Steve & Cookie's By the Bay

Wonderful meal. Excellent service!!

Great Like Always!!

This place is absolutely amazing everytime!!

Steve and Cookies is always wonderful! Oscar was a dream! Friendly, efficient and professional. He also n.v has a great memory remembering what I had ordered on my last visit.

One of our fav places!!!!

Great food. Exceptional wine list with some great values. A great dining experience.

Delicious meal crab cakes, steak , an appetizer dish of pasta and crabmeat, and apple raspberry crisp excellent service as always

5 Star! Steve & Cookies never disappoints and is one restaurant if you're visiting the shore that you have to go to. A reservation is a must.

Our overall experience was good enough to come again in the near future.
High expectations due to lots of 5 star reviews and hard to come by table reservations were not met, however.
The lamb and beef were cooked to near-perfection, but generally the food did not “blow us away.” Additionally we thought the visual plate presentation was strangely lacking.
That being said, our dinner and drinks were delicious, the nearby piano tunes were a plus, and serving staff were helpful.

One of my favorite restaurants!! I have never had a bad meal here ever , This time my only complaint was my scallops & lobster were over cooked. I didn’t complain or say anything Bc we love it here and of coarse will come back!

We were able to find a spot at the bar while we waited for our table. Fortunately, there was a cancellation and the hostess was able to get our seats 30 minutes early. We enjoyed the atmosphere and food specials, especially the Prussian Pearls.

Excellent as usual

Love this place! Awesome food and service. Wish we lived closer we’d definitively come more often!

Amazing! Absolutely amazing! Everything there is over the top! Food , service and ambiance....been to hundreds of restaurants...Steve and Cookies is the best!!!

As always, dinner was perfect. Had the sausage pasta and house salad. Beautiful.

As always. Great food, great service all at a fair price

Beautiful atmosphere. Wait staff exceptional. We even met Cookie and thanked her for a great experience. Salads were perfection and the entrees were satisfying. I had the pork chop, it was great. My husband had the filet and he loved it. We were too stuffed for dessert.

Excellent waitress but can’t remember her name. Small, petite light skin African American with an Afro hair style. We come there frequently and she is the best!!

Great time

Everything was amazing from start to finish, we were a little early for our reservation so we had a drink at the bar and we were seated promptly at our reservation time. Our server, Danny, was great! We will definitely be back!

Valentines

We went to Steve and Cookie's for Valentine's Day dinner so of course it was busy. It is our Go To place for birthdays and anniversaries and other special events. We'd come more regularly except for the distance from our home. The reason I rate it so highly it that the food and service are consistently excellent. We also appreciate Cookie's generosity providing free dessert for a birthday or anniversary and a rose for every lady on Valentine's Day. More important is her generosity to the local community.

Awesome restaurant! We were seated at a table with a gorgeous view of the water. The food was also stellar. Five stars all around and we highly recommend!!

It was wonderful, pleasant servers, quaint atmosphere, and the food is to die for.

Loved it. Great cocktails, appetizer and dinner. One of my most favorite places.

Always love the food, service and atmosphere year round!

The food was very good and was matched by the service.

Went for an early Valentines Day dinner and had a fabulous meal. Highly recommended!

Always a sure thing. Never disappoints!

It’s the best

Fabulous as always. Our favorite restaurant on the island !! Never disappoints. Highly recommend

Steve & Cookie's always is consistent. Good Food, Good Atmosphere

Always a good meal. Wish it was easier to get a reservation during the summer.

This place was amazing. The food was outstanding and cooked to perfection. The staff was friendly and the service was great.

This was our third evening at Steve & Cookie’s By The Bay, and like the first two, our experience from cocktail through dessert and coffee, was super! I keep ordering the duck because it is superb and know that I won’t ever experience that anywhere else...now my friends order it as well.

You will be charmed - go!!

Food and service was phenomenol. our seat was in the middle of the walkway for the waitresses and everyone else. One of the people at our table was continually getting bumped by people walking by . The noise level was through the roof. We couldn't even talk to each other. I would reccomend the restaurant for food and service. However be warned : watch where they sit you.

Perfect atmosphere for a 65th birthday celebration. Excellent service and delicious food. Love it here!