Sweet Tomato's

Name: Sweet Tomato's
Address: 15 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island, NY, United States, 11965
Telephone: (631) 749-4114
Price range: $31 to $50
Rating: 3.4

3.4 (9)

$31 to $50

Italian

15 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island, NY 11965

About this restaurant

Sweet Tomato�s Restaurant & Bar, on Shelter Island, serves fresh and contemporary Italian cuisine in its warm and homey eatery. For the ideal start to your meal, enjoy the sweet peas and Bolognese-filled fried arancici rice balls served with marinara and the calamari alla griglia topped with feta cheese, fresh herbs, seared artichokes and Kalamata olives, both of which are great to share. Some of Sweet Tomato�s Restaurant & Bar�s specialty entr�es include the chicken scarpariello half organic chicken in red wine vinegar with sausage, lemon, rosemary and roasted potatoes and the vegetable risotto topped with parsley. Pasta dishes, such as the 8-hour braised short ribs bone-in with homemade pappardelle, the classic fettuccine Bolognese and the rigatoni della nonna with eggplant, are delicious and made to order. On beautiful days, enjoy your meal at Sweet Tomato�s Restaurant & Bar on the outdoor patio.

Not available on OpenTable

Unfortunately, this restaurant is not on the OpenTable booking network. To check availability, please contact them directly.

Is this your restaurant?

Claim this listing

There’s more to explore

Discover countless more restaurants like this one with our app.

Scan the QR code to discover countless more restaurants like this one with our app.

Open app

Additional information

Dining style
Casual Dining
Price
$31 to $50
Cuisines
Italian, Pizzeria
Hours of operation
Lunch: Saturday & Sunday: 12:00pm - 4:00pm Dinner: Monday- Thursday, Sunday: 5:00pm - 10:00pm Friday & Saturday: 5:00pm - 11:00pm
Phone number
(631) 749-4114
Website
http://www.sweettomatos.net/
Payment options
AMEX, Diners Club, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
Dress code
Casual Dress
Executive chef
Alfredo Alvarez

Location
15 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island, NY 11965
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
Parking details
Street Parking
Additional
Bar Dining, Bar/Lounge, Beer, BYO Wine, Counter Seating, Full Bar, Gluten-free Options, Patio/Outdoor Dining, Takeout, Wine

Tartufo$21.00
pear, gorgonzola and black truffle.
Tuscani$20.00
prosciutto di parma, pecorino, arugula and white truffle infused oil.
Margharita$16.00
san monzano tomato, house made mozzarella, basil, evoo, mediterranean seasalt.
Salsiccia$17.00
sweet italian sausage, broccoli rabe and pecorino.
Marinara$19.00
tomato, oregano, anchovies, capers and olives.
Uevo$18.00
smoked speck, egg and fontina cheese.
Frutti Di Mare$23.00
local little neck clams, fresh diced tomato, garlic and oregano.
Fungata$22.00
porcini, shitake, portobello and fresh goat cheese.
Scampi$24.00
shrimp and basil pesto.
Quattro Formaggi$23.00
house made mozzarella, gorgonzola, ricotta and parmigiano reggiano.
Etna$21.00
tomato, crispy eggplant, basil and ricotta salata.
Diavola$22.00
tomato, hot sopressata, crushed red pepper, mozzarella and black olives.
La Pizzetina De Lucathis$9.00
kids pizza, san manzano tomato

Per Mangiucchiare O Dividere

Olives Marinate$6.00
Grissino E Prosciutto$9.00
Ricotta Dip$8.00
Calamari Fritti$11.00
Trio De Bruschetta$12.00
Artichokes Dip$9.00

Insalata

Insalata Di Granchio$18.00
jumbo crab meat, string beans, almonds, kalamata olives, tomato and citrus dressing
Pere E Spinaci$16.00
pear and spinach, feta cheese, baked tomatos, roasted walnuts, poached egg and dijon dressing
Finocchio E Zucchine$14.00
fennel and marinated zucchini, parmesan crostini, prosecco and shallot vinaigrette
Misticanza$12.00
satur farm rocket arugula w/ lemon, evoo and shaved parmiggiano
Fior Di Zucca E Prosciutto$17.00
zucchini blossom w/ prosciutto and ricotta tomato dressing

Antipasti

Minestra Del Giorno$12.00
soup of the day
Cipolle Vadalia Artoste$18.00
wood fire roasted onion stuffed w/ shrimp stew
Polipo Fritta$18.00
delicately prepared and marinated octopus, flash fried with a citrus smoked paprika aioli
Involtini Di Radicchio$14.00
goat cheese stuffed radicchio, toasted pine nuts, cucumber julienne and raspberry dressing
Carpaccio Di Manzo$22.00
beef filet mignon carpaccio, shaved parmiggiano and arugula
Crudo Del Mercato
local fish crudo of the day
- Mp
Calamari a La Griglia E Carciofi$16.00
smoked lemon marinated calamari and artichokes over watercress w/ truffled balsamic drizzle of seasonal sorbet
Miscela Di Tartare Di Mare$28.00
tuna, salmon, sea scallops, jumbo crab meat and savory avocado gelato
Burrata Di Buffala$16.00
grape tomatos and pesto dressing
Cheese and Cured Meats Board
- Mp
Raw Bar and Shellfish Platter
- Mp

Plancha

Polipo Iberico$18.00
spanish octopus
Scampi Giganti$22.00
jumbo prawns
Verdore Del Isola$12.00
local vegetables

Primi Piatti

Il Filetto Di Manzo$40.00
filet mignon, sautéed shitake mushrooms and red wine reduction
La Milanese Con L'osso$38.00
veal milanese and arugula salad
Pesce Del Giorno
whole catch of the day
- Mp
Pollo Scarpariello$26.00
half chicken w/ lemon, rosemary, peppers, red wine vinegar and roasted potatoes
Vongole$24.00
peconic little neck clams, cherry tomatos, jalapenos, basil, white wine and nutmeg
Stracotto Di Manzo$32.00
our famous bone in braised beef short ribs with home made pappardelle

Pasta E Risotto

add toppings ($2/each): tomato sauce, parmesan cheese, ham, fresh tomatoes, fresh mozzarella.

Rigatoni Alla Norma$24.00
fried eggplant, tomato, basil and shaved ricotta salata
Linguine Ai Gamberi E Zucchine$26.00
shrimp and zucchini, garlic and evoo
Orecchiete Alla Pugliese$22.00
broccoli rabe and italian hot sausage
Tagliolini Alla Cinghiale$30.00
home made pasta with braised wild boar ragu, porcini mushrooms and cherry tomatoes
Ravioli Alla Pere E Gorgonzola$32.00
poached pear and creamy gorgonzola w/ black truffle butter sauce
Fettucine Al Ragu Di Funghi$24.00
mushrooms bolognese and parmiggiano reggiano
Risotto a L'aragosta$34.00
lobster, sweet peas, chives and cognac
Risotto Agli Asparagi$24.00
local asparagus, shallots and italian parsley
La Pasta De Baby Sarah$9.00
kids pasta

Contorni E Piatti Piccoli

Patatine Parmigiane Tartufatte$8.00
truffle and parmesan fries
Cime Di Rapa$8.00
braised broccoli rabe
Asparagi Alla Griglia$9.00
grilled asparagu
Risotto in Bianco$10.00
cheese risotto
Ratatouille$10.00

What 9 people are saying

Sweet Tomato's reviews from people who’ve dined at this restaurant. Based on recent rating.

Overall ratings and reviews

3.4

3.4 based on all time ratings

3.1Food
3.6Service
3.8Ambience

Noise • Moderate

9 Reviews

H
Heathcliff
New York City125 reviews
3.0
Dined on September 2, 2015
1. Overall 3
2. Food 3
3. Service 4
4. Ambience 4
Grab a table on the porch and enjoy a nice Italian inspired meal or pizza in the center of this tiny village. Inside is cozy and better for a chilly night. I can't say it was spectacular but it was very enjoyable and the location & atmosphere make it worth another visit.
Is this helpful?
e
elc67
New York City4 reviews
5.0
Dined on August 19, 2015
1. Overall 5
2. Food 5
3. Service 5
4. Ambience 4
Were seated promptly. Wait staff was very attentive. Food recommendations were perfect! Enjoyed our meals. Will definitely return.
Is this helpful?
FF
FoodFanatic
New York City1 review
5.0
Dined on August 12, 2015
1. Overall 5
2. Food 5
3. Service 5
4. Ambience 5
This is has been a favorite of mine for several years and it still remains top-notch under the new ownership. Staff was friendly, accommodating and knowledgeable in the cuisine and wine pairings. Food was absolutely delicious-my friend even stopped mid sentence to comment on her first bite! The calamari a la plancha was super tender. The spinach salad with pears - heavenly. Our main courses were the shrimp with linguine and the fish of the day which was fluke served over broccoli rappe with a puttanesca type tapenade (minus the anchovies). They were both excellent. I come from a family that is no stranger to good cuisine and was glad that this place didn't change under the new management. Thanks for another wonderful dining experience!
Is this helpful?
OT
OpenTable Diner
New York City2 reviews
5.0
Dined on July 31, 2015
1. Overall 5
2. Food 1
3. Service 1
4. Ambience 1
Well. We just lost our favorite restaurant.... We LOVED Sweet Tomatoes and have been frequent visitors over the last few years. But no more. Jimmy is gone. The attentive waitstaff is gone. The service is gone. The delicious food is gone. We have tried Sweet Tomatoes twice since the new regime....and will not be going back. Don't waste your time or money either. You will be disappointed. Further, a dead restaurant on Shelter Island on a Friday night....hmmmmmm....maybe the word has already gotten around.
Is this helpful?
s
scattone
New York City6 reviews
1.0
Dined on July 7, 2015
1. Overall 1
2. Food 2
3. Service 3
4. Ambience 3
The special " Cioppino" came incomplete. Two ingredients were missing and no mention to the customers about the missing items. I will not mention the excuse from the chef. A party of 25 people with 6 children in a separate table took over the restaurant from a noise point of view. The children were out of control with no supervision from the adults. When we complaint to the waitress....she just shrugged her shoulders. The noise totally ruined our evening.
Is this helpful?
J
Judy VIP
South Carolina11 reviews
5.0
Dined on July 3, 2015
1. Overall 5
2. Food 5
3. Service 5
4. Ambience 5
Three nights on Shelter Island and we stumbled upon Sweet Tomato's the first night. Despite the fact that we had planned to dine-around.... we ate there every night! Food is creative and great!! Service is friendly and comfortable but outstanding!! Best spot on the island!
Is this helpful?
OT
OpenTable Diner VIP
New York City24 reviews
3.0
Dined on June 30, 2015
1. Overall 3
2. Food 2
3. Service 3
4. Ambience 3
We were greatly disappointed from the last time we visited. Apparently the former owner and manager left and the operation, mainly the food, is drastically different (worse). We would not go back.
Is this helpful?
OT
OpenTable Diner VIP
New York City21 reviews
2.0
Dined on June 16, 2015
1. Overall 2
2. Food 2
3. Service 4
4. Ambience 4
The service was great but there seems to be a downgrade on food quality unlike in the past. Pizza was dry. Salad was a little overdressed, and tasted more like oregano. The popular short ribs was a miss. It was not tender at all. And it was a little on the bland side. I was disappointed how it's changed. Service was excellent but if the restaurant completely loses its special feel, personal touch, and quality food, we'd probably rather somewhere else.
Is this helpful?
HW
HankW
New York City5 reviews
4.0
Dined on June 6, 2015
1. Overall 4
2. Food 4
3. Service 4
4. Ambience 4
If seated along the perimeter walls, the architectural molding makes it impossible to get comfortable because the molding sticks in your back
Is this helpful?

FAQs

Sweet Tomato's offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (631) 749-4114.

Sweet Tomato's is rated 3.4 stars by 9 OpenTable diners.

Not available on OpenTable

Unfortunately, this restaurant is not on the OpenTable booking network. To check availability, please contact them directly.

Is this your restaurant?

Claim this listing

15 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island, NY 11965

Additional information

Neighborhood
Shelter Island
Hours of operation
Lunch: Saturday & Sunday: 12:00pm - 4:00pm Dinner: Monday- Thursday, Sunday: 5:00pm - 10:00pm Friday & Saturday: 5:00pm - 11:00pm
Price
$31 to $50
Cuisines
Italian, Pizzeria
Dining style
Casual Dining
Dress code
Casual Dress
Parking details
Street Parking
Payment options
AMEX, Diners Club, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
Executive chef
Alfredo Alvarez
Additional
Bar Dining, Bar/Lounge, Beer, BYO Wine, Counter Seating, Full Bar, Gluten-free Options, Patio/Outdoor Dining, Takeout, Wine

Website
http://www.sweettomatos.net/
Phone number
(631) 749-4114

Sweet Tomato's

About this restaurant

Not available on OpenTable

There’s more to explore

Additional information

Woodfire Brick Oven Pizzas

Tartufo$21.00

Tuscani$20.00

Margharita$16.00

Salsiccia$17.00

Marinara$19.00

Uevo$18.00

Frutti Di Mare$23.00

Fungata$22.00

Scampi$24.00

Quattro Formaggi$23.00

Etna$21.00

Diavola$22.00

La Pizzetina De Lucathis$9.00

Per Mangiucchiare O Dividere

Olives Marinate$6.00

Grissino E Prosciutto$9.00

Ricotta Dip$8.00

Calamari Fritti$11.00

Trio De Bruschetta$12.00

Artichokes Dip$9.00

Insalata

Insalata Di Granchio$18.00

Pere E Spinaci$16.00

Finocchio E Zucchine$14.00

Misticanza$12.00

Fior Di Zucca E Prosciutto$17.00

Antipasti

Minestra Del Giorno$12.00

Cipolle Vadalia Artoste$18.00

Polipo Fritta$18.00

Involtini Di Radicchio$14.00

Carpaccio Di Manzo$22.00

Crudo Del Mercato

Calamari a La Griglia E Carciofi$16.00

Miscela Di Tartare Di Mare$28.00

Burrata Di Buffala$16.00

Cheese and Cured Meats Board

Raw Bar and Shellfish Platter

Plancha

Polipo Iberico$18.00

Scampi Giganti$22.00

Verdore Del Isola$12.00

Primi Piatti

Il Filetto Di Manzo$40.00

La Milanese Con L'osso$38.00

Pesce Del Giorno

Pollo Scarpariello$26.00

Vongole$24.00

Stracotto Di Manzo$32.00

Pasta E Risotto

Rigatoni Alla Norma$24.00

Linguine Ai Gamberi E Zucchine$26.00

Orecchiete Alla Pugliese$22.00

Tagliolini Alla Cinghiale$30.00

Ravioli Alla Pere E Gorgonzola$32.00

Fettucine Al Ragu Di Funghi$24.00

Risotto a L'aragosta$34.00

Risotto Agli Asparagi$24.00

La Pasta De Baby Sarah$9.00

Contorni E Piatti Piccoli

Patatine Parmigiane Tartufatte$8.00

Cime Di Rapa$8.00

Asparagi Alla Griglia$9.00

Risotto in Bianco$10.00

Ratatouille$10.00

Overall ratings and reviews

FAQs

Does Sweet Tomato's offer delivery through OpenTable or takeout?

How is Sweet Tomato's restaurant rated?

Not available on OpenTable

Additional information