Sicilia Mia

Cousin was in n town...

Sicilia Mia is amazing! Our favorite place for special occasions. The staff makes you feel like family. Eduardo and Giuseppe are fantastic.

Worst service I’ve ever had, for how much we spent. We waited several minutes to be served water, then waited several minutes longer to have our drink order taken. The first thing our server says to us is, “I have a big table to help so I’m just going to take your orders real quick. Do you know what you want?” Haha.

The food was spectacular, yes, but the young server we had couldn’t have been less interested in waiting on us. Be prepared for larger groups to take priority over a two top.

Always wonderful! The hot spinach salad is always, always wonderful. The fried calamari and shrimp appetizer are light, flavorful, and cooked beautifully; tender, NOT rubber, served with wonderful warm marinara sauce. Pastas are tender and NOT over cooked. Dessert - fabulous!

Always dependable food. Never eaten a bad meal Lunch or dinner is delicious.

Absolutely spectacular!

Family run business, very authentic Italian atmosphere. Don't let the strip mall location fool you their signature dish, spaghetti carbonara is excellent. Prepared fresh right in front of you, very authentic, very cheesey. The waitstaffs attention to your needs is excellent, very warm and friendly. They have excellent pizza!

We especially enjoyed visiting with the lady assigned to our table.

I brought a few of my girlfriends here to experience the food as I’ve been here several times and consider this place a favorite. We had a great time there. Never once felt rushed to eat and leave. We were able to eat the most delicious food and visit as long as we desired. The service was great too. Never felt neglected by our servers or rushed to hurry and leave. Now all my friends want to bring their spouses too!

What a great surprise-external -strip mall. Pushed through hesitation because it is on a strip mall. Entered door and felt like I was back in a wonderful Italian neighborhood restaurant outside of Rome. Excellent food and experience.

When I got to the restaurant they did not have my reservation. Yet when I was seated, I got an email from OpenTable confirming that I have been seated. I don’t understand why they didn’t have a reservation, yet I was getting notices that they did. I’m not sure if it is a glitch on your end, or on the user end.

Fantastic food. Hands down the best customer service I’ve experienced in quite a long time. 10/10

I love the food everything es fresh 😋 delicious., and the customer service is very good

Everything from start to finish was very good, I didn’t give 5 stars because that is perfection but they were awesome and the food was very good, my wife was very happy

Our Christmas Eve dinner was amazing! Angelo and family are the best -- it's the only place my Sicilian wife really wants to go to, and for good reason! Everything was wonderful.

amazing carbonara pasta. LOVED it. They serve homemade bread with 3 dips whilst you wait for your meal. Best to get a reservation, they were turning people away. A bit chilly by the front door, I would recommend asking for a table away from the door. We will definitely be going again when we have another special occasion.

The food here was amazing, we got the carbonara and it was everything I dreamed it would be! Love the presentation with the fresh cheese wheel and fire! We will definitely be going here again, especially since it doesn’t break the bank!

The food is great. Usually the service is excellent, too. This time, however, it took a long time to get our food and it was not a complicated item. Unfortunately we were on a schedule.

This location is in a strip mall next to a grocery store. Doesn’t look overly important but the food and service was great! We were warmly greeted when we came in and ushered right to our table. Our waiter was most helpful in our food selection. Everything was delicious. We wanted to try the delightful looking desserts but were too full.

Delicious! Good lunch selection and good price!

Dinner for 4 and the meal was wonderful from the Gnocchi, Lasagna and the special Butternut Squash Ravioli. Only complaint was music could not compete with large party and asked to have it adjusted and they turned it off. Much appreciated.

I absolutely love the food at this restaurant! I read some prior reviews that were negative regarding the two top tables. I appreciated those reviews simply so I was prepared. My expectations were set so I was not disappointed. The 2 top tables are small and it was right next to the dessert counter. There were times people and or staff were standing there, but I didn't find this to be intrusive at all though. My friend and I had our monthly bestie date. We ordered 1 appetizer and three entre's to split (we couldn't decide so we indulged). Definitely WAY too much food as we could have shared the app and 1 entre. But it was so worth it and we had left overs! The food was incredible! The service was on point! And all though we had a small table the staff was there to clear up any empty dishes to make sure there was room for our feast! I'll be going back soon!

Food was great! We had a very good time. Waitress very helpful and great recommendations.

The food was so good and very authentic. The sauces and pasta were perfectly done with just the right proportions. Appetizers were excellent as were the desserts. Will definitely go agsin.

Great, authentic Italian food find! I'm from Italy and will vouch for this place. I will be back for sure.

Excellent restaurant. My wife and I live in Idaho Falls, Idaho, and everything we have the opportunity to come to Utah, we always stop at this restaurant. There are really friendly and are the best out there!

Sicilia Mia is my go-to for all occasions- birthdays, dates, a Tuesday. The crew is the best around and makes me feel like I’m a VIP. It’s truly magical!!
Amo la mia Sicilia Mia famiglia❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

Reasonable food -- some interesting items. Ambiance is poor. Big open room, cold tables by front door, uncomfortable chairs, echoes... like of like eating in a school room cafeteria. Warm spinach salad was good, Cesare salad wet and spongy. Bread is really good!

Overall Experience was very good. The only 2 issues I had I listed under ambiance - but this may have been more centric to the location (near the desert area/kitchen entrance) - It is expected with location and design of the facility.

The other issue was with the actual open table reservation - normally I am seated upon arrival, however this experience we waited about 20 minutes) unsure if this was that many large groups limited seating options.

Aside from those issues the food and service was great.

This place is awesome! For those seeking an authentic Italian experience, this is the place to go. Best pasta I've ever had and the service is mostly by people from Italy which is a nice touch. If you speak Italian, this place is that much better too.

We often dine with the Sicilia group of restaurants, but hadn't been to the Highland Drive location for a while. We were happy to realize that there were still a lot of paisanos still working the front and back ends, and enjoyed wonderful appetizers, service, entrees, and cordial conversation in Italian, which always makes us happy. Shout out to Angelo, who took extra good care of us, and allowed me to substitute my own whole wheat pasta for the white flour pasta that they normally use, and also to Marco, who cooked that wonderful special with the same pasta

Perfect as usual. You never get disappointed with them.

We enjoyed celebrating my brother's birthday and the atmosphere and food couldn't have been better. The staff were engaged and we had an absolute wonderful meal and enjoyed the experience immensely!

Food was way overpriced for what we got. The hype is they put the pasta from the frying pan in the kitchen into the cheese wheel and put a little bit of everclear in the cheese wheel, light it on fire, boom $25 dollars later you have some so-so pasta the size of a fist on your plate. Pizza's looked good, but overall the value of this place was not good. Expect to pay $40+ for 2 entrees.

The food was AMAZING!! And the service and presentation was great!! Will be back for sure!

Live up north, this restaurant is worth the drive. The best Italian food in the city. Save room for dessert too. The noise level is a little loud, lots of people in a not so big place. It's nice that they'll be opening a location Downtown soon.

Food was wonderful, servings were small, I was expecting larger Italian family style portions. I will definitely go back! Authentic Italian is amazing!

One complaint was that the cooks smoked with the back door open, wind blew the smell of smoke right to our table.

Having made reservations ahead a time we were expecting a nice Italian dinner out. Instead we were seated at a table directly in front of their dessert display case therefore we had strangers standing over our table the entire hour we were TRYING to dine. Furthermore if strangers weren’t trying to look at the display case, servers stood directly over us staring the entire time. Their two seater tables are WAY too small to accommodate their normal dinner portions and the server was constantly trying to make it work. I seriously wanted to just say “put the whole dinner in a to-go box” so I could get out of there. I definitely won’t be returning. For the price of this restaurant, you can find many Italian restaurants that have excellent food as well as the ambience you deserve.

This place is a must do. Food was great, service was excellent, and it was very authentic.

The spaghetti carbonara was a delicious dinner that comes with a show!