The Dining Room at Castle Hill Inn
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Limited number of seated diners
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Meyer Lemon Soufflé
Olive sablé, lemoncello anglaise
Miso gratinee, citrus, phytoplankton tempura
Dry Aged Beef Ribeye
Potato pave, winter greens,cognac-peppercorn sauce
Amazing! Food and service was top notch, we’ll be going back.
We had Alex as our waitress. we LOVE Alex!!! she was awesome and funny and she even stuffed our own blue cheese olives (sorry again if you see this LOL)
The lamb tasting shoulder cut was inedible.
This used to be the best restaurant on the island.
Great service and great view, no better place for a special occasion dinner in my opinion
Our server Carl was outstanding. His knowledge of the menu and wine list allowed us to expand our pallets. Overall, a wonderful dinner experience.
Amazing service and food! Absolutely blown away by everything castle hill had to offer
Gorgeous setting, delicious food with superior service provided by courteous, pleasant, attractive and knowledgeable staff. Will make multiple reservations now for the coming summer!
Amazing all around!
Absolutely loved this experience! The food was delicious, the ambiance was perfect for an intimate date, and the service was wonderful. The team is so kind and attentive. 10/10, would recommend.
Diligent and knowledgeable wait staff, and the food was spectacular. We ate in the sunset room which was cozy and romantic. The Covid barriers did not distract from the ambiance, in fact it allows for conversation privacy. This was not our first time dining here and will not be our last.
Thank you Anthony. We are glad you enjoyed and happy to know our measures for safety did not affect the atmosphere. We look forward to serving you again soon.
Great food and service. Very nice place. Will definitely come back.
Thank you. Your positive review means a lot to us.
Highly recommend this location for dinner to anyone. We spent our first meal together after we got engaged. The waiters and hostesses were very friendly giving us champagne immediately to celebrate. The service, food and wine selection was fantastic. I would totally come back again!
Thank you John. We are honored to have earned your recommendation and thrilled you could celebrate your engagement with us. We hope you'll both come visit us again. Congratulations!
We came in for my wife's birthday. It was a tasting menu that provided a few options for appetizers and entrees and it was absolutely amazing!
Great place for celebration or date night.
Will definitely going back.
Castle Hill offered a unique dining experience, with excellent staff who were very attentive and friendly throughout the night. the meals we had were great and with the offered courses with breads in between the portions were very satisfying. great atmosphere, and hope to be back in the summer to enjoy the ocean views.
Castle Hill never disappoints. It is a real treat to dine there.
Thank you! We love what we do and we are glad our guests feel will taken care of.
What a wonderful experience, one of the best dinners i have ever had. Will be returning!
Valentine’s Day early
Wonderful dining experience as we celebrated my birthday. The food is always superb and the waitstaff are very attentive without interrupting the flow of the evening. Kudos!
Thank you! We are very happy you enjoyed it all.
We came to celebrate our engagement. They did a wonderful job of putting us at a great table in a quiet and romantic space. The food is excellent, the service was impeccable, and we had a wonderful evening there
Thank you for celebrating such a special moment with us. We are glad you both enjoyed and congratulations!
We were so happy that we made dinner plans at the dining room at Castle Hill. It was a very inviting and warm atmosphere. Our the wait staff was knowledgeable and friendly and attentive. Everything we would want in a dining experience. Thank you for making a special night that much more memorable!
We are happy you made those plans too! Thank you for the review and we are so glad you had such a special night.
We came here for anniversary it never disappoints
Amazing dinner and excellent service. Dan was a fantastic waiter. The passion fruit soufflé was incredible. Tables were spread out and we felt very safe. Can’t wait to go back.
Such a wonderful dining experience. Everything was perfect.
A perfect choice for my birthday celebration! Excellent service.
The service and staff are what makes it to amazing. We’ll continue to enjoy future dinners there.
This pre-fixe meal was outstanding. Beautifully prepared and presented. Dan our server was very attentive and provide wonderful information to enhance our meal.
Just cant give a 5 star during COVID - otherwise, fantastic.
Absolutely impeccable food and service!!
So many great memories. The food is excellent, ambience is top notch and overall is a great experience.
Alex was amazing! Super knowledgeable and friendly. 10/10 would recommend.
I would have rated them higher but there were timing issues with our entrees. At these prices you don't expect to have these sorts of issues,
Everything was perfect except a woman with a very loud voice talking "shop" for the whole room to hear. Not Castle Hill's fault to be sure, but it took away from the otherwise perfect night and ambience.
Carl and the food were incredible as always!
Attention to detail. Good food selection. Ambiance galore. We enjoy this restaurant immensely.
From start to finish, Carl led us through an awesome set of courses paired with wine that was right on. A great night!
Wonderful dining experience
Wonderful meal and service
Delightful experience as always.
The Dining Room at Castle Hill Inn is rated 4.9 stars by 2254 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.