The Old Mill

Name: The Old Mill
Address: 5775 W Mill Rd, Mattituck, NY, United States, 11952
Telephone: (631) 621-2251
Price range: De $31 a $50
Rating: 4.6

4.6 (50)

De $31 a $50

Americana

5775 W Mill Rd, Mattituck, 11952 NY

Haz una reservación

2 personas

28 jun 2025

7:00 p.m.

Reservado 45 veces hoy

Acerca de este restaurante

Ideal por sus vistas panorámicas
Encantador
Joya de la zona

Built circa 1820 as a grist mill, The Old Mill Inn is a newly-renovated historic, waterfront, adults-only (18 years+) bar and restaurant on Mattituck Creek, located on the North Fork of Long Island. It serves classic American fare with a fresh local twist such as fish & chips, crispy squid, oysters, cheese burgers, and seasonal local vegetables by Executive Chef Kyle Bloomer.

The past and the present collide inside the historic bar room (serving classic cocktails, wine and beer-on-tap) where the mill's original gear shaft stands among the wooden ceiling beams signed by past patrons, dating back to the late 1800s. The new owner received the award for Historical Renovation of the Year from the Long Island Preservation Society in 2024.

Información adicional

Ambiente
Informal
Precios
De $31 a $50
Cocinas
Americana, Pescados y Mariscos, Bar de ostras
Horarios
Lun, Mié–Dom 16:00–23:00 Sáb, Dom 12:00–15:00
Número de teléfono
(631) 621-2251
Página web
https://www.oldmillnorthfork.com/
Opciones de pago
AMEX, Mastercard, Visa
Dress code
Informal y elegante
Chef ejecutivo
Kyle Bloomer

Ubicación
5775 W Mill Rd, Mattituck, 11952 NY
Zona
Mattituck
Intersección en calle
Free valet on weekends. Otherwise, use parking lot on West Mill Rd.
Parking details
Servicio de estacionamiento
Adicional
Acceso para silla ruedas, Bar completo, Cargo por descorche, Cervezas, Cócteles, Opciones libres de gluten, Para no fumadores, Vinos

Menú

El menú de The Old Mill se actualizó por última vez el 7/5/2025.

DINNER

Oysters

Fresh Local Oysters
Jumbo Wild Shrimp, Beet Cocktail SauceUSD 22.00

Shellfish Platter

Shellfish PlatterUSD 79.00
One Dozen Oysters, Four Jumbo Shrimp, Fluke Ceviche

To Share & To Start

Smoked Beet Dip, Labne, Grilled PitaUSD 16.00
KK’s Farm Big Green Salad, Asparagus, Radish, CarrotUSD 17.00
Smashed Artichoke, Whipped RicottaUSD 19.00
Fluke Ceviche, Avocado, Cucumber, Blue Corn ChipsUSD 23.00
Squid a la Plancha, Shishito, Chili Crisp, Basil AioliUSD 22.00
Crab & Artichoke Dip, Sourdough ToastUSD 24.00
Fried Oyster Sliders, Smokey Slaw, Fresno Chili MayoUSD 21.00
Black Garlic Chicken Wings, Crème Fraiche RanchUSD 20.00

Classics

Double Burger, Gruyere, Onion, House-Made PicklesUSD 24.00
Little Gem Caesar Salad, Anchovy, Bacon, BreadcrumbsUSD 23.00
Fish & Chips, Classic Tartar SauceUSD 32.00
Roast Chicken, Maitake, Spring Onion, Salsa VerdeUSD 36.00
Swordfish, Asparagus, Artichoke, Olive, Red ChimichurriUSD 44.00

Sides

Grilled AsparagusUSD 14.00
French FriesUSD 11.00

Lo que dicen 50 personas

Reseñas de The Old Mill de comensales del restaurante. Basadas en valoraciones recientes.

Calificaciones y reseñas generales

Solo los comensales que han comido en este restaurante pueden realizar reseñas

4.6

4.6 de acuerdo a calificaciones recientes

4.5Comida
4.7Servicio
4.6Ambiente
4.1Valor

Ruido • Moderado

50 reseñas

S
Stephanie VIP
Nueva York40 reseñas
5.0
Comieron hace 2 días
1. Global 5
2. Comida 5
3. Servicio 5
4. Ambiente 5
Just continues to be a special experience. Tops is the view. And the service. And the food. The caesar salad is incredible. A bit noisy but it was a night when the window doors were closed.
¿Te fue útil?
m
margaret VIP
Gran Boston87 reseñas
5.0
Comieron hace 2 días
1. Global 5
2. Comida 5
3. Servicio 5
4. Ambiente 5
Love everything about the Old Mill. It was a delicious dinner.
¿Te fue útil?
S
Stacey VIP
Nueva York36 reseñas
2.0
Comieron hace 5 días
1. Global 2
2. Comida 2
3. Servicio 3
4. Ambiente 4
I was very disappointed in this restaurant because years ago it was so great. The location is fabulous but the menu is very limited, the prices were on the high side and the food was not that tasty. I am very sorry to say that I would not go back.
¿Te fue útil?
S
Stephanie
Nueva York44 reseñas
2.0
Comieron hace 7 días
1. Global 2
2. Comida 2
3. Servicio 5
4. Ambiente 2
The service was terrific. The music was loud and the acoustics weren’t helpful. The fish and chips were too heavily battered and the chips were lukewarm and tasteless. The smash burger was boring. The striped bass with curry was tasty, but needed something like rice for the sauce, rather than just the bok choy.
¿Te fue útil?
C
Christina
Región de la Bahía de San Francisco4 reseñas
5.0
Comieron hace 7 días
1. Global 5
2. Comida 5
3. Servicio 5
4. Ambiente 4
Renovation was spot on. Location is magical. Food is elevated tavern food and perfect for the spot and for summer.
¿Te fue útil?
L
Lisa VIP
Región de la Bahía de San Francisco30 reseñas
5.0
Comieron hace 7 días
1. Global 5
2. Comida 5
3. Servicio 5
4. Ambiente 4
Just an all around fantastic culinary addition to the North Fork. We love everything about this place and are thrilled to have another "go to", place for nofo dinner. The noise level inside is a bit overwhelming...music and lots of loud chatter against mostly hard surfaces is hard on the vocal cords but...The Old Mull is WORTH IT, 10000%! *****To the staff! They are a real standout in an area where one is mostly getting served by clueless high-school and college kids, this staff is clearly from restaurant heaven! 😍😍😍😍😍😍
¿Te fue útil?
s
sara
Nueva York4 reseñas
5.0
Comieron en 20 de junio de 2025
1. Global 5
2. Comida 5
3. Servicio 5
4. Ambiente 5
Amazing food, views and ambiance. Joe&Eric are great servers/bartenders! Can't wait to come back
¿Te fue útil?
A
Allan
Nueva York1 reseña
3.0
Comieron en 20 de junio de 2025
1. Global 3
2. Comida 3
3. Servicio 5
4. Ambiente 1
The location is awesome and the restoration is really great but the noise level is crazy loud. My wife and I could barely speak to each other. If I ever go back I will sit outside weather permitting. We ordered a KK’ s mixed greens salad and it was terrible the greens were very tough it was like eating weeds! The manager comped us on the salad. We both had fish and chips which were delicious. I would highly recommend that selection. Our server was Kim and she was outstanding and very attentive to our needs and concerns I would rate our experience as average at best.
¿Te fue útil?
C
Christie
Palm Springs/Ciudades del desierto de la palma1 reseña
3.0
Comieron en 19 de junio de 2025
1. Global 3
2. Comida 3
3. Servicio 3
4. Ambiente 4
I wanted to love it since the building and views are setting the stage for something great, but they are missing on the food entirely. We were not impressed with 3/4 appetizers we tasted. The ceviche was the only well balanced dish that arrived. The service and attentiveness was lacking as well. Hoping they’ll work out the kinks and we would only return if so.
¿Te fue útil?
K
Karen
Nueva York30 reseñas
5.0
Comieron en 15 de junio de 2025
1. Global 5
2. Comida 5
3. Servicio 4
4. Ambiente 4
love it that they have GF options 👏👏First time in years I was able to order GF fish and Chips yahoo so yummy . Thank you for caring. love everything about old mill . Just afraid it will be impossible to get into when people know how wonderful it is . congrats on doing it right
¿Te fue útil?

Preguntas frecuentes

The Old Mill tiene una calificación promedio de 4.6 estrellas, según 50 comensales de OpenTable.

Sí, generalmente puedes reservar este restaurante con solo elegir la fecha, la hora y el tamaño del grupo en OpenTable.

Haz una reservación

2 personas

28 jun 2025

7:00 p.m.

Reservado 45 veces hoy

5775 W Mill Rd, Mattituck, 11952 NY

Información adicional

Intersección en calle
Free valet on weekends. Otherwise, use parking lot on West Mill Rd.
Zona
Mattituck
Horarios
Lun, Mié–Dom 16:00–23:00 Sáb, Dom 12:00–15:00
Precios
De $31 a $50
Cocinas
Americana, Pescados y Mariscos, Bar de ostras
Ambiente
Informal
Dress code
Informal y elegante
Parking details
Servicio de estacionamiento
Opciones de pago
AMEX, Mastercard, Visa
Chef ejecutivo
Kyle Bloomer
Adicional
Acceso para silla ruedas, Bar completo, Cargo por descorche, Cervezas, Cócteles, Opciones libres de gluten, Para no fumadores, Vinos

Página web
https://www.oldmillnorthfork.com/
Número de teléfono
(631) 621-2251

The Old Mill

Haz una reservación

Acerca de este restaurante

Información adicional

Menú

Oysters

Fresh Local Oysters

Jumbo Wild Shrimp, Beet Cocktail SauceUSD 22.00

Shellfish Platter

Shellfish PlatterUSD 79.00

To Share & To Start

Smoked Beet Dip, Labne, Grilled PitaUSD 16.00

KK’s Farm Big Green Salad, Asparagus, Radish, CarrotUSD 17.00

Smashed Artichoke, Whipped RicottaUSD 19.00

Fluke Ceviche, Avocado, Cucumber, Blue Corn ChipsUSD 23.00

Squid a la Plancha, Shishito, Chili Crisp, Basil AioliUSD 22.00

Crab & Artichoke Dip, Sourdough ToastUSD 24.00

Fried Oyster Sliders, Smokey Slaw, Fresno Chili MayoUSD 21.00

Black Garlic Chicken Wings, Crème Fraiche RanchUSD 20.00

Classics

Double Burger, Gruyere, Onion, House-Made PicklesUSD 24.00

Little Gem Caesar Salad, Anchovy, Bacon, BreadcrumbsUSD 23.00

Fish & Chips, Classic Tartar SauceUSD 32.00

Roast Chicken, Maitake, Spring Onion, Salsa VerdeUSD 36.00

Swordfish, Asparagus, Artichoke, Olive, Red ChimichurriUSD 44.00

Sides

Grilled AsparagusUSD 14.00

French FriesUSD 11.00

Lo que dicen 50 personas

Calificaciones y reseñas generales

Preguntas frecuentes

¿Cuál es la calificación de The Old Mill?

¿The Old Mill acepta reservaciones actualmente?

Haz una reservación

Información adicional