Best American Restaurants in Mystic

Oyster ClubOyster Club
(1606)
$$$$
American | Mystic, Connecticut
Engine RoomEngine Room
(372)
$$$$
American | Mystic, Connecticut
Winvian FarmsWinvian Farms
(81)
$$$$
American | Morris, Connecticut
The Schoolhouse at CannondaleThe Schoolhouse at Cannondale
(1335)
$$$$
American | Wilton, Connecticut
Present CompanyPresent Company
(377)
$$$$
American | Simsbury, Connecticut
Millwright'sMillwright's
(1223)
$$$$
American | Simsbury, Connecticut
Café RoutierCafé Routier
(1387)
$$$$
American | Westbrook, Connecticut
Mill Street Bar & TableMill Street Bar & Table
(326)
$$$$
American | Greenwich, Connecticut
South EndSouth End
(459)
$$$$
American | New Canaan, Connecticut
Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar, Stamford CTPrime: An American Kitchen & Bar, Stamford CT
(259)
$$$$
American | Stamford, Connecticut
Grant's Restaurant and BarGrant's Restaurant and Bar
(1409)
$$$$
American | Hartford / West Hartford, Connecticut
Artisan - West HartfordArtisan - West Hartford
(89)
$$$$
American | Hartford / West Hartford, Connecticut
Washington PrimeWashington Prime
(278)
$$$$
American | South Norwalk, Connecticut
The J House RestaurantThe J House Restaurant
(205)
$$$$
American | Greenwich, Connecticut

Best Italian Restaurants in Mystic

Tarantino RestaurantTarantino Restaurant
(155)
$$$$
Italian | Westport, Connecticut
Bricco Restaurant - West HartfordBricco Restaurant - West Hartford
(267)
$$$$
Italian | Hartford / West Hartford, Connecticut
Rustica Ristorante - ChesterRustica Ristorante - Chester
(571)
$$$$
Italian | Chester, Connecticut
Carbone's RistoranteCarbone's Ristorante
(501)
$$$$
Italian | Hartford / West Hartford, Connecticut
Valbella ConnecticutValbella Connecticut
(448)
$$$$
Italian | Riverside, Connecticut
Columbus Park TrattoriaColumbus Park Trattoria
(70)
$$$$
Italian | Stamford, Connecticut
Quattro PazziQuattro Pazzi
(281)
$$$$
Italian | Stamford, Connecticut
ApplausiApplausi
(186)
$$$$
Italian | Old Greenwich, Connecticut
Ballo Italian RestaurantBallo Italian Restaurant
(2979)
$$$$
Italian | Uncasville, Connecticut
Il PalioIl Palio
(779)
$$$$
Italian | Shelton, Connecticut
Osteria RomanaOsteria Romana
(104)
$$$$
Italian | Monroe, Connecticut, Connecticut
Louie's Italian Restaurant and BarLouie's Italian Restaurant and Bar
(346)
$$$$
Italian | Greenwich, Connecticut
Bricco TrattoriaBricco Trattoria
(1306)
$$$$
Italian | Glastonbury, Connecticut
TrevaTreva
(1242)
$$$$
Italian | Hartford / West Hartford, Connecticut
Tarry Lodge Enoteca and Pizzeria - New HavenTarry Lodge Enoteca and Pizzeria - New Haven
(684)
$$$$
Italian | New Haven, Connecticut

Popular restaurants in New York Area

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in New York Area

HAVEN Riverfront Restaurant and Bar
(194)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Edgewater
Smoke Jazz and Supper Club
(247)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Upper West Side
Mitchell's Fish Market - Edgewater
(91)
$$$$
Seafood | Edgewater
Serafina 105
(121)
$$$$
Italian | Upper West Side
View all New York Area restaurants
Mystic Locals Are Talking About
What are some fun things to do in Mystic?
You have to stop in Curated, the little gallery on Main Street.
OT
OpenTable Diner - Denver
What’s great about the dining scene in Mystic?
outside dining gives great views of river and sunsets
L
Lenny - New York Area
What do you love most about Mystic?
The Cottrell Street green that overlooks the river, and the boardwalk!
J
Jade - New York Area

Treat your taste buds: Explore Mystic restaurants.

Mystic Restaurants

Oyster ClubOyster Club
1606 reviews
$$$$
American | Mystic, Connecticut

Dan Meiser and his team provide an amazing fare. Farm to table ensures wonderful quality. The recipe's are creative. Awesome oysters. Great wine selection, by the glass and by the bottle. My favorite restaurant in the area. More

OpenTable Diner -
Engine RoomEngine Room
372 reviews
$$$$
American | Mystic, Connecticut

We shared a delicious Flintstone Ribeye. The steak was excellent. The Caesar salad could have been more flavorful. The dressing tasted bland. More

OpenTable Diner -
Latitude 41Latitude 41
618 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Mystic, Connecticut

We went to celebrate my birthday and ate in the tavern. I was surprised that it wasn’t busy at all on a Friday night - there was no one in the dining room. My husband had the fish and chips and I had the stuffed pork chops. Both were excellent! Music was awesome, as was the service. This may become our new favorite! More

OpenTable Diner -
Go Fish RestaurantGo Fish Restaurant
281 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Mystic, Connecticut

I ordered a tuna entree, and in my opinion would have been beat over white rice instead of yellow rice. Besides that it was great. More

OpenTable Diner -
Chapter OneChapter One
81 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Mystic, Connecticut

Though a martini served in a water glass was different, the food here is too good to find fault with anything. Everything was very tasty. This is now going to be one of our favorite spots when in the Mystic area. More

OpenTable Diner -
4 Roosevelt Asian Bistro4 Roosevelt Asian Bistro
Reviews Coming Soon
$$$$
Asian | Mystic, Connecticut

Please return soon for more information on 4 Roosevelt Asian Bistro located at 4 Roosevelt Ave, Mystic, CT.More

Mystic Diners' Choice Winners

Mystic's best restaurants based upon thousands of OpenTable diner reviews
Oyster ClubOyster Club
1606 reviews
$$$$
American | Mystic, Connecticut

Dan Meiser and his team provide an amazing fare. Farm to table ensures wonderful quality. The recipe's are creative. Awesome oysters. Great wine selection, by the glass and by the bottle. My favorite restaurant in the area. More

OpenTable Diner -
Engine RoomEngine Room
372 reviews
$$$$
American | Mystic, Connecticut

We shared a delicious Flintstone Ribeye. The steak was excellent. The Caesar salad could have been more flavorful. The dressing tasted bland. More

OpenTable Diner -
Go Fish RestaurantGo Fish Restaurant
281 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Mystic, Connecticut

I ordered a tuna entree, and in my opinion would have been beat over white rice instead of yellow rice. Besides that it was great. More

OpenTable Diner -
Latitude 41Latitude 41
618 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Mystic, Connecticut

We went to celebrate my birthday and ate in the tavern. I was surprised that it wasn’t busy at all on a Friday night - there was no one in the dining room. My husband had the fish and chips and I had the stuffed pork chops. Both were excellent! Music was awesome, as was the service. This may become our new favorite! More

OpenTable Diner -
Chapter OneChapter One
81 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Mystic, Connecticut

Though a martini served in a water glass was different, the food here is too good to find fault with anything. Everything was very tasty. This is now going to be one of our favorite spots when in the Mystic area. More

OpenTable Diner -