Best American Restaurants in Shadyside

Price: Moderate (62)Price: Expensive (47)Price: Very Expensive (23)

69 restaurants available nearby

1. Ritual House

4.8

Exceptional(1226)

Price: Expensive

• American • Downtown

Booked 45 times today

Ritual House is an excellent choice for contemporary American cuisine, as acclaimed by numerous patrons. Many diners heap praise on the unique and eclectic atmosphere, with special attention to the attentive service, impressive décor, and appetizing food. It offers an array of delectable dishes including a commendable Pastrami hash, croque madame, and a dessert offering of Crème Brûlée Cheesecake and Lemon Dream. Their Brunch has been described as "fantastic," one of the best in the city, and standout dishes include the chicken wing appetizer and beet salad with tuna. Notably, guests appreciated that the chef would stop by tables to discuss the food and the restaurant, reflecting dedication to a great dining experience. Ritual House is highly recommended for its brilliant atmosphere, top-tier service, and most importantly, its stellar contemporary American cuisine.

2. Grand Concourse

4.3

Awesome(8196)

Price: Moderate

• American • Downtown

Booked 113 times today

Grand Concourse in Pittsburgh is highly praised for its superb seafood cuisine. The restaurant, situated in a beautifully maintained old train station, offers a unique ambiance that customers frequently appreciate. Its seafood dishes such as scallops, halibut, and salmon are mentioned in several reviews as being consistently of first quality and cooked to perfection. The seafood pasta and seafood trio also received high praise. This seafood excellence is complemented by equally impressive service. The staff, including servers like Kevin, India, and Greg, were mentioned personally by customers for their outstanding service. Grand Concourse was depicted as a perfect location to celebrate special occasions, with its exceptional seafood cuisine evidently contributing to this stand-out dining experience.

3. Butterjoint

4.7

Exceptional(2890)

Price: Moderate

• American • Oakland

Booked 27 times today

Butterjoint is a comfy bar and restaurant located in North Oakland. Our welcoming and eclectic atmosphere is appropriate for almost any occasion - whether it be meeting a friend for a drink, celebrating an important event, or relaxing after work. Our menu is a mixture of familiar Pittsburgh foods (think pierogies, hamburgers, French fries) and French bistro classics (beef tartare, raclette, mussels), and seasonal classics that come and go throughout the year. We put care into our vegetarian dishes too, including making our own tempeh, falafel, and veggie patties from scratch. Menu items change frequently--usually every day--and reflect many long-standing relationships we have with farms and breweries in our region. In addition to reservations, we also have a thirty seat bar that is first come, first serve. We don’t know exactly how old the bar is, but it’s at least seventy years old (probably older) and very cozy. Our friendly bartenders are here to make something you like.

4. Spork

4.8

Exceptional(995)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • East Liberty

Booked 6 times today

Spork stands out as not merely one of the best restaurants in Pittsburgh, but as a premier destination for innovative Contemporary American cuisine according to numerous rave reviews. The inventive menu consistently impresses diners with dishes like crispy octopus, lamb saddle, mushroom ravioli, and a cold soup tasting. Reviewers specifically praise the restaurant's creativity, quality ingredients, and meticulous preparation. The aesthetic of the venue also enhances the experience, with one reviewer describing it as "cozy but fun". In addition to the food, Spork's service also garners high marks for being attentive, engaging, and knowledgeable. The common thread across all reviews is the eagerness of patrons to return, indicating the restaurant's success in crafting an unforgettable dining experience.

5. ELEVEN

4.8

Exceptional(6049)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Downtown

Booked 40 times today

ELEVEN is a renowned dining establishment known for its brilliantly executed American cuisine. The restaurant is prominently mentioned amongst the best in Pittsburgh, appreciated for its fantastic food and outstanding service. Its creative dishes, crafted with local ingredients, ooze quality and are celebrated for their inventive use of summer ingredients and flawless cooking techniques. Renowned for its excellent, efficient service and elegant, unassuming atmosphere, guests have found the staff to be knowledgeable and the environment to be comfortable. Whether you're savouring their flawlessly cooked pork chop, delighting in the seafood tasting, or indulging in their ground-breaking agnolotti, ELEVEN remains a stalwart of the Pittsburgh dining scene, consistently delivering appetizing meals from appetizers to dessert.

6. Altius

4.8

Exceptional(6219)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Mt. Washington

Booked 60 times today

Altius, located in Pittsburgh, is celebrated for its exquisite Contemporary American cuisine. Reviews consistently highlight the gourmet food, outstanding service, and fabulous ambience. Altius is praised as one of the best restaurants in Pittsburgh, with a menu that goes above and beyond expectations. The contemporary decor is set against an impressive backdrop of the city, providing a unique dining experience. Guests note that the exceptional food is presented beautifully and tastes consistently excellent. Many reviewers mentioned special occasions enriched by the gourmet food, excellent service, and the stunning view. It's clear from the reviews that Altius makes every dining experience memorable.

7. Morcilla

4.9

Exceptional(1781)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Lawrenceville

Booked 17 times today

Morcilla is an excellent Spanish cuisine restaurant, widely reputed for providing a unique and delightful dining experience. Numerous customers have praised Morcilla's ability to deliver authentic Spanish flavors in a comfortable, upscale environment. Described as a venue for 'small bite courses with a Spanish twist', its diverse menu consistently impresses first-time visitors and regulars alike. Dishes such as the oxtail, charcuterie, and octopus have been especially highlighted for their exceptional taste. Customers remark on the knowledgeable staff and commend how well-balanced the flavors are, making every dish a culinary adventure. Many reviews emphasize the restaurant's atmosphere and service as elements contributing to the overall outstanding experience. Despite location or awards not being specified, the reviews speak volumes about Morcilla's commitment to Spanish cuisine, making it an unmissable dining destination.

A photo of Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse - Pittsburgh restaurant

8. Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse - Pittsburgh

4.7

Exceptional(2227)

Price: Expensive

• American • Downtown

Booked 58 times today

Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse, based in Pittsburgh, is an outstanding choice for Steakhouse cuisine, highly lauded in customer reviews for its excellent food and service. The restaurant consistently impresses with its impeccable steaks, cooked to absolute perfection, and its flavorful soups, with memorable touches such as Brussels sprouts with bacon marmalade and potatoes Gruyère gratin. The staff, including servers DJ and Ashley and manager Jeffrey, are praised for their exceptional hospitality. Patrons appreciate the restaurant's ability to create an ideal dining atmosphere, whether it's accommodating their preference for a quieter area or celebrating special occasions. Given its consistently high ratings, customers recommend Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse to anyone seeking a high-end dining experience in Pittsburgh.

9. Fig & Ash

4.7

Exceptional(2067)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Northside

Booked 23 times today

Fig & Ash is a leading purveyor of Contemporary American cuisine, impressing customers with its inventive and deliciously prepared dishes. Reviewers laud it as their favorite place for a "sublime experience," where the flavors, textures, and temperatures of the meals are unmatched. Noteworthy dishes include the woodfired heirloom carrots, pork chop, and the strip steak, each celebrated for their perfect execution. Diners also praise the restaurant's "flawless" service, stating their needs are anticipated and catered to with utmost precision. With its lively ambiance, Fig & Ash also offers different dining areas each with its unique character, ensuring a memorable dining experience is guaranteed on each visit. This restaurant clearly surpasses expectations in terms of food, service, and atmosphere, making it an essential destination for lovers of Contemporary American cuisine.

A photo of The Capital Grille - Pittsburgh restaurant

10. The Capital Grille - Pittsburgh

4.9

Exceptional(4181)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Downtown

Booked 46 times today

The Capital Grille in Pittsburgh, often referred to as the city's best steakhouse, is praised for its exceptional service and high-quality meals. Many customer reviews emphasize the restaurant's attentive, knowledgeable waitstaff and the upscale ambience that enhances every dining experience. Patrons often leave feeling delighted and satisfied by the establishment's well-prepared steaks and broad selection of wines. The restaurant is also known for its generosity in celebrations, preparing small surprise treats for special occasions. Whether it's a casual lunch or a special celebration, The Capital Grille offers an unforgettable steakhouse experience, maintaining its standing as a beloved local dining destination.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

Shadyside

American