Sugar River Pizza Company
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Contactless payment available
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
We had a vegetarian pizza which was outstanding. We had it with the pan crust. A garden salad was our appetizer along with Tomato Bisque soup. Highly recommend the restaurant.
This is the best pizza in Madison. They have a great selection plus the flavors can't be beat. My favorite is the Mediterranean and it is full of so many tasty ingredients. I especially appreciate their attention and respect for the pandemic. With tables are spaced apart and everyone is wearing masks, so I feel very safe there. This is one place that I visit over and over again.
Patio was nice and food was good.
Our Anniversary brunch was enjoyable with our Bottomless Mimosas. The brunch pizzas are a wonderful creation outside brunch fare.
We were not able to be seated for our reservation when we arrived so the manager said she would send breadsticks on the house when we were seated which never happed. The atmosphere was loud and the service was average at best. We had to ask for refills and she never asked if we wanted anything else. She was very abrupt and unpleasant and was definitely not that busy as the restaurant was only at 50% capacity at most and when we walked in there were 5-6 people just standing behind the desk.
Great to be inside eating great food. The server was efficient and just friendly enough. Can't wait to go back. Best pizza ever!
Great tomato soup, large portions, leftover for lunch today
Excellent food, pizza and sandwiches. Service was excellent also.
Great service, good food, Covid protocols in place.
Best Pizza in Madison area! I would highly recommend .
Really great pizza! Quality food at a moderate/reasonable price (~$15 for a medium size pizza).
Very clean and they did a great job with social distancing. Table was ready on time and they encouraged us to take our time and relax. Pizza was excellent and the beer selection had something for everyone in our party.
Great food and service!
Spacing was great - seated immediately Everything was excellent
Excellent bacon cheeseburger pizza, Cody our server was fabulous, hope he's there on our next trip. Always Excellent food and service. Our favorite place for pizza.
Meal was excellent. Our server had some great food and drink recommendations.
Would go there again.
We love Cody!! He’s an amazing personable server.
great food, great service, excellent atmosphere. one of my favorite places for lunch
The service was wonderful, the pizza delicious, the ambiance inviting. We also love to celebrate birthdays there because the complimentary dessert is ‘to die for,’ as the saying goes.
Enjoyed it very much. My wife and I got our favorite pizza -- the MacDaddy.
I highly recommend it to anyone that wants good food and a good time
Great food and awesome service. Love this place!
First problem was they did not have a table for us even with our reservation. Offered a bar seat instead. We decided to wait for a table-it took about 15 minutes. Ordered breadsticks as appetizer-supposed to be really good. They were almost burned- the cheese was nard and brown and no real flavor. I had shrimp ravioli and my husband had a calzone. Large calzone but again almost burned. Couldn’t really taste shrimp in pasta due to heavy cream sauce. Our waiter, Ethan, was excellent and did take the breadsticks off our bill. If we lived in Madison, we would not come back.
Great as always. Support your local businesses. They need it during this difficult time we all face.
Cody was excellent the entire night! He took great care of us.
Always great food. Lasagna is wonderful and salads are generous. Lots of choices for drinks. Temperature in dining room is sub-zero. Be sure and wear a sweater or jacket.
First time going there, been recommended by friends. The appetizers were awesome, but the pizza was fabulous. Great selection of craft beers. Will definitely be back again
We went for my birthday. Needless to say, the birthday surprise at the end of the meal
was outstanding!!! I took my brother and sister-in-law who had never been here and they just were pleasantly impressed!! This is my new place to go to celebrate a birthday for anyone!!
Wonderful food and server.
This has been our favorite place to eat since 2017. We now live in Deerfield and make the drive to get the best pizza and breadsticks in the Madison area (the seasoning on the breadsticks is amazing- paired with their homemade ranch, amazing). The servers are always outstanding, so nice and attentive! Another thing to mention is their expansive beer selection. One of their management staff is so knowledgeable about all their beers and he’s always willing to take the time to offer us his recommendations based on our tastes (my husband loves this). If you’re in the area, you have to try Sugar River!
Service and food was excellent. First time there. Waitress and staff very friendly and helpful with menu choices. Only problem is we could not get a third order of Cheese Curds because they ran out. It was not a problem, because we really didn't want one, but, they did say our second order was their last one. :-)
Nice outdoor patio, great service, pizza and salads, delicious!
Delicious hand tossed pizza!! Service great in outdoor area of restaurant and nice atmosphere for dining outside.
food was good but a long wait - was told the wait time was because the lasagna was so big it had to be put through the oven twice. when it came, it was neither big or hot!
SRP already had excellent food and beverage selections. First time I dined at the restaurant since covid hit. SRP has all the safety protocols down pat. Physical distancing, cleanliness, safety protocols are all in place. At no time did my wife or I feel unsafe. Excellent food, good service and a very safe dining atmosphere. Well done SRP.
It seemed to take a long time for the pizza to arrive. But the server was excellent. He frequently checked on us and refilled our beverages often. Pizza was also excellent.
Love your pizzas and salads!
Loved that we could sit outside and social distance. I also love booking on open table.
THE. BEST. PIZZA! Friendly service with attention to all things COVID related! Will definitely make a trip back again!
Nice outdoor patio. Lots to choose from on the menu; food was fantastic.
Service and food was fantastic, a must place to have pizza and a beer when in Madison.
Sugar River Pizza Company offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (608) 497-1800.
Sugar River Pizza Company is rated 4.7 stars by 330 OpenTable diners.
Sugar River Pizza Company does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://srpverona.hrpos.heartland.us/menu.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.