Tellers: An American Chophouse
Monday-Friday: 12:00pm- 3:00pm
Monday- Thursday: 5:00pm - 10:00pm
Friday- Saturday: 5:00pm - 11:00pm
Sunday: 3:00pm - 9:00pm
* Our full dinner menu will be available at the bar beginning at 3pm, Monday-Friday.
You will not find a better lunch value anywhere.
What a nice way to treat yourself to an exquisite dining experience. From the time at the bar talking with the highly experienced bartenders, to sitting at our table for dinner, the experience was just outstanding. We had the crab cakes (2)'small but delicious served with a white sauce, the octopus which had to be the most tender octopus that I ever had, delicious, crab meat salad, awesome and the duck fries, crunchy!!!
For dinner we had 2 of the tellers special ribeyes....huge to say the least, very juicy and tender. The scalloped potatoes were cheesy and full of flavor, the burnt broccoli was amazing, crashed spinach just creamy.
Lisette took great care of our table. It was a wonderful dining experience. The outside was all lit up, very romantic!
Service was excellent as usual, had the veal for the first time, veeeeerrrrryyyy good
Excellent quality meats and shellfish in a wonderful atmosphere
Well the pan seared wontons came out they were like warm. Next the steak was well done and the second steak was rare. They could not get it right,
Went for lunch to celebrate a long,hard road my friend had finally receiving her Masters! Had to go somewhere special and I think I chose the perfect place! We had THE best time and received the best service and delicious food that I usually do when my husband and I go for dinner. I feel like it’s hard to find an up scale restaurant these days that offer a beautiful lunch. Was so perfect to celebrate a well earned accomplishment and thank you to the Hostess and our waiter for making the whole experience more special than expected. I look forward to going back for lunch and of course dinner.
Went to US Open casually dressed. Decided to eat to avoid traffic. Pleasant find in Islip. No complaints. Meal great
Tellers is a gorgeous venue . Its former life it was a bank on Main Street in Islip . High ceilings , vaulted windows . The place has a great feel . The menu has a lot to offer but it is a chop house . So come for the meats .We started out with a dozen clams on the half shell, diver scallops and Lobster /Shrimp wontons My son and I split the Porter house for two . Heavenly . My daughter had a special , Black Grouper . So good she would not share . For dessert we had the Teller fudge cake and creme brulee. Some after dinner drinks finished the night . What a great place ! Great food , Great atmosphere .
Great place, still after all of these years still magnificent inside and out
Service gets better as , drinks change for the better, been going since 2002
tellers is always wonderful but the wine pairing dinner was exceptional !
Very disappointing restaurant, quality was horrible and service wasn’t what would be expected. Dishes and glasses were dirty and desserts tasted like something from a grocery store not a pastry chef. Absolutely awful experience and would never go back.
Best Steakhouse on Long Island. Adam was our server - knowledgeable, friendly and attentive. Will definitely ask for him to be our server again.
Wonderful anniversary dinner. Had the Sunday pre fixe. Everything was perfect! Highly recommend!!
As always another great night. Food was excellent, service was great. Definitely out go to spot for a great steak
always a great meal along with great service...also the setting is a beautiful place to eat inside or outside.
Highly professional wait staff
Eaten there several times and never been disappointed. It is always a delicious and pleasant experience!
I’ve been here several times before but this place continues to impress me with each visit getting better. Our waiter was one of the best I’ve ever had in my life, which made the overall experience and evening that much better.
Good dinner with a tasty porterhouse for two scallops appetizer with great sides. Capped off with a Baileys coffee and Creme brulee
Best steakhouse on Long Island.
Great food, Great service , Great time ! Highly recommend the Inside the Vault experience (1st Friday every month) and dinner afterwards.
From start to finish our meal was excellent! Two people had petite filet mignon & 2 had the skirt steak. All were prepared as requested & were very good.
You can always count on getting great food and outstanding service. You will never be disappointed .
We had a great experience! The Tellers Staff is professional, friendly and on point. We can’t wait to go back and enjoy another delicious meal!
We were promptly seated. Our server helped us decide between two wines. Food was delicious. Steaks and sides were perfect. Recommend the skirt steak and fries in duck fat. It was a very special birthday celebration.
Everything was great until a bunch of little kids started screaming and running around. There was a party and it was difficult to have a romantic dinner with these kids screaming. Horrible experience
Me and my husband has been coming to Tellers for his birthday. It’s one of his fave restaurants. It’s extra special this time because it’s his first birthday as a Father. To start we had the shrimp and lobster wontons as suggested by our waiter and we were never disappointed. It was delish! Then we both had the sirloin steak with Parmesan truffle crust. They were cooked to perfection! For the sides we shared the Mac and cheese, creamed spinach and the duck fat fries. I wasn’t a fan of the Mac and cheese, we will not order it next time. But the creamed Spinach and the fries were as good as I remembered it. Then they gave us ice cream for the special occasion. All in all it was a great dining experience. We will be back.
Great value for Price fix lunch ! We will be back.
A wonderful place
All time favorite. The best in every way. The staff is the best.
Great as usual Steve was always there when we needed him menu fantastic deserts top notch thanks Tellers
It was great!
All was excellent. Great price fix lunch! Only negative - too cool where sitting.
Tellers is a great restaurant.
Great service great food great restaurant will be back soon
Great steaks great price what else can I say. Excellent experience. Look forward to dinning here again.
We celebrated our anniversary at Tellers last evening and it was excellent. Food, service & ambiance - it was truly special. The food was so delicious and we are still talking about It! We always go to Tellers for special occasions and they never disappoint.
Exquisite service and food!
In my opinion Teller's is one of the best steakhouses on the Long Island. Great food and service. Can be a little loud because of the close quarters. We had a reservation but did have to wait 35 minutes for our table. The price you pay for a good meal at a popular destination.