It was an excellent dinner. The steak was perfect

Service out on the patio was a delay, and the rare steak was well done. The food also came out a bit cool, so herb butter didn't even melt on the steak

From the ambience to the food preparation and presentation, everything was excellent. There was a good depth to the menu but the flavors of our meal were the stars of the evening. It is worth the drive to Jekyll for a great meal and an enjoyable evening out.

This is a very nice restaurant. The staff was very accommodating. My wife only took one bite of her dessert and did not like it. The staff quickly replaced it for a different type at no charge.

The steaks and side had no seasoning. No salt, butter, pepper, or anything. If you go you may want to try the fish.

Food was excellent. Service was very good would highly recommend

We have come to enjoy The Reserve (a very nice menu and, in my view, the best steak in the area) and we were glad to see on this particular night that it had a good crowd of patrons. Service was good but the wait staff may have been taxed by the larger crowd. All-in-all, it was a great experience.

Overall not bad. I feel for a more fine dinning place I would think the dress code would be a little higher. Food was pretty good.

Great setting. Table looked out toward the water. Drinks were very good and food was well prepared and seasoned.

Great food and service. Went for my wife’s birthday and they gave her a free desert. We will definitely going back.

Third time dining here while visiting Jekyll. Food was delicious (steak, scallops, pork chop and a number of sides. But what we really loved was being able to have a nice dinner outside, no matter the weather, with their heaters and covered porch. We will not eat inside until we have our vaccines and this place was perfect! If you are careful, like us, you can eat here with no worries!

Had a delicious lunch, we all got their burger, so I can’t speak for the rest of their menu, but it was delish. This has become our place to go during COVID due to their wonderful outside dining. Great covid protocols!

We are glad we decided to try The Reserve out while staying at the Westin. My wife and I were celebrating our 12 year anniversary and this was the perfect place to do it. It was amazing food and service. We will definitely be coming back again!

Bring your pay check b/c this place is $$$ but worth it!

This was our first experience here. The atmosphere was very calming and quiet which was what we were looking for since this was a date night. Wilton was an amazing server. The sides were really good. The steak was just ok, we had the 22 ounce tbone cooked medium. It was cooked to our specifications but the cut of meat was slightly tough. The taste was very good, just not as tender and we would’ve liked. We would go back if in the area again but would order a different cut of meat. Thanks for an enjoyable experience.

We truly enjoyed our experience, and everything was delicious, especially the creme brûlée! Our server Ashley was personable and professional and even recommended mocktail mojitos since we’re dry January-ing. Our only critique is that music would have enhanced the ambiance, but otherwise, we had a fantastic dinner. Thank you!

Was very disappointed. Beautiful ambiance, but the food was too expensive and far too bland.

My wife and I were camping on Jekyll and were kid free. Highly recommend The Reserve and give it the BEST review.

Server did everything he could but kitchen delayed him. I have had a better steak at chain restaurants and for $50 expected better. Calamari was overly breaded. Disappointing experience when dining at a Westin Resort.

We throughly enjoyed the Reserve, our experience would have been slightly better if not for the pandemic. We did feel though that they took great care to be safe and to have a delightful dining experience.

I love Westin hotels and usually have had a good dining experience however on this particular evening our waiter was not very attentive he was very busy talking to his coworkers which gave us an outcome of poor service. He brought our food before he brought our silverware and did not check back on us regularly to see if we needed anything. My steak was burnt on the outside and my boyfriends fish was very dry. We wereVery disappointed as we were expecting a five-star experience.

Waiter Mr. Wilson from Jaimaca was stellar. Best high end restaurant in Jekyll and may be only one.

Attentive wait staff
Great with kids
Flexible seating

Excellent restaurant with gorgeous setting. The prices are fair for the quality of the steaks and sides. Everything was perfect

Celebrating a milestone birthday with an evening dinner outside on the patio. We both had the surf and turf. On the pricey side but an Excellent meal. The service was outstanding.

Wonderful experience
Food was excellent as was the service

Brothers Anniversary

Great service...a little hotel predictable...good food...love Jekyll

Restaurant was above average to nice. However, I made reservations two weeks prior to our arrival requesting a window table and was told non were available when we arrived due to a request made the day before. ???? We then sat next to two window tables that remained empty for our entire stay. Frustrating! Last minute requests should not over ride reservation request made weeks in advance. I'll consider this prior to making future reservations.

Great evening with great service and food. Being locals in St Simons The Reserved was suggested by friends. A huge compliment here. Food was fantastic, the scallops with bacon jam off the hook fresh. My t-bone was cooked perfect,

Everything about The Reserve was amazing!!!! My daughter loved her 13th birthday so much!

We live locally and dined here for our first time this past Saturday (and the first amongst our group of friends). Our server was very sweet- she was attentive and provided great "silent service" to ensure we were enjoying ourselves (visibly present at our table but not necessarily interruptive sine it was "date night"). There was a one drawback to our dinner but we feel that was rectified within the dining experience. I will add that someone needs to revisit their recipe for béarnaise sauce- I was scared to actually taste it due to it not looking anything like béarnaise (color, consistency, etc.) but the herb butter on top of my steak was outstanding.
Definitely try the Peanut Butter Pie!

Valentines Day

Been traveling for over 40 years and this was the worst dining experience I’ve ever had. It was noisy, over priced, substandard service, undercooked seafood and the mediocre food.
I wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone.

Great service, and my companion’s salmon was very good. However, my pork chop, which was supposed to be a house specialty, was incredibly dry. It was a great piece of pork, but really should have been marinated or cooked slower. Or better yet, both. The sweet potato casserole that came with it was superb, the best part of the meal!

Great ambiance but lack luster food. Both of our steaks were undercooked. We would’ve ordered a second drink but our server was not attentive so we didn’t have the chance. We had heard great reviews of this place but it was probably the worst steak I’ve ever had.

Always a favorite for special occasions. Staff is accommodating and attentive.

This is my fourth time here I will be back I love the service Top notch Very fine dining I love this place

Very upscale restaurant is what I am use too. I will be back

Great meal. My husband and I both got steaks and they were excellent . Service was nice.

Daughters Birthday. Service and attention very good. Had to return 2 overcooked steaks - but they did quickly replace.