Tony's of Indianapolis
(317) 638-TONY (8669)
Tony's of Indianapolis is a modern steakhouse serving huge portions of hand-cut steaks and seafood. We offer an extensive and thoughtfully selected wine list that pairs perfectly with our outstanding menu. At Tony’s, we proudly serve USDA Prime steaks and aged, all natural American beef that we cut and trim in-house. All of our prime-cut steaks are prepared with our proprietary seasoning composed of paprika and a distinct blend of sea salts and peppers. Tony’s seasoning creates a depth of flavor, giving it a deep char while sealing in the juices. Enjoy our steaks along with the freshest seafood brought in daily. This is the place where traditional steakhouse fare shares a table with innovative cuisine. When you're looking for the very best dining experience, choose Tony's of Indianapolis. We welcome you with open arms and look forward to serving you. Grazie Tony
Incredible atmosphere. Lively, bar area, setting is great also for a date night in the dining area. Service is impeccable. Food was extraordinary.
We celebrated our first wedding anniversary at Tony’s, and had the best experience!
Love the food here. Best steaks in Indy. Can be a little stuffy. But servers and steaks are the best
Loved it! It was a celebration evening and this was the perfect restaurant to do that.
Just want to give a big shoutout to Peyton Dennard the Assistant Manager for squeezing me in last minute. The food was amazing and can’t wait into we see again! Thank you guys for a lovely night.
Tony’s is a great place to dine overall!
The service, hospitality, scenery, food, and drinks were fantastic!
Service, food and experience were top notch!!
Tony’s is the new kid among the downtown high-end steakhouses, and it is striving hardest to beat them all. We were amazed that the kitchen was able to offer such a wide array of items when all restaurants are suffering such low patronage.
This restaurant is our new favorite go-to! Thank you for a fabulous anniversary dinner!
Excellent. Believe Tony’s has the best steak in town!
As always, Tony’s was outstanding! Definitely our favorite restaurant.
Great food and environment. Service did a great job educating us on menu.
Only thing I did not like was , the sourdough bread. Everything else, spectacular!
Tony’s always delivers with customer service and quality! They allowed me to store an Anniversary present in their safe and then deliver the gift after dinner...
Great place, Alexander the server is the best and always takes care of us.
Wonderful food, service, and spirits. Would recommend
We loved our first experience at Tony's in Indianapolis. Bill was our server and couldn't have been more awesome! He was so, so friendly and upbeat - which is something I LOVE. Our meal was out of this world and his recommendations on what to order were on spot. We will definitely return at some point.
Quinn’s bone in filet was one of the best if not the best non wagyu filets I’ve ever had.
Hands down the best restaurant in Indy. Service was great, atmosphere great and the food was excellent.
One of the best steaks I have ever had! The bone in ribeye was cooked to perfection and the flavor was outstanding.
Very good dinner, great service. The staff is really friendly and welcoming. Food is great quality, super fresh. We had both steak and seafood. The crabcake alone is worth the trip.
The staff was wonderful even with covid. They were attentive and also very thorough with cleaning in between customers. The managers came over to check in and even Tony stopped over to say hi and make sure we’re doing well. The food was beyond my expectations and every bite was just as delicious as the last!
Alexander was amazing! Very attentive. Food was very good. CRABCAKE! CRABCAKE ! CRABCAKE!
Amazing as always. Tony’s is one of our favorite spots and never disappoints
Server was pleasant, but our table quickly became second fiddle once a larger party was seated near us.
Went with dry aged pork chop, should have gone with the steak. Thought I'd give it a try. It was massive. Tough to cut, tough to eat & tough to digest. Wish I'd ordered differently. Wife ordered chicken & said it was outstanding.
The food and service both were fantastic. Alexander was our server, as we had requested him to be. He is spot on with recommendations IF you need them. No pushy at all, just very helpful and attentive . We will be back again
Thank you !
The crab cake has been better in the past. Also not enough choices on veggies and with the current Pandemic I was shocked to see that the proper face coverings were not being used we will not be back unsafe. When making a choice to dine out I call to ensure that we are going to a business that practices social distancing and is using the proper face coverings and gloves. Also do they have shields or anything to separate the guest at least enough space you might want to visit Ocean Prime the bar area which has up shields and uses your phone for the menus and the staff have the correct face coverings just to at least know what to do. Thank you but no Thank you to Tony's UNSAFE DINING!!!
Food was very good!
Serving staff very polite.
Very packed to our surprise during Covid. Full House
Tony's has become our favorite place in town for a special dinner. In this case we celebrated my wife's birthday - everything from drinks at the bar, to the steaks, to the live jazz trio (LIVE MUSIC!!) was excellent. And the service was attentive and responsive without being over-present.
Waiter was excellent! Knew each and every item and answered all our questions. If you're looking for an exceptional upscale restaurant, Tony's downtown Indy is your place!
Excellent food and service. One of the best dining experiences I have had.
Our server, William, was wonderful. He made us feel special and yet right at home - all at the same time. Thank you!
My $70 bone-on filet arrived at our table so cold that the $4 Gorgonzola butter placed on top hadn’t even tried to melt.
I returned the steak only to get it back slightly warmer on the exterior but still cold on the inside and still not able to melt the butter on top.
I returned it again. It came back warmer, but no longer medium rare. The chef melted the butter and placed it in a separate dish.
This entire process took over 15 min. By the time I finally just said screw it, my wife was nearly done with her steak, the sides had started to get cold.
With all that said, my wife and I were celebrating our 32nd anniversary.
I’m not in any hurry to return.
Hi Tim, thank you for your review and we sincerely apologize for the inconvenience. We assure you that this is not indicative of our standards and would appreciate it if you could call us at 317-638-TONY (8669) our manager Michael Morgan would love to speak with you.
Excellent food and service. Best prime rib in town and the lobster tail was delicious! Great job by the wait staff as well!
Every dish was outstanding! Our server was great and was right on with recommendations. Will definitely go back after I fast for 2 weeks!!
I recently celebrated my anniversary at Tony's Indianapolis. The atmosphere was perfect, especially since we were one of 4 tables in the restaurant at the time, the lighting and music created a romantic mood. We split the porterhouse, medium rare. The food was incredible, the calamari was crispy, the steak was cooked perfectly and melted in your mouth definitely the best I've ever had, the mac n cheese was super rich, and they surprised us with a cheesecake at the end that was perfect with the blueberry drizzle. The service and hospitality were amazing, our waitress Haley was very attentive and sweet and wore a clear mask which was a nice touch, we even got a few visits from the manager. Today I received two letters from Tony's, one was handwritten from our waitress and the other was signed by the owner himself with his personal card enclosed. Everyone at Tony's made our day special, and for that I will definitely return.
Tony's was great! The steaks were cooked perfectly and our service was great.
Went for our anniversary. Service was fabulous, food was delicious, ambience was great. Our only issue was there were two individuals that were loud and seem to be drunk. Manager and staff were friendly and helpful to keep them quiet and satisfied with their dinner. No fault to the staff and they handled them very well. Otherwise, I was very pleased with everything.
My steak was over cooked, my son’s steak was way undercooked. They made me a new steak which was good. My son sent his back, it came back still extremely rare but he ate it anyway. The sides were average but the cheese cake was out of this world. I would go back just for that.
I had the 24 ounce Porterhouse and it was the best steak that I’ve ever had. The seasonal salad was also incredible. Service was above and beyond, just an overall great evening. I will be back and will recommend to my friends.
Tony's of Indianapolis offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (317) 638-8669.
Tony's of Indianapolis is rated 4.8 stars by 1019 OpenTable diners.
Tony's of Indianapolis does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://tonysofindianapolis.com/shop/.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.