. Indigenous

4.7

Exceptional(833)

Price: Expensive

• American • Sarasota

Booked 12 times today

Indigenous is a highly recommended restaurant, renowned for its outstanding American cuisine. Patrons have applauded its diverse and inventive menu, along with unparalleled service and inviting ambiance. Specific highlights from the reviews include the wild mushroom bisque, which is "incredibly flavorful", and the pork chop, known for being thick, juicy, and caramelized. The restaurant receives continuous praise for the freshness of its ingredients, creativity of dishes, and their attentive staff. Reviewers also mentioned Indigenous' excellent wine list and the frequent changes to the fish dishes, ensuring every visit offers something new and exciting. The restaurant's sustainable approach to dining has also been widely recognized, making it a leader in the culinary scene.

A photo of Wink Wink Food and Drink restaurant

10. Wink Wink Food and Drink

4.5

Awesome(193)

Price: Expensive

• American • Sarasota

Booked 1 time today

Wink Wink Modern Lounge is highly rated for its fantastic international cuisine and unique atmosphere. Patrons commend its innovative menu and the quality of its meals, mentioning the tenderness of the miso steak, the delightful flavor of its brussel sprouts and the creativity behind the bison ribs. The restaurant offers a fun and eclectic atmosphere with a 50's tropical vibe, and attentive service that adds to the overall dining experience. Reviewers have also noted the excellent cocktail selection, with many praising the bartender's skill. Whether dining inside the funky restaurant or on the breezy patio, guests commend Wink Wink Modern Lounge for providing a consistently enjoyable dining experience.

How is content generated

Discover best American restaurants in Siesta Key

Discover the vibrant American dining scene in Siesta Key, Tampa / Central Florida West, Sarasota / Bradenton, where you can indulge in a variety of American cuisine options. Whether you're craving juicy steaks, fresh seafood, gourmet salads, or hearty pastas, the area's restaurants cater to every taste with high-quality ingredients and expert preparation. Enjoy the relaxed yet sophisticated atmosphere that characterizes many of these establishments, ideal for both casual and formal dining experiences. Patrons consistently praise the attentive service and the consistently delicious food, indicating a commitment to excellence across these dining venues. Each restaurant in this locale strives to provide a memorable culinary adventure, emphasizing the importance of a satisfying dining experience. This area is a must-visit for food enthusiasts and anyone looking to savor the best of American cuisine in a beautiful coastal setting.

Explore OpenTable

Siesta Key

American