The Lakehouse

We all enjoyed everything we ordered. The service was terrific and very observant of allergies. Our waiter was attentive and I would absolutely return again.

Finally got a reservation and the food did not disappoint. Every dish was excellent and desserts were great. While we had a reservation and had to wait a while, the staff made up for it with an appetizer for the table.

Quickly becoming our favorite Long Island restaurant

First time dining here. Was so enjoyable. Food and service excellent. Very attentive waitstaff. Would highly recommend this restaurant.

Lunch menu was limited. Too many salad options. Need to have other app options if there are salads as entrees. Any question we asked waiter he needed to go in back to get answer. Was not terrible but was not great.

The Lakehouse has become one of our favorite restaurants. Great food, service, and a view...can't ask for more than that.

We just love this place. The food and service was outstanding as usual.

Excellent as always
The lakehouse is my favorite restaurant on Long Island.
The food and service is exceptional.

Meal and service were outstanding. Many interesting menu items that you won't find elsewhere. Not sure what the fuss is regarding the view. It's a nice setting, but nothing special

Continues to be one of my favorite restaurants. There were 3 of us , went on a Tuesday evening for dinner the waiter was attentive We had the oysters and clams for appy, and scallops , duck and pork chop for dinners. Desserts are amazing also

Great view from all angles of restaurant. Food was delicious, service friendly. Great, relaxed overall experience.

An Elegant setting
Exceptional food and service was top notch

Food was great and being on the water made it that much better. The staff is very friendly and they were always on top of things. My steak was cooked to perfection. Dessert was unreal as well! Can't wait to get back!

First time there, was amazing. Food was fantastic. Waitress was so kind .

Everything about the dinner was perfect. Food, ambiance, service.

The Lakehouse has delicious food. Great service. A staff that knows their menu and is very accommodating to their guest and their dietary needs. The ambience is wonderful and the view is great. It is not a cheap evening for dinner. They have a place to tie up your boat and on a nice night you can eat outside or enjoy some after dinner drinks on the adarondak chairs they have outside near the water. They change their menu seasonally.

Been many times since they relocated, food & Service are always exceptional and the reason we drive 45 minutes each way for a visit.

Great restaurant with a beautiful outdoor patio with gorgeous water views. Food and service was very good. Save room for dessert because that was one of the best parts of the meal. Smore sundae was amazing. Will definitely return.

Food excellent staff even better
I would definitely recommend this restaurant

Almost an amazing meal! The chef never disappoints us

Food was so very good. It is a perfect place for a special occasion or just a lovely evening out alone or with friends. A little disappointed with the service this time. We thought the waiter was not as attentive as he could have been. This is the first time dinning out that a dessert menu was brought to us before our main course arrived. The waiter (who will remain nameless) obviously was not paying attention.

Great location. Food was excellent. Scenery was amazing. Waitress was barely interested. We had to ask her name. We asked if there were specials she told us to read the menu. Bus boy was attentive and helpful. A waitress like this could ruin things for the business. The food and the location is top notch. She needs more training.

Been enjoying the Lake House since we first visited the Bay Shore location so many moons ago and now to the new, beautiful waterfront location. Have never had a bad meal....The Lake House is my wife's favorite restaurant and on this occasion it was my sister's 65th birthday and she was thrilled to finally enjoy the LH experience.

Will continue to frequent the LH...but not so often that the visits aren't always an event I don't get excited about!!!!

Keep up the good work LH....

Frequent visitor and sitting outside makes all the difference, amazing. Our waiter was so-so. He never came to check on us once after we got our food - very frustrating when four of us had to flag someone down to get another drink and salt/pepper. Food is good, enjoyed the shrimp and hearts of palm very much. Crab dip just ok (kinda boring tho). My sons eggs on his Eggs Benedict were over cooked which was disappointing. Having said all that, we enjoy this restaurant and will definitely be back.
FYI: this time of year the honeybees were everywhere so be aware if that sort of thing bothers you but there isn’t much they (the restaurant) can do about it.

We celebrate our anniversary each year for dinner & they never disappoint! Staff -atmosphere-food are all terrific!

My only complaint was we had to make a 5:00 pm reservation to see empty tables sit there for the next 2 1/2 hours?

It was awesome. We went for a friends birthday and she absolutely enjoyed herself. The food, music level and chit chat throughout the restaurant was perfect. The balance was exceptional. I will definitely be coming back here again.

Great place for dinner whether with a group or on a date.

We went to celebrate a special wedding anniversary. I had requested an outside table because we wanted a water view .in addition I mentioned when I made the reservation that we were celebrating an anniversary.The table was ready when we arrived however it was very humid and hot outside so we asked to be seated at a table with a water view inside.They were completely accomodating and seated us in a perfect spot.The food was outstanding The service was impeccable .it is also reasonably priced for a restaurant if this caliber .At the end of the meal they brought our dessert with a candle On it to honor our anniversary although we hadn’t mentioned it since we made the reservation This restaurant is a must go to for fine dining on Long Island.We will be back

Food was absolutely delicious as always. Table on deck was wonderful with a nice breeze and beautiful sunset. Service was ok. Got there early and sat out by water. We were told that a server would be by to take drink orders, but, after a wait, we were told by another that we had to go to bar to get our own drinks. Never got any bread with dinner. Overall, though, the food and ambiance make this a great place to dine.

The food is very good here and of course the view is fantastic. The service is usually very good. Today it seems like everybody from the waiter to the runners to the busboys were having an off day. I won’t hold it against the place. I love it here. The fish tacos were fabulous and the shrimp salad that my friend ordered was fantastic. Tuna tartare app was incredible. I don’t remember the last time I’ve ever had a crème brûlée as delicious as the one at the lake house

Had an excellent meal with good service. Nice ambiance, beautiful view. We will be going again.

Outstanding food ,spectacular views, very poor service

I celebrated my birthday here and it was very nice. It was a bit of a drive from NJ but worth it. The setting is lovely, on the water where the Fire Island ferries come and go. The food was very good as was the service. The atmosphere was relaxed and the staff was friendly. It was a Monday night so we were able to get a table with a view of the water. It also wasn't too noisy.

This place was a 10/10. Calamari crab tuna tar tar, and mussels were phenomenal. I ordered the halibut with orzo and lobster sauce that was to die for. The NY Strip was 10/10. The steak came out a little over cooked but the server took an appetizer off the bill which was very kind and unexpected. Cinnamon donuts were so warm and sweet. Everything was great including the outdoor view of the moon reflecting off the water. Will definitely be a frequent customer.

I have been to a lot of waterfront dining restaurants on Long Island and this is one of the best. The food is excellent and the view is wonderful. We have come in the winter too and with the fireplace it is warm and cozy. The staff are all friendly and the service has always been wonderful. The last time we were there my whole family ordered the Halibut and we all agreed that it is the best fish dish that we have ever had. They also have a great desert menu. I have had the donuts a few times. They have two different dipping sauces and are delicious. It's a fun desert because they can easily be shared.

The food was amazing, the service outstanding, and it was an all around great experience to celebrate our parents anniversary.

Excellent food!! Service was a little slow. But everything was perfect!

Every coarse was better than the last. Gus was our waiter and he was the most helpful attentive waiter ive had in months! One of the best restaurants the South Shore has to offer!!

the restaurant is very pretty the outdoor seating and view are beautiful