Sugar Factory - Indianapolis
Private dining
Book your next event with us
Additional information
- Dining style
Casual Dining
- Cuisines
American, Contemporary American, Dessert
- Hours of operation
Mon–Thu 11:00 am–11:00 pm Fri 11:00 am–12:00 am Sat 10:00 am–12:00 am Sun 10:00 am–10:00 pm
- Phone number
(463) 217-0383
- Website
- Dress code
Business Casual
- Private party facilities
We welcome you to explore our Private Dining options, perfect for any occasion.
- Private party contact
Dana Sugarman: (844) 893-7902
- Neighborhood
Downtown Indy
- Parking details
None
- Additional
Bar/Lounge, Late Night, Wheelchair Access
Popular dishes
Menu
Sugar Factory Appetizers
Basket of Fries$9.00
Delicious and fried to perfection
Buttermilk Onion Rings$12.00
Chipotle mayo dipping sauce
Chicken Fingers$13.00
Crispy chicken served with classic ranch sauce
Spinach Artichoke Dip$16.00
Melted mozzarella and Parmesan cheese served with warm tortilla chips
Buffalo Chicken Wings$16.00
Tossed in buffalo sauce topped with green onions, celery sticks, and served with ranch dressing
Beer Battered Calamari$17.00
Tossed with old bay and parsley served with marinara sauce and lemon
Popcorn Shrimp$17.00
Tossed with old bay and parsley served with marinara sauce and lemon
Sampler Platter$28.00
Crispy chicken fingers, buffalo wings, mac pops and onion rings served with dipping sauces
Sugar Factory Rainbow Sliders$25.00
Our classic sliders served on colorful buns with American cheese, pickles, crispy onions and Sugar Factory sauce Accompanied by a complimentary duck to take home
Soups & Salads
Tomato Bisque$9.00
Creamy tomato soup, basil and Parmesan garlic bread
Caesar Salad$14.00
Romaine hearts, shaved Parmesan cheese, brioche croutons Parmesan crostini with creamy Caesar dressing
Ginger Sesame Chicken Salad$20.00
Shredded cabbage, julienned carrots, water chestnuts, green onions, basil, toasted sesame seeds, roasted peanuts, cilantro and crispy wontons with ginger sesame dressing
Pan Roasted Salmon Salad$28.00
Slowly cooked salmon, chopped romaine hearts, avocado, mango, cucumbers, roasted bell peppers, red onions, cilantro, basil toasted pine nuts, and lemon vinaigrette
Sandwiches
Served with Signature Fries
Grilled Cheese Sandwich$14.00
Artisan white bread, aged cheddar cheese griddled golden brown, served with creamy marinara
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich$18.00
Crispy breaded chicken breast tossed in buffalo sauce, shredded romaine lettuce, tomatoes and herb mayo on a toasted brioche bun
Chicken Breast Sandwich$18.00
Slow roasted chicken breast, melted Swiss cheese sliced avocado, romaine lettuce, sliced tomato and herb mayo, served on a toasted French baguette
The Sugar Factory Club$18.00
Roasted turkey breast, crispy applewood bacon, provolone, cheddar, romaine lettuce pickles, avocado, tomatoes and herb mayo on toasted artisan white bread
Steak Sandwich Melt$19.00
Seared and thinly sliced steak with sauteed onions and mushrooms, topped with melted provolone and parmesan cheese, herb mayo, served on a toasted baguette
Monster Burgers
Handmade with 8oz Angus Beef and Served with Signature Fries
The Signature Sugar Factory Burger*$18.00
8 oz Black Angus beef, melted cheddar cheese pickles, shredded lettuce, tomato, crispy onions Sugar Factory sauce on a toasted brioche bun
The Big Cheesy*$20.00
8 oz Black Angus beef, topped with melted American cheese, creamy mac & cheese, applewood bacon pickles, shredded lettuce, tomato, crispy onions and BBQ sauce on a toasted brioche bun
Waffle Breakfast Burger*$21.00
8 oz Black Angus beef, melted cheddar cheese applewood bacon, country sausage, classic vanilla bean waffle, fried egg, hash Brown, gravy and served with warm maple syrup
Blue Cheese Bacon Burger*$18.00
8 oz Black Angus beef, blue cheese crumbles, crispy applewood bacon, pickles, shredded lettuce, tomato, sauteed mushrooms, caramelized onions, crispy onions and Sugar Factory sauce on a toasted brioche bun
California Veggie Burger$18.00
Dr. Praeger's® vegan patty, melted provolone cheese sliced avocado, shredded lettuce, tomato, crispy onions herb mayo and served on a toasted brioche bun
South Beach Flair*$22.00
Black Angus beef topped with shrimp, applewood bacon, plantains, shredded lettuce, tomato, crispy onions, chipotle mayonnaise, chimichurri sauce and served on a toasted brioche bun
Flaming Hot Cheetos® Burger*$21.00
8 oz Angus burger, topped with Flaming Hot Cheetos® crusted pepper jack cheese, more melted pepper jack, pickles, shredded lettuce, tomato, crispy onions, chipotle mayo and served on a crushed Flaming Hot Cheetos® toasted brioche bun
24K Gold$150.00
Dripping in 24k gold leaf, this gold covered Sugar Factory signature monster burger is served with gold dusted french fries. Foodgod Truffle Ketchup®, and The Holly Gold insane milkshake. The Holly Gold insane milkshake is a rich chocolate milkshake blended with Ferrero Rocher® golden truffles, topped with a gold draped chocolate glazed donut, whipped cream, a milk chocolate macaroon, a gold dusted chocolate covered vanilla ice cream bar, and golden Ferrero Rocher® truffles. Served in a decadent dark chocolate mug that is dripping in 24k edible gold!
Pastas
Served with Toasted Garlic Bread. Add chicken breast $7, shrimp $9, steak $14 or lobster MP
Spaghetti Marinara$19.00
Garlic, basil and Parmesan cheese
Penne Alfredo$19.00
Garlic, basil and Parmesan cheese
Chicken Penne Alfredo$24.00
Garlic, basil and Parmesan cheese
Cajun Chicken Penne Alfredo$25.00
Penne pasta, basil and Parmesan cheese
Shrimp Penne Alfredo$27.00
Garlic, basil, and Parmesan cheese
Roasted Lobster Mac & Cheese (Serves 2)$150.00
A monster sized potion of creamy mac and cheese filled with fresh Carribean lobster, roasted garlic truffle oil, and topped with two roasted Caribbean lobster tails, Parmesan, and toasted bread crumbs
Sugar Factory Grill & Entrees
Brick Chicken$28.00
All-natural chicken breast, slow roasted and basted with thyme and garlic, served with mashed potatoes green beans almondine and lemon-herb sauce
Chicken and Waffles$28.00
Buttermilk fried chicken served on a buttered vanilla bean waffle served with warm maple syrup
Pan Roasted Salmon$35.00
Slow roasted salmon, mashed potatoes, grilled asparagus and bacon herb sauce
Roasted Lobster Tail Frites$45.00
Served with garlic, herb butter, asparagus and Parmesan fries
Prime NY Steak Frites*$45.00
10 oz prime NY strip pan roasted with garlic herb butter, asparagus and Parmesan Fries
8 oz Black Angus Filet*$48.00
8 oz grilled filet mignon served with mashed potatoes, green beans almondine and garlic herb butter
Black Angus Filet & Lobster Surf and Turf*$78.00
8 oz angus beef and roasted lobster tail, melted butter, mashed potatoes and green beans almondine
Sugar Factory Sides
Grilled Asparagus$8.00
Mashed Potatoes$8.00
Macaroni & Cheese$8.00
Green Bean Almondine$8.00
Old Fashioned Milkshakes
Vanilla$12.00
Vanilla ice cream blended with vanilla sauce served in a caramel swirled mug, topped with whipped cream and white chocolate curls
Chocolate$12.00
Chocolate ice cream blended with melted chocolate sauce topped with whipped cream and dark chocolate shavings
Strawberry$12.00
Strawberry ice cream blended with strawberry sauce, topped with whipped cream and white chocolate strawberry shavings
Chocolate Cookie Jar$14.00
Vanilla ice cream blended with Oreo® cookie crumble, chocolate chips, caramel and chocolate sauce topped with whipped cream. Oreo® cookies, mini chocolate chips and drizzled with more caramel sauce
Butterfingers®$14.00
Vanilla ice cream blended with Butterfingers® served in a chocolate swirled mug, topped with whipped cream, crumbled Butterfingers® and a fun sized Butterfinger®
Insane Milkshakes
Tie Dye Milkshake$19.00
Vanilla ice cream blended with vanilla sauce topped with whipped cream. Pop Rocks® rainbow sprinkles, candy necklaces cotton candy and served in a chocolate covered mug with Skittles®. Pop Rocks® and drizzled with red, blue, green and yellow chocolate sauce
Nutella® Banana Milkshake$19.00
Vanilla ice cream blended with Nutella® and sliced bananas, topped with whipped cream, a chocolate dipped banana, a unicorn lollipop, a candy necklace and served in a chocolate covered mug with rainbow sprinkles
Princess Make A Wish$21.00
Vanilla ice cream blended with vanilla sauce rainbow sprinkles, topped with whipped cream, a marshmallow wheel, white chocolate Kit Kat® bar, a pink frosted cupcake with a birthday candle and served in a white chocolate covered mug with pink sprinkles
Caramel Sugar Daddy® Cheesecake$19.00
Vanilla ice cream blended with cheesecake pieces and caramel sauce, topped with whipped cream, a slice of NY style cheesecake, Sugar Daddy® candy, a rainbow lollipop and served in a chocolate covered mug with crushed graham crackers
Giggles Snickers® Milkshake$19.00
Cookies and cream ice cream blended with toasted peanuts, topped with whipped cream, caramel waffles, a Snicker® bar rainbow sprinkles and served in a chocolate covered mug with Snicker® pieces and rainbow sprinkles
Cookie Monster Make a Wish$21.00
Cookies and cream ice cream blended with vanilla sauce, topped with whipped cream, a blue glazed donut, a chocolate chip cookie, a blue frosted cupcake with a birthday candle and served in a chocolate covered mug with chocolate chip pieces
Campfire Spiked S'mores Milkshake$31.00
Chocolate and coffee ice cream blended with espresso, toasted marshmallow Virginia Black® Whiskey, topped with an insane seven layer s'more cookie served on top of a chocolate covered mug with Hershey® bar pieces and dusted with graham cracker crumble and pieces. This drink contains alcohol. Must be 21 or older
- Non-Alcoholic$19.00
Dessert Menu
New York Cheesecake$14.00
Topped with strawberries, blackberries, blueberries, raspberries, raspberry sauce and whipped cream
Chocolate Cake$14.00
Layers of chocolate devil's food cake, dark chocolate icing with bittersweet chocolate fudge sauce chocolate curls, chocolate malt balls and whipped cream
Oreo® Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich$17.00
Cookies and cream ice cream sandwiched in between two Oreo® stuffed chocolate chip cookies, topped with whipped cream. Oreo® cookie crumble and drizzled with chocolate sauce
Cookie Skillet$19.00
Warm chocolate chip cookie stuffed with Nutella®, dusted with powdered sugar a scoop of vanilla ice cream, drizzled with rainbow white chocolate sauce sprinkled with M&M's® and duck candy confetti
Fondue$26.00
Warm melted milk chocolate with toasted marshmallows, strawberries, bananas, cheesecake bites, red velvet cake, gummy bears and brownie bites
Old Fashioned Sundaes For two
The Classic$15.00
Giant scoops of vanilla, chocolate and strawberry ice cream, topped with whipped cream, fudge sauce, rainbow sprinkles and a gummy cherry!
Strawberry Cheesecake Overload$16.00
Giant scoops of strawberry ice cream, topped with whipped cream, strawberry sauce cheesecake bites, strawberries and white chocolate strawberry shavings!
Cookie Jar$16.00
Giant scoops of cookies and cream and cookie dough ice cream, topped with whipped cream, caramel sauce, chocolate sauce, crushed Oreos® and homemade chocolate chip cookie pieces!
Chocolate Blackout$17.00
Giant scoops of chocolate ice cream, topped with whipped cream, chocolate sauce, chocolate chips, chocolate brownie pieces, crunchy chocolate pearls, dark chocolate shavings, chocolate sprinkles and a gummy cherry!
Banana Split$17.00
Giant scoops of strawberry, chocolate, vanilla ice cream, topped with whipped cream, strawberry sauce, caramel sauce, chocolate sauce, strawberries, caramelized bananas, chocolate malt balls, rainbow sprinkles, chopped walnuts, powder sugar and a gummy cherry!
World Famous Sugar Factory King Kong Sundae
24 scoops of ice cream drizzled with chocolate, caramel and strawberry sauce, topped with whipped cream, caramelized bananas, marshmallows, chocolate chip cookie pieces, a glazed donut, a red velvet cupcake, white chocolate strawberry curls, gummy bears, Reese's Pieces®, crushed Oreos®, rainbow and chocolate sprinkles, graham cracker crumble, waffle cones unicorn pops, candy necklaces, gummy cherries and sparklers!
- Serves 12$99.00
Hot Chocolate
S'mores Hot Chocolate$8.00
You'll feel like you're toasting marshmallows over a campfire when you take a sip of this delicious' S'mores hot chocolate! Made with rich decadent milk chocolate and toasted marshmallows then topped with homemade whipped cream. Hershey chocolate pieces graham cracker crumbs and a marshmallow rim!
Pink Unicorn Hot Chocolate$8.00
As unique as a unicorn and as pretty as a princess, you dont want to miss out on this fun, flavorful PINK hot chocolate! Made with rich pink white chocolate and topped with homemade whipped cream, colorful marshmallows, delicious pink and blue chocolate sauce and shining star sprinkles
Classic Hot Chocolate$8.00
Sometimes the most simple things are the best! Enjoy our rich classic hot chocolate made from scratch with smooth, rich milk chocolate and topped with mini marshmallows and chocolate curls
Drinks
Miami Tropical Punch$40.00
Soak of the Miami sunshine with fresh peaches, pineapple juice tropical mai tai punch and pina colada flavors Bursting tropical flavors are shaken up with El Recuerdo Mezcal White Tequila El Recuerdo Mezcal Gold Tequila coconut rum spiced rum grenadine and Triple sec, Tropical gummy drops floating on top of this refreshing blend will have/you soaking up the Miami sunshine wherever you are in the world. Designed and tasted by Jorge -Gamebred' Masvidal
- Non Alcoholic$34.00
The Watermelon (Meloncito 305)$40.00
It's summer all year long with this refreshing blend of Voli Vodka, fresh watermelon, fresh lemon, and citrus soda. Topped with a mountain of gummy sour watermelon slices. Designed and tasted by Pitbull
- Non Alcoholic$34.00
Fuzzy Peach Penguin Mango (The Tongue Twister)$40.00
This fresh and fruity Voli Vodka cocktail blends up fresh peach and mango puree with sparkling citrus soda! Finished with gummy fruit slices and gummy peach penguins. Designed and tasted by Pitbull
- Non Alcoholic$34.00
Lollipop Passion$40.00
Our signature goblet is a true taste of the tropics. We have blended together a wonderful mix of melon, coconut, and pineapple to create a taste sensation no one will be able to resist! For the final touch we garnish this yummy goblet of goodness with lollipops
- Non Alcoholic$34.00
Strawberry Cadillac Repurposed Margarita$40.00
Cruise into sweet strawberry sunshine with this Villa One reposado Margarita! Crafted with Villa One Reposado, Grand Marnier, strawberries, triple sec, fresh lime juice, simple syrup and a dash of sweet & sour. A Cadillac Margarita goblet wouldn't be complete without a garnish of pink Cadillac gummies. gummy apple rings and key lime fruit gummy slices on the rim! Designed and taste by John Varvatos and Nick Jonas
- Non Alcoholic$34.00
Hpnotiq Long Island Iced Tea$40.00
Dare to get hypnotized by this classic corkoction! With the addition of hpnotiq, the refreshing bler d of peach rum, vodka, triple sec el recuerdo mezcal white tequila and freshly blended citrus jukes will have you stuck in a trance- your eyes will be mesmerized by the giant gum m y snake crawling and climbing all over your glass. Topped with gummy lemon fruit slkes. We dare you to take another sip!
- Non Alcoholic$34.00
Soul Manho$40.00
This powerfully flavor packed goblet will knock you right out of the ring. Be ready to body slammed with the sweet flavors of fresh peach and fresh pineapple which are brightened up by refreshing lemonade and topped off with Teremana Tequila Blanco. The addition of triple sec and Hennessy make this an outrageously delicious cocktail. Gummy cherries, tropical drops, strawberry rock candy, and a green lai wrapped goblet add all the right notes. Designed and tasted by Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson
- Non Alcoholic$34.00
The Peoples Watermelon Cadillac Margarita$40.00
Cruise through with one of our gummy Cadillacs to sip on this refreshing blend of fresh watermelon juice, Teremana Blanco Tequila & Grand Marnier with a dash of Triple Sec, fresh lime, and fresh pineapple, You won't want to waste asipof this delicious goblet. Topped with sour patch watermelons gummies, lime fruit slices, gummy pink Cadillacs and grenadine floater. Designed and tasted by Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson
- Non Alcoholic$34.00
West Coast Sunset$40.00
This new twrst on an old favorite will show you exactly why sunsets are best on the west coast! Made with smoot h 818 tequila blended together with rich gran marnier, fresh peach and orange flavors and topped off with crisp lemonade and a grenadine floated Garnished with juicy orange wlieels and yummy gummy flamingos this drink will have you goin back to call! Designed and tasted by Kendall Jenner
- Non Alcoholic$34.00
Cali Love$40.00
This one of a kind Goblet will have you feeling like palm trees, ocean breeze, salty air, sun-kissed hair? Made with smooth 818 tequila blended with crisis apple and tropical pineapple flavor and topped with sweet key lime slices and yummy apple rings! This drink is guaranteed to leave you crushing on Cali! Designed and tasted by Kendall Jenner
- Non Alcoholic$34.00
Sunshine Breeze$40.00
This unique and refreshing goblet will leave you soaring on the breeze! Made with smooth 818 tequila and perfectly blended with Tropical Redbull, sweet peaches and tangerlnes, fresh pineapple juice and topped with yummy peacn rings, bright tropical drops and classic lemon heads!This drink Is guaranteed to give you wings! Designed and tasted by Kendall Jenner
- Non Alcoholic$34.00
Candy Shop$40.00
We'll take you to the candy shop! Join us" In Da Sugar factory' for a magical blend of smooth Branson Cognac, tasty Teremana Tequila and Malibu rum! This goblet is sure to leave you "feeling like it's your birthday topped with a refreshing mix of fresh peaches, pineapple juice and orange juice! Garnished with tasty sour peach slices, peach rings and colorful soda pop gummy mix! Designed and tasted by $0.50
- Non Alcoholic$34.00
Strawberry Lemonade Smash$40.00
Stay fresh with this smooth blend of Strawberry Indoggo and Virginia Black Whiskey blended together with Peach Schnapps, fresh lemonade, strawberries and a candy finish of classic lemon heads, gummy strawberries and candy lemon fruit slices to top off our delicious version of a strawberry lemonade. Designed and tasted by Snoop Dogg
- Non Alcoholic$34.00
Tropical Fruit Punch$40.00
Let s get tropical with this blend of Strawberry Indoggo and strawberry rum blended together with smooth Teremana tequila, fresh pineapple and orange juices and delicious peach and tro skal flavors Topped with tropical candy crops. gummi twin cherries and sour peach fruit slices, this one of a kind goblet packs a punch while providing relaxing island vibes. Designed and tasted by Snoop Dogg
- Non Alcoholic$34.00
The Big Cloud$40.00
join us at The Sugarfactory for an Ncredlble one of a kind blue raspberry flavor packed goblet! Made with a smooth blend of 818 tequila, selvarey rum, tropical pineapple, fresh peach and melon. This wouldn't be complete without the fluffy blue raspberry cotton candy garnish. This delicious Goblet is sure to have you walking on a cloud! Designed and tasted by Nick Cannon
- Non Alcoholic$34.00
Mamitas Hurricane$40.00
Tear into this flavor packed goblet, made with casa Mexico silver tequila, Marnitas pineapple hard seltzer, a sophisticated blend of rums, fresh lemonade and tropical mai tai flavors! This hurricane goblet will get your mojo going with a big flavorful twist! Designed and tasted by Mario Lope? and Brody Jenner
- Non Alcoholic$34.00
Watermelon Sugar$40.00
Come and aet that summer feelin at The SugarFactory! This flavor packed Goblet will leave you feeling watermelon sugar high with smooth Sunny vodka, tasty selvarey rum and blended with fresh watermelon, tropical pina colada and crisp lemonade. Topped with classic lemon heads, yummy watermelon and lemon slices! don't know if I could ever go without this Goblet Designed and tasted by Stassie karanikolaou
- Non Alcoholic$34.00
Pretty In Pink$40.00
Pink is more than just a pretty color at The Suqarfactory This Goblet will leave you looking on tire pink side of life with smooth Sunny vodka, crisp Casa Mexico tequila and blended with fresh strawberry and raspberry lemonade Topped with fluffy strawberry cotton candy and a sprinkle of fun glitter! You dont wanna miss this one of a kind goblet designed and tasted by Stassle karanikolaou
- Non Alcoholic$34.00
Magic Cotton Candy$40.00
This delicious peach cocktail is a sweet mix of Virginia black whiskey, peach puree, sweet tea with sour patch peaches and a burst of strawberry lemonade cotton candy!
- Non Alcoholic$34.00
Raspberry Watermelon Mojito$40.00
Escape the heat with this tart and tasty favorite. Made with delicious fruit juices & Selvarey white rum topped with sour watermelon and raspberry gummies and fresh mint leaves. It will cool you off In style. Designed and tasted by Bruno Mars!
- Non Alcoholic$34.00
Mai Tai$40.00
We bring this Tahitian delight to you via warm tropical trade winds. Fresh orange and pineapple juices are blended to perfection with coconut and Selvarey white rum.Topped with a dark rum floater this loseious libat Ion will make the Tiki gods smile. Designed and tasted by Bruno Mars!
- Non Alcoholic$34.00
Henny Moon$40.00
Enjoy the deep sm oooooooooothness of Hennessy, the sweet citrus of fresh tropical tangerine juices and the lightness of 818 Tequila! Garnished with glitter sour stars and moons and sour peach hearts, this magical creation will have you howling at the moon with every sip!
- Non Alcoholic$34.00
Classic Watermelon Pina Coiada$40.00
You deserve a vacation, lucky for you watermelon pina coladas are what we like! This refreshing blend of Selvarey white rum, coconut rum, fresh pineapple, coconut, and watermelon is topped with a mountain of tropical gummy flamingos and tropical gummy flip flops. Designed and tasted by Bruno Mars!
- Non Alcoholic$34.00
While Gummi$40.00
You can't help but play with your food w nenyou order this fresh and fruity rum peach based cocktaiL It will be as much fun to drink as it is to fish out the worms!
- Non Alcoholic$34.00
Ocean Blue$40.00
Adventure awaits in the deep blue sea. You'll be reminded of the ocean nearby when you see al the sharks swimming in this Hpnotiq cocktail!
- Non Alcoholic$34.00
Sour Apple Lolly$17.00
You'll feel nostalgic after the first sip of our liquefied sour apple lollipop Rimmed with Bubble Gum Pop Rocks® this martini finishes with a bang!
Watermelon Burst$17.00
The crisp taste of watermelon bursts from the glass. After one taste of this delightful treat you'll wonder where the candy wrapper is
Bubba Bubba Gum$17.00
You will be trying to blow bubbles after a few sips of this unique bubble gum cocktail We get you started as we garnish this beauty with a ribbon of Bubble Tape®
Key Lime Pie$17.00
A deliciously rich one of a kind martini that is creamy with the perfect sweet-tart ratio. Topped with light fluffy whipped cream and graham cracker crumbs, this tasty treat will leave you thirsting for more with each zesty sip!
Cotton Candy Cosmopolitan$17.00
Cotton candy memories make this one a can' t-miss. We fuse the flavors of cotton candy vodka with a traditional cosmopolitan an top it off with a puff of cotton candy. This martini is straight off the boardwalk
Root Beer Float$18.00
You'll think you' re drinking a real root beer float, only our version is made with spirits instead of ice cream! This creamy concoction is heaven in a cocktail glass
Peace, Love & Harmonie$18.00
We make this enchanting margarita with Hpnotiq Harmonie and natural fruits. You'll experience an explosion of fruity flavor with a hint of rose In this classic cocktail
Grape Crush$18.00
This fantastic blend of grape goodness topped with classic Grape Crush" soda pop will have you thinking you are drinking straight from the can
American Honey$18.00
This delicious drink is made with chocolate, a touch of cream and a bit of sweet honey. It's topped off with some bubbles and dusted with a pinch of cinnamon for the finishing touch
Coconut Cream Pie$17.00
A perfect blend of creamy coconut with a distinct hint of caramel topped with light and fluffy whipped cream and toasted coconut flakes. This decadent dessert martini will make you think we slid a slice of fresh baked pie straight into your glass
Chocolate Mudslide Martini$17.00
This creamy blend of vodka, Kahlua and Bailey s Irish Cream will exceed all of your chocolate expectations. Garnished with a chocolate drizzle, chocolate rim and dark chocolate shavings
Raspberry Sin$17.00
This sinful treat will tease your taste buds. It's made with juicy red raspberries and white chocolate with a fluffy white cloud floating on top
Mint Chocolate$17.00
The famous pairing of mint and chocolate is elevated to a tasty new level making this mixture a favorite among chocolate connoisseurs
Coconut Chocolate Bar$17.00
A lovely medley of coconut chocolate and nuts will make you think we melted a candy bar straight into your glass
Red Velvet$17.00
This decadent dessert has found Its way Into a cocktail glass in this absolutely exquisite martini. A velvety duo of chocolate and a cream cheese frosting rim make this a must have
Peanut Butter Cup$17.00
A celebration of one of rite most well-known duets, the always tempting combo of peanut butter and chocolate does anything but fall short of its namesake in this mouthwatering martini
White Chocolate$17.00
No chocolate cocktail menu would be complete without a white chocolate martini. We bring together the delicate taste of vanilla and white chocolate in this little piece of paradise
S'Mores$17.00
You'll want to cozy up next to a campfire as you sip on this marriage of marshmallow and chocolate with a graham cracker rim
Caramel Truffle$17.00
Attention chocolate and caramel lovers- this Is the choice for you! These two flavors go hand in hand in this wondrous libation
Caramel Macchiato$17.00
Our version of the espresso martini brings the robust flavor of coffee together with the silky tastes of caramel and rich chocolate This martini is accented with a creamy caramel vanilla foam to add another layer of delight
Banana Chunk$17.00
You like peanut butter, you like bananas and you like chocolate... so do we! Here's three of our favorite things all rolled into one fabulous martini
What 697 people are saying
Overall ratings and reviews
Reviews can only be made by diners who have eaten at this restaurant
- 3.5Food
- 3.5Service
- 3.9Ambience
- 2.9Value
Noise • Moderate
Loved For
Indiana
Most Booked
Indianapolis
Kid Friendly
Indianapolis
Most Booked
Sort by
Filters
- OT
OpenTable Diner
Indiana
1 review
overall1food1service1ambience11.01 review
Dined 1 day ago
Where to begin…took my 3 kids for end of summer celebration and was extremely disappointed. First, I almost missed it because I was looking for the famous Sugar Factory sign only to find a plastic banner. Upon entering I gave our name and hostess said they cancelled our reservation then said “just kidding!” Guess she thought that was funny. Anyway, as soon as we sat down I noticed the dead flower on the table, stacks of cleaning supplies across the room and burned out tv monitors. Our server then came to take our order. My daughter ordered the $40 peach drink. I was hesitant because that’s a LOT of money for a drink but we were there to experience it so I set my expectations high for that amount. He brought the drink and it was nothing more than 3 gummy orange slices and a few gummy bears with koolaid poured over them. Tasted artificial. He then proceeded to tell us the 15 items on the menu that they were out of. We ordered the sliders and asked for half of them plain. He told me they were unable to do that and all of them had to be the same. When they came out the buns were burned and the meat was dry. After our meal we went to the candy shop area. There were no containers to put the candy in. They were stacked up behind the register. No one was working so we had to basically get them ourselves from behind the counter. Only half of the candy was labeled and the bins looked dirty. The hostess and another employee walked right past us we stood in front of the register. I had to ask her if someone was working so she came over and proceeded to tell me how she couldn’t wait to go home. My daughter got a piece of cake from the case and when are opened it it was hard as a brick. Over $250 later We left totally disappointed and shocked that the place is still open. I can’t imagine it will be for long!! - OT
OpenTable Diner
1 review
overall2food1service5ambience32.01 review
Dined 1 day ago
the food was super bad! I didn’t expect for the price that I paid the quality of the food to be that bad! The food was cold and the hamburger that I had the bread was so bad! literally the worse type of bread I had in my life. will not back that’s for sure. - K
Kimmp
1 review
overall3food3service4ambience33.01 review
Dined 2 days ago
This is a fun place for a special occasion. We wish we would have eaten lunch at home though and just ordered desserts. - b
beckerboo
Indiana
vip7 reviews
overall1food1service1ambience11.07 reviews
Dined 3 days ago
This was one of the worse “fine” dining experiences I have ever had! Expensive and unique dining experience with Steak ‘n Shake level service. They brought out my meal a full 10 minutes before the rest got their food, which tasted like salmon (maybe cooked on same surface?) and was dry. I swapped for shrimp stir fry (which was actually good) per the managers request, thinking he’d cover the cost. Nope! By the time that finally came, I had already eaten half my daughters grilled cheese, and no longer hungry. It had now been over 50 mins from the time I initially ordered food. Hubby got the lobster tails. Tasted fine but they forgot the butter that it was supposed to come with. Server was basically non existent (she was oversat with a large party) Daughter ordered specialty grilled cheese and was great but again they forgot the specialty sauce they advertise it with. Son got the pasta and loved it. Got free ice cream for his birthday ordered vanilla but chocolate came out. The whole experience took almost 2 hours, from the time we got sat, 12 mins after coming in for our rsvp, 15 mins before we got our first drink of water, 30 mins after that before we got our meal, 30 mins to correct a meal and 30 mins to get our shake and bill. DO NOT GO HERE!!!!! - CR
CReid
Indiana
1 review
overall2food4service3ambience32.01 review
Dined 3 days ago
Extremely overpriced. Food was good but so expensive. We paid nearly $300 for dinner for 4 and 2 desserts. Portions sizes are small. Music is very loud. An extra 20% service charge is automatically added to your bill. We tried one of their goblet beverages and it was very sugary and weak. Didn't even get a buzz from the alcohol. Not worth the $46. If we ever return, which I doubt, we'll be ordering nothing but dessert. Save your money. - DM
DesiraeeM
Chicago
1 review
overall2food1service3ambience32.01 review
Dined 4 days ago
Chicken tenders hard! To hard to eat. Told us 40 mins later that they were out of milk. Then the kitchen is closed. No toilet paper or soap in bathroom. Fries cooked to long. Good got brought out to us cold. It was horrible. No worth the money - OT
OpenTable Diner
Indiana
1 review
overall2food2service1ambience52.01 review
Dined 4 days ago
Bachelorette party. The server did not put our drink order in, our food was out and done before he recognized the drinks were not at the table. The manager did end up bringing the drinks and comping them. The server was not professional or adding to the experience in any way, unfortunately. - B
Bella12
Indiana
1 review
overall5food5service5ambience55.01 review
Dined 4 days ago
We went for my granddaughter’s 12th birthday and she loved it! From the food to the pretty flowers. We sat in pink room and had Jason as our server and he was so sweet and efficient. The food was so fun and delicious. We ordered he Kong sundae and not only was the sundae amazing but the dancers were so fun! Already planned next birthday there next month! - EH
EHolloway
Indiana
1 review
overall2food3service1ambience32.01 review
Dined 4 days ago
We made reservations for a friends 30th birthday. The reservations were made for 4:30pm and we were not seated until 5:15pm. I don't understand the point of a reservation if we still had to wait that long, not to mention the reservations were made WEEKS in advance and there were only 3 of us. It's not like we had a large and difficult group. Once seated, we waited appx 20 minutes before a waitress even acknowledged that we were there. The music was SO loud that we couldn't even hear each other speaking and all left with a headache. For the price of the food, is was definitely underwhelming. It was generic burgers and chicken sandwiches with ice cold French fries and we paid $45-$50 per person. I definitely left there disappointed and will let my friends and family know about our experience. - HG
HeatherG
Indiana
2 reviews
overall5food5service5ambience55.02 reviews
Dined 4 days ago
The hostess, server, and manager were all amazing today! We only had a few minutes of waiting after we checked in for our reservation, which gave us time to look around and snap some pictures. Then Amber H. took great care of us! - CH
CharlotteH
San Francisco
1 review
overall5food5service5ambience55.01 review
Dined 4 days ago
Ricky was great!! Made my sons birthday experience awesome!! - OT
OpenTable Diner
Chicago
1 review
overall3food2service1ambience43.01 review
Dined 4 days ago
Food took to much time.. and restaurant wasn’t very busy… arrived at different timings.. way to expensive and massive plates no kids friendly…no options to add or take away stuff Our server was not very polite or when we requested something she didn’t care and never brought extra maple. Silverware was like they didn’t wash it well… probably we won’t come back - AH
AnquinetteH
Indiana
1 review
overall5food5service5ambience55.01 review
Dined 5 days ago
Loved the atmosphere, decor. Please let your guest know about the mandatory surg charges, so the sticker shock won't be so bad. I tried to order Fish and chips, but you didn't have the supplies in. Thanks - OT
OpenTable Diner
Chicago
1 review
overall2food3service1ambience22.01 review
Dined 5 days ago
Incredibly slow service. Not all items are available in the menu. The lights dimmed during our dinner four to five times to celebrate birthdays and special events. If you want something a little slower and quieter (with better service too), I suggest going for breakfast or on a weekday. Our waiter often forgot about us; at one point we had our meal but then it took another 20 minutes to track down any server for utensils. This is restaurant is definitely a novelty; one and done. - DL
DisneyLuv
Indiana
5 reviews
overall1food3service1ambience31.05 reviews
Dined 5 days ago
Went for my daughters 13th birthday (we have been to the Chicago one) reservation was for 6:45a got seated about 7:10 not too big of a deal but was taken to table Brought waters then everything was downhill from there! They were out of the milkshake my daughter wanted, the Cuban sandwich my husband wanted and when asking server for beer options she said “I don’t know we really just focus on our specialty drinks” she finally found a beer list on her tablet, he ordered one and 15 min later she comes back and says they don’t have it, so he ask for a different one (we are not picky nor complainers) 15 more min later she returns to say “sorry, we don’t have that one either. At that point he said- just give me a class of wine like hers and pointed to my drink. We receive our food, no silverware- napkins so I went up to hostess bc we couldn’t find waiter and asked for 4 sets, she seemed annoyed. 1/2 way into our meal she brings a sealed up lollipop and says, “here I didn’t forget, your drink was suppose to come with a lollipop” it was mostly finished at that point but we appreciated her bringing it. She looks over and says, your wine should be up soon. 20 min later she comes back with the wine and is offering boxes for our food!! My husband kindly explained it was pointless to bring the wine at this point - our meal was over. She did apologize and took off bill. Then came back and said “ok your total is $136 my husband asked to at least glance at the bill, they don’t print it out- they just have it on their tablet. She handed her tablet over and my husband reviewed. I had already warned him of the automatic 20% tip but then there is a place to add additional gratuity 🤔 we gave it a chance but we won’t be back. Disappointed for sure. - S
Sweettooth
Indiana
1 review
overall1food1service1ambience31.01 review
Dined 5 days ago
Food and service were terrible. I will not be back. - OT
OpenTable Diner
Indiana
1 review
overall5food5service5ambience55.01 review
Dined 5 days ago
After reading some reviews, I was nervous about going. If you research ahead of time, you will know about the 20% gratuity and the prices before you go. Lena was our server and she was amazing. We shared one of the alcoholic beverages. It was plenty for 2 people! I had the Rainbow Sliders. Very tasty. My husband had the Salmon and Hashbrowns. Also , very good. He started off ordering the Brick chicken and I was pleasantly surprised that the waitress said she would go with another item in the menu, as it was not One of their favorites and didn’t want him to be disappointed. We ended with a snickers milkshake. It was pricey, but we knew that going in. Will definitely go back for special occasions. - YB
YumBoston24
San Francisco
2 reviews
overall1food1service1ambience11.02 reviews
Dined 6 days ago
Really the worst restaurant I’ve been to. My “lucky charms latte” was just steamed milk with cereal, and then they tried to charge me an extra $4.50 when I asked them to please add espresso to it. Also the food was rubbery, and the milkshake was thin. Also it took 30 minutes to pay our bill in a mostly empty restaurant. We laugh about it now, but really a bad brunch experience. Way more style than substance. - DJ
DaJa
Indiana
1 review
overall5food5service5ambience35.01 review
Dined 6 days ago
I loved it I will come again thank you so much 😊 - c
chocolatecchip
Indiana
3 reviews
overall3food1service3ambience23.03 reviews
Dined 6 days ago
if you want to throw a 15 yr olds birthday party then sure go here butttt it’s extremely loud and the food is beyond mid and hella overpriced (i could have made something the same or better at home) at least my server (in training was nice) and the food came out fast - OT
OpenTable Diner
Indiana
1 review
overall2food1service1ambience32.01 review
Dined 6 days ago
Food was cold and horrible - OT
OpenTable Diner
1 review
overall5food5service5ambience55.01 review
Dined 6 days ago
Great spot for Date Night - DC
DavionC
Indiana
1 review
overall5food5service5ambience55.01 review
Dined 6 days ago
Lena was the best server we ever had she was outstanding with us 10/10 - JS
JoshuaS
St. Louis
1 review
overall2food1service4ambience32.01 review
Dined 6 days ago
Desserts are good but the food is most certainly not worth the price and the drinks are extremely overpriced for what they are. - DE
DECrook
Indiana
vip12 reviews
overall2food2service3ambience22.012 reviews
Dined 7 days ago
Family venture to this restaurant knowing the overpriced and underwhelming reviews. Really just going for the experience, the over the top desserts they promote, and because it’s a relatively new restaurant in downtown Indy. The 5 of us were seated in a booth. Service was prompt and the server was good. The menu was challenging. Drinks were outrageously priced ($45 plus for a goblet beverage) and the selections for the main entrees lacked interesting options. My wife had the salmon salad which was surprisingly good. The salmon was cooked perfectly. I ordered the charcuterie board which was laughable. The only redeeming part of it was the pastry baked Brie. The rest was sliced cheese, some pieces of pepperoni and salami, mustard, some fresh fruit and what looked like strawberry jam. The kids burgers were huge and decent. The milkshakes the children got were good and my son’s Cookie Monster shake brought a smile to his face. The bill at $300 was steep…also reading that they have a straight 20% gratuity included in the bill but the restaurant, after over charging for everything else, takes 3% of the tip as well. Even our children, ages 17,14,12, felt the restaurant was overpriced and underwhelming. We checked this box, and will not return. - ET
ETown
Indiana
vip6 reviews
overall2food3service4ambience42.06 reviews
Dined 7 days ago
Overpriced - H
Heather
Indiana
2 reviews
overall5food4service5ambience55.02 reviews
Dined 7 days ago
Justyce was a great server. She was knowledgeable about the menu and gave great recommendations for lunch. - OT
OpenTable Diner
Indiana
3 reviews
overall2food2service2ambience12.03 reviews
Dined on August 3, 2022
Super bummed to see this restaurant looking so rundown already. Sugar Factory opened less than five months ago in Indianapolis and the interior looks rough. No need to detail every sub-par detail we experienced today but just a heads up that it’s not the exciting experience you may be hoping for. - OT
OpenTable Diner
Indiana
1 review
overall3food3service3ambience33.01 review
Dined on August 2, 2022
Our waiter Lena was fabulous for my daughter’s 16th birthday table of girls. Service was extremely slow, though - but out of Lena’s control. The dancers were great. - VM
VictorM
Orlando
vip1 review
overall3food3service2ambience33.01 review
Dined on August 2, 2022
The Sugar Factory is far from a normal experience. Though it wasn’t bad, it’s wasn’t great either. It had the feel of a place trying to determine if it was upscale or just high priced fluffy dining experience. The food is way expensive and not properly described. The desserts were amazing in appearance and so-So in taste and experience. I really wanted to like the Sugar Factory but it was too much, in the wrong places…. - OT
OpenTable Diner
Indiana
vip1 review
overall3food3service3ambience53.01 review
Dined on August 2, 2022
My husband and I took our children (ages 15 and 13) for the last day of their summer break before starting back to school. We let the kids get some of the special nonalcoholic drinks (at $40 each), and we each ordered a meal. We split one dessert between the four of us. The meal was over $200. The drinks (although overpriced) and dessert were great. The main course food was marginal at best. The presentation of the main course was poor as well. I asked to substitute french fries for broccoli and was charged nine dollars for a side of broccoli. One of the items that was supposed to come with the meal (marinara sauce) did not come. We had a 1215 reservation did not get seated until 1230 despite the restaurant being nearly empty, and it was after 1 o’clock before we got our food. I was very disappointed overall. I do want to emphasize that the drinks were cool and the dessert was excellent. There was nothing wrong with the food specifically it just did not have the wow factor considering the price. A grilled cheese was $15 and a buffalo chicken sandwich was over 20. If we go again we will skip the meal and only go for dessert. - s
someone
Indiana
1 review
overall2food2service2ambience22.01 review
Dined on August 1, 2022
The waitress told us how everything works and it's sad that they are only big and known because they pay celebrities to go there. The food is expensive and not worth the hype. The host was not very welcoming either. - S
Sweetpea
Indiana
1 review
overall5food5service4ambience45.01 review
Dined on August 1, 2022
My daughters birthday - MB
MichaelB
Philadelphia
4 reviews
overall1food2service1ambience11.04 reviews
Dined on August 1, 2022
I would not recommend this restaurant to anyone. The music is played very loud and becomes deafening when a birthday celebration occurs. We waited 30 minutes before a waiter took our order. Then my wife and daughter received their meals but mine was not delivered and we did not see a waiter for 2.0 minutes to ask about it, and it arrived 10 minutes later. They never brought my daughters drink. The prices are outrageously high and the food was only mediocre with tiny portion sizes. When they brought the check we were informed that there was a mandatory 20% gratuity already charged. When I spoke to the manager I was informed that he was not allowed to decrease the gratuity as per corporate rules, so he had to deduct 20% from our food total. This chain is a total rip-off, we will never go again. - LK
LeahK
Indiana
1 review
overall3food2service3ambience43.01 review
Dined on July 31, 2022
I would definitely skip dinner and only go for the dessert! Food is so expensive and not very good, but dessert was great. Also, the big dry ice drinks become a block of ice that is totally undrinkable. - JS
JoanneS
Chicago
5 reviews
overall4food4service4ambience44.05 reviews
Dined on July 31, 2022
It was pricey for what we got. I feel the drinks r too expensive but it was a fun place to take pictures - TC
ToniC
Chicago
1 review
overall5food5service5ambience55.01 review
Dined on July 31, 2022
Food and drinks were good. Beautiful place to celebrate a birthday. - OT
OpenTable Diner
Indiana
1 review
overall5food5service5ambience55.01 review
Dined on July 31, 2022
It was a wonderful experience - SA
SilviaA
Denver
2 reviews
overall1food1service1ambience11.02 reviews
Dined on July 31, 2022
We made a reservation at 8:45pm and it took them 45 minutes to sit us. Once we got sat, it took them another 15 minutes to even come around and offer waters. There were kids everywhere at 9:30 running around the restaurant The drinks aren’t worth all the hype either If you’re looking for a place to enjoy a drink this isn’t it. - JL
JanetL
Indiana
1 review
overall2food2service2ambience42.01 review
Dined on July 31, 2022
We had an 8 o’clock reservation and we checked in at 8 PM At 8:25 I had to track down the hostess who was out and about in the restaurant not at the hostess stand to ask her when we might be seated. I also had to speak with the manager. Once seated our server was very good. Management at this new location has not yet mastered what will need to be done or maybe they need different management. Many people were upset. Hopefully in a few more months they will get the hang.
FAQs
Sugar Factory - Indianapolis is rated 3.5 stars by 697 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable.
Make a reservation
49 W Maryland St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Additional information
- Neighborhood
Downtown Indy
- Hours of operation
Mon–Thu 11:00 am–11:00 pm Fri 11:00 am–12:00 am Sat 10:00 am–12:00 am Sun 10:00 am–10:00 pm
- Cuisines
American, Contemporary American, Dessert
- Dining style
Casual Dining
- Dress code
Business Casual
- Parking details
None
- Additional
Bar/Lounge, Late Night, Wheelchair Access
- Website
- Phone number
(463) 217-0383
- Private party facilities
We welcome you to explore our Private Dining options, perfect for any occasion.
- Private party contact
Dana Sugarman: (844) 893-7902