Diners' Choice: American restaurants in Cape Cod and the Islands

OpenTable

Updated June 05, 2025

Looking for restaurants with the best overall American cuisine in Cape Cod and the Islands? You’re in the right place. Each month OpenTable analyzes more than 400,000 new diner reviews. We sort the results by category to help you discover new favorites. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

Salt Raw Bar + Fine Cuisine

4.8

4.8 (1088)

$30 and under

American

Plymouth

About the restaurant

SALT RAW BAR + FINE CUISINE

Top review

JulieVIP

Dined 2 days ago

I rarely write reviews but our experience at Salt was extraordinary! The halibut with lemongrass curry was the best I’d ever had. And the truffle ramen noodles (we added chicken) was outstanding. Followed by the chocolate cremux (sinfully yummy) and a tiny tini, it was the perfect dinner!

Ships Inn

4.9

4.9 (493)

$31 to $50

American

Nantucket

About the restaurant

The Ships Inn Restaurant offers one of Nantucket's finest dining experiences. Located in an historic whaling captain\'s mansion built in 1831, the dining room and lounge are below street level and have an updated colonial atmosphere. Tall windows along two walls let in the summer breezes and let escape the sounds of happy conversation. This restaurant is a very good choice for an evening out with friends, and there are cozy, intimate alcoves for more romantic encounters. American/French cuisine is featured, with everything freshly prepared on the premises. Chef Mark Gottwald's food is bold and flavorful, and presented with understated elegance. Dinner menu selections include lobster, calamari, crab cakes, salmon, prawns, chicken, duck, beef, and lamb. Only the freshest ingredients are used. Members of our restaurant staff have been part of the Ships Inn family for an average of seven years or more. Friendliness, attentiveness, and food knowledge are the cornerstones of our operation.

Top review

Kevin

Dined on Jun 5, 2025

Excellent as always. Best steak on island. Scallop appetizer perfect

Black Eyed Susans

4.7

4.7 (275)

$30 and under

American

Nantucket

About the restaurant

Nantucket favorite for over 30 years. Black Eyed Susan's offers a cozy atmosphere with an open kitchen and both counter and table service. Chef Todd Edwards has returned, bringing back beloved dishes like linguini with clams and tuna tartare, along with exciting new options. The menu features fresh, seasonal ingredients from local farms for a true farm-to-table experience. Enjoy a hearty breakfast with eggs, pancakes, or French toast, or savor a delightful dinner with lamb barbacoa, monkfish tonkatsu, or lemongrass fluke. Classic dishes like whole leaf Caesar salad and capellini with tomatoes and basil are also available. Plus, feel free to BYOB! Whether you're dining with friends and family or enjoying a romantic evening, Black Eyed Susan's warm atmosphere, delicious food, and friendly service make it a must-visit destination on Nantucket.

Top review

Debbie

Dined 3 days ago

Amazing food. Great service. Really accommodating of our toddler granddaughter at a 5:30 reservation. Appreciated that. Ate outside and truly a delightful evening.

Pepes Wharf Restaurant

4.8

4.8 (3047)

$30 and under

American

Provincetown

About the restaurant

Pepe's Wharf is an iconic seaside restaurant known for its beautiful waterfront views overlooking Provincetown Harbor. We have 2 fantastic decks, with one incredible view of Cape Cod Bay due to our unique location directly on the beach in Provincetown. Pepe's is the place where you can enjoy delicious New England inspired cuisine, or one of our many cocktail creations on our new Upper Deck Bar! Pepes offers a chic and festive P'town experience! Hope to see you soon!

Top review

John

Dined 2 days ago

Wonderful food with exemplary service in a beautiful setting in the heart of Provincetown.

Embargo

4.6

4.6 (823)

$31 to $50

American

Hyannis

About the restaurant

Embargo is open and is the place to be on Cape Cod, featuring a chic and sophisticated atmosphere with amazing food and handcrafted cocktails. Our menu features dry aged steaks cooked to perfection, mouth watering tapas, and of course, fresh local seafood. Each meal becomes an event when shared with friends and family!

PLEASE NOTE: DUE TO HIGH DEMAND, we do not guarantee reservations for outdoor patio seating. Tables are sat on a first come, first serve basis. If you have a reservation and request outdoor seating, you may endure a brief waiting period. All reservations are held for 10 minutes and will be considered cancelled without a phone call. Please also note we only take reservations for dining tables only.

Top review

brianVIP

Dined 4 days ago

Always a fun trip and experience. Tapas great as were the drinks

or, The Whale

4.7

4.7 (627)

$30 and under

American

Nantucket

About the restaurant

or a lively brunch, or, The Whale is your destination on Nantucket's Main Street. This bistro and bar offers a vibrant atmosphere and a menu that reflects the island's diversity. Start your day with a delicious brunch featuring classics like eggs Benedict and pancakes, along with unique options such as the veggie mushroom bowl topped with a fried egg. For lunch, enjoy choices like the blackened swordfish sandwich or a classic turkey BLT, and don’t miss Manny's refreshing bistro frisée salad. As evening falls, the dinner menu shines with dishes like lobster cavatelli, made with homemade pasta, and roasted chicken with crispy potatoes. The bar features an extensive selection of wines and cocktails, perfect for relaxing after a day of exploring. Sip on local craft beer or a signature cocktail on the spacious outdoor patio and soak in the island's charm. Whether for a casual lunch or a romantic dinner, or, The Whale is the perfect choice.

Top review

Nigel

Dined 5 days ago

We went with 5 starters and skipped the entrees - great decision because they all sounded fabulous and they lived up to expectations. Shout out to our server from CT - she was awesome!!

Discover more

Pinehills East Bay Grille

4.6

4.6 (224)

$31 to $50

American

Plymouth

About the restaurant

At East Bay Grille Pinehills, located at The Pinehills Golf Club in Plymouth, Massachusetts, we offer fine cuisine in a warm, yet casual environment. Our daily menu includes ocean fresh seafood, varietal pastas, and choice cut steaks, in addition to savory sandwiches and craft pizzettas. Get comfortable in our cozy Grille Room, relaxing veranda, or enjoy a cocktail around the fire pit. Whether you are just finishing a round of golf or enjoying a night out with family or friends, you can escape the everyday here at East Bay.

East Bay Grille at Pinehills Golf Club is a public restaurant. You do not need to be a member of the Golf Club or resident of the community to dine with us.

Top review

PeterVIP

Dined on Jun 24, 2025

Always reliable… great GM/staff…very personable… treat you like family… fun atmosphere….food is good and the ambiance on a beautiful summer night is great! Nice job.

Breeze & Sailor’s Valentine at The Nantucket Hotel

4.5

4.5 (14)

$50 and over

American

Nantucket

About the restaurant

Breeze Restaurant at the Nantucket Hotel is a year-round dining destination offering fresh, seasonal takes on New England classics by Chef Michael Hervieux. Enjoy breakfast, lunch, dinner and Sunday Brunch in a relaxed setting, with standout dishes. The Breeze is a year-round guest favorite, and Sailor’s Valentine outdoor dining on the Front Porch is available from May 25 through October 12.

Top review

Christina

Dined on Jun 24, 2025

The halibut and the salmon were fabulous and our kids loved their food. Only negative was we sat on the wraparound porch - which was lovely, but someone must have been smoking in the street nearby and I couldn't locate them to as then to move along. Again, not the restaurants fault but was still unfortunate.

Patio American Grill

4.7

4.7 (1218)

$31 to $50

American

Provincetown

About the restaurant

Patio American Grill is your go-to culinary destination in Provincetown. Located on lively Commercial Street, we offer a delightful mix of fresh seafood, globally-inspired dishes, and a vibrant atmosphere that embodies the charm of Cape Cod. Our menu features the freshest catches and innovative creations, including succulent lobster rolls, mouthwatering steaks, handcrafted pastas, and vegetarian options. Be sure to try our famous raw bar with freshly shucked oysters, a true Provincetown favorite. The inviting ambiance at Patio enhances your dining experience. Enjoy our spacious outdoor patio for people-watching or relax inside with chic décor that sets the stage for a romantic dinner or a fun gathering with friends. Whether you’re in the mood for a refreshing cocktail, a fine glass of wine, or one of our signature frozen drinks, our friendly bartenders are here to help you find the perfect beverage to complement your meal. Come savor the flavors of Cape Cod at Patio American Grill!

Top review

RuthVIP

Dined 1 day ago

Great food and great service is a winning combination!

Linx Tavern

4.7

4.7 (285)

$30 and under

American

Brewster

About the restaurant

Linx Tavern is the restaurant attached to the Golf Course at Ocean Edge. Ocean Edge is a gorgeous luxury resort situated right on the coast. This is fantastic for diners because they can hear the tide come in as they dine out on the Tavern's spacious outdoor patio. The good news is that Linx is available for the general public as well as those staying at the resort. Linx features an international menu with dishes taking inspiration from every corner of the globe.

Top review

Jennifer

Dined on Jun 27, 2025

Food was great, waiters and waitresses were great.

Explore Diners' Choice best of Cape Cod and the Islands

Explore more Diners' Choice lists