Best American Restaurants in Rapid City

Price: Moderate (6)Price: Expensive (3)

9 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Tally's Silver Spoon restaurant

1. Tally's Silver Spoon

4.6

Exceptional(511)

Price: Expensive

• American • Rapid City

Booked 21 times today

Located in Rapid City, Tally's Silver Spoon is a gem in American cuisine. Patrons have showered praises for its innovative American dishes, as one reviewer notes, “I’d describe the cuisine as innovative American. The soups rotate and are excellent.” The dishes offered, from the Foie Gras starter to the Bison Maytag Marsala Mushroom pasta and the fried chicken, have been lauded for their exceptional taste and generous portions. The restaurant's "indecision menu" is a hit among customers, and the wine selection is also highly spoken of. The service is on par with Michelin-star restaurants, making dining at Tally’s Silver Spoon a remarkable culinary experience.

2. Delmonico Grill

4.2

Awesome(1397)

Price: Expensive

• American • Rapid City

Booked 17 times today

Delmonico Grill appears to be a high-end dining destination, well-respected for its distinctively American cuisine. Reviewers had exceptional experiences, with many hailing from different parts of the country, including California and Chicago. The mention of dishes like the Delmonico ribeye, Kona ribeye, and prime rib, all traditional American favorites, underscores the restaurant's commitment to American gastronomy. The recurring praises for their service, atmosphere, and quality of their food, even on busy nights, suggests a dedication to excellent customer service. One review highlighted the freshness of ingredients and the chefs' expertise. This, in combination with the 'cozy atmosphere,' and praises like 'best meal of our lives' and 'incredible', epitomizes the quintessential American dining experience. The Delmonico Grill is clearly a gem in the American culinary scene, cherished and appreciated by its guests for its outstanding food and service.

A photo of Murphy's Pub and Grill restaurant

3. Murphy's Pub and Grill

4.2

Awesome(359)

Price: Moderate

• American • Rapid City

Murphy's Pub and Grill stands out as a top-notch gastro pub. Reviewers applaud its delightful menu with options ranging from 'Fancy Fried Pickles' to 'Buffalo Meatloaf'. Its extensive wine list is admired by guests who enjoy pairing their meals with perfectly selected wines. A guest cited the 'Redneck Sausage Sampler' from the all-day menu, expressing high praise for its unique flavor profile. The restaurant is lauded for its fast and efficient service, creating a relaxed yet vibrant atmosphere. The unique fusion of traditional pub dishes and gourmet cuisine makes this restaurant a must-visit for anyone seeking an innovative gastro pub experience.

A photo of Dakotah Steakhouse restaurant

4. Dakotah Steakhouse

4.6

Exceptional(1784)

Price: Moderate

• American • Rapid City

Booked 21 times today

Dakotah Steakhouse is an acclaimed spot in Rapid City known for its exceptional Steakhouse cuisine. Reviewers repeatedly laud the restaurant for its variety of steaks, including both beef and bison selections. The meats are locally sourced, which speaks to its freshness and quality. One customer particularly commended the Ribeye for its flavor and tenderness. Also noted are Dakotah's Beef Tips which have also garnered high praise. Service and ambiance are additional points of pride for the steakhouse. The restaurant's atmosphere, which does not cram customers together, sets it apart from other establishments in the city. Dakotah Steakhouse is consistently described as a place offering superior service, great food, and a fabulous setting.

A photo of Sear Black Hills Steakhouse restaurant

5. Sear Black Hills Steakhouse

new

4.6

Exceptional(160)

Price: Expensive

• American • Rapid City

Booked 5 times today

Sear Black Hills Steakhouse, located in Rapid City, is lauded as a top contender in the Steakhouse cuisine category. Customers rave about the well-prepared steaks bursting with flavor and the mouth-watering sides, with many noting that the steak is cooked to perfection. A standout mention is the Sear bone-in rib eye, described as a flavor explosion. Complementing the food is the exceptional service, with servers who are prompt, professional, and knowledgeable about the menu. The relaxing ambiance and high-quality dining experience make Sear Black Hills Steakhouse a must-visit. The restaurant leaves customers eagerly looking forward to their next visit.

6. Gold Bison Grill

4.1

Excellent(88)

Price: Moderate

• American • Rapid City

The Gold Bison Grill, set in the lobby of the Holiday Inn, is a bastion of stellar American cuisine. Patrons laud their exceptional service, with many highlighting their courteous and attentive staff. The restaurant's food has received glowing reviews, with dishes such as the walleye and the ribs earning high marks for their excellence. The establishment is also noted for special occasions such as Mother's Day, with customers appreciating the great food, attentive service, and the live music enhancing the atmosphere on such occasions. Reviewers highly recommend the Gold Bison Grill for both locals and tourists, citing the great food, drinks, and perfect service.

A photo of Minerva's - Rapid City restaurant

7. Minerva's - Rapid City

4.5

Awesome(333)

Price: Moderate

• American • Rapid City

Booked 3 times today

Minerva's in Rapid City is a brilliant exemplar of contemporary American cuisine. Reviews rave about the excellent customer service and delicious food, underlining its status as a top-notch restaurant option. The menu offers a wide range of options, from a refined kids menu, to an expansive selection of wines. Diners have particularly commended dishes like Bison ribeye, the chicken stir fry and their unique take on the BLT. Meanwhile, the ambience of the restaurant is also praised, including the tasteful decor and comfortable chairs. Overall, Minerva's is a solid choice for a remarkable dining experience, be it a vacation meal, an anniversary dinner, or a casual get-together.

8. The Park

3.5

Very Good(12)

Price: Moderate

• American • Rapid City

Located in Rapid City, The Park restaurant is a shining gem of American cuisine. Many reviewers note the restaurant's beautifully designed upscale decor and atmosphere which complements the unique flavors of their food. Despite the menu being limited during its soft opening, customers rave about the delicious and generous appetizers, and the bourbon praline ice cream which is a major highlight. The Park offers an expansive buffet, pleasing even the most discerning diners with its delicious choices. The attentive waitstaff adds to the enjoyable dining experience. As the restaurant continues to grow and expand its staffing, it promises to be a cherished destination for American cuisine enthusiasts.

9. Old Chicago

4.2

Awesome(72)

Price: Moderate

• American • Rapid City

Booked 1 time today

Old Chicago Restaurant, a recent addition to Rapid City, boasts excellent American cuisine, particularly noted for their deep dish pizza and fried pickles. While some reviews call for more sauce, the majority applaud the quality of food and service. One reviewer stated that the "food was great, the waitress was great, and the beer was fantastic," emphasizing the wide selection and knowledgeability about the offer. Furthermore, this establishment is not only praised for its delicious food but also for its social commitment, seen in their support of the Black Hills Works opening fundraiser. Old Chicago guarantees an unforgettable American dining experience.

How is content generated

Discover best American restaurants in Rapid City

Discover the essence of American cuisine in Rapid City, South Dakota, where a diverse array of restaurants serves up a rich tapestry of flavors that cater to every palate. From steakhouses that perfect the art of the sear to contemporary eateries blending local ingredients with modern culinary techniques, Rapid City is a hub for food lovers seeking quality and variety. These establishments prioritize locally-sourced ingredients, ensuring that each dish not only tastes fresh but also supports local producers and reflects the region's culinary heritage. Visitors and locals alike rave about the exceptional service, the inviting atmospheres, and the innovative menus that make dining in Rapid City a memorable experience. Whether you're looking for a family-friendly environment, an upscale dining experience, or a cozy gastro pub, Rapid City’s American dining scene offers something special for everyone. This city’s commitment to maintaining high culinary standards and creating welcoming spaces for diners underscores its reputation as a premier destination for authentic American cuisine.

Explore OpenTable

Rapid City

American