Sisters at the Martha
We celebrated our 5 year anniversary this evening before attending a play at the Barter. Everything about our meal was above and beyond EXCELLENT. We can’t wait to come back! Thank you so much for making our evening special!
Both our entrees had too many noodles for the price and not enough veg or seafood. My husband's mussles were overcooked. My veg dish had too many carrots and some chopped green veg that were overcooked and had lost their color...not enough variety of colorful vegetables for the price.
The duck legs were also overcooked.
Sisters at the Martha was excellent as always. They have a good wine selection, and the server-recommended toffee bread pudding for dessert was outstanding!
Friendly, comfortable, with good menu. Food delicious.
The service and the food were both outstanding. I enjoy Sisters each time we come there to dine.
The food was good, but not outstanding. The food lacked in seasoning. Service was great. The wine list provided did not match what was available.
Although the food tasted good, for the price of the dinner entrees i would have expected at least an additional side or salad to be included. Key lime pie was not memorable. Not the tart lime flavor baked yummy kind. A bit like instant pudding and cool whip. Redeeming qualities were the historic dining room and a quiet room. Absolutely no music playing. Right across from the Barter Theater for easy dining pre theater. Probably would recommend only for a first time theater visitor's convenience. A one time for me.
The food was amazingly delicious! We had the deviled eggs and cheese plate for starters. My husband had the crab bisque and it was wonderful! Very light and refreshing. For our entrees, we had filet and salmon. Filet was so tender you didn’t need a knife. Salmon was fresh and sweet. For dessert, we had the chocolate and banana cake, which I thought was very dry but my husband had the peanut butter creme brûlée and it was so refreshing and light!
Everything was wonderful - the food, the service, the atmosphere. We will definitely go back.
Overall we were disappointed. The lighting was so poor I could hardly read the menu which was quite limited and not at all as advertised on the website. Perhaps that had been a lunch menu but when questioned our waiter said they don't serve lunch. We won't be back.
We made early reservations due to a play that we were going to see. Service quite slow, appetizer of hummus good, wife enjoyed tuna appetizer. My pasta was only fair and was half eaten due to need for us to be on time for the play.
The hotel included breakfast as part of a package. In general a typical breakfast not bad but not outstanding.
Excellent food! Loved the menu. Took my family there to celebrate Mother's Day to enjoy Sunday brunch. Everyone really had a good time and commented how much they enjoyed the meal.
There was only one thing that all of us though was very odd and it was the fact that the tv was on the entire time during the brunch. It's one thing to see a tv in a bar area but this was a very nice, upscale ambiance so none of us appreciated having it on in the background. If it were not for the tv, I would have rated it a 5 star experience.
Tried the new menu for the first time and was not disappointed! My husband, cousin and I all enjoyed our entree. Amazing! Thank you for a delightful dinner!
Dinner for 2 on a Sunday evening was a very pleasant experience. Our server was personable and attentive. We selected an appetizer, salad, 2 pasta entrees and dessert . Everything was presented in a timely fashion The food presentation was attractive and it tasted delicious. We will return !
Easter Sunday occasion. A bit expensive but food and service made up for price.
My partner and I decided to visit Sister's before watching a play at the Barter. The menu items are extraordinarily overpriced, and the service is slow and unenthusiastic. I didn't finish my food because the noodles were over cooked to inedibility. Our desserts were the only items I didn't feel like I was getting ripped off on. The restaurant is very aesthetically pleasing, and the atmosphere is perfect for a romantic night out. It's a shame that such a beautiful restaurant fails to serve quality entrées. If you decide to visit, be sure to grab dessert because it was delicious.
We had a large group (8 people). Waiter was prompt and attentive. Food was excellent. The desserts were to die for.
Not a huge fan of the new menu smaller portion size for the price and a lot of fluff. Waitress was outstanding just disappointed in the price for quantity and quality of food. Miss old menu/chef
The highlight of our visit was first the wonderful service and then the tasty meal. Great atmosphere. And did I mention the service was great!
We were the only couple dining. Aside from 3 people at the bar, we were alone. Staff was very friendly. Menu is limited. Food is good. Prices are high.
Awful - when we requested a table away from the noise we got a huffy response that "we seat by sections" duh - you and every other place ever.
Then the 2 dollar up charge to go from mashed potatoes to basmati rice - they are both inexpensive plates fillers
We had a free glass of wine for everyone on tour party coupon - we were told "we aren't taking those anymore" really nice breach of promise - so for your 2 eight dollar glasses of wine you lost a regular (monthly) customer who drops at least 150 each time
Awesome night manager Britt and server Courtney
We were seated, and then they forgot about us. We watched 4 other tables get seated, order their drinks, and even order their food before I finally waved down a server. They had just forgotten about us. The meal was fine, the service, once we had it, was fair, and the restaurant is overall a nice quiet place.
We were celebrating our anniversary. We were disappointed in the service and food. The restaurant does not meet the standards of the rest of Martha Washington Inn.
Five star rating in all categories ! Just like last year ! Great service, menu and ambience.
Couldn't have been better. Will surely be back in 2018 !!!!
Loved it and cant wait to go back, best hamburgers and fries I have ever had!
A little disappointing. We were a party of four seated at a round table that was better suited for six or more. Very hard to have a conversation. My steak was over cooked and not very tender. Definitely not worth what I paid. The server apologized and offered to bring me another one, or give me a free dessert. The crowd at the bar was a rowdy while watching a football game and yelling obscenities. It made the patrons in the restaurant a little uncomfortable.
It is a bit pricey, but Sisters never fails to impress. The service, food, and ambience are spectacular.
I was disappointed by the "uneveness" of our Thanksgiving dinner. Shrimp served without shrimp forks, gravy that was heavy and unappetizing. The cranberry sauce looked to be out of a can rather than freshly made. The vegetables, however, were quite good especially the succotash. The turkey was nicely done, but the prime rib was lacking flavor and juices.
Our waiters were attentive - service was good.
Went to Sisters while on weekend getaway. food was delicious, loved the potato soup. Nice and cozy atmosphere by the fireplace.
My wife and I had a meal here before going to a play. The food was good and the room was great for two couples to have a conversation over dinner.
A lovely setting, delicious food, and excellent service. Our family group of 6 was seating at a comfortable round table and given much attention by our waitress. We all enjoyed our meals and the wine suggested by the waitress.
This was a post-theater meal after a matinee performance. We had eaten a large lunch earlier in the day and therefore just had soup and salad forgoing any entrees (though the entree options were very appealing). We both had the crab bisque which was quite good and incorporated a good serving of the crab. Both of our salads (a wedge & a mixed kale) were also good though the blackberries included in the kale mix were quite seedy. The pumpkin cheesecake we shared (made by a local Abingdon bakery...Anthony's) was also good. Since few other local restaurants are open on a Sunday evening, Sisters was rather busy & that may have slowed the service a bit, but it is definitely worth a visit.
Our meal took over two hours to be served, causing us to be late for a play. I would recommend you allow plenty of extra time to eat and be served, or go on a night when you do not have any other plans. Our food was great; it was just a very long wait to get it. We did not order anything out of the ordinary or requiring extra preparation. The acting manager tried to help by offering an extra round of drinks, but didn't seem to have much authority to do anything else to make it right, which further frustrated several members of our party. Also, signage out front for the restaurant entrance would be helpful, since it is in the hotel, to avoid having dinner guests walk through the hotel looking for it.
We liked the crab bisque and loved the pork osso bucco with root vegetables which is large enough for two people. Ambiance is very casual.
Great place to go before the Barter Theater. Excellent food, service is exceptional, atmosphere is perfect.
If you're going to a performance at the Barter Theater, this is where you want to go. It's not cheap, but it is excellent in every way. Plus, after dinner the theater is only a very short walk.
Don't skip dessert.
Beautiful. Full of history. Great food and service. Great location.
The restaurant was amazing, the service was great, and the food was wonderful and well-prepared. If we had a complaint, it would be that we would have wanted more or the specialty: the deviled eggs of the day. For two people, we only got to enjoy one each and then there was a third to split. We felt like this should be an even number for a party of even numbers. Other than that, everything was exceptional.
Excellent meal! I had the bacon/horseradish encrusted salmon w/Rosseto
and grilled root vegetables! Yummy! My husband had steak and said it was perfect. I would not hesitate to splurge on dinner at Sisters. Also quite a few lower priced meals that looked delicious as well.
This was a wonder choice to celebrate our 36th Anniversary.
The food at the Sisters restaurant was some of the best my wife and I have had in sesveral years. the Beef and Lamb chops were both excellent, veggies and potatoes great, even the bread was awesome ! For dessert the Creme Brule' was great! Service was very good and everyone was very friendly.