Diners' Choice: Neighborhood gem restaurants in Cayman Islands

OpenTable

Updated June 05, 2025

Looking for the best restaurants that are the best neighborhood gems in Cayman Islands? You’re in the right place. Each month, OpenTable analyzes nearly 2 million global diner reviews from the past four months. We sort the results by location and category to help you discover new favorite restaurants. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

Ristorante Pappagallo

4.9

4.9 (528)

$31 to $50

Italian

West Bay

About the restaurant

For parties exceeding 10 people or for additional availability, please contact us at 949-1119 or email us at manager@pappagallo.ky.
Whatever the occasion, Pappagallo provides the perfect setting to satisfy all your senses. From the moment you step onto the wooden bridge leading to the entrance you are transported into another world. We offer several dining options, but it is the spectacular details of our 30-foot Cayman-style, Silver Thatch roof that is truly breathtaking! Under the inspired guardianship of Chef Alex Menegon who demands freshness of food as an absolute priority, the contemporary cuisine at Pappagallo is typified by its simplicity and freshness with Italian daily homemade pastas. Chef Alex uses as much locally caught seafood as is available and only the best of USDA Certified meats are offered; For the sweets-lover, a dessert menu starring only handcrafted desserts. So, sit back, relax and enjoy one of the best dining experiences in Grand Cayman!

Top review

Pat

Dined 6 days ago

We never return to Grand Cayman without at least one visit to Pappagallo. While we lived in Cayman it was our go to place. After 25 years it remains at the top of our list and never fails to provide an excellent experience.

Aria

4.9

4.9 (158)

$31 to $50

Mediterranean

Grand Harbour

About the restaurant

At Aria, we pride ourselves on delivering superior quality throughout every aspect of the dining experience, every time. Expect the freshest, highest quality ingredients, knowledgeable staff, exceptional service, and a beautifully designed, modern space.

We’re the leading innovator in Mediterranean cuisine on the island, with chefs hand-picked from across the Mediterranean. Our menu honors the history and heritage of the food, while still managing to be fresh and modern.

And as part of the Agua Hospitality Group our guests can expect the same superior quality and experience they have come to enjoy at our other establishments.

For event inquiries, please visit: https://www.ariacayman.ky/events

Top review

Lena

Dined on Jun 7, 2025

Great experience! We did go on a busy night so service was a bit slow however food was great.

Discover more

Experience

Brunch at Aria From 11:30 - 2:30 PM

Experience

Express Lunch

NOVA

4.9

4.9 (68)

$31 to $50

Mediterranean

West Bay

About the restaurant

NOVA offers an idyllic and inspired dining experience on the stunning shores of the Cayman Islands. Nestled on the north shore of West Bay, this beachfront gem serves a unique blend of Mediterranean-Japanese fusion cuisine, offering delicious, hearty dishes paired with innovative cocktails. With its open-air setting, NOVA provides the perfect backdrop for a laid-back yet elegant dining experience. Enjoy a refreshing poolside lunch, followed by handcrafted cocktails on the beach, or savor a sunset dinner with picture-perfect ocean views. This dog-friendly restaurant features an outdoor patio by the ocean, making it the ideal spot to gather with friends and family. Whether you're seeking delicious food by the sea or a memorable sunset experience, NOVA offers a one-of-a-kind atmosphere in West Bay.

Top review

Debi

Dined on Jun 21, 2025

Great food with casual resort flair! Service was excellent and food fresh and delicious,

Bella Trattoria

4.9

4.9 (53)

$31 to $50

Italian

West Bay

About the restaurant

Step into our Italian trattoria, where the rustic charm meets modern flair.
The warm ambiance invites you to savor the essence of Italy, with exposed brick walls and cozy seating.

Top review

OpenTable Diner

Dined on Jun 20, 2025

We chose Bella Trattoria for the last dinner of our vacation, and we are so glad we did! We felt the warm welcome from the moment we walked in. The food was authentic, fresh and just incredible! Our server was attentive, knowledgeable and really cared about making the experience enjoyable for us. We will definitely be back the next time we are in Grand Cayman. Highly recommend.

The Brasserie - Grand Cayman

4.8

4.8 (452)

$31 to $50

Global, International

George Town

About the restaurant

The Brasserie is the pioneer of the farm-to-table movement in Grand Cayman, setting the expectation for fresh local menus throughout the island. The grassroots establishment produces organic eggs on site, wild raw honey from its 50 hives, coconuts from the 202 palms at Coco Bluff Farm, and catches daily fresh seafood with its two fishing boats, Brasserie Catch I and Brasserie Catch II. Surrounded by an edible garden with flourishing fruit and nut trees, enjoy a unique dining experience outside in the greenhouse terrace or indoors in the elegant dining room or intimate wine cellar. The seasonally inspired and sustainable menu of delicious modern Caribbean cuisine is paired with signature cocktails and an extensive fine wine list.

The Brasserie restaurant is a boutique 65 seat restaurant with bar that warms the soul with its British colonial charm. The restaurant is a hidden gem known by locals for its incredible fresh and interesting modern Caribbean cuisine.

Top review

RichardVIP

Dined 2 days ago

Wow! What a dining experience! We had the tasting menu and chose our own wine since we saw a 20 year old Italian wine we “had” to have. The food was exquisite, and the service fantastic. This has made our “must visit” list for all of our future Grand Cayman trips. I am so sad we did not try it 17 years ago when we were first on island.

Ms. Piper's Kitchen + Garden

4.8

4.8 (622)

$30 and under

International

Seven Mile Beach

About the restaurant

Set in the backyard within the heart of 7MB, Ms. Piper’s cottage is a collection of keepsakes of her travels, inspiring our dishes, cocktails, décor, music and thoughtful details.

Her kitchen is a testament of a journey greatly lived. An imprint of the cultural and spiritual life she has pursued and enjoyed. A celebration of graceful aging; that is abundant and eternal. We are creating a meaningful space with a nod to the free spirits, the stylish vagabonds, the young at heart and effortless feminine energy.

Ms. Piper exists in our dreams. She is a figment of our imagination, yet lives in all of us, whispering: “LIVE A LITTLE.”

Top review

Kevin

Dined 5 days ago

Very great tasting food and great experience overall.

Calypso Grill Cayman

4.8

4.8 (329)

$50 and over

International

West Bay

About the restaurant

Island Life. French doors open out onto the terrace overlooking Morgan's Harbour as a soft breeze flows in from the North Sound. This is the Calypso Grill in West Bay. A place to gather with delicious fish and seafood cooked simply with a relaxed and welcoming atmosphere. Executive Consultant Chef Emily Scott, General Manager Lisa Macaulay and all the Calypso Team look forward to welcoming you to this unique location.

Top review

Rhonda

Dined 5 days ago

Fabulous food and service! FABULOUS! The atmosphere was fun and a view of tv water is always a bonus! There were three of us and we all thought everything was delicious! The shrimp and lobster in champagne sauce was an amazing meal and the sticky toffee pudding was the best I’ve ever had!!!

VIVO

4.7

4.7 (181)

$31 to $50

Vegetarian / Vegan

West Bay

About the restaurant

The word VIVO originates from the Latin vīvō and means 'alive' or 'to live'.

Our eco-friendly menu offers vegan, vegetarian, gluten and seafood options.

From farm-to-table we select our ingredients with the greatest care, to serve you organic, natural, healthy and delicious food prepared with passion and positive energy.

This is our mission!

Top review

OpenTable Diner

Dined on May 14, 2025

The staff were so friendly - they obviously take great pride in their restaurant! Our son/wife and toddler granddaughter are all vegan & there were so many choices for them! The ambiance - quiet oceanside sunset - was breathtaking yet informal. Highly recommend!!

ABACUS Caribbean Lobster & Steak House

4.7

4.7 (19)

$50 and over

Continental

Camana Bay

About the restaurant

ABACUS fuses Golden Era Caribbean swagger with modern day Cayman style, creating an entirely new Lobster & Steakhouse experience. The restaurant, which is located in Seven Mile Beach at Camana Bay neighborhood, serves elevated contemporary twists on modern Seafood & Steakhouse dishes. This includes its namesake: “ALL YOU CAN EAT” Caribbean Lobster Tails featured Tuesday, Thursday and Saturday. Our Prime Steaks and Seafood paired with our exceptionally curated wine list providing the perfect enhancement to your dining experience.
Owners, Neil Bryington and Markus Mueri have the pleasure with Chef Charith Heman’s accomplished culinary team, along with your Host, Ryan Reed and his experienced team to welcome you to ABACUS, enjoy professional, attentive service in an inviting atmosphere. ABACUS is an intimate, but high-style destination. Our Bar embracing Cayman Cocktail Culture with our selection of fine Cocktails and the collection of rare Bourbon’s, Whiskey, Tequila and Caribbean Rums.

Top review

Fatimah

Dined on Jun 17, 2025

Wonderful experience overall, particularly with the service by Corey. The all you can eat lobster was to die for.

Milkberry

4.5

4.5 (22)

$31 to $50

Sushi

Grand Cayman

About the restaurant

Born from a love of sushi, the freshest ingredients, and bringing people together, our menu pairs classic sushi with unexpected touches. Seasonally inspired whenever possible, our menu relies on the highest-quality fish and freshest local ingredients available to bring out the best flavors in every dish.. While originality abounds in our creative dishes and the playful ingenuity of our chefs’ concepts, respect for Japanese sushi tradition is evident in our preparation and attention to detail. Everything is made fresh and from scratch, daily.

Top review

LoriVIP

Dined on May 11, 2025

Incredible service and amazing food! Highly recommend and cannot wait to return!

Explore Diners' Choice best of Cayman Islands

Explore more Diners' Choice lists