The American Hotel

Name: The American Hotel
Address: 45 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY, United States, 11963
Telephone: (631) 725-3535
Price range: $50 and over
Rating: 4.6

4.6

634 Reviews

$50 and over

French

Top Tags:

The American Hotel is one of the few historic hotels remaining in the United States. Here, visitors can come and visit and take a trip back in time to the mid-1920s when smoking rooms and jackets were commonplace among velvet furniture and strong whiskey served on the rocks. During the summertime.
Of course, The American Hotel is more than just a hotel, it houses an excellent restaurant as well. There are multiple dining areas depending on what kind of experience guests are looking for. The Main Dining Room is a lively and rambunctious room that holds about 80 people while the Drew Room is a quieter, more private area for those looking for an intimate evening. The food is quintessential American cuisine from across the United States.

Not available on OpenTable

Unfortunately, this restaurant is not on the OpenTable reservation network.

If you like, we'll notify you by email if this restaurant joins.

Is this your restaurant?

Claim this listing

Order delivery or takeout

Additional information

Dining style
Fine Dining
Price
$50 and over
Cuisines
French, American, Seafood
Hours of operation
Breakfast Sat, Sun 8:00 am–10:45 am Lunch Daily 11:30 am–4:00 pm Dinner Mon–Thu, Sun 4:00 pm–9:00 pm Fri, Sat 4:00 pm–9:45 pm
Phone number
(631) 725-3535
Website
http://theamericanhotel.com/
Payment options
AMEX, Diners Club, Discover, JCB, Mastercard, Visa
Dress code
Smart Casual
Private party contact
Mary Ferrara: (631) 725-3535

Location
45 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Neighborhood
Sag Harbor
Cross street
Bay Street
Parking details
Street Parking
Additional
Beer, Cafe, Cocktails, Corkage Fee, Full Bar, Indoor Fireplace, Non-Smoking, Patio/Outdoor Dining, Patio/Outdoor Dining, Private Room, Takeout, Weekend Brunch, Wheelchair Access, Wine

Popular dishes

Bone Marrow$25.00
Toasted Baguette
Long Island Duckling Confit$26.00
Frisée, Vinaigrette
Terrine de Foie Gras Garni$23.00
Foie Gras Saute au Porto Branca*$40.00
Brandade de Morue$18.00
Extra-Virgin Olive Oil
Smoked Trout Garni$21.00
Fresh Horseradish Sauce
Champignons Sauvage on Brioche Toast$28.00
Smoked Scottish Salmon$28.00
with Garnishes and Toast Points

Shellfish

Blue Crab and Avocado Cocktail$28.00
Crab Cake$26.00
with Arugula
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail (5)$29.00
with Cocktail Sauce and Citrus Mayonnaise
Oysters Rockefeller (6)$28.00
Oysters Romanoff (6)$32.00
Gardiner's Bay Littleneck Clams*
- per 8$22.00
- per 12$28.00
Chris Coyne's 'Peeko' Peconic Oysters Mignonette*
- per 8$32.00
- per 12$42.00

Caviar

American White Sturgeon*
- 28g$90.00
Classic Osetra Sustainable*
- 28g$150.00
Classic Beluga Hybrid "Rumania"*
- 28g$215.00

Breakfast and Lunch

Omelets$26.00
Eggs Benedict*$28.00
Smoked Salmon Eggs Benedict*$28.00
Brandade de Morue*$28.00
with Poached Egg and Hollandaise
Brioche French Toast$26.00
with Berries and Maple Syrup

Sandwiches

Sandwiches are served with Cole Slaw and Potato Salad or Mixed Greens

Lobster B.L.T.$35.00
Duck Sandwich$29.00
Side of Lime Mayonnaise
Portobello Mushroom Grilled Veggie Sandwich$26.00
Triple-Decker Chicken Breast Club$28.00
Blue Crab Cake Burger$28.00
Croque Monsieur$26.00

Seafood

Jumbo Shrimps (5)$44.00
Sauce Beurre Blanc or en Salade
Scottish Salmon Grillé*$44.00
Champignons Vin Blanc or Salade à la Mala
Local Filet of Flounder$40.00
à la Meuniere or Amandine
Sesame Tuna à la Nage*$52.00
Atlantic Cod 'Fiorentina'$42.00
Peppercorn Crusted, Beurre Citron
Blue Claw Crab Cakes$44.00
North Atlantic Lobster$82.00
Steamed or Grilled
Lobster or Vegetable Risotto$50.00

Birds and Meat

Organic Chicken Paillard Grillé$39.00
Chicken and Shrimp Cobb Salad$34.00
Bacon, Avocado, Cucumber, Tomato, Poached Pear
Long Island Duckling Breast*$44.00
à l'Orange, Wild Rice
Australian Lamb Chops au Jus*$64.00
Sirloin Steak Bearnaise*
- 10oz$65.00
Sirloin Steak au Poivre*
- 10oz$65.00
Filet Mignon Maitre d'*
- 6oz$58.00
- 8oz$68.00
Tournedos Marchand de Vins*
- 8oz$72.00
Chef's Choice*
Seasonal Abats, Game or Provincial Classics

What 634 people are saying

Overall ratings and reviews

4.6

4.6 based on all time ratings

4.6Food
4.6Service
4.6Ambience
4.1Value

Noise • Moderate

634 Reviews

R
Rick
New York Area
1 review
5.0
1 review
Dined on February 17, 2023
overall5food5service5ambience5
Excellent service, wine list recommendation from sommelier and the food was equally as great
Is this helpful?
RM
RMC92
New York Area
38 reviews
vip
5.0
38 reviews
Dined on February 15, 2023
overall5food5service5ambience5
Valentines Day
Is this helpful?
LB
LBJ7
Washington DC
10 reviews
5.0
10 reviews
Dined on February 14, 2023
overall5food5service5ambience5
Classic cozy and excellent service. The food is wonderful. We are happy to sit in any of the rooms offered. Loved my long stemmed rose given to me upon arrival for Valentine’s dinner. Has been my favorite occasion and brunch place for 40 years!
Is this helpful?
PN
PeteN
New York Area
2 reviews
5.0
2 reviews
Dined on February 14, 2023
overall5food5service5ambience5
We sat in the bar area near the fireplace and were very comfortable. I don’t know how many people work there, but it seem like a thousand and the service was outstanding. We Started with a few oversize cocktails that were delicious. We ordered a bunch of different things and everything was amazing. Combine the food and the atmosphere… his is Highly recommend.
Is this helpful?
KW
KarenW
New York Area
1 review
5.0
1 review
Dined on February 12, 2023
overall5food5service5ambience5
It was a great experience the food was delicious and the service was outstanding . loved the atmosphere.
Is this helpful?
OT
OpenTable Diner
New York Area
4 reviews
5.0
4 reviews
Dined on February 12, 2023
overall5food5service5ambience5
Everything was incredible. Food, service, ambiance, everything was tremendous!!!
Is this helpful?
BA
BarbaraA
Greater Boston
4 reviews
vip
5.0
4 reviews
Dined on February 9, 2023
overall5food5service4ambience3
We had not been to the American Hotel in several years until a friend invited us to go about a month ago. We could not wait to go back and celebrated an early Valentine's date last night. The French onion soup gratinee was truly spectacular with a rich broth and lots of gooey cheese. We both had fish entrees that were perfectly cooked and served with a tasty and not overcooked array of veggies. The wine list is well-known and the sommeliere helped us choose a wonderful white Portuguese wine that was the perfect accompaniment to the meal. We finished with a shared chocolate mousse. We'll be back soon!
Is this helpful?
LP
LPeterX
New York Area
32 reviews
vip
5.0
32 reviews
Dined on February 4, 2023
overall5food5service5ambience5
Classic food - Done WELL Amazing room- Amazing service
Is this helpful?
V
Vanessa
New York Area
6 reviews
vip
5.0
6 reviews
Dined on January 28, 2023
overall5food5service5ambience5
The most spectacular service and dining experience in Sag Harbor, hands down!
Is this helpful?
M
Michaeld
New York Area
20 reviews
vip
5.0
20 reviews
Dined on January 21, 2023
overall5food5service5ambience5
Best restaurant in the Hamptons. Elegant, top service & delicious traditional menu!
Is this helpful?
L
Lovesanibel
New York Area
2 reviews
3.0
2 reviews
Dined on January 19, 2023
overall3food3service5ambience5
No lobsters for lobster special. Friend and i came especially for this promotion. Not available at 7 pm.
Is this helpful?
L
Laud
New York Area
1 review
5.0
1 review
Dined on January 19, 2023
overall5food5service5ambience5
Amazing meal and even better service! Crab and avocado appetizer and oysters Rockefeller were unreal.
Is this helpful?
BR
BayRidger
New York Area
54 reviews
vip
5.0
54 reviews
Dined on January 10, 2023
overall5food5service5ambience5
The American Hotel never disappoints. Lenny was the best and Vinny makes a mean martini. The beef Bourguignon and oysters Rockefeller were delish! Can’t wait to go back.
Is this helpful?
OT
OpenTable Diner
New York Area
4 reviews
5.0
4 reviews
Dined on January 9, 2023
overall5food5service5ambience5
A really enjoyable meal
Is this helpful?
BR
BillR
New York Area
3 reviews
5.0
3 reviews
Dined on January 8, 2023
overall5food5service5ambience5
Great staff and food was awesome
Is this helpful?
TH
TerriH
New York Area
22 reviews
vip
5.0
22 reviews
Dined on January 7, 2023
overall5food5service5ambience5
Always a wonderful evening of great food and service!
Is this helpful?
AR
AdamR
Atlanta Metro
1 review
5.0
1 review
Dined on January 3, 2023
overall5food5service5ambience5
Phenomenal food and service in a great space. Always great!
Is this helpful?
ML
MaryL
New York Area
8 reviews
vip
4.0
8 reviews
Dined on January 1, 2023
overall4food4service4ambience3
We’ve been dinning at American Hotel restaurant for over 10 years, and they are always consistently good!
Is this helpful?
CC
CC123
London
3 reviews
2.0
3 reviews
Dined on December 30, 2022
overall2food3service2ambience3
Our waiter was the usual uptight and pretentious type — which I’ve grown accustomed to over the years as a patron of the American Hotel. But if you are going to be stuck up and French, at least get the order right. I asked for white wine, he brought me red. I asked for green salad, he brought me potato salad. I asked for no Mayo, there was Mayo on the plate. Not going back anytime soon.
Is this helpful?
JO
JOHN
San Antonio
30 reviews
vip
5.0
30 reviews
Dined on December 29, 2022
overall5food5service5ambience5
Everything is delicious and the service is great. Love this place
Is this helpful?
c
carolmc
New York Area
21 reviews
vip
5.0
21 reviews
Dined on December 28, 2022
overall5food4service5ambience5
There is no place better on the East End than the American hotel for ambience and quality around the holidays!!
Is this helpful?
FS
FrancieS
New York Area
17 reviews
vip
5.0
17 reviews
Dined on December 26, 2022
overall5food5service5ambience5
We were sat right away, nice corner table. Food and service were great!
Is this helpful?
PC
PhelanC
New York Area
9 reviews
5.0
9 reviews
Dined on December 24, 2022
overall5food4service5ambience5
Service outstanding
Is this helpful?
RA
RANDOLPH
New York Area
29 reviews
vip
4.0
29 reviews
Dined on December 24, 2022
overall4food4service4ambience4
Excellent Christmas Spirit and lovely setting. Wine list was perfect and festive for the night too.
Is this helpful?
L
Logues
New York Area
2 reviews
5.0
2 reviews
Dined on December 21, 2022
overall5food5service5ambience5
Phenomenal experience as always! Highly recommend a visit!
Is this helpful?
MF
MichaelF
London
2 reviews
4.0
2 reviews
Dined on December 16, 2022
overall4food4service5ambience4
The food is excellent and the wait staff polite and friendly but the manners at the front desk need to be polished. It would seem to be basic protocol to look up from the reservation book or computer, look the arriving guests in the eye, make a polite remark such as "how are you?" and then escort to the table. The norm at The American Hotel (this goes back years) is to grunt "what's the name?" without making eye contact and then "follow me".
Is this helpful?
K
Knowsfood1
New York Area
123 reviews
vip
5.0
123 reviews
Dined on December 15, 2022
overall5food5service5ambience5
They deserve 5 stars. Consistently great French based, delicious, specialties like duck, flounder, and hard to find game, fish classics.
Is this helpful?
N
Netties15
New York Area
44 reviews
vip
5.0
44 reviews
Dined on December 14, 2022
overall5food5service5ambience5
Delicious fine dining. The lobster BLT sandwich is outstanding. Spinach salad was soo good. Rose wines to wash it all down. A perfect lunch enjoyed by my daughter and me to celebrate her birthday. Such a special place, such a perfect meal.
Is this helpful?
W
Wonderful
New York Area
47 reviews
vip
5.0
47 reviews
Dined on December 13, 2022
overall5food5service5ambience5
We had a lovely dinner at American Hotel on Tuesday, November 13th. We arrived almost an hour before our reservation, but they were able to seat us right away. The restaurant is decorated so beautifully for Christmas. We were greeted immediately by our wonderful server, I believe his name was Ed. We were told about the happy hour menu, which is a great deal. We started with two delicious martinis, then had the lobster bisque ( I think it was the best I’ve ever had), a salad, steak au poivre and a delicious grilled shrimp dinner. Entrees came with whipped potatoes and a vegetable medley. Also wonderful bread. Everything was perfect and the service was wonderful from start to finish. Forgot to mention we also had a very good Bordeaux blend glass of wine. The restaurant isn’t cheap, but it’s worth every penny. We will be back!
Is this helpful?
OT
OpenTable Diner
Greater Boston
2 reviews
5.0
2 reviews
Dined on December 11, 2022
overall5food5service5ambience5
Always a great meal in a classic setting.
Is this helpful?
L
Localvisitor
New York Area
37 reviews
vip
5.0
37 reviews
Dined on December 10, 2022
overall5food5service5ambience5
As always. Great food, service and ambiance.
Is this helpful?
J
Jcjf
New York Area
38 reviews
vip
5.0
38 reviews
Dined on December 9, 2022
overall5food5service5ambience3
Food was well prepared and service very good
Is this helpful?
OT
OpenTable Diner
New York Area
5 reviews
5.0
5 reviews
Dined on December 9, 2022
overall5food5service5ambience5
Consistently good.
Is this helpful?
s
stephend
New York Area
1 review
vip
5.0
1 review
Dined on December 8, 2022
overall5food5service5ambience5
Holiday lunch
Is this helpful?
M
Monica
New York Area
104 reviews
vip
5.0
104 reviews
Dined on November 29, 2022
overall5food5service5ambience5
Food was excellent. Service was warm and attentive.
Is this helpful?
s
skinstud47
New York Area
15 reviews
vip
5.0
15 reviews
Dined on November 29, 2022
overall5food5service5ambience5
Food has improved immensely since the last visit. Everything was exceptionately good..
Is this helpful?
A
Alsace
Washington DC
24 reviews
5.0
24 reviews
Dined on November 28, 2022
overall5food5service5ambience5
Perfectly well executed French food! Paired with an amazing Chardonnay The wine list is mind blowing! Extremely professional service An awesome experience!
Is this helpful?
l
lanative
Los Angeles
35 reviews
vip
5.0
35 reviews
Dined on November 27, 2022
overall5food5service5ambience5
We love this wonderful spot. Terrific ambiance, food, and gracious and attentive service. The historic atmosphere is unlike anywhere else in the Hamptons. Thank you for making our time there so special!
Is this helpful?
LD
LouieDel
New York Area
203 reviews
vip
4.0
203 reviews
Dined on November 26, 2022
overall4food5service5ambience4
Our 1st dinner back at the AH. It was glad to see that things haven't changed. Still one of the BEST restaurants in New York. The quality of the service & hospitality was only topped by the well prepared meal that we ordered.
Is this helpful?
KB
KarenB
New York Area
2 reviews
5.0
2 reviews
Dined on November 26, 2022
overall5food5service5ambience5
Enjoyed another fabulous meal with superb service. Chefs special are creative and worth a try.
Is this helpful?

Safety precautions

Cleaning & sanitizing
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Common areas deep-cleaned daily
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
Physical distancing
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables

Protective equipment
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
Screening
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
- Staff temperature check required

FAQs

The American Hotel offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (631) 725-3535.

The American Hotel is rated 4.6 stars by 634 OpenTable diners.

Not available on OpenTable

Unfortunately, this restaurant is not on the OpenTable reservation network.

If you like, we'll notify you by email if this restaurant joins.

Is this your restaurant?

Claim this listing

Order delivery or takeout

45 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Additional information

Cross street
Bay Street
Neighborhood
Sag Harbor
Hours of operation
Breakfast Sat, Sun 8:00 am–10:45 am Lunch Daily 11:30 am–4:00 pm Dinner Mon–Thu, Sun 4:00 pm–9:00 pm Fri, Sat 4:00 pm–9:45 pm
Price
$50 and over
Cuisines
French, American, Seafood
Dining style
Fine Dining
Dress code
Smart Casual
Parking details
Street Parking
Payment options
AMEX, Diners Club, Discover, JCB, Mastercard, Visa
Additional
Beer, Cafe, Cocktails, Corkage Fee, Full Bar, Indoor Fireplace, Non-Smoking, Patio/Outdoor Dining, Patio/Outdoor Dining, Private Room, Takeout, Weekend Brunch, Wheelchair Access, Wine

Website
http://theamericanhotel.com/
Phone number
(631) 725-3535
Private party contact
Mary Ferrara: (631) 725-3535

The American Hotel

Not available on OpenTable

Order delivery or takeout

Additional information

Lobster BLT

Oysters Rockefeller (6)

Spinach Salad

Soups

Simple Onion Soup$17.00

Soupe à l'Oignon Gratinee$21.00

Petite Marmite$20.00

Lobster Bisque au Chaudron$23.00

Salads

Salade du Jour$19.00

Spinach Salad$22.00

Caesar Salad$18.00

Appetizers

Bone Marrow$25.00

Long Island Duckling Confit$26.00

Terrine de Foie Gras Garni$23.00

Foie Gras Saute au Porto Branca*$40.00

Brandade de Morue$18.00

Smoked Trout Garni$21.00

Champignons Sauvage on Brioche Toast$28.00

Smoked Scottish Salmon$28.00

Shellfish

Blue Crab and Avocado Cocktail$28.00

Crab Cake$26.00

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail (5)$29.00

Oysters Rockefeller (6)$28.00

Oysters Romanoff (6)$32.00

Gardiner's Bay Littleneck Clams*

Chris Coyne's 'Peeko' Peconic Oysters Mignonette*

Caviar

American White Sturgeon*

Classic Osetra Sustainable*

Classic Beluga Hybrid "Rumania"*

Breakfast and Lunch

Omelets$26.00

Eggs Benedict*$28.00

Smoked Salmon Eggs Benedict*$28.00

Brandade de Morue*$28.00

Brioche French Toast$26.00

Sandwiches

Lobster B.L.T.$35.00

Duck Sandwich$29.00

Portobello Mushroom Grilled Veggie Sandwich$26.00

Triple-Decker Chicken Breast Club$28.00

Blue Crab Cake Burger$28.00

Croque Monsieur$26.00

Seafood

Jumbo Shrimps (5)$44.00

Scottish Salmon Grillé*$44.00

Local Filet of Flounder$40.00

Sesame Tuna à la Nage*$52.00

Atlantic Cod 'Fiorentina'$42.00

Blue Claw Crab Cakes$44.00

North Atlantic Lobster$82.00

Lobster or Vegetable Risotto$50.00

Birds and Meat

Organic Chicken Paillard Grillé$39.00

Chicken and Shrimp Cobb Salad$34.00

Long Island Duckling Breast*$44.00

Australian Lamb Chops au Jus*$64.00

Sirloin Steak Bearnaise*

Sirloin Steak au Poivre*

Filet Mignon Maitre d'*

Tournedos Marchand de Vins*

Chef's Choice*

Featured Items

Mondays: Prime Rib Night*$59.00

Wednesdays: Lobster "All You Can Eat"$69.00

Overall ratings and reviews

Cleaning & sanitizing

Physical distancing

Protective equipment

Screening

FAQs

Does The American Hotel offer delivery through OpenTable or takeout?

How is The American Hotel restaurant rated?