Diners' Choice: Neighborhood gem restaurants in Cape Cod and the Islands
OpenTable
Updated May 05, 2025
Looking for the best restaurants that are the best neighborhood gems in Cape Cod and the Islands? You’re in the right place. Each month, OpenTable analyzes nearly 2 million global diner reviews from the past four months. We sort the results by location and category to help you discover new favorite restaurants. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!
About the restaurant
Leading Nantucket’s thriving restaurant scene, The Nautilus (est. 2014) is an island staple built on the idea of a shared social experience. Founders Liam Mackey (food), Clinton Terry (drink) & Stephen Bowler’s (wine & business) island-mentality of being “serious about what we do, but not taking ourselves too seriously” perfectly sums up The Nautilus experience. The highly regarded culinary program is a sort of ‘New England coastal cuisine meets Asian & global haute street food’ vibe featuring small plates served tapas style, combined w/ larger group feasts (think Peking inspired duck). The culinary inspired cocktails draw on both seasonal & regional inspirations while the wine & sake list is recognized as a “Best Of” by Wine Spectator. Fueled by curated, energetic music, the stimulating yet neighborly atmosphere makes the new & unfamiliar feel comfortable & intimate, a philosophy that seamlessly ties the food, cocktails, wine & ambiance together to crTop review
P
Panos
Dined 2 days ago
About the restaurant
A wine, martini, tapas bar, with full dinner menu and specials, in Harwich Port Cape Cod, MA. Old world style with a modern twist.Top review
B
Brian
Dined 4 days ago
About the restaurant
La Cucina Sul Mare in Falmouth serves up a blend of Italian and Mediterranean cuisine prepared by skilled chef and owner, Mark Cilfone. The interior of the eatery is warm and inviting with large hand painted murals, large picture windows that provide a view of busy Main Street and tin ceilings. La Cucina Sul Mare specializes in the preparation of Northern Italian dishes using old world cooking skills.
Be sure to try the saltimbocca, marsala, piccata, limone, parmigiana, lobster and asparagus ravioli with sauteed sea scallops, sweet potato encrusted scrod or the almond encrusted salmon. La Cucina Sul Mare serves up freshly made pasta and seafood dishes daily.
Top review
T
TimVIP
Dined 4 days ago
About the restaurant
The Oyster Company Raw Bar & Grille has been celebrating Cape Cod's freshest catch for over 2 decades with its incredible dishes, relaxed atmosphere and our Famous Oysters from our Own Oyster Farm. The sashimi oysters on the half shell with yellowfin tuna sashimi and wasabi aioli and the fresh lobster quesadilla with melted cheese and chipotle mayo make tantalizing starters. Some of The Oyster Company Raw Bar & Grille's specialty entrée dishes include the Shrimp and the Scallop Sauté with tomatoes, black garlic and pappardelle pasta. Guests can also choose the Grilled Native Swordfish. The Oyster Company Cioppino -linguini with lobster saffron sauce topped with lobster, shrimp, scallops, mussels and clams, which are all as beautifully prepared as they are delicious. Outdoor seating under Tent in Season.**Raw Deal** Half Price Oysters everyday until 6:30pm
Come, enjoy our Award Winning Restaurant & Raw Bar
See you Soon!
Greg Burns
Che/Owner/Oyster Farmer
Top review
S
Stephen
Dined on May 5, 2025
About the restaurant
If you can't get a reservation we do reserve tables for walk-ins. We accept reservations for inside dining only. Nestled in the heart of Orleans, Cape Cod, our restaurant offers a unique fusion of Italian-inspired cuisine. Our menu is carefully crafted to cater to a wide range of tastes, so whether you’re in the mood for Italian classics, steaks, fresh seafood, or American favorites, you’ll find something to delight your taste buds.
Our dishes are made with the freshest ingredients, including pasta and sauces, to create authentic and flavorful meals. Our seafood is sourced from local waters and is always fresh and delicious.
In addition to our Italian-inspired dishes, pizza, steaks, and seafood, we also offer a variety of American cuisine, including burgers, salads, and more. Our menu is designed to cater to all tastes, so there’s something for everyone. In the warmer months dine on our deck, outdoor patio, or sit and have a cocktail by the fire pits.
Top review
C
Curt
Dined on May 5, 2025
Discover more
About the restaurant
At East Bay Grille Pinehills, located at The Pinehills Golf Club in Plymouth, Massachusetts, we offer fine cuisine in a warm, yet casual environment. Our daily menu includes ocean fresh seafood, varietal pastas, and choice cut steaks, in addition to savory sandwiches and craft pizzettas. Get comfortable in our cozy Grille Room, relaxing veranda, or enjoy a cocktail around the fire pit. Whether you are just finishing a round of golf or enjoying a night out with family or friends, you can escape the everyday here at East Bay.East Bay Grille at Pinehills Golf Club is a public restaurant. You do not need to be a member of the Golf Club or resident of the community to dine with us.
Top review
S
StephenVIP
Dined 2 days ago
About the restaurant
Casual indoor/outdoor dining, open year-round. Located mid-island, currently serving breakfast and lunch 7 days a week and dinner Wednesday through Saturday for the winter.Seasonally, we have a beautiful outdoor bar, serving up drinks and food for before or after a trip to the beach, as well as a full outdoor patio and indoor dining room! We also serve 30 different homemade flavors of ice cream at our ice cream counter from May through Columbus Day.
Follow us on Instagram @iknantucket @ikcateringpalmbeach @ikinflightcatering
Top review
T
Tom
Dined on Apr 25, 2025
About the restaurant
The name “Colombo” is the Italian form of “Colomba” the latin word for “dove”, which is the “Bird of Peace”. It is in the spirit of peace that friends and family gather to celebrate the every day occurrences that touch our lives. Great food, drink and conversations are the cornerstones for the sharing of these convivial, day-to-day passions at our Italian restaurant.Colombo’s Cafe & Pastries stands for the beloved concept born in Italy of the “gathering place”… truly a place that “welcomes everyone, every day… at any time” translating as “Benvenuti a tutti” in Italian, whereby the tried and true, centuries-old tradition of “all are welcome” prevails.
Top review
S
SusanVIP
Dined on Apr 12, 2025
About the restaurant
Experience the culinary mastery of Chef Shane Coughlin at the newly renovated Wild Goose Tavern!Embracing its coastal roots, the restaurant features an expanded bar and a modernized ambiance, while preserving its inherent charm. Step into a vibrant space adorned with captivating murals, promising an unforgettable dining affair. Delight in an array of tantalizing dishes from our new menus, showcasing Chef Shane's innovative twists on American pub classics, alongside expertly crafted beverages, including our famed Goose Fries.
Join us on Main Street, Chatham for alfresco dining, where every bite is a journey through coastal flavors!
For inquiries about hosting private events, please visit our website. We eagerly anticipate welcoming you to the Goose!
Top review
J
JosephVIP
Dined on May 5, 2025
About the restaurant
Discover Anna’s Harborside Grille, a cherished family-owned restaurant named in loving tribute to the founders’ mother. Nestled by the waterfront, this establishment promises a cozy dining experience infused with Greek and Mediterranean flavors.Open daily at 11:30 AM, begin your culinary journey with appetizers like Aegean fries, crispy calamari, or the delightful Spanakopita—a savory spinach pie with fresh herbs and feta, enveloped in flaky filo dough. Indulge in Greek classics such as stuffed peppers, souvlaki, or the rich layers of moussaka, combining eggplant, potato, and ground beef in a savory tomato sauce, crowned with béchamel.
Anna’s Harborside Grille also boasts live entertainment every night of the week, ensuring a lively backdrop to your meal. Join us for bar promotions on weekdays and enjoy an incredible meal with a scenic ocean view.
Experience unparalleled hospitality and culinary delights at Anna’s Harborside Grille—an inviting escape along the waterfront.
Top review
L
LisaVIP
Dined on Apr 19, 2025
Explore Diners' Choice best of Cape Cod and the Islands
Explore more Diners' Choice lists