Rick Erwin’s Nantucket Seafood
20 minutes waiting to be seated.
We were seated at a bad table with one of us facing a staff work area and people walking to the restroom having to brush past my chair. We asked for another table when we sat down but were told nothing was available. I might recommend this place but I would ask for a table not in a corner
We love the food and the atmosphere! Celebrated our Seventh Wedding Anniversary. So looking forward to going back soon!!!!
Celebrated our 10 year wedding anniversary. We’ve never been, but the time was right. Food and service was excellent.
Was good but did not rise to my previous experience.
Everything went great. Food was awesome. Service was awesome. We wound up doing the three course meal as items were what we were planning to order anyway and was great value.
Awesome staff, friendly and professional...it was an extra bonus Rick dropped by our table...
Outstanding service, as always. Food perfectly prepared. Beautiful day to dine at Rick Erwin’s.
Excellent filet, it melts in your mouth. Service was good, just waited along time for our main courses
Very nice food in an upscale setting.
Great service. Great food.
Lobster was a little chewy the night we were there. The free desert for our anniversary was a nice touch though.
Celebrating Mother’s Day and my family absolutely loved it!!
Food and drinks were fantastic. Service was top notch! Mr Erwin and stopped by the table to check on everything. Highly recommend!
Good food. Great waitress. A bit too loud!!!
Great time. The food was of high quality as well as the service. Valet parking downtown is a real plus. My wife and I had an excellent wedge salad with Blue Cheese. I also had a cup of the She Crab soup which was excellent. We had the fried flounder which comes with super side dish of grits and cheese and charred brussel sprouts (both excellent). The grouper was also excellent. The next time I may have the grouper but with the grts and brussel sprouts. Overall great service and quality food.
Asked to be seated at the window said she would check she never returned.Where we set was VERY noisy.
Great place for a celebration! The ambience and the service are top notch. We needed to make several changes to our reservation and the hostess and waitstaff were very accommodating. Great for seafood lovers, a nice variety of specialty dishes on the menu. The owner made sure to stop at each table and greet diners. Highly recommend
After searching on open table for oysters, the first hit was Rick Erwins Nantucket Wow what a nice experience. I was in town for business and wanted oysters. Jason was my waiter and he suggested the perfect ones to my taste. This made for an excellent meal and the champagne was perfect! Thank you Jason I will visit when I am here next month
Elegant dinning room. Good service. Very extensive menu with multiple gluten free choices. The food is outstanding with good steaks as well as seafood.
Early Mother’s Day. Thoroughly enjoyed dinner and drinks. Waitress suggestions were spot on.
My friend's birthday was today. We had a "Happy Birthday" sign on the table. This made her feel special when we arrived. The food was excellent and the service exemplary...my favorite restaurant! My friends were impressed with the total picture!
Thank you! Deb Peabody
We were celebrating my wife’s birthday, and it was an exceptional experience. Andres, our waiter, was very attentive. Rick Erwin stopped by our table too see that we were happy. So did the manager.
My wife had crab cakes: they were as good as the menu description. My seared Ahi was well over an inch thick and wonderfully rare.
We are both well pleased and will be sure to return.
40tj anniversary, excellent service, food was delicious.
Service was poor, very poor...waiter waisted food on my table and dropped a glass that shattered and almost hit my guess
Great flounder!!!Saxon and Jenna were superb servers! Great experience!!!!
Wonderful seating on the patio. Absolutely wonderful food. The waiter was very nice but not attentive enough. We ran out of water a few times, and once we had our entrees and were “settled”, our table wasn’t visited again until we were completely done eating. I’m not sure if he was busy or not, but for the price and based on other reviews I read, I was disappointed in the service.
Stellar calamari, lobster, crab cakes, and scallops though!
Perfect celebration restaurant with an exquisite menu.
We took our daughter for her Birthday to Nantucket. Was a special occasion (first restaurant visit since the pandemic happened). Service was impeccable, and the food is really the best in the Upstate. A little pricey, but you get what you pay for!!
Excellent and and service. Alyssa our server was absolutely great. Definitely will be back again.
Went for 5th anniversary dinner and enjoyed everything! The staff and our waiter were great and took great care of us from the time we walked through the door.👍
Birthday celebration! Food and service were exceptional! Always one of our favorite special occasion restaurants!
Saxon was a wonderful and most attentive wait person.
Happy Day Dinner & first visit! Everything was pleasant.
We had a WONDERFUL ANNIVERSARY DINNER AND OUR WAITER WAS ISSAC!!! A VERY KIND AND WONDERFUL MAN! OUR WHOLE EXPERIENCE WAS SIMPLY OUTSTANDING; FOOD, SETTING, STAFF EVERYONE JUST OUTSTANDING !!!!
Amazing food, great atmosphere. The mussels were to die for!
Food was very good. Our waiter was Issac and he was outstanding
Saxon was most attentive & helpful. Food was delicious. The birthday sparkler was a delightful surprise. We will come back again the next time we are in town.
Great late evening meal! Service was fantastic and the food terrific. Best piece of Grouper and Swordfish my wife and I’ve had...a greeting from Rick completed our meal experience. Highly recommend R.E. Nantucket!
Rick Erwin’s Nantucket Seafood is rated 4.8 stars by 4413 OpenTable diners.
Rick Erwin’s Nantucket Seafood does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://www.rickerwins.com/gift-cards/.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.