St. Elmo Steak House
Indy's best steakhouse!
Book your next event with us
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
20 oz. ground ribeye with sauted onions, smothered in Gorgonzola served with mushroom duxelle toast
USDA Prime New York Strip
strip with abundant marbling resulting in superior tenderness and flavor
Great food and service as always
Awesome Experience as always! Thanks for the great booth! See ya next game! Go Colts!!!
Let’s talk about this place...Joe heard about it in a NFL podcast.
1. Mark our server was so awesome.
2. They are renowned for their Cocktail Shrimp for a reason. It will clean up your sinuses!
3. St. Elmo cola was amazing. Is 4 fingers of house-made bourbon with 2 luxardo cherries aged in bourbon as well (OMG)
5. Steaks will melt in your mouth.
6. It was the best lobster bisque I ever had.
7. Loaded potato was so good that Joe finished before the steak!
8. Cocktails were amazing! I had to have a cosmo and it was on point!
#stelmosteakhouse #steakhouse #dinner #discoveringplaces #indiana #indianapolis
Excellent service. Tables spaced out for social distancing. Food was great, steak was cooked perfect. Highly recommend and would return.
The food and service was great! Wonderful ambience for a nice date night for a special occasion
St. Elmo Steak House was perfect as always! Amazing shrimp cocktail, great steak and wine selection, and desserts were delicious! Our family gets together once a year and always has a great time - never rushed.
We had another great dinner at St.Elmos! Jake was our server and he was awesome. The food was so good! We love eating here.
They did a great job of social distancing. Our waiter, Jake, was excellent.
Top Notch as always! Best steak house in town and in Indiana as far as I know.
Excellent service and food quality. Aged steak had a wonderful flavor. Classic Old fashion had an excellent flavor and presentation.
Diner was delicious as expected and Ricardo, our server, was great.
Always excellent. Been dining here personally since 1991.
If you are in the mood for steak and shrimp cocktails with spicy horseradish sauce in a higher end venue, this is the place.
Great visit. Food and service were fantastic.
Birthday for my wife.
Waiter was wonderful. I’m sorry, I can’t remember his name.
Despite mid-pandemic atmosphere, my first visit after many recommendations and insights was just as advertised. Food was outstanding, and service was top notch. The only slight disappointment was the creamed spinach. I know this isn't the major draw, but its quintessentially part of a steakhouse repertoire. It wasn't enjoyable at all. Everything else was amazing and worth the price. Would absolutely return.
We had a wonderful dinner which was made even better by the excellent service provided by Scott.
I have worked in high end fine dining restaurants from the French Quarter of New Orleans to Palm Springs California for thirty years and I can tell your this place hits on all cylinders. In spite of the terrible overtime loss my favorite football team suffered in overtime my friend and I had a fantastic meal immediately after the game. The waiter handled the meal perfectly. Shout out to that man (he told me his name, I wasn’t listening) he’s a professional. My experience was so much fun it prompted me to write this review and I never do this type of thing. Absolutely check this place out!
The food was amazing and so was the service. Even the hostess was friendly. A very inviting environment!
Server Kate is an incredible asset to the restaurant. We are from out of town and St Elmo is always a destination highlight.
The restaurant specializes in steak, yet over-cooked my filet, then under-cooked the replacement steak and had to fire it up again. At no time did a manager visit our table to apologize and the waiter did not take the steak off of our check. I could not eat with my family as they were done by the time their 3rd attempt arrived. I love this restaurant and haven't had an issue in the past. I expected our visit on Sunday, November 22, 2020 to be no different.
Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback Sheryl. We would like to extend our apologies for your disappointing experience. Please check your inbox as I have sent you a private message to discuss in detail the issue noted above. Thank you.
The shrimp cocktail is a must order. I ordered the 14 oz Rib eye, definitely not a quality cut. A fine steakhouse, perhaps I was unlucky
This was the best place I’ve ever had dinner
Best steakhouse I have been to. This was my third time and it never disappoints.
Typically a go to when in Indy, but this time was somewhat of a disappointment. The service was stellar (Rick), but 2 out of our 4 steaks where grossly underdone. We politely asked for them to be cooked more and they came back 10 minutes later not much better.
Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback Jim. We would like to extend our apologies for your disappointing experience. Please check your inbox as I have sent you a private message to discuss in detail the issue noted above. Thank you.
The service was excellent! The food was delicious! Highly recommend!
Had a wonderful meal starting with the famous shrimp cocktail, which was delicious. Our meal was exquisite. The filet mignon was so tender it practically melted! Also, the Elmo cola was perfect! Next time we are in Indy, we will definitely come back!
This was to celebrate my 10-year anniversary. Best filet mignon I've ever had. Best service I've ever had. Best dining experience I've ever had. Period.
We love the place, the fillet and the service, we had a wonderful dinner!
St. Elmo's is always a great place to go for nice night out. Great food and great service.
Our dinner here was a celebration of our wedding. Glenn was amazing! He was knowledgeable of St Elmos history as well as having the perfect ratio of being attentive to us & letting us enjoy the experience of St Elmos. We had a food allergy & special attention & care was given under this special circumstance. The temperatures of our steaks were PERFECT & the shrimp cocktail that St Elmos is known for exceeded our expectations! It is very spicy but very tasty. I cannot say enough of our visit to St Elmos & we will definitely visit again when we are in the area.
James & Laura Davis
I love St. Elmo. Perfect date night location for local residents, a “bucket list” experience for Indy visitors. Food, service & ambiance is as good as ever. Is an 8 Oz fillet worth $44. Probably not, but it’s market price, like it or not. I can’t afford to go often, but our birthdays celebration on Nov 20 was as good as expected.
Per usual St Elmo’s continues to provide the best service and delicious food. We came for a birthday dinner during COVID and every table was more than 6 ft apart and the servers wore masks. Everything looked and smelt very clean and we felt very safe there. 10/10 always recommend!
Romantic atmosphere and amazing service. Steaks and shrimp cocktail are out of this world!
Great food and service as always
The food is always great. I was surprised there was no social distancing there were no empty tables and really no distance chairs back to back.
St. Elmo Steak House is rated 4.8 stars by 17114 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.