Mystic Restaurants

Make a free reservation

View all 31153 restaurants in New York Area

Best American Restaurants in Mystic

Oyster ClubOyster Club
(1646)
$$$$
American | Mystic, Connecticut
Engine RoomEngine Room
(388)
$$$$
American | Mystic, Connecticut
Winvian FarmsWinvian Farms
(83)
$$$$
American | Morris, Connecticut
The Schoolhouse at CannondaleThe Schoolhouse at Cannondale
(1357)
$$$$
American | Wilton, Connecticut
Millwright'sMillwright's
(1263)
$$$$
American | Simsbury, Connecticut
Present CompanyPresent Company
(411)
$$$$
American | Simsbury, Connecticut
Café RoutierCafé Routier
(1405)
$$$$
American | Westbrook, Connecticut
Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar, Stamford CTPrime: An American Kitchen & Bar, Stamford CT
(283)
$$$$
American | Stamford, Connecticut
South EndSouth End
(467)
$$$$
American | New Canaan, Connecticut
Grant's Restaurant and BarGrant's Restaurant and Bar
(1434)
$$$$
American | Hartford / West Hartford, Connecticut
Division WestDivision West
(226)
$$$$
American | Hartford / West Hartford, Connecticut
Artisan - West HartfordArtisan - West Hartford
(122)
$$$$
American | Hartford / West Hartford, Connecticut
Washington PrimeWashington Prime
(293)
$$$$
American | South Norwalk, Connecticut
Stonebridge RestaurantStonebridge Restaurant
(536)
$$$$
American | Milford, Connecticut
Bar Americain at Mohegan SunBar Americain at Mohegan Sun
(2071)
$$$$
American | Uncasville, Connecticut

Best Italian Restaurants in Mystic

AssaggioAssaggio
(28)
$$$$
Italian | Branford, Connecticut
Tarantino RestaurantTarantino Restaurant
(161)
$$$$
Italian | Westport, Connecticut
Bricco Restaurant - West HartfordBricco Restaurant - West Hartford
(295)
$$$$
Italian | Hartford / West Hartford, Connecticut
Osteria RomanaOsteria Romana
(84)
$$$$
Italian | Westport, Connecticut
TerraSole RistoranteTerraSole Ristorante
(649)
$$$$
Italian | Ridgefield, Connecticut
ApplausiApplausi
(195)
$$$$
Italian | Old Greenwich, Connecticut
Quattro PazziQuattro Pazzi
(294)
$$$$
Italian | Stamford, Connecticut
Valbella ConnecticutValbella Connecticut
(458)
$$$$
Italian | Riverside, Connecticut
Il PalioIl Palio
(803)
$$$$
Italian | Shelton, Connecticut
Carbone's RistoranteCarbone's Ristorante
(521)
$$$$
Italian | Hartford / West Hartford, Connecticut
Ballo Italian RestaurantBallo Italian Restaurant
(3078)
$$$$
Italian | Uncasville, Connecticut
Columbus Park TrattoriaColumbus Park Trattoria
(76)
$$$$
Italian | Stamford, Connecticut
Rustica Ristorante - ChesterRustica Ristorante - Chester
(579)
$$$$
Italian | Chester, Connecticut
Osteria RomanaOsteria Romana
(112)
$$$$
Italian | Monroe, Connecticut, Connecticut
Bricco TrattoriaBricco Trattoria
(1347)
$$$$
Italian | Glastonbury, Connecticut

Popular restaurants in New York Area

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in New York Area

HAVEN Riverfront Restaurant and Bar
(174)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Edgewater
Smoke Jazz and Supper Club
(102)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Upper West Side
Serafina 105
(134)
$$$$
Italian | Upper West Side
View all New York Area restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Mystic restaurants.

Mystic Restaurants

Oyster ClubOyster Club
1646 reviews
$$$$
American | Mystic, Connecticut

As usual, the food and service was spot on. Everything was done amazingly efficiently and the new hostess was bright and cheerful and a breathe of fresh air. Our server was wonderful and the food was outstanding. We will be back... again! More

OpenTable Diner -
Engine RoomEngine Room
388 reviews
$$$$
American | Mystic, Connecticut

Jackie was an outstanding server. We started with fried brussel sprouts w. mushroom salt, sherry reduction & house made creme fraiche. AMAZING. The Double Randy, two 3oz Beriah Lewis beef patties, bibb lettuce, american cheese & happy sauce was perfect. Unfortunately for me The Grass Fed,Lewis Family Farm grass fed beef w. house cured bacon, pimento cheese & whiskey pickles came out cold. My wife ordered her burger well done, so I'm sure my burger sat under a heat lamp. Jackie offered to heat it up or make me a new one, but I never send food back as I don't want to anger the kitchen staff. I ate it as it's a great burger.I spoke to the manager and to my surprise she took it off the check. I have been here before and everything was always perfect. Tonight was still a 4 1/2 star experience. We will be back. More

OpenTable Diner -
Go Fish RestaurantGo Fish Restaurant
294 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Mystic, Connecticut

Reasonable wine list, and great hot bread and bean spread. We each just had soup and the salad with salmon, both were good especially the salad. Service was quick and attentive. More

OpenTable Diner -
Chapter OneChapter One
91 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Mystic, Connecticut

We found you in Yelp and it was a great time with friends. Good food, pleasant service! More

OpenTable Diner -
Latitude 41Latitude 41
623 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Mystic, Connecticut

Alanna was a wonderful server and she was even training a new server that night. Started with Oysters and split a small Ceasar, which was really quite large. Both were great. Also a Shrimp Bruschetta which was just OK, as it was chopped pieces of shrimp which got lost in the peppers and tomato.For dinner The Lobster Pot Pie was tremendous, but the Bourbon Seared Scallops were disappointing as the brussel sprouts were boiled or cooked in a pan,very mushy.They are always better when grilled and crunchy, but that's just a personal choice. The Monkey Fist dessert was a winner. If I could I would give a 4 1/2 star rating. We will be back. More

OpenTable Diner -
4 Roosevelt Asian Bistro4 Roosevelt Asian Bistro
Reviews Coming Soon
$$$$
Asian | Mystic, Connecticut

Please return soon for more information on 4 Roosevelt Asian Bistro located at 4 Roosevelt Ave, Mystic, CT.More

Mystic Diners' Choice Winners

Mystic's best restaurants based upon thousands of OpenTable diner reviews
Oyster ClubOyster Club
1646 reviews
$$$$
American | Mystic, Connecticut

As usual, the food and service was spot on. Everything was done amazingly efficiently and the new hostess was bright and cheerful and a breathe of fresh air. Our server was wonderful and the food was outstanding. We will be back... again! More

OpenTable Diner -
Engine RoomEngine Room
388 reviews
$$$$
American | Mystic, Connecticut

Jackie was an outstanding server. We started with fried brussel sprouts w. mushroom salt, sherry reduction & house made creme fraiche. AMAZING. The Double Randy, two 3oz Beriah Lewis beef patties, bibb lettuce, american cheese & happy sauce was perfect. Unfortunately for me The Grass Fed,Lewis Family Farm grass fed beef w. house cured bacon, pimento cheese & whiskey pickles came out cold. My wife ordered her burger well done, so I'm sure my burger sat under a heat lamp. Jackie offered to heat it up or make me a new one, but I never send food back as I don't want to anger the kitchen staff. I ate it as it's a great burger.I spoke to the manager and to my surprise she took it off the check. I have been here before and everything was always perfect. Tonight was still a 4 1/2 star experience. We will be back. More

OpenTable Diner -
Go Fish RestaurantGo Fish Restaurant
294 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Mystic, Connecticut

Reasonable wine list, and great hot bread and bean spread. We each just had soup and the salad with salmon, both were good especially the salad. Service was quick and attentive. More

OpenTable Diner -
Latitude 41Latitude 41
623 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Mystic, Connecticut

Alanna was a wonderful server and she was even training a new server that night. Started with Oysters and split a small Ceasar, which was really quite large. Both were great. Also a Shrimp Bruschetta which was just OK, as it was chopped pieces of shrimp which got lost in the peppers and tomato.For dinner The Lobster Pot Pie was tremendous, but the Bourbon Seared Scallops were disappointing as the brussel sprouts were boiled or cooked in a pan,very mushy.They are always better when grilled and crunchy, but that's just a personal choice. The Monkey Fist dessert was a winner. If I could I would give a 4 1/2 star rating. We will be back. More

OpenTable Diner -
Chapter OneChapter One
91 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Mystic, Connecticut

We found you in Yelp and it was a great time with friends. Good food, pleasant service! More

OpenTable Diner -