Of course, The American Hotel is more than just a hotel, it houses an excellent restaurant as well. There are multiple dining areas depending on what kind of experience guests are looking for. The Main Dining Room is a lively and rambunctious room that holds about 80 people while the Drew Room is a quieter, more private area for those looking for an intimate evening. The food is quintessential American cuisine from across the United States.
Safety precautions
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Popular dishes
Crab Cakes a la Moutarde
2 reviews
Carre D'agneau Printaniere – Rack of Lamb with Seasonal Vegetables*
2 reviews
Lobster B.L.T. with Green Salad*
1 reviews
Menu
One of our absolute favorites. Always a delight. Mussels are absolutely wonderful.
Always delicious food and wonderful service
Front porch provides a much needed warm place for outdoor dining during winter!
For a romantic night out, American Hotel is unsurpassed on the South Fork. Food, ambience, wine list are all top shelf. Yeah, it’s pricey, but a delightful experience is delivered consistently, which to my way of thinking makes it all worth it
Food was great
Very friendly staff and manager
Was here the night before Valentine’s Day. Service and food always great. Nice quiet table next to the fireplace too. Warm, charming setting inside.
I always love coming here! Great food, service, and setting makes for a memorable time.
Excellent cocktails, fresh seafood and meal. Consistently delicious.
Weekend away during COVID. Food was delish: veal chops, lamb chop, steak au poivre, desserts (lemon mascarpone cheesecake and Reíne sabe). Cabbage side was perfectly cooked. And let’s not forget the croque monsieur. Yes...in two day stay at hotel, we ate there four times. Or typical of us, but the good was that good!
Friendly welcoming staff, fantastic food, and the greatest atmosphere. A wonderful experience. We can not wait to return!
Wonderful dining experience with great quality food
Vinny , the bartender is wonderful...food wonderful, service great... extremely COVID safe
Would have given a 5 star but waiter failed to mention the burning hot plate.
This place is a true throw back. The food is a 10 the staff is amazing and the place makes you feel like you want to stay for hours no trendy BS just good old fashion Sag Harbor dining.
Food has been incredible lately. Duck, steak , salads. Service is always perfect and staff always friemdly.
Wonderful lunch and ambience.
The staff was very helpful food delicious... would highly recommend
EXCELLENT DINING EXPERIENCE FROM BEING GREETED BY ALLISON, TO THE ATTENTIVE AND VERY, VERY KNOWLEDGEABLE WAITPERSON, AND THE SUPERBLY PREPARED FODO AND DRINKS.
PERFECT EVENING FOR ANY EVENT OR CELEBRATION.
Cozy and inviting the perfect place for a winter dinner especially during Covid
Absolutely Delicious food and Dirty Martini was perfectly prepared crisp and clean. I will definitely be back to dine again and have told my friends as well
Tha American Hotel is always perfection! The staff is always incredibly friendly, the food is terrific! They have mastered Social Distancing, so there is never an uncomfortable moment. Definitely try the Rainbow Trout appetizer. Always delicious!
We sat in the back garden. Tables are well spaced, heat lamps helped, but be sure your feet are well insulated.
Food was delicious and Dennis was an excellent server.
Always enjoy coming here for a well executed classic line up. However, was very disappointed that after explicitly booking the table by the fireplace, it was given away because I came in 8 minutes after my booking time (when standard restaurant practice is to hold a table for 15 mins).
Always a treat. Great food
Anniversary
American hotel is one of my favorite restaurants. I was super excited to spend my anniversary there.
The service was good, waitress nice but certainly wasn’t amazing. When asked the different ways in which they prepare the flounder she gave a very short answer.
Ambiance never disappoints though.
My lobster came and was undercooked. Presentation was amazing but the fact that the chef and servers allowed an obviously undercooked lobster to be delivered to the table I think is awful. Totally fixable with a broiler but then I’m not eating with my husband....
They definitely need to up their game in the kitchen.
The American Hotel is a wonderful experience. The food, service and ambiance are fabulous.
Gorgeously historic place. Wonderful service. Great food.
It's our go to place to celebrate a special event.
Very expensive
Love this place!!!
Absolutely amazing! Fantastic food, warm welcoming service, beautiful and luxurious atmosphere. It is real treat!
One of our favorite places for decades. Never had a bad meal or time here.
Sat on the back patio for lunch, it was all that I have come to expect from this place. Good service, good food, nice atmosphere. The ladies room was a mess but that is because people are slobs.
Excellent food and nice outdoor tables with distancing
loved the ambiance, the service was excellent. would love to go back
One of my absolute favorite restaurants. Fantastic food, service and ambiance every time!
Despite the cold temps on the porch, the warmth of the staff and the delicious food made for a great bday dinner for my husband.
Enjoy a delicious breakfast in a very quiet environment
The place is outstanding! You truly feel in the old days in this luxury’s hotel
This is not the first time that I’ve had dined at the American Hotel, how ever it is the first time that I got the OpenTable information sent to me
FAQs
The American Hotel offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (631) 725-3535.
The American Hotel is rated 4.8 stars by 211 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.
