Tony's of Indianapolis

We loved the atmosphere in the restaurant but feel the steaks were average and overpriced.

Lovely place. Great service and great food! Loved getting to meet Tony himself as well, that was a nice touch.

This was our first visit and I must say it was a lasting impression and we will return. The crab cake was incredible, barrel cut filet was cook perfect and had great flavor also the service was spot on. I've passed on our experience to several friends and we look forward to seeing you the next time.

Dinner was wonderful as always. Service was also outstanding as always. Our only complaint is the band playing in the bar area was a little loud. Other than that, the food and service is why we continue to go back. There is not a better steak in town.

Tony's was absolutely amazing. From the incredible customer service to the delicious food, everything was perfect. My husband and I felt like VIPs, and we will definitely be back.

Birthday dinner

Was my wife's and I anniversary and we were recommended to try Tony's, it met and exceeded our expectations, we were blown away by the entire experience, the food was outstanding and the service was outstanding as well, I would highly recommend Tony's to anyone wanting a great dinning experience,

Anniversary

My wife and I had dined at the Cincinnati location previously and recommended this to our friends so we could try the one here in Indy. It was a great choice. I definitely like the vibe in Indy better than Cincinnati. The food was excellent at both locations. The steaks are superb. Better than St. Elmos and virtually every Indy steakhouse. Everything we had was a unanimous 👍.

Excellent meal and service!

My friend and I had dinner before the theater about which we informed the waiter. We had great cocktails, shared the Brussels sprouts salad before our entrees. We ordered the filet and salmon entrees. They were beautifully prepared and presented. Our waiter was very friendly and attentive as were all the staff. The one downside was that the entrees came out later than expected so we could not eat as leisurely as desired. The waiter checked several times and apologized profusely which we appreciated.

3 diners, no alcohol, 3 appetizers, no salads, 3 entrees......bill with 20% tip was $370.

At $100/person (not including tip or alcohol) I felt the value was good, not great. There is a lot of high-end competition at that price point.

The wait staff & timing of food delivery was excellent . I had the dry-aged strip ($65+) and I would not spend the extra money on it next time. Another diner with me had the standard strip offering and it was just as good for $25 less.

The shrimp cocktail and crab cake appetizers are highly recommended. In fact, the main reason I would return would be for those two appetizers.

Great service.

Everything was great. The food was second to none, and the service was just as good. Only complaint was that there was a slight draft (its particularly cold this evening) and it was a little louder than expected. Both of these were likely caused due to us being seated near the entrance and close to the bar, so I don’t really hold them to fault. It was one of the best dinner experiences I have ever had and I look forward to my next visit.

EXCELLENT in every way!!

Had a great evening the meal was delicious and our waiter Josh was very informative of the menu.My wife and I were celebrating our fourty seventh wedding anniversary and were seated in a very comfortable cozy spot where we could overlook the entire surroundings had a great time.

Birthday for my husband. Very pleased with having the owners and managers come around often to meet and greet us. Everybody so pleasant. Made us feel special. A nice portion of food. Had enough for the next day.

The steak and crab cakes we're incredible.

The food, service and atmosphere were terrific.

Wonderful dinner. 12 oz barrel cut filet. Oysters and crab cake to start. Cesar salad with parmesan crisp is always a great salad. This is our go to place for nirthday dinners. Its a splurge but so worth it. Service is exceptional.

The service was top notch. And the food is fantastic. You cannot beat the 14 oz New York Strip. All portions are also very large. Bring a big appetite.

We had a nice time and our server, Brandon, was great! I would go back but maybe not for a full meal but for drinks at the good looking bar!

We visited for my daughter’s birthday and they brought her a special dessert!

The service was excellent. The food was outstanding. Our waiter took a personal interest in our dinning and ourselves. Great experience!

This was our second visit in the last 9 months. As the first time, service was exceptional with Alexander and May. Me wife had the 9oz Filet and I had the Tuna. Both were perfect with the 3 piece jazz in the background. As a prior Chicago resident, this tops many of the downtown Steakhouses,

Another awesome dinner with outstanding service. We love Tony's!!

Great food and experience. Wonderful service

We often visit... this occasion was my husband’s bday. Both my son and Steve had seafood, very well prepared and presented. I stuck with the amazing fillet.
Isaiah, we truly enjoy seeing you and catching up. We feel Tony’s has become our extended family.
Thank you!

The steak was one of the best I have ever had and the service was exceptional. Our waiter Mario was awesome and would definitely recommend to anyone looking for an exceptional experience.

Fantastic- our Waitress McKenzie was absolutely phenomenal - Tony was so down to earth and a very gracious host!

A group of 5 friends met for dinner at 5PM on Tuesday. Reservations were made although at 5PM there was no one else there. By the time we left however, the joint was jumping. Servers, Manager & Owner all stopped by to check to ensure all was well & it was. Their food is delicious. My husband loved his filet ($44). The 4 Mac n cheese was ok. I had the crab cake ($21). It was delicious as well. I also had the greek salad which was wonderful. I asked that they put no onion in it & if they wanted to throw in a little extra feta, it would be great. They did but when the bill came, I had been charged an extra $3 for the cheese. All 3 bills presented to us were incorrect & had to be redone, which took way top long. I should have been advised, in advance, of the $3 charge because after spending over $100 on 2 meals, I feel like that was unnecessary. Everyone loved what they ordered & it all looked very good.

Exceptional food and the presentation was superb. The service was the best I have had while living in Indianapolis. Great wine and drink list.

Great food and outstanding service. Brandon was extremely professional, attentive, and polite. We will be coming back.

Had a fabulous dinner at Tony’s celebrating my birthday! Food and service was outstanding. Can’t wait to go back!~

We were staying across the street and saw how busy Tony’s was every night so we decided to try them out. The vibe of the restaurant was a little more modern than your stereotypical steak house. The food was good with large portions. We had leftovers that were promptly boxed up for us, but we had to ask 3 different people to get some plastic utensils to take with us since we were staying in a hotel and wanted to be able to enjoy our leftovers. We would eat there again and the food was good, but there are several other places we might chose first.

I would have given 5 stars across the board except for the ambiance was ruined by the loud, drunk woman sitting next to us. The restaurant did what they could to quiet her but she was not to be hushed.