Nicky's on the Bay

Name: Nicky's on the Bay
Address: 150 S Clinton Ave, Bay Shore, NY, United States, 11706-8632
Telephone: (631) 892-6694
Price range: De $31 a $50
Rating: 3.7

3.7 (8)

De $31 a $50

Pescados y Mariscos

150 S Clinton Ave, Bay Shore, 11706-8632 NY

Haz una reservación

2 personas

16 jun 2025

7:00 p.m.

Reservado 27 veces hoy

Acerca de este restaurante

Ideal por sus vistas panorámicas
Apto para niños
Innovador

Welcome to Nicky’s on the Bay — a top-rated waterfront restaurant in Bay Shore, NY, known for fresh seafood, handcrafted cocktails, and stunning views of the Great South Bay. For over a decade, we’ve been Long Island’s go-to seasonal destination for dockside dining and unforgettable sunsets. Whether you arrive by car or pull up by boat, you're always welcome at Nicky’s — where every seat comes with a view.

Áreas del restaurante

Información adicional

Ambiente
Informal
Precios
De $31 a $50
Cocinas
Pescados y Mariscos, Americana contemporánea, Americana
Horarios
Lun–Jue, Dom 11:00–22:00 Vie, Sáb 11:00–23:00
Número de teléfono
(631) 892-6694
Página web
https://www.nickysonthebay.com/
Dress code
De vestir
Instalaciones para eventos privados
Nicky’s on the Bay in Bay Shore, NY, offers an exceptional waterfront venue for private parties and special events. Whether you're planning a birthday, anniversary, bridal shower, corporate gathering, or any celebration, Nicky’s provides a memorable setting with panoramic views of the Great South Bay and Bay Shore Marina.

Ubicación
150 S Clinton Ave, Bay Shore, 11706-8632 NY
Zona
Bay Shore
Intersección en calle
W Main Street 27A
Parking details
Estacionamiento público
Public transit
Bayshore Train Station
Adicional
Acceso para silla ruedas, Bar / Sala pública, Comida al aire libre, Comida para llevar, Para no fumadores, Salón privado, Vista

Lo que dicen 8 personas

Reseñas de Nicky's on the Bay de comensales del restaurante. Basadas en valoraciones recientes.

Calificaciones y reseñas generales

Solo los comensales que han comido en este restaurante pueden realizar reseñas

3.7

3.7 de acuerdo a calificaciones recientes

3.6Comida
3.8Servicio
4.1Ambiente
3.4Valor

Ruido • Moderado

8 reseñas

C
Carol
Nueva York6 reseñas
5.0
Comieron hace 4 días
1. Global 5
2. Comida 5
3. Servicio 5
4. Ambiente 5
I have been here a couple Of times this season and the view and food never disappoints. Had the Chicken Milanese with arugula salad , with a balsamic glaze. Everything was absolutely delicious. The staff, very friendly and helpful. Will definitely be back again.
¿Te fue útil?
D
Donna
Nueva York3 reseñas
5.0
Comieron en 6 de junio de 2025
1. Global 5
2. Comida 5
3. Servicio 5
4. Ambiente 5
Great super friendly staff, service and delicious food!
Nicky's on the BayRespuesta enviada hace 7 días
Thank you for the kind words, Donna! We’re so happy to hear you enjoyed the food and service — and we’ll definitely share your shoutout with the team!
¿Te fue útil?
M
Mike
Unspecified1 reseña
1.0
Comieron en 6 de junio de 2025
1. Global 1
2. Comida 1
3. Servicio 1
4. Ambiente 2
Was not crowded. Supposedly there is new owners, bugs everywhere no citronella candles. Service was absolutely terrible. Shrimp was undercooked , linguine and clam sauce had no flavor. Never came back to ask if we wanted more drinks. No salt and pepper and Parmesan cheese for the table. Never got it. Even asked the manager for it never got it. Asked for the bill got the bill 20 minutes later. Had to go up to the counter to pay the bill just so we could leave. Absolute terrible experience. Never going back
¿Te fue útil?
N
Natalia
Nueva York1 reseña
1.0
Comieron en 6 de junio de 2025
1. Global 1
2. Comida 2
3. Servicio 2
4. Ambiente 2
We dined at your establishment last night. It was a group of six girls. We had many wonderful drinks. We ordered food at seven and did not get our dinner till 9 o’clock after several times the waitress kept saying five more minutes five more minutes needless to say never coming again
¿Te fue útil?
D
Danielle
Nashville2 reseñas
2.0
Comieron en 4 de junio de 2025
1. Global 2
2. Comida 2
3. Servicio 3
4. Ambiente 4
It was so nice to sit on the water! The crab cakes were good but overall the portions were small and 46$ for a lobster roll and the amount of lobster you get feels like robbery. Super nice sitting outside but deff not worth the cost!!!
¿Te fue útil?
C
Carol
Nueva York6 reseñas
5.0
Comieron en 4 de junio de 2025
1. Global 5
2. Comida 5
3. Servicio 5
4. Ambiente 5
Excellent place for lunch or diner. For an appetizer had the Thai Chili Calamari it was just perfect to start the meal. The Steak Frites was absolutely delicious. The Malibu Pineapple Mojito, perfect. Food was great, staff excellent, beautiful view and atmosphere. Highly recommend Nicky’s on the Bay, you won’t be disappointed.
Nicky's on the BaySe respondió el 5 de junio de 2025
Wow, thank you so much, Carol! We're really glad you had such a great time. Hope we get to see you again soon for another beautiful day on the bay!
¿Te fue útil?
L
Leslie VIP
Región de la Bahía de San Francisco25 reseñas
3.0
Comieron en 25 de mayo de 2025
1. Global 3
2. Comida 2
3. Servicio 3
4. Ambiente 2
We were a bit disappointed with our experience, but perhaps expectations were too high. The mussels didn’t impress. No seafood forks or serving spoon were provided. The excuse for everything was only being open for a week. The halibut was good, but stuffed shrimp was very average. No coffee? Perhaps the reservation should come with a disclaimer early in the season.
Nicky's on the BaySe respondió el 2 de junio de 2025
Thank you for sharing your experience with us. We’re sorry to hear some aspects of your visit fell short of expectations. Early in the season, there are always a few areas we work hard to fine-tune, and feedback like yours helps us do exactly that. We’re glad you enjoyed the halibut and truly hope you’ll consider visiting again later in the season — we’re confident your next experience will be much stronger.
¿Te fue útil?
A
ANTHONY VIP
Nueva York3 reseñas
3.0
Comieron en 24 de mayo de 2025
1. Global 3
2. Comida 3
3. Servicio 5
4. Ambiente 3
Food tool almost an hour to come out, place was not full, no worth the wait.
Nicky's on the BaySe respondió el 2 de junio de 2025
We understand how frustrating it can be to wait on food, especially when the restaurant doesn’t appear to be full. While some delays can happen behind the scenes, we always aim to deliver a smooth and timely experience. We appreciate you giving us a try and hope you’ll consider visiting again.
¿Te fue útil?

Preguntas frecuentes

Nicky's on the Bay ofrece pedidos para llevar; para hacer tu pedido para llevar, llama al restaurante al (631) 892-6694.

Nicky's on the Bay tiene una calificación promedio de 3.7 estrellas, según 8 comensales de OpenTable.

Sí, generalmente puedes reservar este restaurante con solo elegir la fecha, la hora y el tamaño del grupo en OpenTable.

Haz una reservación

2 personas

16 jun 2025

7:00 p.m.

Reservado 27 veces hoy

150 S Clinton Ave, Bay Shore, 11706-8632 NY

Áreas del restaurante

Información adicional

Intersección en calle
W Main Street 27A
Zona
Bay Shore
Horarios
Lun–Jue, Dom 11:00–22:00 Vie, Sáb 11:00–23:00
Precios
De $31 a $50
Cocinas
Pescados y Mariscos, Americana contemporánea, Americana
Ambiente
Informal
Dress code
De vestir
Parking details
Estacionamiento público
Public transit
Bayshore Train Station
Adicional
Acceso para silla ruedas, Bar / Sala pública, Comida al aire libre, Comida para llevar, Para no fumadores, Salón privado, Vista

Página web
https://www.nickysonthebay.com/
Número de teléfono
(631) 892-6694
Instalaciones para eventos privados
Nicky’s on the Bay in Bay Shore, NY, offers an exceptional waterfront venue for private parties and special events. Whether you're planning a birthday, anniversary, bridal shower, corporate gathering, or any celebration, Nicky’s provides a memorable setting with panoramic views of the Great South Bay and Bay Shore Marina.

Nicky's on the Bay

Haz una reservación

Acerca de este restaurante

Áreas del restaurante

Información adicional

Menú

Lo que dicen 8 personas

Calificaciones y reseñas generales

Preguntas frecuentes

¿Ofrece Nicky's on the Bay pedidos para llevar o a domicilio mediante OpenTable?

¿Cuál es la calificación de Nicky's on the Bay?

¿Nicky's on the Bay acepta reservaciones actualmente?

Haz una reservación

Áreas del restaurante

Información adicional