My boyfriend and I ate here for Valentine’s Day.. It was relaxing and quiet. It was just so peaceful there and the food, especially the Steak was PERFECT. Our hostess was amazing. Everything was always right there for us. The place wasn’t too packed. I loved it. It was a Valentine’s Day well spent. I’ll be back 😊

Tarry Lodge is always a great experience. Great food, friendly and knowledgeable staff and a cozy atmosphere. Enjoyable as always!

This was my second time at the Tarry Lodge. I am in love with the brunch menu. The service was impeccable and the atmosphere was relaxing. The restaurant makes every effort to keep everyone safe! Thank you!

The service was wonderful - the octopus appetizer was very good - the cacao e pepe was really disappointing - flavor wise, very good. Not sure if it sat in the kitchen too long but there was no sauce, it was clumpy and warm, not hot. We have dined here before and never had this experience - just an off night.

New Years eve dinner here was amazing! The food was delicious, we loved the spaghetti carbonara and the olive oil ice cream! There service was lovely and they were so kind there! They made our night extra special by giving us complimentary moscato with our desserts! We will absolutely be going back!

We went for New Year’s Eve dinner and had the best time. All patrons were sparse and well spaced out, all employees wearing masks. We got the burrata, Brussels sprouts, pistachio, honey drizzled pizza and Montelpuciano wine and it was so delicious. The service was perfect and we loved the seventies music they were playing. The staff ensured we had a special night and we couldn’t be more grateful.

Everything was great except music was not good & too loud

The team at Tarry Lodge was astounding. On a rainy cold Saturday, they set up an outdoor dining experience just for us and my parents to be as safe as possible to celebrate our Christmas. So much love for them.

The manager, Louis is so good at his job! We adored him, food was delicious and the service was really good. Their bread is amazing and very addictive. Pizza was delicious and several home made pasta dishes. We came home with leftovers and some of their Bread! ❤️❤️❤️

Food was wonderful as usual. Very impressed with the COVID precautions taken. Great experience. Felt safe dining and staff were wonderful!

I love this place. The food is really good, and the staff are attentive. It was raining and so all dining was indoors. Tables were well spaced out, and ones that were adjacent to another were split by plexiglass. But when I went, no party was adjacent to another party.

We had a great meal and the restaurant did a wonderful job safely distancing the tables and following safety protocols.

good outdoor dining

the food was absolutely delicious. nice atmosphere and kept to all covid 19 guidelines. would definitely recommend.

Party of 4 on a Sunday evening. Ordered apps and main courses. No one finished their dishes, there was something just a bit disappointing about everyone's food. One pasta dish was undercooked, the sliced steak had a huge, thick piece of sinew through the center of it which had to be cut around to eat but also, trim the outside gristle to chew. It was just very underwhelming and felt lazy to let a cut of meat like that go out the door. The salted caramel dessert was really no different than a pudding, it was sold to us as being much more unique. I wouldn't bother coming here again, nor would I recommend this to anyone, it was memorable for bad things vs. being neutral enough to forget, which is secondly preferable to being so good I'd recommend. Consider something else unless you're in a bind - and then tread carefully.

We dined outdoors. Service was great, food was great.

Food and service were excellent. We had the octopus appetizer, which was tender and grilled to perfection, then the kale salad, followed by the bronzini and eggplant parmesan. Portions were plentiful and presentation was top notch. If I had to make some constructive criticism, I'd say that the fingerling potatoes showed up in too many dishes, some variety of root vegetables would be appreciated. Lastly, the espresso was a huge watery disappointment, or as my father used to say acqua lorde. Please teach your wait staff how to pull a proper espresso.

Our party of four sat outside on a very comfortable autumn evening recently and it was from start to finish a really enjoyable experience. Our server, Sam, was engaging, inviting and very attentive. The food was very good, the overall experience was enjoyable thanks to the Sam and the folks in the kitchen.

Overpriced for what you get. Bathroom was dirty and had flies. You're paying for the name.

Nice outdoor dinner during COVID time. Felt safe and enjoyed very good food.

Our servers and hostess were so wonderful! They made our celebration of a special occasion all the more happy and memorable. Our pizzas and salads were so incredibly delicious that we had none left to take home. This restaurant is very much worth a visit!!

Ate outside where there were more about eight tables on the sidewalk. It worked for us.

Server worked hard. In and out of the building.

Steak, bolognese and eggplant dishes were all very good. Salads are excellent.

Limited menu, but enough choice. Very good wine list.

Very good value.

Every dish was a home run. All the dishes had great flavor and presentation. Service was excellent.

The service was poor...not enough waitstaff. One waitress with 8 tables...water and drinks weren't refilled and the food was mediocre and bland. The meatball pizza arrived without meatballs.

Great spot to take a student to brunch in New Haven. Very close proximity to the residential colleges. And great bottomless bloody mary's!

Food and service was great!!

Awesome pizza!!

As good as it ever was!
The street is quiet apart from the odd motorcycle - can't be beat on a late summer evening.

Due to Covid and the stupid CT government's continued restrictions, despite low infections, the ambiance was not the usual. The staff did a marvelous job serving us and the food was excellent. All best wishes for economic recovery to TL. Mary

The food was great. first time trying the fungi pizza -very good!

It was very busy sat nite. Probably short help. Food was very good and so was the wine.

Able to reserve a spot outside and service was excellent- host to server to staff. Food delicious- partner was a little thrown by the arugula on the pie- Really, I could sit and just eat that focaccia and salad all night. 90 mins exactly right for 3 courses- thank you, Tarry Lodge for a lovely first dinner out since quarantine.

Bathrooms were dirty. Faucet in sink did not work. Inexcusable

Tarry Lodge is our “ go to” restaurant. We are never disappointed.

Everything was great; the food, the cocktails and especially the host and waiter!

The food is always top notch and service is attentive. From, pasta to pizza to fish and salads - delicious. The portions are plentiful. The only complaint from everyone in our party was about the music. Please change your playlist and turn it down. Something relaxing and not notable would be much better than the odd mix of pop.

Always a lovely experience. Great service, great food.

Great food and great staff. Followed the COVID restrictions while keeping a pleasant atmosphere.

Amount of invoice echo rita this for food that was only fair. Will not visit again.

The location is kinda tough for parking but it’s a great restaurant the food is amazing, and the service is right on par.