Sourcing as much of our ingredients as possible from the farms of the Hampton's, the local fisherman of Montauk and neighboring producers, we are offering an a la carte menu for our guest to enjoy the best the area has to offer.
While there is a focus on produce and seafood, there will be plenty for guests to enjoy outside of that scope, too. We are looking forward to you joining us this season!
Lobster & Kimchi Fried Rice
Ssam Sauce, Radish, Sesame, Scallion
Preserved Lemon, Salmoriglio, Pumpernickel Toast, Smoked Chili Oil Nasturtium
Patty Pan Squash, Castelvetrano Olive Salsa Verde
Location is beautiful but the food wasn’t as impressive. It was good, but not great. My scallops were cooked perfectly but the corn & peas base seemed hard & dry. My husband described the lobster tagliatelle, one of their specialties, as “average”. The menu is limited. We expected more seafood options with a name like Showfish. Service was subpar. They were too eager to clear the table even though we had an early reservation, it was out of season, & they weren’t particularly busy. A dozen clams on the half shell came without a seafood fork. When one was requested, they first tried to substitute an espresso spoon. Really?
Service was horrible
I highly recommend that you order the cauliflower!
I did not realize that Showfish is located in the Gurney's... can't say I would have booked it if I had known this as the resort is pretty meh to me. The restaurant is located on the water, has a fun vibe and a good menu. I thought the food was good, but I wouldn't make the trip out just to eat here. There was an engagement or wedding party in the private room, but they only had half of the space - the rest had regular diners and all the doors were open so we had to listen to their DJ vs. the restaurant music. The other drawback was the wine selection, which was nothing to rave about.
Overall very good. Friends ordered the tuna and quite frankly it was kind of gross and presentation was weird. It was basically a ton of tuna (for 2-3 people) on a slab. No sides. No real presentation. Just a weird main dish with nothing else.
Otherwise all was good.
Fabulous ambience & outstanding food. Felt like we were in the Caribbean
Angry Lobster was so spicy that our guests could not eat it. We wish they were warned.
Food was not worth the money. Ordered a whole Fish to share and got a dry fillet. Vegetables were soaked in oil. No plates to eat what we wanted to share. Poor service and extremely loud music. Will not return.
The outdoor bartender was dismissive and not very friendly as she wanted to be done with her shift as we arrived having been told by staff to wait there. Other than that, the staff were friendly and the food was very good. The atmosphere was beautiful. We were seated inside with the patio doors open facing the water. Absolutely beautiful setting.
Great restaurant, 10/10 on food, decor, ambiance and service. Add to that a beautiful water view, plenty of outdoor tables and easy parking... we will definitely be back! Btw, the lobster rolls here are FANTASTIC.
Best experience we’ve had in a new city, my significant other and I have never been to Montauk before and Showfish was definitely the place to make it memorable, thank you.
Great place to eat , drink and enjoy all Montauk has to offer. Highly recommend anyone traveling to Montauk to make a reservation .
Todo muy rico pero era muy caro y lo habitaban pero lo podrían Haber rebajado
Great pancakes,Beautiful setting, Good service!
Busy and noisy spot on a Saturday night. Reservation honored in a timely fashion. Service was excellent - just the right amount of attention. Drinks were generous and the food was well prepared. Pricy but not out of line for an upscale resort area.
Waiter was attentive and friendly. The setting was beyond amazing to celebrate our Wedding Anniversary!
The restaurant is right on the Marina. It’s decorated very nicely. The staff was so nice. Portion sizes were very big. Everything was delicious. We would definitely go back.
Was a fine meal but a few options were not as advertised and all of our food (appetizers, drinks, and entrees) was brought at once and that was confusing. With some spotty service the experience was okay but could be better - I figure it was just a busy evening
Great food and location!
fabulous food…fabulous views! a perfect nite…
Food was incredible! Get the angry lobster, lobster kinchi and the pizzas
Wonderful time! Food was delicious
My new favorite place in montauk! can’t beat the service or the food!
Delicious!!!! And beautiful view!
Had to walk back to hostess after having been seated for 20 mins at our reservation to have someone come and take a drink order. Service was just not there. They tried making up for it with free dessert but the night was spent waiting for someone to pay attention to us. Food was good though.
We sat for 15/20 minutes before anyone came to our table to ask if we wanted drinks/food. When he finally came over he insisted we needed to order everything at once. Horrible service
The service was terrible, it took over an hour and a half for us to get our food. Our waitress never checked in or apologized for the long wait. The food was incredible but it was overshadowed by the poor service.
Magical in the summer to be on star island it was a lively + gorgeous Dining room the service left me wanting more
I enjoyed my lunch but after leaving I realized I left my credit card and had driven an hour back to Southampton when I called to confirm that they had it. I spoke with Jen and asked if she could mail it to me as I was leaving town the next day to fly back to Texas. She said no problem they would mail it… it has been over a week and nothing so far. I have called at least 30 times at all hours that they are open and it goes to voicemail EVERY time! So frustrating…I emailed and left voicemail messages too, NO RESPONSE!
I had to find the waiter to get initial service after being seated.
They didn’t get the appetizer order correct and it had to be sent back
Had to find the server as they forgot one of the two main courses.
Literally, had to get up out of my seat twice.
There was no apology or even acknowledgement of the service or order.
Was overall disappointing
Tuna not the best quality. Somollier didn’t know anything about correct wine temperatures. Red wine bottle put in an ice bucket. Gelato dessert arrived half melted. Our waitress tried her best to circumvent these issues.
Weird waiter. Music was way too loud
Atmosphere is awesome but $55 over cooked Branzino and over cooked chicken was a shame. Cheesecake Dessert was fair . $250 for a dinner you expect properly cooked meals . Love ScarpettA but this didn’t come close
Food was mediocre for the price.
Great table/food /service....view is spectacular!
Amazing! Food, Staff & Ambiance exceptional! Luigi is awesome
We were seated over an hour after our reservation time and no one seemed to mention it. They need to pace their reservations better.
Couldn’t accommodate our reservation
Food was excellent. Service is struggling like all restaurants out east. It’s tough to get staff. :(
Showfish is rated 4.5 stars by 233 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.