Tony's of Indianapolis

Excellent food, and superb service! This place was hands-down delicious. You have to try the bourbon butter they bring with the fresh, warm bread. Worth. Every. Calorie.

Great dinner and service was outstanding!

The experience was wonderful. We have dined at fine restaurants and the portions at Tony’s are bountiful. The atmosphere and dining was excellent. We highly recommend. Brandon was our waiter and did a great job. The crab cake appetizer was a meal in itself. Excellent! We had a salad and the crab bisque which were wonderful. My wife had a pasta dish and I had the filet. Both were prepared to perfection. We had a yellow cake for dessert and took home half our meal because the portions were so large. If you are trying to select a restaurant in Indy fine dining if you don’t select Tony’s you’ve made a wrong choice. It was a fun atmosphere, excellent service, great food and a great time. Highly recommend!!

Everything was delicious. This is the second time we’ve dined at Tony’s. Server was a little awkward but overall fine.

5 star service.
High quality food.
Perfectly seasoned.
Priced for special occasions and worth it!

Tony's is a classy, stylish, upscale restaurant with plenty of elbow room! We have chosen Tony's over our old indy steakhouse favorites for the past few occasions! Outstanding cocktails, steaks and service

Impressed by the decor and service. Steak was excellent, perfectly cooked. Had we known portion size, we would have split it. Shrimp cocktail was outstanding. Beet salad was also excellent and also could have easily been shared. Only complaint is that server made every effort to steer my wife from her desired pasta and then fish selection to the sea bass special which was at best mediocre but of course was pricier than what she really wanted.

Wife’s birthday

This was our first trip to Tony’s and we were very impressed. The food was terrific and the service was even better! Peyton, our server, took great care of us. We will be back.

I knew about Tonys from their restaurant in Lexington Kentucky, so when we were walking in downtown Indianapolis and I saw Tonys I told my group that we were changing plans. The food and service was truly outstanding. Everything we ordered was to perfection. Thanks for an outstanding experience.

Best place to eat in Indy! Food is amazing! Service is outstanding! Bartenders are fun and knowledgeable!

I seldom if ever give a five star rating, but exceptional experience. Bill, our waiter, was best we've had anywhere in several years. Informative, kind and attentive, but not overbearing. Michael, manager, stopped to talk and food was exceptional! Will definitely return!

Excellent service, food, and live music.

The best steak restaurant in Indy- skip the “known” places in Indy and try Tony’s!

Tony's in one of our absolute favorites in Indy! You always get friendly, white glove service from the entire staff. Food is top notch and wine is amazing. Thanks for always making our visits special.

Nice place with good quality food but really too expensive even for United States standards.

Had a great experience, Peyton was very attentive performed great. It was a business/pleasure dinner and I think my guest will return soon on their own. Excellent food and drinks!

Absolutely great experience. Tony’s has become my favorite steakhouse in Indy. Great food but even better service.

Food and service were amazing! Highly recommend! Valet parking made the night a breeze!

Perfection

Brandon our waiter was outstanding.

The food was fantastic, and the service was wonderful. The waiter made some great suggestions, not just trying to 'sell' us on some choices. The ambience is great. I rated the noise less than the great due to a table of 4 men at the next table next to us, who were quite loud and were swearing throughout their meal. Not exactly the best setting for them. They probably should have sat in the bar. Other than that, it was a wonderful experience there (it was my 2nd time at the restaurant).

Fantastic service as always. Wonderful meal.

First time. Will return

Wonderful food and great ambiance! The mussels are outstanding and the filet melts in your mouth!

Alexander was our server. He was very nice. Refills on waters were quick and many staff checked on us frequently. The food was wonderful. Steaks done to order were very good. We had no issues and enjoyed the live music.

The food was awesome but both me and my wife were a little disappointed we didn't get a booth for our 23rd wedding anniversary when we made reservations two weeks prior. Tony's is a really nice restaurant it would have been nice to get a complimentary photo on anniversary in the restaurant

Our server Chris was great, and they were so nice to accommodate our whole party.

By far the best in Indy.....Don't miss this place. Service and food was as good as anyplace I have ever eaten at.

Unbelievable start to finish. Beat meal we have ever had. Order the crab cake!!! Mackenzie is an amazing server!!!

Great food, great people, great place. Service is spot on. Steaks are always cooked to perfection!

What an awesome restaurant. The food, the service, the experience was unforgettable. We will return again soon.

Food was great and the service was excellent. I would Tony's to anyone. Perhaps not vegetarians.

Outstanding! Thanks Michael and Makenzie (sorry for the misspelling).!

We were extremely pleased with the the steaks, salads and sides as we were the first time we dined at Tony's. We thought the bread and coffee was just... OK. And, the staff was great.

We were attending a business meeting in town. The hotel highly recommended Tony’s.
Our server answered our questions about the menu and made changes requested for individual tastes. We would dine at Tony’s again.

This was our first experience. We would revisit again.

Great service!

Good food, food service

One of the best waiters I’ve ever had! Excellent food and service, and it was quiet enough that our group could have good conversation at the table.