Diners' Choice: Italian restaurants in Mexico City

OpenTable

Updated September 05, 2024

Looking for restaurants with the best overall Italian cuisine in Mexico City? You’re in the right place. Each month OpenTable analyzes more than 400,000 new diner reviews. We sort the results by category to help you discover new favorites. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

Cancino - Cabrera

4.7

4.7 (159)

MXN300 and under

Italian

Condesa / Roma

About the restaurant

Frente al la plaza Luis Cabrera, una de las colonias con mayor vida nocturna y de las más conocidas de la ciudad, digna de presumirse a nivel mundial.
Cuenta con un patio interno, cuartos de piso de madera y un espacio al aire libre con vista al parque, por lo que podrás admirar la increíble fuente.
Las pizzas al horno de leña son lo más destacado del restaurante, podrás encontrar tradicionales recetas y algunas más innovadoras como la pizza "diavola" y la 4 quesos con uvas, así como el característico fondue que solo podrás disfrutar en Cancino Roma.
La cocina es de influencia italiana pero con toques contemporáneos así que podrás probar desde un delicioso carpaccio de res hasta unos gnocchis en salsa de hongos.
También te encontraras con una amplia selección de bebidas, yendo desde cervezas artesanales hasta una gran variedad de cocteles muy característicos de Cancino.
Cancino se destaca, además de su deliciosa comida principalmente por su excelen

Top review

OpenTable Diner

Dined on Aug 23, 2024

The ambience is amazing, drinks were fantastic and the food was super tasty! I’ll be back

Cancino - Polanco

4.5

4.5 (145)

MXN300 and under

Italian

Polanco/Nueva Anzures

About the restaurant

This Cancino lives very close to the Lincoln Park, it was the first park that was designed in the Polanco neighborhood.
Here you can enjoy the Jocoque La Cosa Nostra, the Vitello Tonnato a classic of Italian cuisine and you can not miss the opportunity to try one of the pizzas the original recipes of Mr. Cancino, who emigrated in the forties from Italy to the Mexican Republic, do not forget to try the desserts of Cancino which are a delight, as a new red fruit crumble, adding a balanced wine list that meets the demands of the area without losing the fresh touch that characterizes us and end with a Mezcal Union the young or old mezcal.
The atmosphere of Cancino Polanquito, is distinguished by being warm, relaxed and charming where it is possible to enjoy lunches, family meals and nights of mezcal, pizzas cocktails with friends, the touch of freshness and warmth that the area needed.

Top review

OpenTable Diner

Dined on Feb 13, 2024

Great food and service! Cool place! Lovely location! Thanks!

Quattro - JW Marriott Sta Fe

4.8

4.8 (520)

MXN310 to MXN500

Italian

Santa Fe / Bosques

About the restaurant

Discover classic Italian cuisine in the heart of Mexico City at Quattro Gastronomica Italiana. This stately eatery, located inside the JW Marriott hotel, is a local favorite, showcasing Northern Italian fare in an elegant dining room, complete with a full bar and an extensive wine selection. Quattro Gastronomica Italiana creates each dish with care, incorporating ingredients imported from Italy to ensure authentic flavors in every bite. Quattro Gastronomica Italiana also feature a diverse menu, including appetizers, fresh soups, pastas, salads, risotto dishes, fresh seafood, steaks, veal specialties and more. Pastas and desserts are made from scratch in-house daily.

Top review

ManuelBvip

Dined on Jun 27, 2024

Love this place, we don’t go as often because of prices but always good

Cortile - Cráter

4.6

4.6 (86)

MXN500 and over

Italian

Jardines del Pedregal

About the restaurant

En el centro de Cortile esta su alma. Descubrimos este espíritu único y le damos una sensación de calidez: un espacio acogedor, excelente comida y vino, con buena compañía en un ambiente cálido.

Top review

OsoMayorvip

Dined on Apr 13, 2024

It is sad that such a great place to dine has the odor problem in the inner section, you need to really improve this issue coming from the exterior. it smells really bad

Fratelli La Bufala - Polanco

4.5

4.5 (146)

MXN310 to MXN500

Italian

Polanco/Nueva Anzures

About the restaurant

Italian franchise of the famous Neapolitan restaurant in the heart of Polanco with a terrace and cozy atmosphere, where diners can see how the pizzaiolo prepares the traditional 100% Neapolitan pizzas in a stone oven, imported directly from Italy and made with volcanic stone from Vesuvius. Thanks to its temperature that reaches 450º, the best pizza in the city will be prepared in just 90 seconds.

The menu also has an exquisite and wide variety of dishes, salads and pastas, whose Mediterranean flavors will transport you directly to Italy. You cannot leave without trying our famous Caesar salad and our homemade tiramisu.

Top review

OpenTable Diner

Dined on Jun 22, 2024

One of the best experiences of my life, I had a stain and Dina the waitress helped us.

Casa D'AMICO

4.7

4.7 (274)

MXN500 and over

Italian

Polanco/Nueva Anzures

About the restaurant

Casa D'AMICO, comida Italiana mediterránea con platillos de diseñador.
Entrega a domicilio, servicio en interior y dos terrazas al aire libre.
Es atendido personalmente por sus dueños, quienes cuidan que cada persona sea atendida como en su casa.
Buscando crear una experiencia inolvidable en cada visita.
Contamos con servicio de mixología en nuestra terraza, salones privados y servicio de valet parking.
Instagram @casadamico433

Top review

FernandoS

Dined on Apr 6, 2024

Outstanding service. Jeferson, our waiter, is thoroughly professional. Very diverse and classy modern Italian cuisine at reasonable values

Prego

4.6

4.6 (160)

MXN310 to MXN500

Italian

Polanco/Nueva Anzures

About the restaurant

At Prego, we value the flavor of our food, ensuring it with the freshness and quality of our products. Our dishes are made on the spot, giving seasoning the leading role, just as Nonna taught us. This is our unique formula for ensuring that our customers have felt at home for 15 years.

Top review

OpenTable Diner

Dined on Jul 5, 2024

An amazing restaurant. True Italian food with great service. The Spaghetti alla Ruota is delightful

Sartoria

4.7

4.7 (2030)

MXN500 and over

Italian

Condesa / Roma

About the restaurant

Sartoria is the gastronomic proposal of Italian chef Marco Carboni (former chef at Osteria Francescana by Massimo Bottura), where he expresses the philosophy of his italian roots, based on the product, the season and a “hand-made” approach.

The menu is focused on seasonality, and products are produced in a sustainable way by small-scale producers. At Sartoria, pasta is produced artisanally every day, respecting italian tradition and simultaneously embracing mexican produce.

The warm ambiance of a traditional italian trattoria comes together with our vision of a contemporary osteria that is both dynamic and cosmopolite.

Sartoria is a pet-friendly restaurant in the outside sitting area. Kindly let us know of your allergies and/or intolerances when making your reservation.

Top review

Ellenvip

Dined 7 days ago

We loved Sartorial! The lasagna was outstanding! The waiters were friendly and attentive. Noise level was much lower than advertised. It was a great evening.

Belfiore

4.7

4.7 (368)

MXN310 to MXN500

Italian

Polanco/Nueva Anzures

About the restaurant

****Please call telephone number 12043928 as alternate in case nobody answers 52820414***
Beginning in November 2003 Belfiore has offered innovative and authentic Italian cuisine, in a welcoming and relaxed environment. With its wood-oven, made in Italy, in which they prepare their famous pizzas. Along with their menu, the restaurant offers a selection of fine wines.

Desde Noviembre del 2003 el restaurante Bellaria – Polanco ofrece una innovadora y autentica cocina italiana. Cuenta con un horno de leña hecho en Italia, en el cual se preparan sus famosas pizzas que siempre son muy bien acompañadas de una selección de vinos premium. Pequeño acogedor y de ambiente relajado la calidad esta a la par de su generosa disposición.

Top review

andres

Dined on Aug 21, 2024

top highly recommended.

Ristorante Romina

4.7

4.7 (423)

MXN500 and over

Italian

Polanco/Nueva Anzures

About the restaurant

Romina is an Italian restaurant specialized in fresh pasta and seafood. With an intimate and exclusive atmosphere. Since its opening in 2010, it offers a careful selection of wines and classic cocktails, curated by Mario and Diego Magaña, which currently has 300 labels and has been awarded, on multiple occasions, by Wine Spectator and Gamberos Rosso magazine. Where labels from Tuscany, Piemonte, Champagne and Bordeaux stand out.

Not recommended for children under 7 years of age.

Top review

PTHOENvip

Dined on Jul 16, 2024

We live in CdMx and Romina is probably our Italian fav. The pasta is home made, the reliably perfect, the wine list has been awarded year after year and ambience is cozy and unpretentious. The place is supervised daily by owner-brothers Diego and Mario, the latter being a certified Italian Wine Ambassador. No wonder local clients repeat.

Explore Diners' Choice best of Mexico City

Explore more Diners' Choice lists