Mystic Restaurants

Make a free reservation

View all 31681 restaurants in New York Area

Best American Restaurants in Mystic

Oyster ClubOyster Club
(1872)
$$$$
American | Mystic, Connecticut
Engine RoomEngine Room
(496)
$$$$
American | Mystic, Connecticut
Harbour House - Inn at MysticHarbour House - Inn at Mystic
(324)
$$$$
American | Mystic, Connecticut
Winvian FarmWinvian Farm
(97)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Morris, Connecticut
The Schoolhouse at CannondaleThe Schoolhouse at Cannondale
(1435)
$$$$
American | Wilton, Connecticut
Millwright'sMillwright's
(1418)
$$$$
American | Simsbury, Connecticut
Present CompanyPresent Company
(522)
$$$$
American | Simsbury, Connecticut
Bailey's BackyardBailey's Backyard
(380)
$$$$
American | Ridgefield, Connecticut
Café RoutierCafé Routier
(1508)
$$$$
American | Westbrook, Connecticut
Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar, Stamford CTPrime: An American Kitchen & Bar, Stamford CT
(409)
$$$$
American | Stamford, Connecticut
South EndSouth End
(508)
$$$$
American | New Canaan, Connecticut
Grant's Restaurant and BarGrant's Restaurant and Bar
(1520)
$$$$
American | Hartford / West Hartford, Connecticut
Division WestDivision West
(226)
$$$$
American | Hartford / West Hartford, Connecticut
Artisan - West HartfordArtisan - West Hartford
(257)
$$$$
American | Hartford / West Hartford, Connecticut
Washington PrimeWashington Prime
(341)
$$$$
American | South Norwalk, Connecticut
Stonebridge RestaurantStonebridge Restaurant
(588)
$$$$
American | Milford, Connecticut
Bar Americain at Mohegan SunBar Americain at Mohegan Sun
(2238)
$$$$
American | Uncasville, Connecticut

Best Italian Restaurants in Mystic

AssaggioAssaggio
(75)
$$$$
Italian | Branford, Connecticut
Tarantino RestaurantTarantino Restaurant
(179)
$$$$
Italian | Westport, Connecticut
Bricco Restaurant - West HartfordBricco Restaurant - West Hartford
(393)
$$$$
Italian | Hartford / West Hartford, Connecticut
Osteria RomanaOsteria Romana
(101)
$$$$
Italian | Westport, Connecticut
TerraSole RistoranteTerraSole Ristorante
(713)
$$$$
Italian | Ridgefield, Connecticut
ApplausiApplausi
(233)
$$$$
Italian | Old Greenwich, Connecticut
Quattro PazziQuattro Pazzi
(333)
$$$$
Italian | Stamford, Connecticut
Valbella ConnecticutValbella Connecticut
(513)
$$$$
Italian | Riverside, Connecticut
Il PalioIl Palio
(886)
$$$$
Italian | Shelton, Connecticut
Carbone's RistoranteCarbone's Ristorante
(617)
$$$$
Italian | Hartford / West Hartford, Connecticut
Ballo Italian RestaurantBallo Italian Restaurant
(3485)
$$$$
Italian | Uncasville, Connecticut
Columbus Park TrattoriaColumbus Park Trattoria
(100)
$$$$
Italian | Stamford, Connecticut
Rustica Ristorante - ChesterRustica Ristorante - Chester
(636)
$$$$
Italian | Chester, Connecticut, Connecticut
Osteria RomanaOsteria Romana
(166)
$$$$
Italian | Monroe, Connecticut, Connecticut
Bricco TrattoriaBricco Trattoria
(1476)
$$$$
Italian | Glastonbury, Connecticut

Popular restaurants in New York Area

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in New York Area

HAVEN Riverfront Restaurant and Bar
(390)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Edgewater
Serafina 105
(110)
$$$$
Italian | Upper West Side
Smoke Jazz and Supper Club
(291)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Upper West Side
View all New York Area restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Mystic restaurants.

Mystic Restaurants

Oyster ClubOyster Club
1872 reviews
$$$$
American | Mystic, Connecticut

We enjoyed our anniversary dinner at Oyster Club on Wednesday night. Our server, Dru, was so lovely and accommodating. The food was unbelievable- my husband is still dreaming about the New York Strip Steak. This restaurant is consistently delicious with top-notch servers. The manager made a point to wish us a Happy Anniversary with some bubbles to start. It was such a special night. Thank you to all from the kitchen to the front who made it so perfect! More

OpenTable Diner -
Engine RoomEngine Room
496 reviews
$$$$
American | Mystic, Connecticut

Awesome. Great job. More

OpenTable Diner -
Latitude 41Latitude 41
694 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Mystic, Connecticut

An excellent restaurant week menu. Not just a choice of three appetizers and three entrees and two desserts. Real good variety. It was a bit loud, but there was a wedding reception and another large group. Not a big deal. Didn't need to scream across the table. More

OpenTable Diner -
Harbour House - Inn at MysticHarbour House - Inn at Mystic
324 reviews
$$$$
American | Mystic, Connecticut

See all specials

We came upon the Inn @ Mystic while en route from Newport RI to New London Ferry and very happy we did (thank you OpenTable for always helping us find favorites!). Such a pretty historic Inn with a wonderful pub style restaurant on one side and dining room option on the other. Staff were very pleasant and nice selection of draft beer. Will definitely return! More

OpenTable Diner -
Go Fish RestaurantGo Fish Restaurant
352 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Mystic, Connecticut

We went to Go Fish for the Mystic Restaurant week menu. Go Fish had a special sushi menu for $25 that had more than enough food and sushi on it to satisfy even my hungry husband. We went early at 5:30 and it wasn't crowded at all. It also was very easy to have a conversation in the restaurant, soft music and good acoustics for talking. The first course, miso soup was excellent, with enoki mushrooms, seaweed and tofu. It wasn't too salty either. The main course was one whole special roll and 3 other smaller rolls. There was also tofu stuffed with rice which was filling. Good wasabi, pickled ginger and an excellent seaweed salad too. Then the dessert I picked was creme brulee which was excellent with a nice crackly crust. My husband had the brownie with vanilla ice cream and it looked really good. I think Go Fish has the best sushi around, so this is an excellent value. More

OpenTable Diner -
Chapter OneChapter One
127 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Mystic, Connecticut

Food was excellent. Space was cozy. Staff was friendly and responsive. More

OpenTable Diner -
RICERICE
1 review
$$$$
Asian | Mystic, Connecticut

A little hard to find as they changed there name but dont judge a book by its cover. Building looks old and run down but the place is really good food and sevice More

OpenTable Diner -

Mystic Diners' Choice Winners

Mystic's best restaurants based upon thousands of OpenTable diner reviews
Oyster ClubOyster Club
1872 reviews
$$$$
American | Mystic, Connecticut

We enjoyed our anniversary dinner at Oyster Club on Wednesday night. Our server, Dru, was so lovely and accommodating. The food was unbelievable- my husband is still dreaming about the New York Strip Steak. This restaurant is consistently delicious with top-notch servers. The manager made a point to wish us a Happy Anniversary with some bubbles to start. It was such a special night. Thank you to all from the kitchen to the front who made it so perfect! More

OpenTable Diner -
Engine RoomEngine Room
496 reviews
$$$$
American | Mystic, Connecticut

Awesome. Great job. More

OpenTable Diner -
Latitude 41Latitude 41
694 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Mystic, Connecticut

An excellent restaurant week menu. Not just a choice of three appetizers and three entrees and two desserts. Real good variety. It was a bit loud, but there was a wedding reception and another large group. Not a big deal. Didn't need to scream across the table. More

OpenTable Diner -
Harbour House - Inn at MysticHarbour House - Inn at Mystic
324 reviews
$$$$
American | Mystic, Connecticut

See all specials

We came upon the Inn @ Mystic while en route from Newport RI to New London Ferry and very happy we did (thank you OpenTable for always helping us find favorites!). Such a pretty historic Inn with a wonderful pub style restaurant on one side and dining room option on the other. Staff were very pleasant and nice selection of draft beer. Will definitely return! More

OpenTable Diner -
Go Fish RestaurantGo Fish Restaurant
352 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Mystic, Connecticut

We went to Go Fish for the Mystic Restaurant week menu. Go Fish had a special sushi menu for $25 that had more than enough food and sushi on it to satisfy even my hungry husband. We went early at 5:30 and it wasn't crowded at all. It also was very easy to have a conversation in the restaurant, soft music and good acoustics for talking. The first course, miso soup was excellent, with enoki mushrooms, seaweed and tofu. It wasn't too salty either. The main course was one whole special roll and 3 other smaller rolls. There was also tofu stuffed with rice which was filling. Good wasabi, pickled ginger and an excellent seaweed salad too. Then the dessert I picked was creme brulee which was excellent with a nice crackly crust. My husband had the brownie with vanilla ice cream and it looked really good. I think Go Fish has the best sushi around, so this is an excellent value. More

OpenTable Diner -
Chapter OneChapter One
127 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Mystic, Connecticut

Food was excellent. Space was cozy. Staff was friendly and responsive. More

OpenTable Diner -