Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. Caribbean

Diners' Choice: Best Overall restaurants in Cayman Islands

Red OpenTable logo
Updated April 05, 2024

Looking for the best overall restaurants in Cayman Islands? You’re in the right place. Each month, OpenTable analyzes nearly 2 million global diner reviews from the past four months. We sort the results by location and category to help you discover new favorite restaurants. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

A photo of Ms. Piper's Kitchen + Garden restaurant
4.8 (380)
$30 and under
Seven Mile Beach
About the restaurant
Set in the backyard within the heart of 7MB, Ms. Piper’s cottage is a collection of keepsakes of her travels, inspiring our dishes, cocktails, décor, music and thoughtful details.

Her kitchen is a testament of a journey greatly lived. An imprint of the cultural and spiritual life she has pursued and enjoyed. A celebration of graceful aging; that is abundant and eternal. We are creating a meaningful space with a nod to the free spirits, the stylish vagabonds, the young at heart and effortless feminine energy.

Ms. Piper exists in our dreams. She is a figment of our imagination, yet lives in all of us, whispering: “LIVE A LITTLE.”

Top review
Dined on Apr 8, 2024
Such a charming place. The ambiance was just lovely. The food was delicious and the staff was outstanding. I would go back in a heartbeat and recommend it fully to others.
A photo of Aria restaurant
4.7 (97)
$31 to $50
Grand Harbour
About the restaurant
At Aria, we pride ourselves on delivering superior quality throughout every aspect of the dining experience, every time. Expect the freshest, highest quality ingredients, knowledgeable staff, exceptional service, and a beautifully designed, modern space.

We’re the leading innovator in Mediterranean cuisine on the island, with chefs hand-picked from across the Mediterranean. Our menu honors the history and heritage of the food, while still managing to be fresh and modern.

And as part of the Agua Hospitality Group our guests can expect the same superior quality and experience they have come to enjoy at our other establishments.

For event inquiries, please visit: https://www.ariacayman.ky/events

Top review
Dined 2 days ago
Food and service cannot be faulted, a wonderful afternoon
A photo of Blue Cilantro restaurant
4.7 (194)
$31 to $50
Fusion / Eclectic
George Town
About the restaurant
For reservations please call the restaurant directly at 345-945-4372. Looking forward to seeing you!

Blue Cilantro, Where East And West United In Taste. French Mediterranean Asian Fusion, Chef Shetty ,Owner And Chef Blends Asian Spices With French & Mediterranean Cuisine, Extraordinaire Chef Shetty Behind The Restaurant Is Something Of A Legend, Fresh Blue And White Décor, Hang out At The Blue Perspex Bar, Try Our Four Or Six Course Dinner Menus To Enjoy Blue Cilantro Cuisine.

Top review
Dined on Apr 2, 2024
Very good food, the appetizers were wonderful and the soups and salads were excellent. We had both the bisque and the soup of the day (Potato), both were excellent and the caesar salad was great. We were almost full before our entrees arrived! But the entrees were awesome too, I thought the lobster tail was wonderful and the mushroom risotto. Everyone enjoyed what they ordered, no disappointments. And then we got desert, and the Sticky toffee was AMAZING. The service was wonderful, very friendly and attentive. Absolutely recommend!!
A photo of The Brasserie - Grand Cayman restaurant
4.8 (412)
$30 and under
Global, International
George Town
About the restaurant
The Brasserie is the pioneer of the farm-to-table movement in Grand Cayman, setting the expectation for fresh local menus throughout the island. The grassroots establishment produces organic eggs on site, wild raw honey from its 50 hives, coconuts from the 202 palms at Coco Bluff Farm, and catches daily fresh seafood with its two fishing boats, Brasserie Catch I and Brasserie Catch II. Surrounded by an edible garden with flourishing fruit and nut trees, enjoy a unique dining experience outside in the greenhouse terrace or indoors in the elegant dining room or intimate wine cellar. The seasonally inspired and sustainable menu of delicious modern Caribbean cuisine is paired with signature cocktails and an extensive fine wine list.

The Brasserie restaurant is a boutique 65 seat restaurant with bar that warms the soul with its British colonial charm. The restaurant is a hidden gem known by locals for its incredible fresh and interesting modern Caribbean cuisine.

Top review
Dined 3 days ago
Excellent service and very fresh food. Old style restaurant. The snapper was fabulous.
A photo of Sunshine Grill restaurant
4.8 (218)
$30 and under
Seven Mile Beach
About the restaurant
The Sunshine Grill Grand Cayman is Trip Advisor’s number 1 rated restaurant in the Cayman Islands. Enjoy world-class casual dining with true Caribbean flair for breakfast, lunch, dinner or drinks. Our colorful poolside restaurant with award winning food at an affordable price has made The Sunshine Grill a favorite for local residents and international visitors alike. Everyday favorites at The Sunshine Grill include the BEST angus burgers, award winning fish tacos and island specialty drinks.

Reservations for parties of 2 to 4 people are easily accommodated at this time, if you wish to call ahead to confirm please feel free to do so or email us from our Sunshine Suites Resort Website.

Top review
Dined on Apr 7, 2024
Always excellent service and great food. Ate there twice this week!
A photo of Calypso Grill Cayman restaurant
4.8 (52)
$50 and over
West Bay
About the restaurant
Island Life. French doors open out onto the terrace overlooking Morgan's Harbour as a soft breeze flows in from the North Sound. This is the Calypso Grill in West Bay. A place to gather with delicious fish and seafood cooked simply with a relaxed and welcoming atmosphere. Executive Consultant Chef Emily Scott and Head Chef Kye Byford, General Manager Lisa Macaulay and all the Calypso Team look forward to welcoming you to this unique location.

Top review
Dined 5 days ago
It was a delightful evening, we had great service , delicious food and perfect ambiance.
A photo of Agua Restaurant & Lounge restaurant
4.7 (233)
$31 to $50
Contemporary Italian
Camana Bay
About the restaurant
Agua Restaurant & Lounge is a staple in The Cayman Islands having operated since 2010.

Agua Restaurant & Lounge is a seafood restaurant rooted in Italian tradition, inspired by Peruvian cuisine and grounded in local culture.
Snugly situated dockside in the vibrant New Urbanist town, Camana Bay, it offers a carefully curated menu that incorporates fresh local produce and internationally sourced ingredients on plates prepared by a passionate multi-national team of chefs.

Top review
Dined 4 days ago
Agua consistently delivers tasty food, setting itself apart in Cayman by ensuring you don't need to reach for the salt shaker. The service is attentive, with hosts and servers going above and beyond. The ambiance is delightful. While the close seating outside can lead to some noise, it's a small price to pay for such a culinary treat. Plus, the gnocchi is a standout dish worth savoring.
A photo of Ave at Seafire Resort & Spa restaurant
4.7 (343)
$31 to $50
Seven Mile Beach
About the restaurant
Mediterranean Seafood + Steaks
Come with the whole family or sneak away for a romantic dinner at Kimpton Seafire Resort & Spa’s Ave.
Our Executive Chef Massimo De Francesca and his team have created a diverse menu inspired by Mediterranean flavors with local, seasonal ingredients. From fresh catch to prime cuts of steak, the restaurant offers a wide selection of preparations for everyone in the family. The food is delicious, and yet the views are equally compelling. At 24 feet above sea level, Ave overlooks Seven Mile Beach, with seating indoors and on the outdoor terrace. The interior design is open, airy and inviting, with a casual, community vibe that makes you feel welcome before your first bite.
Finish your night in our lounge with a selection from our list of hand-crafted cocktails made with seasonal fruits and house liqueurs.
Ave is where eating well is a day well-spent.

Top review
Dined on Apr 1, 2024
Our server May was outstanding! Very friendly and anticipated our needs. Food was excellent, especially the octopus and coconut shrimp appetizers. Fans outside on the deck made dining outdoors in 80+ degrees comfortable and virtually mosquito-free.
A photo of Avecita at Seafire Resort & Spa restaurant
4.7 (129)
$31 to $50
Seven Mile Beach
About the restaurant
Nestled inside Ave at Kimpton Seafire Resort, you'll find Avecita. It confidently stands out as the center of attention and a truly inventive dining experience - a must have reservation on the island. You'll enjoy a Spanish tapas - style menu featuring modern and traditional dishes perfected on a wood fire grill. An inventive beverage-pairing program that features rare and iconic Spanish wines, along with handmade cocktails that blend in local produce.
The focus of the contemporary space is the Chef's Table, where 10 guests can enjoy the custom tastings as they are created before your eyes. Should you wish to enjoy the Avecita Chef's Table please contact the restaurant directly at +1-345-756-4111 or restaurantreservations@seafireresortandspa.com
Whether you’re seated at the Chef’s counter or at the communal table, Avecita is a culinary memory you’ll take home as a favorite souvenir.

Top review
Dined on Mar 29, 2024
Reuben gave us fantastic service for our anniversary dinner!
A photo of Beach House - The Westin Grand Cayman Seven Mile Beach Resort & Spa restaurant
4.6 (310)
$31 to $50
Seven Mile Beach
About the restaurant
Enjoy dining inside or out with spectacular views of Seven Mile Beach.
Ferdinand’s claim to fame is the famous Sunday Brunch.
Open only for brunch on Sundays from 11.30 am to 2.30 pm

Top review
OpenTable Dinervip
Dined on Apr 6, 2024
We had a wonderful experience here. So much so that we went back again on the same trip! Server was fabulous - remembered our orders, gave us a few little extras - lovely view, food was excellent - highly recommend!
Explore Diners' Choice best of Cayman Islands
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Press
  • Restaurant reservation software
  • Industry insights
  • Hospitality resources
  • Marketing resources
  • Operation resources
  • How to open a restaurant
  • For restaurants
  • For restaurant groups
Join us on
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2024 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 500, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
Agoda Logo
OpenTable Logo