Best American Restaurants in Sharpsburg

An Unforgettable Evening at Capital Grille From the moment we stepped into Capital Grille , it was clear we were in for an exceptional dining experience. This five-star establishment truly lives up to its reputation, delivering on every front from the elegant ambiance to the exquisite cuisine. Our server, Horacio, was an absolute standout and a significant contributor to our wonderful evening. He struck the perfect balance of attentiveness and discretion, always appearing precisely when needed without ever feeling intrusive. Horacio's knowledge of the menu, from the intricate preparation of each dish to the perfect wine pairings, was truly impressive. He offered insightful recommendations that elevated our meal, and his genuine enthusiasm for the food and wine was infectious. Beyond his professionalism, Horacio's warm and personable demeanor made us feel incredibly welcome and valued. And the food! Each course was a masterpiece of flavor and presentation. Every dish was a testament to the culinary team's skill and creativity. Overall, our dinner at Capital was an absolute delight. The combination of an impeccable setting, culinary artistry, and the outstanding service provided by Horacio made for a truly memorable evening. We highly recommend this restaurant to anyone seeking a top-tier dining experience.

Justin was our server and was excellent! He made our specialty cocktails and was very polite,friendly and accommodating to our dinner needs.

Good food, great service from Natalie. Anniversary treat was very nice.

Our hostess and servers were awesome. Our waiter was very knowledgeable and friendly. The food was outstanding. The Crispy Calamari was crisp and thin with an orange sauce at the bottom and some delicious creamy sauce on top. There were a few slices of fried and crusted limes, which were delicious. I had the Seafood Tasting, which was cook to perfection and resting on a bed of pea pure and lentils al dente, which was awesome. My wife had the Ricotta Cavatelli, which was very tasty too. We shared the Carrot Cake for dessert, which was like a cake with a thin outside layer of something like a cheese cake and the carrot cake inside with crispy walnuts. The bill was surprisingly reasonable. We will most definitely go back when we return to Pittsburgh.

We had a wonderful meal at the Commoner. The atmosphere was lovely with good lighting. Out food was delicious. I highly recommend the spicy crab dish. It was incredibly flavorful and great to share. Our server, George, was professional and attentive. We really couldn’t ask for more. We will certainly return our next trip to Pittsburgh