Rusty Bucket - 86th & Ditch
There were no condiments on the tables
When we asked the server for some
pepper he brought it.
He indicated they were kept off the table so they could be cleaned before and after each use
Good plan
Thank you
Food is always great.
Service fine.
Wish there were other draft beer choices.
Server was rushed food was lacking in quantity especially the fish and chips duaughter order a drink by the time it came she was just about done eating, must have been a shortage of water
Valentines Day dinner. Great service with great food made my family very very happy !!
The food was wonderful and our server was very friendly. We will be going back soon.
The food was awesome! We got the nachos (which are massive), and they were so delicious! Gary’s famous margarita was good too. The staff was friendly, this place is a hidden gem!
Waitress was sweet but distracted or just unorganized.
Had to be reminded of all requests.
Seemed rushed and inexperienced.
Food was great as always
Our table of five all had concerns about the length of time it took to get our food. A little frustrating.
Always consistently great food & service! Our “go to” place for family dinners, game nights & even special occasions!
Never disappointed. Food is consistently delicious. The Rusty is one of our go to restaurants.
Great atmosphere and food
Server (Nancy) had a great attitude and was fun. Steak was excellent and cooked just right! We also had fish and chips, and Rueben. Everything was great. Loved the Nickel Salad too. Wish they had more top shelf Bourbon.
Good nothing exceptional just good
This is one of best kept secrets in town. It’s always clean and the staff is always friendly.
Family night out - have kids - food was good bar food (nachos dang good) - just a hair loud for kids and the like but well done overall!
Ok, I'll make my review at least 50 characters in length.
Portion size was small for an entree salad. Service was ok - not terrible but not remarkable either. Seated quickly with reservation. Kids enjoyed their meals. A bit pricey for quality. Bathrooms were dirty for a restaurant (on par with rest areas).
We usually have a wonderful meal at this restaurant but tonight the French Onion Soup was BAD.
First time there since they changed the menu. $14.49 for a bowl of chili seems excessive since most of it was pasta. Server left a little to be desired; manager had to bring us refills. Louder than normal but that was because of Colts game. Most disappointing visit we have had since started going there.
The service, food and ambiance were great!
Was good, but my taco salad hardly had any meat on it. It was tasty though and service was great! Not sure it's worth the price, but was a nice lunch. Thank you.
The interior is a little worn, but the food was very good and service was better than expected
food and service was good but charged $7.00 for the margarita which was listed at $5.00
Fun atmosphere, friendly staff and yummy comfort food!
Food quality fair
Great food, servers, bartenders and atmosphere.
If you haven’t been to this gem...you need to go.
We had A fantastic Waitress ? Mattie? She was tremendous. We will be back!!!!!!
A great local restaurant with good food and great service. All food is prepared fresh.
Great place, great food, wonderful bartenders and servers.
If you haven’t tried this ‘Cheers-atmosphere’ gen...you are missing out.
Food is consistently good! Great overall value.
The food was fresh and made in-house. Turkey burgers were among the best I've had. My grandchildren had the chicken fingers which were moist and lightly breaded.
Always great service and great food! I would definitely recommend this restaurant!
Restaurant could use a face lift. Tablecloths are plastic and torn.
Service was slow. Food a bit overpriced compared to other establishments.
Great place, great food and great service! One of our favorite places.
Great time with friends. Food and service was great.
GREAT FOOD, wonderful people and servers and a fun and relaxing atmosphere.
For those who haven’t been...you need to go.
Everything on the menu is excellent.
Always great food and our server was friendly and efficient.
We had a party of 9 including 5 kids (ages 3-12). Trying to get a reservation for that size party on a Saturday night in the Indy area is not easy, especially last minute. We were able to snag a table thru the Open Table app only about 25-30 min earlier. None of us had ever been before and actually hadn’t even heard of it. We were surprised to learn they had been there for 10 years! Our waiter was wonderful! Very personable, made some great suggestions and even offered to comp some fried pickles for us to try since we were “newbies”. They were amazing as was all of our food! Highly recommend the Buffalo Chicken sandwich, burger, pork tenderloin and fish and chips (and don’t forget the fried pickles with ranch:). There is a good sized bar in the middle of the restaurant but plenty of other seating around. Like I said, we had kids with us and it was a completely appropriate atmosphere. Great place, will definitely return!
Great, friendly go-to place. If you haven’t been, please go. It is a friendly neighborhood restaurant/bar with excellent food and servers.
It was our firzt time there and we were treated great by our waiter. When we were done eating, he brought us a free dessert to share. The service was excellent and the food was great!
