Diners' Choice: American restaurants in Upstate New York

OpenTable

Updated June 05, 2025

Looking for restaurants with the best overall American cuisine in Upstate New York? You’re in the right place. Each month OpenTable analyzes more than 400,000 new diner reviews. We sort the results by category to help you discover new favorites. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

Lizzie Keays Restaurant

4.9

4.9 (121)

$31 to $50

American

Warrensburg

About the restaurant

Under new ownership, local celebrity chef Billy Trudsoe a native to the Adirondacks who you saw on Hells Kitchen “battle of the ages,” season 21 on the Fox network has taken over this historic restaurant. You can try Chef’s world famous, “black forest chicken” his signature dish he presented to Gordon Ramsay. Also, his divers scallops which helped seal a big win for the blue team during a challenge. Chef Billy's team has developed an upscale casual dining concept right here, in the heart of Warrensburg , New York. Building his brand “BTrue’s Mad Flava,” our restaurant will offer creative dishes for everyone. Chef Billy is an award-winning chef, that has been cooking up delightful meals for his patrons throughout the Adirondacks for over 25+ years. Born and raised in Chestertown, New York he is overly excited for the opportunity to serve this community. Live music on Tuesdays & do not miss our new remodeled Dinning room.

Top review

karim

Dined 6 days ago

First time at Lizzie Keays after hearing a lot of good things. Our waitress was attentive and knew the menu quite well which really helped narrow down some choices as the menu has quite a lot of good options. Everything we ordered was excellent, even the side salad was perfect, with fresh greens and a nice choice of dressings. The Black Forest chicken and mushroom ravioli were probably the standout orders but as I said, everything we ordered was delicious. Lizzie Keays is a great new addition to the culinary scene and we are all excited to go back!

Motus

4.9

4.9 (669)

$31 to $50

American

Utica

About the restaurant

mōtus (Latin); movement, progress, passion, revolt

A tradesman's gastropub with an undeniable message of purpose.

Top review

PeterVIP

Dined 4 days ago

Superb meal for all of our group, lamb shank was amazing with sauce to die for. Beef Tartare was beautifully presented with lovely garnishes , great cocktails that update periodically, impeccable service and thoughtful options for gluten free diners including an amazing focaccia bread option and most items on menu could be adjusted (aside from a few sauces) This is my favorite restaurant in the area

Discover more

Experience

Summer Sunday dinner Series

Simply Crepes - Canandaigua

4.9

4.9 (173)

$30 and under

American

Canandaigua

About the restaurant

Simply Crêpes is located among the boutique shops in historic downtown Canandaigua just minutes from the city pier at the northern tip of the lake. A walk or drive from the Lake House. Stop by before or after your wine tour along Seneca, Keuka, Cayuga or Canandaigua lakes. This casual eatery with country charm offers patrons a variety of comfort food with a focus on crêpe dishes for breakfast, lunch and dinner. Breakfast menu can include "the best french toast", crêpes filled with eggs & bacon or stuffed with fresh strawberries. Pair breakfast with a boozy coffee flight or mimosa flight, cold pressed local juice. For lunch or dinner, smoked salmon and vegan "capable" Thai coconut curry. Dessert crêpes are stuffed with fruit or Nutella and topped with ice cream. Brunch is served all day. Simply Crêpes is open Monday through Sunday. Closed Tues. During the summer, dine outside in our cozy garden patio and enjoy a full outdoor bar at North Central Bar. Live music Friday & Saturday nights.

Top review

Sandra

Dined on May 25, 2025

We went mid-afternoon, so it was not too busy. We had reservations and were seated right away. Food was excellent. Staff was friendly.

Morgan & Co. - Glens Falls

4.9

4.9 (1493)

$31 to $50

American

Glens Falls

About the restaurant

Morgan & Co. is a New American Restaurant in downtown Glens Falls, NY. With an always fresh menu, Morgan & Co's dishes reveal a variety ranging from tandoori-spiced dishes to Berkshire pork chops, Carolina barbecue and high end sandwiches. We call it “comfort food with a Mediterranean-Bohemian flair.” The bar celebrates American spirits and American artisanal wines. Run by 2009 Chopped winner Rebecca Newell-Butters and her husband, chef Steve Butters, Morgan & Co is sure to be a dining experience you won't forget!

Top review

JohnVIP

Dined on May 24, 2025

Always enjoy a meal at M&M on the porch as the temps increase allowing an outdoor dining experience yet protected from the elements. Wife had wedge salad and ribs which are always tasty. Seafood bouillabaisse which is delicious and our 25 year old, big appetite son could barely finish the Texas brisket lasagna.

Simply crepes - Pittsford

4.8

4.8 (166)

$30 and under

American

Pittsford

About the restaurant

A full-service restaurant. Offers progressively traditional, French Canadian farmhouse vibes. Scratch-made comfort food is handcrafted in our kitchen using fresh meats, produce, signature sauces and dressings.

Nosh on some of fan favorites for breakfast like French toast, Maple Sausage Stackers, oatmeal creme brulee, simply strawberry crepes. Lunch can be healthy! Many gluten and dairy free options. Try a Mediterranean Chicken (or make it vegetarian with tofu). Vegan friends love the Thai Curry Crepe. Food Network has featured our Rugby Crepe on The Best Thing I Ever Ate. Come for dinner and grab a burger or fried chicken sandwich. After dinner espresso martini and nutella dessert crepes!

This location boasts historic digs along the Erie Canal in Pittsford with weekday happy hour. Live music, events occur across the street. Order take out and our team members will deliver to your table at Collins Pavilion and Lock 32! Event spaces are available for meetings and private gatherings.

Top review

Meaghan

Dined on May 25, 2025

Had a great experience for brunch at Simply Crepes in Pittsford! The food came out quickly, and was delicious. Staff was great and knowledgeable about allergies and recommendations. Every time I dine here, I have a great experience! Highly recommend their mimosas and breakfast crepe!

1833 Kitchen & Bar at the Aurora Inn

4.9

4.9 (1674)

$50 and over

American

Finger Lakes

About the restaurant

Award-winning, refined seasonal cuisine created by Chef Elsa Jorgensen is inspired by the diverse and fresh regional offerings. Using as many New York State products as possible to create a thoughtful and delicious culinary experience. Our seasonal a la carte menu is paired perfectly with the many Finger Lakes and Old World wines from our Wine Spectator award-winning wine and beverage list.
The Aurora Inn is warm and welcoming with exquisite décor. From intimate anniversary dinners to parties for up to 25 guests, we are prepared to make yours an event to remember. Whatever the occasion, it will be remembered for fine cuisine, warm service, and beautiful surroundings.

Top review

Debra

Dined 2 days ago

Beautiful on the lake atmosphere! The food is outstanding, flavors are perfectly balanced. Staff is friendly and professional.

Josie's Table

4.7

4.7 (1176)

$30 and under

American

Albany

About the restaurant

Josie's Table offers amazing local farm to table cuisine accompanied by our signature craft cocktails.
Something new and unique to the Albany area.

Top review

Jackie

Dined on Jun 7, 2025

Wonderful Decor and atmosphere. Our server was great and the food was outstanding!!

Discover more

Simply Crepes - Webster-Penfield

4.8

4.8 (155)

$30 and under

American

Webster

About the restaurant

Modern French Canadian comfort food in a cozy, full-service setting.
Enjoy scratch-made dishes featuring fresh meats, produce, and signature sauces. Breakfast favorites include Maple Sausage Stackers and Oatmeal Crème Brûlée. For lunch, explore healthy gluten-free, dairy-free, and vegan options like the Thai Curry Crepe. Dinner brings comfort classics—think burgers, fried chicken sandwiches, and indulgent dessert crepes.

Full cocktail & coffee bar, weekday happy hour, beer on tap, and a fire pit patio. Private dining and event space available.

This location boasts a full cocktail and coffee bar with weekday happy hour, beer on tap, lounge, and outdoor patio with fire pit. Event spaces are available for meetings and private gatherings.

Top review

Arthur

Dined 7 days ago

Highly recommend this restaurant and other partner restaurants operating under the same name. Had been to the branch in Canandaigua previously and found both it and the Webster branch to be an excellent choice for a meal Food was tasty, portions good, service excellent!

1909

4.9

4.9 (141)

$50 and over

American

Cooperstown

About the restaurant

With an emphasis on fresh, local ingredients, guests will find a menu that offers something for every palate, including the finest cuts of meats, fresh seafood and salads. The cozy setting, featuring outdoor seating on the veranda in season, and the serene backdrop of Otsego Lake provides a perfect complement to your dining experience.

Top review

Blair

Dined 2 days ago

A wonderful experience from start to finish! Such a lovely surprise in this small town.

The Stewart House

4.9

4.9 (126)

$30 and under

American

Catskill

About the restaurant

Please note reservations are for the 1883 Tavern Only.
For large parties please call to reserve the private dining room. 518-444-8317

1883 Tavern features an Art Deco bar and dining room. Farm-sourced dishes comprise an ever-evolving menu. Enjoy dinner in a historical setting on the banks of the Hudson River with weekly specials, an inventive cocktail, fine wine or local craft beer. Happy first hour each day we’re open (half price drinks), live music on Thursday nights and a burger & beer special, Friday martini & mussels special (every martini comes with a side of mussels), Sunday Bloody Mary menu and special Sunday Roast dinner with all the fixings.

River Garden open Memorial Day to Labor Day, outdoor bar and live music. Featuring Tommy Boy food cart.

Top review

Chester

Dined on Jun 6, 2025

Friday night mussels and martinis is an excellent buy and delicious! The special soft shell crab was great too!

Explore Diners' Choice best of Upstate New York

Explore more Diners' Choice lists