Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar, Huntington, NY
parmesan-white truffle sauce
Birthday dinner for my wife with good friends
Great service, great food and an amazing view. We will definitely be back!
We had an amazing experience! Our waiter, Joe, was beyond phenomenal.. His knowledge and expertise were beyond comparison!
Prime is our favorite restaurant and this visit was just like all the others ... a GREAT TIME. I chose Prime for my 50th Birthday. We had a nice table for 8 in the center. The front desk staff were friendly and warm in their greeting. The server was prompt and also left us alone to enjoy our time together. The food was wonderful and cooked perfectly for everyone at the table. Dessert ended a great meal, and it too did not disappoint. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED! GREAT PLACE A++ :)
My absolute favorite place to eat on Long Island. The merry oysters are always extremely fresh and delicious. The steak is always cooked to absolute perfection, and I never had a side that wasn’t absolutely amazing. Best food, best drinks, best view.
Still as good as it ever was. Had the petit filet mignon...medium rare. Was spot on from the first bite to the last.
Both of our steaks were incredibly fatty and overcooked. I ordered a beef Wellington it was half fat and cooked beyond being belief. Their beef Wellington and steak have always been great in the past. No idea what happened. But for what we’re paying, not acceptable.
This a a great place for any occasion! The food and service are spectacular.
I made a reservation a week before going and specifically stated "no booths" in the comment section as I had elderly people with mobility issues with me. I had to wait for the table and got exactly what I didn't want - a booth. The hostess ignored me and walked away. The food was good but we had a long wait to get it - the waiter came to the table and told us the kitchen was backed up. The poached lobster in butter was cold as was the $18 small side of masked potatoes. The waiter forgot one dessert and it took 15 min to get the forgotten ice-cream. The bread was forgotten and arrived after the appetizers. At these prices, one would expect hot food even when the tables were full. Unfortunately, that was not the case. With so many restaurants, I think my trips to Prime will be fewer.
Montauk Roll delicious! Best Filet Mignon and Mac it's nice spending them at a place where you feel it's appreciated. If you haven't been to Prime, GO! Sunday Brunch is always a good way to start, or check our their Power Lunch. '
Managers were amazing with quick acknowledgement of my undercooked filet mignon
We make it a point to celebrate my wife’s birthday at Prime every year. Typically, they offer a gift card to the birthday girl to come back which does entice us to return for a non-special occasion. In fact, we were celebrating with amour best friends who also were celebrating a birthday. This year, especially with it being a special number birthday for my wife, there was no acknowledgement and the service was quite lacking for Prime. Every restaurant has their nights but it was just unfortunate that for a special occasion, we had to experience not the best service.
Always amazing at Prime.
Prime should have a frequent diner program like the Scotto chain!
Food was delicious and cooked to perfection. Fantastic server, attentive and personable.
So surprised at the level of professionalism and hospitality. Like a NYC high rated restaurant!
Food was unique, wine list expansive . You can have a grouping of 3oz of wines to try out. Very clever. Fresh catch of day was John Dory and beautifully prepared.
Gorgeous setting by water. Can’t wait to go back when the weather is warmer
Best steakhouse around
Incomparable food served in a beautiful setting by superior wait staff!
Great food, ambiance and waiter. I love the view !
My husband and I enjoyed a fabulous special meal at Prime. The strip steak was outstanding.
I went here for a Brunch on Sunday. I arrived early and was seated promptly which was appreciated. What took.away from the time that was saved was 40 min unexplainable wait time for a simple eggs ,bacon ,potatoes and toast. To add insult to injury,the table that arrived after me recieved all four of their meals before us which was Burgers and fries and more. I am above beyond and extremely disappointed at the level of service received and the lack of interest and apology from my waiter . True Disappointment.
Always a great dining experience. Service is top notch and the menu is a treat.
We have been going to Prime for many years and as usual the service was great and the food was cook to requested desire.
Food is good but I beginning to question the premium price on it , Service (Frank) was very pleasant and very informative. Maybe its the summer when I have a no problem dining there, much different vibe then
Well done! No, not my steak I like it medium and, as always, it was done perfectly.
We usually come by boat. Nice change for a quiet Saturday lunch.
The service wasn’t as always... when seated the bread didn’t come until I asked for it ... the waiter didn’t ask if we wanted wine .. we had to ask for it... The dessert given as a compliment (which was very nice of the restaurant to do because of the mishaps) wasn’t what we wanted .. they should have asked what we liked and then bring that..
We have come to Prime to celebrate my best friends birthday coming from Queens, to only receive lack luster service from our server (about 40 minutes between checking on us.. to bring out undercooked steaks, (ordered medium) and they came out RAW and cold to touch. They had sent another steak to the table in regards to the other two undercooked and it came out Raw and cold !
THREE DIFFERENT STEAKS ordered and All three came out not correct to the order, inedible and we had to get food on the way home from dinner!! That shouldn’t happen!
The service was awful and it wasn’t even a busy evening! We never got the chance to order dessert in celebration of my friends birthday because the waiter wasn’t even serving us!
Talk about humiliating and embarrassing to come to a TOP tier restaurant and getting lackluster service?!
A LI hotspot that delivers on atmosphere and location with a few tasty dishes, sushi, but falls short in the entree department!
We celebrated our grandson's 16th birthday. This is the 2nd time we've been there. Food was exceptional as was the service
I have been to Prime multiple times, it had become my go-to for celebrations of all kinds or just a casual dinner. Prime was the first place I had eaten at right before I fell in love with Huntington and ended up moving here! However, this particular visit had left a very sour taste in my mouth.
I had made a reservation and requested a corner table because I have had issues where the wait staff or other guests tend to run their hands on the back of your chair as they pass you or you get knocked in to when you sit in the middle tables. It was busy when we got here but a table had just left and because we hadn't ordered yet, we asked to be moved to a table closer to the wall... literally 2 steps away. Long story short, the waiter was not pleasant about any of it, it was a much bigger scene than I thought it would be literally with huffing and puffing. He even moved us with attitude and I was already embarrassed as other diners were watching and then he did not return to us to take our order after we had already informed him we were ready. We felt like we were being punished as we watched him dote on his other tables. But as usual, our bill was given and payment taken quickly.
We came to celebrate my friend's birthday, the runner had literally dropped her dessert with a candle on the table and left. How sad and embarrassing because I spoke so highly about this place. Management was present watching over the dinner rush, standing there in their suits; how sad that not one of them asked how dinner was going or to round on their customers.
Let me say, our bill for 3 people is typically $300-$400, we come for the food, drinks, experience AND especially service. I was very disappointed this time around. Well, time to try other places to spend my hard earned money.
We were at Prime In Huntington For our 1st time as we celebrated our anniversary.All I have to say it was outstanding.Joe was our waiter and he was amazing and all I know was that my wife and I were treated very well.I will be returning..
Mr. Bohlsen, thank you for the gift certificate. It was definitely a pleasure going back to Prime. My wife and I very much enjoyed our dinner and the evening.
Again, thank you.
Joseph N. Guariglia
We had GREAT SERVICE and Our Dinner was VERY VERY GOOD ! THE ABSOLUTE BEST VIEW on
Long Island !
Food was very good. Water view from the table was pretty.
Very good service; good menu, well prepared and great ambience
Always love coming here. Thank you for another lovely evening!
Food was absolutely amazing! The beef Wellington was done to perfection. Will definitely return
Food was excellent as well as service. But be prepared for high prices.
Amazing!!! 10/10 would recommend !!
Valentines Day prefix menu , food was outstanding, service excellent, an overall great experience
The food was incredible, as always. Our waiter was such a delight! Checking in was a nuisance since they forgot about us after waiting for 15min. The busboys kept walking by our table and and never took any empty dishes, we could tell our waiter was a little perturbed about it. But our waiter really made it a great experience, and the food is always delicious.
Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar, Huntington, NY offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (631) 385-1515.
Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar, Huntington, NY is rated 4.5 stars by 4543 OpenTable diners.
Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar, Huntington, NY does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://shop.brgroup.biz.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.