Montego Bay Restaurants
Make a free reservation
Check out diners' favorite restaurants in Montego Bay
Updated on
Diners’ Choice Awards are based on where your fellow diners book, dine, and review. Only verified diners get to review restaurants on OpenTable, so our data doesn’t lie.
Sugar Mill Restaurant
Price: Very Expensive•Jamaican•4.7(198)Discover the taste of quintessential Jamaican cuisine, refined with a modern day twist. Enchanting island flavours are infused into every dish with herbs and spices grown right here in our garden. At Half Moon Resort we are committed to sourcing locally grown and seasonal produce. The Sugar Mill Restaurant is as historic as it is iconic. You will be overcome by a sense of awe as you enter the former Running Gut Estate. It is nestled in an alcove beside a 17th century water mill. You can feel the history within the existing walls that once served as the foundation of a sugar cane plantation dating back to 1676.Marguerites Seafood by the Sea
Price: Expensive•Caribbean•4.2(368)Ranked the Best Seafood Among Montego Bay Restaurants! Our fine dining restaurant is the only place to experience a piece of incredible history while enjoying a first-class meal in Montego Bay. Marguerite’s iconic seaside setting has been the crown jewel of Montego Bay for over 55 years. With an unparalleled level of service, the elegant and sophisticated almond terrace bustles with an eclectic mix of tourists and celebrities. Our signature offerings of creatively prepared seafood, table-side Caesar salad presentation and an award winning wine selection, welcomes clientele who appreciate a consistent standard of excellence.
See what locals rave about in Montego Bay
From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
- AAngelaSan Francisco Bay Area •2 reviews5.0Dined 5 days agoFood and service was outstanding! Customer service was phenomenal- they even opened the doors early as we arrived before our reservation time and it looked like it was going to rain. Tableside Caesar salad was excellent! Filet and sea scallops melt in your mouth! And the strawberry lemon drop was sweet and sexy at the same time lol Everything was just delicious and we would definitely be back again!More infoMarguerites Seafood by the SeaPrice: Expensive• Caribbean• Montego Bay•4.2
- TTiandraCaribbean •1 review5.0Dined on Jun 3, 2025Celebrated my birthday at Sugar Mill Restaurant and it was a 10/10 experience. Staff was amazing. Food was spectacular. They sang the happy birthday song and I got complimentary cake. Overall great experience. Definitely recommend!More infoSugar Mill RestaurantPrice: Very Expensive• Jamaican• Montego Bay•4.7
- RRosemaryVIPNew York City •16 reviews5.0Dined on Jun 1, 2025Really delicious food, esp the pastas but honestly everything was so goodMore infoDelMarePrice: Very Expensive• Seafood• Montego Bay•4.6
- RRonniqueCaribbean •1 review5.0Dined on May 29, 2025Our server’s name is Latoya (not sure if I’m correctly spelling it) her customer service skills are top notch. The overall ambiance of the lounge was amazing and I will definitely be going backMore infoPure Ultra LoungePrice: Moderate• International• Montego Bay•4.1
- MMichelleDetroit / Eastern Michigan •6 reviews4.0Dined on Feb 21, 2025My sister and I went here for her birthday dinner. The cocktails were good, I got an expresso martini. For dinner we both ordered the oxtails & she also got a lobster tail dinner. The oxtails were tough, only for 4 bones. We were not pleased. Also I mentioned on my reservation it was her bday. No one came by to sing to her but there were several other birthdays there as well. So I'm sure they were very busy. However on a Friday night that place is POPPIN!!! It was packed with hundreds of people, great music & dancing.More infoPier 1Price: Expensive• Seafood• Montego Bay•3.7
Frequently asked questions
The best reviewed restaurant in Montego Bay is Sugar Mill Restaurant
The restaurants with the best service in Montego Bay are DelMare, Sugar Mill Restaurant and Pure Ultra Lounge
The restaurants with the best ambiance in Montego Bay are Sugar Mill Restaurant, Marguerites Seafood by the Sea and DelMare
Explore OpenTable
- Montego Bay Cruise Port
- Dump-Up Beach and Events Park
- Half Moon Tennis Camp
- Bellefield Great House and Gardens
- Falmouth Jamaica Cruise Port
- Coffee River Cave
- Tryall Golf Club
- Bad Hole Cave
- Rocklands Bird Sanctuary
- Long Mile Cave
- Museum of St. James
- Cockpit Country
- Greenwood Great House
- Fort Montego Craft Market
- Rose Hall Great House
- Swaby's Swamp Safari
- Rose Hall Lighthouse
- Doctor's Cave Bathing Club
- Greenfield Stadium Trelawny
- Half Moon Bay Equestrian Centre