Tony's of Indianapolis
(317) 638-TONY (8669)
Tony's of Indianapolis is a modern steakhouse serving huge portions of hand-cut steaks and seafood. We offer an extensive and thoughtfully selected wine list that pairs perfectly with our outstanding menu. At Tony’s, we proudly serve USDA Prime steaks and aged, all natural American beef that we cut and trim in-house. All of our prime-cut steaks are prepared with our proprietary seasoning composed of paprika and a distinct blend of sea salts and peppers. Tony’s seasoning creates a depth of flavor, giving it a deep char while sealing in the juices. Enjoy our steaks along with the freshest seafood brought in daily. This is the place where traditional steakhouse fare shares a table with innovative cuisine. When you're looking for the very best dining experience, choose Tony's of Indianapolis. We welcome you with open arms and look forward to serving you. Grazie Tony
The food was delicious. Old fashioned cocktails were amazing!
Excellent as always!
Jumbo crab cake a d cheesecake are a definite yes!!!
I've been to every single premiere steakhouse in Indy. For my personal preference this one is the best. Let's face it, at this price point cost is not the deciding factor. Food is phenomenal. I think it's the best in town. Ambience is great. Can be romantic or not- that depends on you. Service is perfect- helpful but not intrusive. Wine list is extensive. Yep, overall tough to beat.
The service, food, and ambiance were excellent. We will definitely come back.
Food was great and Alexander provided great service with great panache!! We will be returning soon!
Amazing service and great food! Will definitely be returning in the future.
Excellent service, the staff and food were wonderful. I did think the band was a little loud. Our server Bill was excellent
The service and food was excellent.
This is our second time here from out of town and it is amazing. Food was great and so was service. Thank you to our server Alexander for helping to make this a great celebration
Food and atmosphere was very refreshing and clean. Great place to take a special date.
From the hostess to our server, Matt, to the bussers with their table scraper, our first time at Tony’s was nothing short of wonderful! 🖤The pride that each and everyone has for their job shows in every way possible! The manager came and spoke to us, and not in a “I’m really glad you’re here but secretly I’m counting down the seconds until you leave” but in a genuine, heartfelt way that made us feel welcomed! 💕
Even with being socially distant, there was one lady that was talking so loud to her dinner guest, that it made us uneasy for him. He was getting his butt chewed out for something he did 5,367 days ago that she just had to talk about that night. 🙄
The food portions are so big, we could’ve easily split everything and still had enough to take home for snacks! 🥩 🥔 🥗 🍤
Let’s not forget to talk about the cheesecake covered in creme brûlée!!! Omgoodness!!! It was sinful! 😈
Then, I found out one of my favorite chefs that I worked with at another establishment, is one of the chefs at Tony’s! It makes sense why it all tastes so phenomenal because he is one of the most talented chefs I know!!!
I highly recommend for everyone to go at least once! You will not be disappointed!!
This was our first time at the restaurant. Very nice evening! Food was great. It took a bit for our eyes to adjust to the lighting. It is dimly lit. The wait staff and the Manager were great. We felt welcome and enjoyed the experience.
Food and service was outstanding. The Filet was cooked a perfect Medium Rare. The Chilean Sea Bass entree was probably one of the best I have ever had. It was served over a bed of barley, topped with caramelized onions & shaved sprouts with a maple sage emulsion. (Amazing!) The Calamari appetizer served with Pepperoncini Peppers, Cherry Tomatoes, & a Garlic Aioli along with the Grilled Caesar salad rounded out our dinner. Definitely planning a return visit.
Very overpriced on certain items. Server offered me calamari and oysters 4 times despite my having declined the first time in which I stated I didn’t like oysters or calamari. The busses took better care of me than the server. He remembered I didn’t want ice in my water after I said that the first time he offered a refill. Server put ice in the water every time.
My husband and I (along with our daughter) had dinner at Tony's for our 11th year wedding anniversary.
I was really anxious because what I look for at restaurants is good customer service. If the service is bad, it ruins everything for me no matter whether the food is good.
Holy cow was I relieved! I really didn't think we'll find a restaurant like this in Indianapolis. Alexander was fantastic! Very attentive and provided suggestions. From drinks to appetizers to main course to dessert was timed perfectly. We were spoiled! The excellent service made everything wonderful!
The food: for appetizers we had shrimp cocktail and mussels... Wow! So good! Love the mussels sauce. We finished the whole thing, lol! By the time we had the main course, I'm already full. My husband enjoyed his filet mignon, my daughter likes her rigatoni and my prime rib was perfectly cooked. For desserts, we tried the vanilla cake and chocolate cake. We also ordered creme brulee but was served cheesecake instead. My husband said it was good and fine with it but I'm counting for the next time we get exactly what we ordered 🙂.
Thank you, Tony's. We'll be back again!
The service alone makes this restaurant. The staff was very attentive to our needs. The timing of the courses came out perfectly and the food was delicious. We ordered the Alaskan King Crab Legs, Shrimp Cocktail, split a caesar salad. I ordered a filet and my husband ordered the pistachio pesto. My filet came out just a little undercooked than what I prefer and our server immediately noticed and took care of it for me immediately and it came out perfectly!
Great service from Brandon. Loved the private room.
While we enjoyed our first time experience at Tony’s Steakhouse, we did not feel that there was anything that differentiated them from similar restaurants. The food was just ok. The service was great though!
Great food and atmosphere
They always have great service and food is excellent.
We went for our 1 year Anniversary and we had the best time ever! It was amazing and I would highly recommend it to anyone!
My wife and I had a great anniversary dinner at Tony's. We both agreed it was the best steak we had ever eaten. Thanks for a great evening!
Went there to celebrate Valentine’s Day and it was wonderful.
Always a great experience. Great for business or a celebration.
Beautiful night, Alexander was fantastic. The valet was horrible, slow and at or point they let a vehicle run out of battery.
I will definitely be back to Tony’s. It was an awesome dinner!
It was a great all around experience..
Tony’s is by far my favorite place to get a steak
We celebrated our ten year anniversary at Tony’s. The food was fantastic, prepared perfectly. The steaks we cooked exactly how we asked for and extremely tender. The staff checked in frequently to ensure our experience was the best. They brought out a small desert treat as a thank you for choosing Tony’s to celebrate our anniversary.
Fantastic restaurant food, ambiance and service are exceptional. One of the best steakhouse in indy
Always a great place to be! Love the live music
Was an amazing night. I had Flowers Delivered to the restaurant and they had us in a corner booth with the flowers on the table when we where seated. Food was amazing again they did not disappoint.
This place was amazing. My girlfriend and I went here the first night of a weekend getaway and it did not disappoint. The seared ahi tuna tartar was our favorite
The menu and ambiance at Tony’s are spectacular. The prices are a little high compared to other Indy steakhouses.
The service is wonderful. Would highly recommend.
Our server that night was the best and the food was outstanding. Go downtown Indy and try Tony's, it beats and restaurant in the city.
The Calamari was delicious! But be warned, there are jalepeños.
Food was great, service was okay.
We are from Cincinnati and visit Tony’s of Cincinnati on a regular basis and happen to be in Indianapolis for a volleyball tournament for my daughter. We decided to go to Tony’s of Indianapolis… Our server Bill was fantastic and the food was amazing. The service here is top notch and you won’t find a better steak in Indy!
Tony's of Indianapolis offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (317) 638-8669.
Tony's of Indianapolis is rated 4.8 stars by 1148 OpenTable diners.
Tony's of Indianapolis does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://tonysofindianapolis.com/shop/.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.