Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar, Huntington, NY

It’s always too loud in the main dining area. Otherwise everything else is always exceptional!

I was there for my birthday and the staff could not be more great! When bringing out my dessert there was a candle and a happy birthday sign. They then told us the dessert was on them and gave me a gift card as well for my next visit. They did everything they could to make my birthday dinner a very special one!

Friendly staff. Helpful with ordering. Food was very good and nice presentation.

This is by far the best steak house from here to NYC amazing food and even better service

Excellent meal and service We were very pleased with food quality. our meals were delicious. The Wait staff was very attentive and pleasant.

Prime Huntington never disappoints. Great food, exemplary service. The special Anniversary Menu was fantastic! My compliments to the chef!

Outstanding as usual

Wow ! What more can I say?!? When it comes to fine dining it’s about the experience and Joe really MADE our night. Upon arrival he greeted us with a smile and his super friendly demeanor, made us feel welcome as if we were at his house. He made great suggestions, anything we needed he was right there before we even had to ask. Everything was perfect from the wine pairings to the exceptional dessert. The cremé bruleé is to die for ! The filet I ordered medium rare melted in my mouth, creamed spinach was delicious ! Definitely going back again soon !!

Great food and terrific service...especially from Frank. We were 4 celebrating our birthdays. The porterhouse steak was delicious...carved up at the table. We shared 2 steaks and it was perfect. They could give a side with the order, but then again most steakhouses don't. I have been to Prime on many occasions and whatever we have ordered was outstanding...including the sushi

Thank you Joe , for a great dining experience. Food was fantastic, wine was amazing, and service was impeccable. Will be coming back soon.

We enjoyed the Anniversary prix fixe menu with wine pairing — DELICIOUS!! The kale Ceasar salad was so unexpectedly delicious, the kale texture was so different, yet so good! I upgraded to include a 12 oz filet and it was perfectly cooked, also did a surf and turf upgrade which was a little less than expected, the piece of lobster was very small. Great service and beautiful atmosphere!

We went to prime for my birthday and it was their anniversary so they had a pre-fixe menu which was great! They offered a wine pairing with the menu and our waiter at first sent over the wine expert to help us. She was lovely and answered questions about wines. After that our waiter ended up telling us about different wines and giving wines to go with different dishes. It was so fun because he knew so much about the wine and made it into a game having us guess what it was by telling us about the history and the type of grape. His name was joe and I would 100% recommend asking for him if you go. He made our dinner fun and he was so knowledgeable about different wines. It was a great nite all in all!

I never had a bad meal here and the service is excellent. I did enjoy the wine tasting this Sunday well worth the price. Ambiance is great!

While the server was super nice, everything was extremely slow and it was not crowded at all during Sunday Brunch. Drinks took quite a while. Waited over an hour for my husband to get his appetizer. Additional 30-40 minutes for entrees. Not sure what is going on but this is 2 times in a row it has been extremely slow to receive drinks and/or food. I feel bad not giving a great review having had so many great experiences prior, which have also been shared. This was just beyond slow, I felt I had to communicate.
Thank you.

As a first time customer at Prime I was not satisfied with the way I was served. The waitress did not go over the menu as they usually do in every restaurant I have been to. I felt rushed into placing my order as the waitress kept coming by asking if we were ready. The waitress spoke very fast and did not even acknowledge that we did not picked any sides with our meal. The place was very noisy, the tables so close to each other and there was no music playing, if there was it could not be heard with so much noise from everyone speaking. Too expensive for the service we got. I do not recommend this restaurant.

Horrible server...I literally put on my cost to leave before she acknowledged the check...

Service was great. Not the best steakhouse but it is local for my wife and I and the food is above average. The drinks are also very good and priced well for the area. We arrived at our reservation time and were seated right away.

Great food and atmosphere. Always good with dealing with allergies. The menu always has a few options I’d like to try.

Joe our server was personable and informative. Our first experience at Prime won't be our last.

Our waiter Bist was excellent! Very attentive and friendly he made our anniversary so special!

GREAT LUNCH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Went for Anniversary dinner with wine. Food and drink were great; recommended pairings worked well. And Anthony was fantastic. Thanks.

We received a gift card from our son, dinner was great, but definitely a restaurant for special occasions as it's quite expensive.

The restaurant is beautiful. We were a arty of four. Ordered sushi as an appetizer that was amazing and then shared an expensive porterhouse steak for 2. The steak was ordered medium rare but it was prepared medium well. My friend ordered a petite filet mignon with the same result. So the steak was disappointing. However, our waiter was great and he brought us an order of sweet potato fries and two desserts on the house so we left happy.

Location. Location. Location. Prime could serve PB outside wicker seats, no cloth, noisy and some guest found it cold enough that they didn’t remove their coats which spoils the atmosphere when fine dining. Steaks cooked perfectly; fig appetizer and Brussels sprouts were delicious. If dinner isn’t in the budget, it’s a captivating place to simply have a drink, seated on a couch by the inside fireplace, outside in Adirondack chairs by the fire pit and in warm months ALWAYS along the harbor. If your lookin for quiet intimacy, save Prime for a night when high energy is your preference.

Perfect date night with friends

Joseph was wonderful! He was so friendly and attentive. The food was great and portioned appropriately. The cocktails were delicious (maybe a little weak but tasty nonetheless) We will definitely dine here again, and request Joseph is possible.

Must have been an off night but everything took forever to come to the table. Even the waiter. If this was my first time I wouldn’t go back but I do like this restaurant and am hoping it will be better the next time.

Despite the negative reviews here and there I must say my 1st experience was indeed a wonderful one. Yes, the food is pricy but its totally worth it because it taste amazingly delicious...my wife and I celebrated our 2 year anniversary here and would like to say a special Thank You!!! to Paul and the Manager for making us feel welcome and appreciated. We are a black couple and weren't treated any different from others compared to other upscale restaurants we've been to. Thank you again and it's worth every dime. Looking forward to dinning here again.

I made a reservation for my mom and stepfather for Christmas... they absolutely loved everything about Prime!

Went for the Sunday brunch. One of the best Sunday brunches we've ever had. Sensational meal!

Take about 25 percent off the prices and the place would be great

The appetizer, caramelized figs, was wonderful and the main courses, the roasted chicken and the fish, were delicious. The service was excellent, as was the setting. The desserts at Prime are disappointing, though. They seem to be intended for children. A little more variety in the desert menu would be lovely

My visit to Prime reminds me that good eating and great service is the reason I keep coming back! Thank you again for an outstanding meal!

My girl friend and I are regular patrons at prime. We have come to expect slower service during the week. Our dinning experience was good as it always is

Service was subpar.

Great service, great food, great looking place also

It was our nephew birthday and we wanted to take him to a really nice restaurant that’s why we pick prime and it didn’t disappoint we had a lovely time. The food was delicious and the service was very good we had no complaints it was a nice time.

Lovely atmosphere... Wonderful food... Good Service

I've been to Prime a few times since the summer and it never disappoints.
Great food, lively, romantic, energetic and awesome service.