Nicky's on the Bay

Name: Nicky's on the Bay
Address: 150 S Clinton Ave, Bay Shore, NY, United States, 11706-8632
Telephone: (631) 892-6694
Price range: De $31 a $50
Rating: 3.9

3.9 (27)

De $31 a $50

Pescados y Mariscos

150 S Clinton Ave, Bay Shore, 11706-8632 NY

Haz una reservación

2 personas

9 jul 2025

7:00 p.m.

Reservado 35 veces hoy

Acerca de este restaurante

Ideal por sus vistas panorámicas
Ideal para cenas al aire libre
Animado

Welcome to Nicky’s on the Bay — a top-rated waterfront restaurant in Bay Shore, NY, known for fresh seafood, handcrafted cocktails, and stunning views of the Great South Bay. For over a decade, we’ve been Long Island’s go-to seasonal destination for dockside dining and unforgettable sunsets. Whether you arrive by car or pull up by boat, you're always welcome at Nicky’s — where every seat comes with a view.

Áreas del restaurante

Información adicional

Ambiente
Informal
Precios
De $31 a $50
Cocinas
Pescados y Mariscos, Americana contemporánea, Americana
Horarios
Lun–Jue, Dom 11:00–22:00 Vie, Sáb 11:00–23:00
Número de teléfono
(631) 892-6694
Página web
https://www.nickysonthebay.com/
Dress code
De vestir
Instalaciones para eventos privados
Nicky’s on the Bay in Bay Shore, NY, offers an exceptional waterfront venue for private parties and special events. Whether you're planning a birthday, anniversary, bridal shower, corporate gathering, or any celebration, Nicky’s provides a memorable setting with panoramic views of the Great South Bay and Bay Shore Marina.

Ubicación
150 S Clinton Ave, Bay Shore, 11706-8632 NY
Zona
Bay Shore
Intersección en calle
W Main Street 27A
Parking details
Estacionamiento público
Public transit
Bayshore Train Station
Adicional
Acceso para silla ruedas, Bar / Sala pública, Comida al aire libre, Comida para llevar, Para no fumadores, Salón privado, Vista

Lo que dicen 27 personas

Reseñas de Nicky's on the Bay de comensales del restaurante. Basadas en valoraciones recientes.

Calificaciones y reseñas generales

Solo los comensales que han comido en este restaurante pueden realizar reseñas

3.9

3.9 de acuerdo a calificaciones recientes

3.7Comida
4.1Servicio
4.3Ambiente
3.5Valor

Ruido • Moderado

Reconocido por

Suffolk
Ideal por sus vistas panorámicas

27 reseñas

R
Richard M. VIP
Nueva York22 reseñas
5.0
Comieron hace 3 días
1. Global 5
2. Comida 5
3. Servicio 5
4. Ambiente 5
Management and staff were very proud of the new opening of this establishment. Food was very good and worth visiting to sit outside for dinner. Service was also very good
¿Te fue útil?
CV
CamilleV VIP
Nueva York3 reseñas
5.0
Comieron hace 4 días
1. Global 5
2. Comida 4
3. Servicio 5
4. Ambiente 5
Asked to be moved to a different table because of the noise in the bar area and was told there were no tables available. Meanwhile, several tables remained empty during our meal. 😡
Nicky's on the BayRespuesta enviada hace 2 días
Thank you for the 5 stars — we truly appreciate it. We're sorry to hear about the seating issue and understand how that could be frustrating. We’ll take your feedback to heart as we work to improve the guest experience. Hope to see you again soon!
¿Te fue útil?
OT
Comensal de OpenTable
Chicago/Illinois1 reseña
1.0
Comieron hace 4 días
1. Global 1
2. Comida 1
3. Servicio 1
4. Ambiente 3
There was a large bug in my partner’s entree cooked into the spinach. The manager was reluctant to refund our table’s food and tried to get us to instead accept a gift card. We will never be back here - terrible.
¿Te fue útil?
H
Heather
Gran Boston3 reseñas
3.0
Comieron hace 5 días
1. Global 3
2. Comida 5
3. Servicio 1
4. Ambiente 4
I had made a reservation a few days in advance. When we checked in was obvious the hostesses had no clue what they were doing and did not care about being nice or polite to customers. The first attempt to check in the girl took our name, didn't even look at us, said okay and dismissed us with a flip of her hand. We went to the bar to wait. After 15 minutes we went back up and again the two hostesses seemed confused and also didn't remember that we checked in. Again we went to wait at the bar. We watched (and could hear) other customers coming up with no reservation and wanting to be seated outside (as was in our reservation) and were seated right away. Again, we went back up, reminded them again that we were still waiting. It took them a while to figure out if there was any availability outside as we put in our reservation. Once we were finally seated we didn't get water or have anyone come to our table for 15 - 20 minutes. We had to flag down a waiter and ask if he could at the very least get us drinks. The ordering process and getting a refill on drinks was terrible. This is the worst experience Ive had at any restaurant ever. The only saving grace was the view, food and the good company we were with.
A 1 persona le resultó útil
E
Ellie VIP
Nueva York17 reseñas
5.0
Comieron hace 5 días
1. Global 5
2. Comida 5
3. Servicio 5
4. Ambiente 5
We havent been back in years and hands down, this was the best experience we have ever had. The service is incredibly top notch. We would like to send Monica a thank you for being so gracious and kind, especially to our daughter at the table.
Nicky's on the BayRespuesta enviada hace 2 días
Thanks so much for the fantastic review Ellie!
¿Te fue útil?
m
monika
Nueva York1 reseña
5.0
Comieron hace 5 días
1. Global 5
2. Comida 5
3. Servicio 5
4. Ambiente 5
the food and service was excellent. the scenery was breathtaking. we would definitely be back again .
Nicky's on the BayRespuesta enviada hace 2 días
Thanks so much for the 5 stars Monika!
¿Te fue útil?
Z
Zena
Carolina del Sur8 reseñas
5.0
Comieron hace 5 días
1. Global 5
2. Comida 4
3. Servicio 5
4. Ambiente 4
Our server, Megan, was wonderful, thoughtful and professional. Enjoyed our food, cocktails and wine. Always a gorgeous view.
Nicky's on the BayRespuesta enviada hace 2 días
Thanks so much for the 5 stars we'll be sure to let Megan know!
¿Te fue útil?
A
Amy-Jo VIP
Nueva York28 reseñas
5.0
Comieron hace 5 días
1. Global 5
2. Comida 4
3. Servicio 5
4. Ambiente 5
We have always liked Nicky’s on the Bay for a casual summer dinner on the water. So glad the new owners invested in updating the indoor dining area as well as the menu. It’s a bit more elevated than all the fried foods of the old menu. We started with the crab cakes. A little too much breading and not enough of the lump crab that I like; the lobster rolls - cold style but could have had a bit more mayo. Also, I don’t always like French fries so I would have liked another side option like fresh fruit or a small salad. My husband ordered the Mac n cheese side and it was delicious and so plentiful!! Our server Brendan was friendly and attentive and Eric, Assistant General Manager, came by twice to introduce himself and chat! How nice! Looking forward to dining there again in the near future!
Nicky's on the BayRespuesta enviada hace 2 días
Thank you so much for the kind words and detailed feedback! We’re thrilled you’ve noticed the updates to both the space and the menu — it means a lot coming from a longtime guest. We’ll be sure to pass your compliments along to Brendan and Eric!
¿Te fue útil?
d
dana
Nueva York1 reseña
5.0
Comieron hace 5 días
1. Global 5
2. Comida 5
3. Servicio 5
4. Ambiente 5
We are so glad we went when we did. Early on July 4th around opening. We have a family member in a wheelchair who has dietary restrictions. Our servers and all who helped us were kind, and with the dietary concerns you are always worried that it will slip by and be overlooked so when the person came out and handed us the dish announcing that it was dairy free, it was so refreshing that they take it seriously enough to reassure you when they bring it out. We’ve always gone to the small location by ferry dock for decades, but with our new restrictions this seemed like the right choice. Thanks to the staff for kindness and patience and a great meal!
Nicky's on the BayRespuesta enviada hace 2 días
Thanks so much for visiting! Glad we could accommodate your family's needs!
¿Te fue útil?
M
MAUREEN VIP
Nueva York24 reseñas
3.0
Comieron hace 6 días
1. Global 3
2. Comida 3
3. Servicio 3
4. Ambiente 5
The table service was adequate. My husbands meal was good. The baked clams were delicious, but my medium rare steak was well done twice. Mashed potatoes were lumpy. The head waiter took the off the charge for my dinner without even being asked. Because of this I will try the restaurant again this summer.
Nicky's on the BayRespuesta enviada hace 2 días
Thanks for the honest review. We're glad you enjoyed the baked clams and that your husband’s meal hit the mark. Sorry to hear your steak wasn’t right — but we’re happy our team took care of it. We appreciate you giving us another shot and look forward to seeing you this summer!
¿Te fue útil?

Preguntas frecuentes

Nicky's on the Bay ofrece pedidos para llevar; para hacer tu pedido para llevar, llama al restaurante al (631) 892-6694.

Nicky's on the Bay tiene una calificación promedio de 3.9 estrellas, según 27 comensales de OpenTable.

Sí, generalmente puedes reservar este restaurante con solo elegir la fecha, la hora y el tamaño del grupo en OpenTable.

Haz una reservación

2 personas

9 jul 2025

7:00 p.m.

Reservado 35 veces hoy

150 S Clinton Ave, Bay Shore, 11706-8632 NY

Áreas del restaurante

Información adicional

Intersección en calle
W Main Street 27A
Zona
Bay Shore
Horarios
Lun–Jue, Dom 11:00–22:00 Vie, Sáb 11:00–23:00
Precios
De $31 a $50
Cocinas
Pescados y Mariscos, Americana contemporánea, Americana
Ambiente
Informal
Dress code
De vestir
Parking details
Estacionamiento público
Public transit
Bayshore Train Station
Adicional
Acceso para silla ruedas, Bar / Sala pública, Comida al aire libre, Comida para llevar, Para no fumadores, Salón privado, Vista

Página web
https://www.nickysonthebay.com/
Número de teléfono
(631) 892-6694
Instalaciones para eventos privados
Nicky’s on the Bay in Bay Shore, NY, offers an exceptional waterfront venue for private parties and special events. Whether you're planning a birthday, anniversary, bridal shower, corporate gathering, or any celebration, Nicky’s provides a memorable setting with panoramic views of the Great South Bay and Bay Shore Marina.

Nicky's on the Bay

Haz una reservación

Acerca de este restaurante

Áreas del restaurante

Información adicional

Menú

Lo que dicen 27 personas

Calificaciones y reseñas generales

Reconocido por

Preguntas frecuentes

¿Ofrece Nicky's on the Bay pedidos para llevar o a domicilio mediante OpenTable?

¿Cuál es la calificación de Nicky's on the Bay?

¿Nicky's on the Bay acepta reservaciones actualmente?

Haz una reservación

Áreas del restaurante

Información adicional