The Preston House & Hotel - Restaurant

Dinner we found to be mediocre, stripe bass bland, beer flat little things seem to be not paying attention. Brunch on the other hand was interesting, tasteful and good variety.

Fabulous food, lovely surroundings. Kim our waitress was great, a bit harried due to under staffed but she made it a great anniversary dinner. A go to spot always excellent!

Excellent food and service. Would definitely go back for a special occasion or birthday.

Incredible pasta dishes. Wonderful menu selections from appetizers to deserts. Definitely recommended!

Wonderful historical home is an amazing restaurant. Superb cuisine and attentive staff. Do not miss this experience!

Very overpriced and not very good

Lovely spot in the wilderness of Riverhead, but very close to several nearby golf courses. You can eat inside or on the outside veranda. Or, even at the attractive bar. The food is excellent and of the highest quality. The chef is creative in his use of local products to produce beautiful and delicious food.

Too pricey.

The food and the service were fabulous. I thought that the portion size was perfect, but my guest was not as impressed. Service was wonderful and not stuffy at all, which was a pleasure!

Service and Food were Awesome..!
Pricey..!

Went for ramen night. Dumpling app was over powered by the sauce. Soups were not even warm. Dumplings in the pho where not edible because the broth was room temperature. Big let down. No one even checked in on us to see if everything was ok. Expected way more from an upscale restaurant.

Very attentive staff and delicious food.

Dinner was amazing, food was delicious, venue is spotless with a nice atmosphere and our waitstaff was outstanding.

Birthday dinner but we skipped the desert and singing happy birthday because the food, service, and vibe were horrible!

Totally understaffed, seated right away but waited 40 minutes for any service. A great waitress recovered the evening but otherwise disappointing. Food was good but management poor. Won’t be going back anytime soon

Very slow service. Ordered scallops, received 3 for n$46.00. Way over priced. Drinks came after appetizers. Poor experience. Will never go back

Fantastic!!!

Service was slow. The food was not nearly as good as it usually is

Our server was very good. Our meal ewh. We’re staying at the hotel. Arrived in time fo check in & have dinner. Appetizers were just ok. As a main course we ordered 2 different house made pastas again just ok. On an up note cocktails were fabulous!!

Food good; prices very high; portions very small; 4 scallops for $46 and lobster roll for $52; outrageously high.

Great food and great cocktails

Very noisy

We sat outside on a lovey patio and enjoyed the live music while we dined- a perfect evening!

A very nice experience with lovely wait staff. The menu offers local fare, which is what we like, and the dishes were very good. Nice local spot in Riverhead

Delicious dinners and drinks and the service was great too! Loved our dinner at Preston House!

Service is always excellent and professional. Oysters were fresh and quite good. The meyer lemon carbonara has some good flavors and was quite enjoyable.

Food was great and staff super friendly, but service was slow. One waiter for the entire upstairs but understand getting staff is difficult these days. He handled it in good humor though.

Friendly professional service, food was very good. Started with $1 oysters, the pasta was so good, I can never order it at my local place anymore, and steak also perfectly done, habanero sauce didn’t disappoint, phew, hot but well balanced. The potato side thing was very crunchy, that’s the only thing that didn’t work, but don’t let that stop you. Drinks also good. It’s expensive, but we’ll worth it. Make a reservation.

Just gorgeous presentation, delicious interesting combinations of flavors, friendly service. We’ll be back!

We arrived 90 minutes after the time for which we reserved, were welcomed with a smile, served excellently, and the meal was delicious. One cannot ask for more.

Probably the best meal I've had on Long Island. Very attentive service. Quality and presentation of all dishes was exceptional. Most of all enjoyed the lamb chop, nicely charred and tasting of lamb when most lamb I get these days has a neutral taste. Summer mushroom bolognese was the definition of umami with so much flavor that the app size was enough for one person. All in all, expensive, but not overpriced.

Beautiful place with wonderful atmosphere and unusually prepared dishes. Service was quick, waiter was knowledgeable and friendly.
A bit pricey but worth it.

We had a most enjoyable evening. The food and service were very good. The staff is amazingly friendly.

Natasha, our server, was beyond our of this world! She made my birthday so special!! The whole staff was phenomenal! The food and flavors created by the chef were so intriguing and went wonderfully together! The atmosphere was so awesome, everything was clean and the ambiance was very chill but chic! 10/10 all around!!

We sat out on the patio/deck. It was a rainy evening but the deck was well protected. We had a fabulous dinner, excellent service and a wonderful time.

Another great meal at Preston House. The lamb wontons were outstanding!! Jacob our sever was fantastic as always.

Highly recommend .

We made the mistake of ordering a $52 lobster roll and crispy Faroe Island salmon. The salmon came out with a flaccid skin and the lobster was salty. The hand cut French fries were standard frozen ones. I sent the salmon back and eventually got something approaching crispy, but the lobster never got any better. In retropect, my date and I agreed that we just should have gotten up and left when we saw and tasted the that mess of a meal. We left with the feeling that it was wishful thinking to believe we could get a fine dining experience in Riverhead. So the meal tarnished the restaurant as well as a town trying to rebuild itself around a great aquarium.

Solid apps, veal chop was yummy. Duck was tasty, but tough. Corn pudding was good. Zucchini blossoms were fantastic.

Jacob our server was exceptional. He was attentive, made appropriate suggestions for food. The food was delicious. The lobster and burrata toast was exceptional as were the lemon ricotta pancakes and the stake and eggs! Preston House is a culinary gem in th heart of Riverhead. Just wish they did lunch during the week

Salad was really excellent, as was the sushi tuna appetizer. The duck entree was a little too salty, but otherwise good. The seafood ramen was mixed. The ramen itself was quite good but the bits of fish, octopus, etc. were dried out and not very tasty. All in all the food was good, but not up to the standard of such an expensive restaurant. The service was friendly but slow - I don't hold that against the restaurant because I know how hard it is to lay on sufficient help these days.