Food was great waiter wasn’t. Do not get Tommy as a waiter.

This was a great time to go. I thought with it being restaurant week, it would be busy and we would have to wait. It was not as busy as I thought it was going to be and the food was great!

Consistently gold food and service at this location.

Very good food. Great place. Definitely would recommend

I visited Rusty Bucket for the first time since the pandemic started. It’s always been a favorite but I came away very disappointed this time. The food was still good, but the service was not up to par. We were seated at a table that was very dirty and had not been wiped down. Asked the waiter to take care of that which he begrudgingly did. The server had no personality and while I didn’t expect him to become my best friend, he could have been a little more congenial. When the food came out, he brought only 3 of the 4 dishes, which in my mind is not acceptable. The person who didn’t have he food insisted the rest of us start, but it felt awkward to do that so we sat uncomfortably waiting for the 4th dish to arrive. We had to flag down the waiter several times during the course of the meal, as opposed to the waiter stopping by occasionally to ask if everything was ok. Having invited out of town guests to enjoy a nice meal out at a favorite restaurant, I was a little embarrassed by the overall experience.

Food and service were great!

Normally we rate this Rusty Bucket a straight five. However when we checked in for our reservation, there seemed to be a lot of confusion. The Hostesses did not seem to know about how to handle open table reservations. We were seated immediately as the resturant was not filled. Then we got a text message to check in with the hostess for our table. Then I got an email from open table about our no show for our reservation. The food and service were great but the resturant has issues taking and handling reservations. My advice, be extremely careful when checking with a reservation.

We had the best server (Carl) that provided us with AWESOME service all evening. He deserves a special kudos not only from the 8 of us that he attended to all evening, but also from the staff and management at The Rusty Bucket!! Great job Carl!!! We hope we get you the next time we come through!

A quick bite with the foamily. From salads to burgers and fish/chips, every one was satisfied. The staff was attentive and checked in on us the right amount. It is a great place for families and friends to get together. The updated menu came at us as a surprise, but we all found something we could sink our teeth into. Doesn't appear they have the daily menu specials, but maybe I didn't catch it on the menu (drink specials were there). Always a pleasure and worth the visit.

My wife has a garlic & onion allergy of which the server was advised. It took three tries for the kitchen to get it right. By then my daughter and m I had g finished our mea

The food was great and we took advantage of their HappyHour specials as well!

Excellent service and happy hour food specials. $5 Juicy Lucy Burger a must have!

Seated quickly and exactly where we wanted to be. Food was wonderful!

Had lunch, it was very cool outside, the fireplace was burning, nice touch. Server was very attentive. There were three of us and we each ordered something different, all good. I live in Worthington but travel to Dublin to enjoy a nice meal.

I had the mushroom pizza with the garic, onion, and truffle sauce.. Sooo delicious! My friend had the cod dinner and it's one of her favorites.

Nice craft beer selection and mix of upscale bar food.

Good and varied menu. Friendly service, but seemed like some more training would be helpful.

Stopped by for lunch. Seated right on time for our reservation. Service was good, food was excellent. Nice spot for larger groups as well, as their tables are fairly flexible.

Had a great server, and it is so great to be able to make reservations

Had a party of 4 and all the food was good. Nice variety for all tastes.

Burger was over cooked and not hot when served.

Our Server was very attentive and polite.
Food was delicious.

Excellent food. We all had hamburgers and they were very good. The French fries were also really good. I will definitely go back.

Great local family restaurant. Good food at a reasonable cost and GREAT service! Highly recommend.

Our drink order got confused as well as our food order, but both were corrected quickly.

This was our first dining experience since pre pandemic. Food was delicious and all Covid precautions were followed.

Food was really good I’m that person who tries wings wherever I go and scale them I ordered the habanero wings and they were definitely fire for sure. Service was pretty fast.

Waiter was excellent

Ordered grilled chicken on a salad. Greens were fine but chicken overcooked and dry.

Took a few minutes to get service but after that everything was fine

As usual, quick service, good food at a reasonable price (can’t beat happy hour).Reservation through Open Table is the best!

Carl was an excellent server! The food was delicious and being St Patrick's Day we were able to get a reservation.

We went for the corned beef special. It was horrible. The meat was hard , not moist like corned beef usually is. Potatoes were not cooked through. Very disappointing.

Good place
Need a bigger menu

Table ready. Friendly, efficient server. Highly recommend.

Warm draft beer and slow service

Waiter sucked (Benjamin). It way to long to get drinks and the bill to leave.

I enjoyed myself. Great for date nights are a casual night out with friends.

Immediately seated and drink orders taken. Excellent choices, good food, excellent service.

It was very good