A lot of hype and not much to offer other than good food. The restaurant gives off a feel of who they are “Girneys Montauk” like they’re special. I didn’t feel the draw to go back when I was leaving at the end of my meal.

We had a most delicious dinner in October overlooking the Ocean with the heaters on. Wear your polo tech and enjoy!! We highly recommend Scarpetta in Montauk. We will be back.

The service was wonderful! We were there for our wedding anniversary and Scarpetta Beach did not disappoint.

Service wasn’t great - food was small portions but expensive- one is really just paying for the view - although we missed the sunset - it was just ok

Awesome ambiance and delicious food!
One of my favorite restaurants!

The view, location, and ambiance is absolutely beautiful. The decor is very pleasing and eye catching. The food is very tasteful and enjoyable. Great warm service. Our waiter was so kind and brought us an anniversary dessert and two glasses of Moet Champagne complementary. A must visit. Also the outside patio is a nice way to start and end your night with a great bar setup and fire pits to keep you warm. Overall great and pleasant experience.

Food was good, service not great, over priced

We had a beautiful evening at Scarpetta Beach. The meal was fabulous, the service was excellent and the view of the beach tied it all up with a bow!

Always a great night with amazing food and top notch service

Food was amazing, great space. However, I booked

You can’t beat the view and food

Exceptional in every way. Food and service is perfect. Dessert may not have been quite as good but this is my favorite restaurant in the Hamptons by far.

Waiter not attentive, except for the tables next to us.

Delicious food and awesome wine lists.

Services not best - poured own bottle of wine and water. We dined here numerous times, services hit or missed sometimes.

Everything was great, except the bread it’s not fresh since last year

Josue the server and Mens the bartender were off the charts!

The pasta was super fresh and we really enjoyed our appetizers and drinks too! Best spot in Montauk for sure. The hotel is also much better than any of the other hotels or resorts.

Everything about our experience was wonderful from start to finish. From the friendly hosts, quick support staff, lovely server, to the beautiful view of the ocean from our table - aces all around. Our server, Dominic, was phenomenal! He delivered impeccable service - he was friendly and fun, very knowledgeable about all aspects of the menu and made perfect recommendations. Thank you Scarpetta for a memorable evening!

Not impressed

Fun day on the beach. Scarpetta is a great way to end the day with fine dining and great food. Great service with the place very busy.

Fun day at beach capped off with Scarpetta. Great fresh markets salad, pasta and fresh fish. Chocolate cake is delish.

We love the food at Scarpetta however they should allow

Food was great and server was very nice but the meal was painfully slow.

Was not seated where I should been

Had so many great experiences on OpenTable. Our party was very excited about this reservation but the entire experience was awful - arrogant, unaccomodating staff, unwelcoming and unavailable. Be carful on the water - if you order one bottle they will keep serving and charge you 10$ a bottle. Never going back here again!

Amazing food and excellent service !

Perfect dinner to celebrate a special birthday!!

Food is delicious, unfortunately the service was so poor. We waited over 10 minutes for a glass of water and some drinks.

Thé édit têts

The service is incredibly horrible ! You will be waiting an hour past your reservation

Best view of the ocean out east!

Amazing restaurant!!! Service and food definitely top notch!!

Food was horrible and we were seated 45 minutes after our reservation time. The service was atrocious and the manager did not care that many parties were unhappy with the wait. Do not go there.

Portions were very small .
Was looking forward to a steak with my bottle of brunello. Only steak on the menu wad a 12 oz wagyu for $75 . Sorry just not worth it!

Impeccable service, Amazing and absolutely delicious food, and gorgeous views. The perfect restaurant for any occasion.

Scarpetta Beach is my absolute favorite restaurant in Montauk. The venue and views are stunning and the food is incredible. We go once a year and I always get the duck ravioli—highly recommend!

Lots of kids and families

Nothing beats the view. Spectacular. Wish I could rave about the whole experience - but I can’t. Picked this place for Father’s Day w the family. 2:30 reservation was all I could get 6 weeks out. Warning: the restaurant is closed from 330-530, due to changeover to dinner. The service was terrible. And the place was dead after 330, which isn’t the the worst thing - but it was like they wanted us out. 45 min after we sat down. And for such a pricey place, not acceptable. Drinks took forever, wrong main course came, and then they were sort of passive aggressive about the justified complaints we made. Nice that they comped the wrong main course- but, ummm. Not really a choice there? Will never come back for a meal in the restaurant again. The bar, for sure.

Bday! Delicious food, ambiance extraordinary with waves crashing on beach. Bar w/ fire pits very warming atmosphere. Highly recommend Scarpetta Beach for any size party or a date night😄

It was nice