There's too much to possibly list on the menu at Sutton's, but everything is made fresh to order and delicious. Fresh flown-in Scallops, Filet Mignon, Prime Top Sirloins, Tuscan Marinated Bone-in Chops, Delmonico cut Ribeyes, grilled Norwegian cold-water salmon, fried shrimp and plenty of pasta varieties and sauces are only a few of the entrees available on the menu. You can also choose from a number of house pizzas, sandwiches, and salads. And don't forget about dessert, too, like the tiramisu and signature bread pudding.
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
It was surprisingly great!! Service was great! I would go again.
Hadn't been to Suttons in years. So glad we went, everything was delicious, service was great and prices were reasonable. Will def be back and won't pass it by
We love Sutton’s. It’s great food at a great value also the mixed drinks are amazing.
Food and wine were both great along with incredible service.
The bread was great but everything else was average. Homemade Italian sausage should look like sausage not ground meat
Food was bland. Nice waitress. Try we're trying during this horrible pandemic. I support local restaurants.
Sutton’s never disappoints. The food is always wonderful and the service fantastic. This is a usual place for us. Will certainly be back.
Awesome food! Whenever you get HOT fries you know that everything else will be good. Large portions and great prices. We will definitely be back to visit again
I haven’t found a thing on the menu that I didn’t like. Highly recommend.
Staff was very nice,and outstanding, food was delicious as always.
Sutton’s is always a solid choice! Never had a bad meal there.
Excellent service, Rhonda was a gem!! Fish and chips Cod was delicious!
I have never had a meal that was not delicious at Sutton’s. If you haven’t been there before put it on your dinner to do list. You won’t regret it
We got a shrimp scampi pasta, not good. Too tart and all he tasted was lemon. Mgr did offer another dish but hubby didn’t want anything else..mgr did comp his meal. I got fettuccine Alfredo with shrimp, it was good but nothing spectacular. Shrimp was really good. The stuffed mushrooms are fantastic.
The ticket was all screwed up, it was worked on 3 times. Came down to $38 for 2 drinks, 1 dinner, 2 “free” desserts (not free) and mushrooms (1 order)
The food was good, the waitress was both patient and friendly, and the decor was fascinating.
Everything was wonderful! Eating the leftovers today and still wonderful. Chicken Marsala yum!
Crowded for Valentines night, but reservation was right on time. Appetizers were excellent, calamari and meatballs, both highly recommended. Service was a bit slow with drinks, but understand with the nights business. Entrees were good. Manager on duty came by table and noticed my seafood pasta dish was a little dry, and went back and made some extra sauce. Very tasty and greatly appreciated. Checked on us several times throughout the night. Seafood pizza was really good.
Will definitely return.
We had never been to Sutton's before. We made a reservation for Valentine's day. The service was great, the food was great, but the music was a bit loud for conservation where we were. The 1st table they gave us we didn't like, so they were very accommodating and gave a table that was open that we did like. And, they didn't have the wine that was on the menu, so they gave us a more expensive wine for the price of the wine that we wanted. Overall, we loved it and plan on going back with friends!
We tried Sutton's when it first opened and we weren't impressed and therefore we didn't go back. Years have passed and we finally decided to give it another try and I'm glad we did. The food was good and very reasonably priced. Our waitress was very helpful and it was appreciated. We won't hesitate to go back again.
Wonderful salmon and Ciopinni! Great experience!
We have a wonderful meal and fabulous service... the only negative was being seated by the door on the left just as you walk in causing our food to get cold quicker than usual.
We had a large party and the service was amazing. Food is consistently outstanding. I will continue to visit regularly
Great good and service.
The menu is all over the place. Having TVs tuned to an NBC crime show with bloody images and such was pretty off-putting.
Great as usual!!
I know it was new years eve, but we booked an early seating. Food was great as always. Our server, not so much. He brought our check and laid it on the table before we finished eating. He never cleared our plates or asked if we wanted dessert. A lady came around and told us that dessert was free on Tuesdays but she never offered to get it for us either. Busy day is not an excuse for poor service.
The perfect place for a large party gathering
Great and friendly service as usual.
We went to Sutton’s for the first time on a Saturday night in December. The ambiance is nice, comfortable, and not fancy. No fancy white linens...but the food was absolutely delicious! The appetizer mussels were amazing- and amazingly priced. My seafood pasta was great. We all left full. Our server heard it was our first time and expertly broke down the menu for us. What a find!
The service was good and friendly and personal. Menu choices were broad so we tried a number of items. Everything was good or better than just good. We will definitely try them again in the next week
Great food and service. Staff was very friendly and food was exactly what we ordered and expected. Will be going back for dinner again soon.
Food is always delicious. They are willing to try new things. I chose to have the grilled sugar snap peas in place of the pasta. I've done this with both the chicken parmesan and the chicken marsala. I was even complimented by the kitchen and wait staff for this. Staff is always friendly.
Our visit was on a quiet rainy evening, service was excellent and waitress was very friendly. Meatballs appetizer was very tasty, and we enjoyed our evening. Food was good, not great as was the value of our evening. Yes, for a quiet evening I would go again.
This place used to be great, but each of the last few visits have been horrible. The carpet is old and dirty, causing the place to smell. The decor is cheap and the lights were missing bulbs and needed dusting. The seafood, which was amazing in the beginning, was so mushy from being frozen too long, that I couldn't even eat it. The sauteed mushrooms were whole, underseasoned and barely cooked. The grilled snap peas, which are my favorite, were also underseasoned and still had strings. We paid an upscale price for a dive restaurant. What a shame.
Always enjoy the great food and good service. Never have I been disappointed.
Food was awesome and the waiter was too!
Took my son there for his birthday. Once again Sutton’s did not disappoint! Great food, great service, great time. If you haven’t tried Sutton’s do your self a favor and go
Sutton’s is always a great place!
Simply perfect 👌 I will definitely be back!
Very good food, pleasant waitress and a good value.
Sutton's does offer delivery in partnership with Uber Eats. Sutton's also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (859) 268-2068.
Sutton's is rated 4.5 stars by 69 OpenTable diners.
Sutton's does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://www.suttonsrestaurant.com/gift-cards.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.