Skip to Main Content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New York / Tri-State Area
  4. Long Island / Hamptons
  5. Shelter Island

Pridwin Hotel

4.2
4.2
120 Reviews
$31 to $50
American

The Pridwin Hotel and Cottages is a classic all-wood American resort hotel that has been providing guests a unique experience on Shelter Island since 1927. The nearly 10-acre site on Crescent Beach was selected for its protected waters, gentle bay breezes, and for its breathtaking water views.

Not available on OpenTable

Unfortunately, this restaurant is not on the OpenTable reservation network.

If you like, we'll notify you by email if this restaurant joins.


Is this your restaurant?
Claim this listing

Additional information

  • Dining style

    Casual Dining

  • Cuisines

    American, Seafood

  • Hours of operation

    Daily 8:00am - 11:00pm

  • Phone number

    (631) 749-0476

  • Payment options

    AMEX, Discover, MasterCard, Visa

  • Dress code

    Casual Dress

  • Executive chef

    Swainson Brown

  • Neighborhood

    Shelter Island

  • Parking details

    Hotel Parking

  • Additional

    Banquet, Bar Dining, Bar/Lounge, Beer, Farm to Table, Full Bar, Non-Smoking, Patio/Outdoor Dining, Private Room, View, Wheelchair Access, Wine

Menu

Dinner served 5:30 pm to 9:00 pm Sunday through Thursday; 5:30 pm to 10:00 pm Friday and Saturday

Appetizers

  • Fava Bean Hummus$11.00

    crudité and grilled flatbread

    • House Smoked Ricotta$13.00

      green tomato marmalade, pea tendrils and grilled baguette

      • Grilled Shrimp$18.00

        tomatillo salsa, pickled red onion and micro cilantro

        • Crudo-Tuna$19.00

          soy-ginger aioli, avocado and corn chips

          • Smoked Salmon Rillettes$13.00

            red onion jam and grill bread

            Salads

            • Strawberry and Tomato Salad$15.00

              smoked blue fish, lemon crème and garden herbs

              • Panzanella Salad$13.00

                smoked onions, feta, cukes, tomatoes and pickled pepper

                • Market Salad$12.00

                  shaved vegetables, herb pistou and tomatoes

                  Entrées

                  • Roasted Duck$34.00

                    confit, braised cabbage, cauliflower crème, gastrique turnips

                    • Coriander -Thyme Crusted Tuna**$36.00

                      eggplant caviar tart and nicoise vinaigrette

                      • Tile Fish**$29.00

                        patty pan, English peas, lardon and baby zucchini

                        • Atlantic Salmon**$28.00

                          green asparagus, fingerling and champagne beurre blanc

                          • Lobster Roll$33.00

                            house made potato bun, herbs, pickles, and fries

                            • Spring Vegetable Friccasee$27.00

                              porcini mushrooms, truffle buratta, summer truffle

                              • Roast Chicken under a Brick$26.00

                                whipped potatoes and coriander-honey roasted carrots

                                • Filet Mignon**$47.00

                                  steak fries, arugula salad and salsa verde

                                  Sides

                                  $7

                                  • Fingerling Potatoes

                                    • Cauliflower

                                      • Honey Roasted Carrots

                                        • French Fries

                                          • Charred Broccoli

                                            What 120 people are saying

                                            Overall ratings and reviews

                                            4.2
                                            4.2 based on all time ratings
                                            • 4.1Food
                                            • 4Service
                                            • 4.6Ambience
                                            • 3.7Value

                                            NoiseQuiet

                                            Sort by

                                            Filters

                                            1. BP

                                              BarryP

                                              New York Area

                                              2 reviews

                                              3.0

                                              2 reviews

                                              Dined on September 1, 2019

                                              overall3food2service3ambience4

                                              The food was not really good. Too bad because it is a great.

                                            2. F

                                              Funfood

                                              Miami

                                              10 reviews

                                              vip
                                              5.0

                                              10 reviews

                                              Dined on August 30, 2019

                                              overall5food4service4ambience5

                                              wonderful place ! great location, friendly staff and very good food

                                            3. D

                                              Drdevi

                                              New York Area

                                              4 reviews

                                              3.0

                                              4 reviews

                                              Dined on August 29, 2019

                                              overall3food4service1ambience4

                                              It took an hour for our food to come out and we have young children. The waitress was not even that apologetic and said she doesn’t cook the food so she doesn’t know why it took so long. Not at all the service we deserved for such an expensive meal!

                                            4. a

                                              angsp

                                              New York Area

                                              2 reviews

                                              vip
                                              2.0

                                              2 reviews

                                              Dined on August 24, 2019

                                              overall2food1service2ambience3

                                              Food was terrible. Dessert was decent. Pretty setting and ambiance. I asked the hostess for a blanket and claimed she did not have one...the restaurant is in a hotel...

                                            5. LC

                                              LCDB

                                              New York Area

                                              10 reviews

                                              2.0

                                              10 reviews

                                              Dined on August 20, 2019

                                              overall2food2service2ambience4

                                              The jazz was amazing but the food was mediocre, service very slow and VERY over priced for what you’re getting. Come on. Beautiful view though and the live music excellent.

                                            6. EG

                                              EricaG

                                              New York Area

                                              3 reviews

                                              4.0

                                              3 reviews

                                              Dined on August 18, 2019

                                              overall4food5service5ambience5

                                              Outdoor seating is a beautiful atmosphere

                                            7. ET

                                              ETM10021

                                              New York Area

                                              20 reviews

                                              vip
                                              4.0

                                              20 reviews

                                              Dined on August 17, 2019

                                              overall4food4service5ambience5

                                              We had a lovely time at The Pridwin for lunch. The view is just beautiful but with a table for six, 3 people couldn't see it because the table was facing the building. Perhaps if the end of the table faced the building, we'd all see the water. No big deal though. Just a thought. Cocktails were special (St Germaine Spritz was so delicious). The food was very nice and the staff could not have been nicer. Great place to go for lunch! Thank you.

                                            8. OT

                                              OpenTable Diner

                                              Columbus

                                              8 reviews

                                              vip
                                              5.0

                                              8 reviews

                                              Dined on August 16, 2019

                                              overall5food5service5ambience5

                                              Thank you to everyone at Pridwin. Also, Happy Birthday J.P.

                                            9. JA

                                              JAMS3

                                              1 review

                                              3.0

                                              1 review

                                              Dined on August 15, 2019

                                              overall3food3service3ambience5

                                              I felt the food choices were limited and our waitress wasn’t very friendly nor was she able to explain what were in the dishes very well. The hotel looked a bit outdated.

                                            10. t

                                              terry

                                              New York Area

                                              15 reviews

                                              vip
                                              5.0

                                              15 reviews

                                              Dined on August 11, 2019

                                              overall5food5service5ambience5

                                              A very nostalgic hotel from some 90 years ago, with hints of the movie "Dirty Dancing". Current owners there about 50 years, to keep up the feeling. The hotel is right across the road, from the bay, and docks, and eating on the 2nd floor outdoor patio, gave you the most magnificent views. Sunset was at about 7:45m and the beautiful sky had color for almost the next hour. The menu, and food prepartation was excellent, with everything tasting so fresh. Vincent, our waiter, was terrific, in terms of knowledge, and execution. My grand daughter has a tree nut allergy, and he suggested nothing fried. When her plate came out with fries on it, he grabbed it, and returned it to the kitchen, and had the whole plate remade, without us having to say a word. We have rented homes in the Hamptons, for over 10 years, and this was out best eating experience to date.

                                            11. NY

                                              NYCFoodie

                                              New York Area

                                              23 reviews

                                              vip
                                              5.0

                                              23 reviews

                                              Dined on August 6, 2019

                                              overall5food5service5ambience5

                                              Lovely dinner at The Pridwin! Beautiful views and delicious food!

                                            12. HR

                                              HarrietR

                                              New York Area

                                              7 reviews

                                              5.0

                                              7 reviews

                                              Dined on August 4, 2019

                                              overall5food5service5ambience5

                                              The Pridwin restaurant is no secret. it is well loved and that is well deserved —great service , food and ambiance!

                                            13. DB

                                              DinaB

                                              New York Area

                                              31 reviews

                                              vip
                                              5.0

                                              31 reviews

                                              Dined on August 4, 2019

                                              overall5food5service5ambience5

                                              The pridwin is always the best spot in the island, always a good meal!

                                            14. OT

                                              OpenTable Diner

                                              New York Area

                                              1 review

                                              1.0

                                              1 review

                                              Dined on August 3, 2019

                                              overall1food1service3ambience4

                                              The four dishes we ordered were all unfortunately terrible. The seafood salad was soggy and apparently pre-made, perhaps having sat in a refrigerator for days. The hummus with crudités dismal, not fresh—its flatbread stale. The “feta salad” overdressed and with ingredients that tasted plastic. Finally one bite of the charred and lumpy gnocchi and we turned it away. I have never written a bad restaurant review, but our food experience here motivated me. Really too bad, because the view is breathtaking and the wait staff is courteous. But you can’t deliver good service with unserviceable food.

                                            15. K

                                              Ksax

                                              New York Area

                                              37 reviews

                                              vip
                                              4.0

                                              37 reviews

                                              Dined on August 2, 2019

                                              overall4food5service3ambience5

                                              Gotta try striped bass!

                                            16. L

                                              Liteacher

                                              New York Area

                                              22 reviews

                                              4.0

                                              22 reviews

                                              Dined on July 30, 2019

                                              overall4food4service5ambience5

                                              The food and service at the Pridwin is very good. The selling point is the view! Sitting on the upper deck with a view of the water is priceless!!! I found when we made reservations and requested outdoor seating, they gave you a table with the best view. While the bill was high, the view and service made up for it! I loved the chicken under a brick! It was flavorful and very moist! Skip the gnocchi.

                                            17. S

                                              Smartfoodinpalmbeach

                                              New York Area

                                              10 reviews

                                              vip
                                              5.0

                                              10 reviews

                                              Dined on July 28, 2019

                                              overall5food5service5ambience5

                                              Sophisticated chef elevates Pridvin restaurant to new high. Among Best food on the entire Shelter Island. Modern, complex flavors, well thought of. Attentive service, stunning views. Great team work.

                                            18. R

                                              Rebarocks

                                              San Francisco

                                              15 reviews

                                              4.0

                                              15 reviews

                                              Dined on July 25, 2019

                                              overall4food5service5ambience5

                                              Lovely water setting. Delicious dinner, good wine selections and excellent service.

                                            19. TF

                                              TurtleFan

                                              Washington DC

                                              17 reviews

                                              5.0

                                              17 reviews

                                              Dined on July 20, 2019

                                              overall5food5service5ambience5

                                              Dinner at the Pridwin Hotel is always one of the highlights of our summers on Shelter Island. The view is the best on the island and would be hard to top anywhere in the world. The food has always been very good but I would say that the meal we had may have been the best ever. The scallops over a chowder type sauce including baby clams was divine. The presentation was lovely and the service was excellent. The waitstaff is usually from Ireland or another European country and they couldn't be more service oriented. If you are lucky enough to get an outdoor table on a nice evening before sunset you will be treated to a very special evening.

                                            20. BK

                                              BhupinderK

                                              New York Area

                                              1 review

                                              4.0

                                              1 review

                                              Dined on July 18, 2019

                                              overall4food3service4ambience4

                                              My husband and I went there to celebrate our anniversary. Unfortunately it was raining so we couldn't experience the view but I can imagine it being beautiful! I had a lobster roll and my husband had the bass. The food was good and the service was great. Definitely recommend.

                                            21. RW

                                              RonW

                                              New York Area

                                              84 reviews

                                              vip
                                              5.0

                                              84 reviews

                                              Dined on July 15, 2019

                                              overall5food4service4ambience5

                                              Beautiful view! Overlooking the water we had a delightful dinner. The portions were generous. The burrata appetizer a was very good and the pork was excellent. Romantic setting.

                                            22. w

                                              weezer

                                              New York Area

                                              1 review

                                              2.0

                                              1 review

                                              Dined on July 15, 2019

                                              overall2food2service1ambience5

                                              Service needs improvement The place has so much potential, it’s sad that it is being squanded

                                            23. s

                                              susane

                                              New York Area

                                              2 reviews

                                              5.0

                                              2 reviews

                                              Dined on July 13, 2019

                                              overall5food4service5ambience5

                                              Beautiful setting over looking the water. The waitresses were lovely and the food excellent. Great value not something one can often say about the Hamptons area. Especially so given the setting. Highly recommend

                                            24. W

                                              Willajane

                                              New York Area

                                              208 reviews

                                              vip
                                              4.0

                                              208 reviews

                                              Dined on July 7, 2019

                                              overall4food4service4ambience4

                                              Lovely setting overlooking Crescent Beach in Shelter Island. Feels like a cottage in Maine or the Adirondack s. Service very good but kitchen a little slow. Don’t come if you don’t want to sit and relax! The food, when it comes, is excellent. Nothing unusual- but fresh and well cooked. Cocktails are imaginative and delicious.

                                            25. DB

                                              DinaB

                                              New York Area

                                              31 reviews

                                              vip
                                              5.0

                                              31 reviews

                                              Dined on July 6, 2019

                                              overall5food5service5ambience5

                                              excellent service, excellent food, always a pleasure to go there

                                            26. DP

                                              DrPaul

                                              New York Area

                                              8 reviews

                                              4.0

                                              8 reviews

                                              Dined on July 5, 2019

                                              overall4food4service5ambience5

                                              Lovely setting. Gracious staff. It made for a lovely summer event trip from sag harbor and back.

                                            27. W

                                              Wmeer

                                              New York Area

                                              12 reviews

                                              5.0

                                              12 reviews

                                              Dined on July 5, 2019

                                              overall5food5service5ambience5

                                              Best views on the island for dinner. Never disappoints!

                                            28. JD

                                              JennyD

                                              New York Area

                                              1 review

                                              2.0

                                              1 review

                                              Dined on July 4, 2019

                                              overall2food3service2ambience5

                                              Had reservations for 4 ,got there on time . Given a great table overlooking the bay. They were not busy yet and several of the servers and bus boy walked by the table at least 10 times not filling our water or giving us menus. I tried to flag someone down but still Waited 20 min until the waitress came over for our drink order . She was extremely apologetic. Ordered Our drinks took other 10 minutes and 2 of them were delivered to the wrong table so they had to go back . They were brought out immediately so obviously not remade. We saw them on the table next to us and the couple didn’t touch them otherwise I would have been upset. The food was good. We had the smoked ricotta and for an appetizer . Said we would be sharing it but only came with 3 baguette pieces.? mozzarella with nectarine salad was good . For dinner we had the gnocchi with mushrooms , brick chicken and lobster roll . Looked up the menu before we went and wanted to try a few items that were no longer on the menu. It changed at the restaurant but not on the website 🙁 Their Servers needs training , The food is good but over priced. Go for the view if you have the money and time. Don’t go thirsty or hungry like we did.

                                            29. t

                                              tastymate

                                              New York Area

                                              42 reviews

                                              vip
                                              5.0

                                              42 reviews

                                              Dined on July 2, 2019

                                              overall5food5service4ambience5

                                              Great food in an amazing setting and fabulous sunset views.

                                            30. OT

                                              OpenTable Diner

                                              New York Area

                                              1 review

                                              2.0

                                              1 review

                                              Dined on July 2, 2019

                                              overall2food1service2ambience4

                                              Go for the view at sunset. Skip the food.

                                            31. OT

                                              OpenTable Diner

                                              Philadelphia

                                              3 reviews

                                              4.0

                                              3 reviews

                                              Dined on July 2, 2019

                                              overall4food4service4ambience5

                                              Vacation spot is great and relaxing. Not much needed to stay and enjoy!

                                            32. HL

                                              HankL

                                              Washington DC

                                              12 reviews

                                              vip
                                              5.0

                                              12 reviews

                                              Dined on June 30, 2019

                                              overall5food5service4ambience4

                                              Food ridiculously good. Service was fine except that it took them an hour to seat us after our reserved time.

                                            33. LD

                                              LauraD

                                              New York Area

                                              8 reviews

                                              5.0

                                              8 reviews

                                              Dined on June 29, 2019

                                              overall5food5service5ambience5

                                              Excellent food and service, beautiful setting on the porch. A little pricey, but you are paying for the setting I guess. The only suggestion would be to provide higher quality rolls and butter! They were not very good.

                                            34. AA

                                              AnnieA

                                              New York Area

                                              4 reviews

                                              2.0

                                              4 reviews

                                              Dined on June 27, 2019

                                              overall2food2service2ambience4

                                              The view is beautiful. The food is god awful. Besides the fava bean hummus, which we enjoyed, everything was dated, subpar, over cooked, etc. The service was really poor. We waited an exorbitant amount of time for drink refills, the check, etc...yet the entrees were right on top of the appetizers. The lovely view is not enough to make me eat here again.

                                            35. GM

                                              GetMeOnTop

                                              New York Area

                                              124 reviews

                                              vip
                                              4.0

                                              124 reviews

                                              Dined on June 18, 2019

                                              overall4food4service4ambience5

                                              The chicken under a brick is very very good. The smoke for Carter was good but the topping was just way too sweet Fabulous sunset as always.

                                            36. OT

                                              OpenTable Diner

                                              New England

                                              1 review

                                              4.0

                                              1 review

                                              Dined on June 17, 2019

                                              overall4food4service2ambience5

                                              Slow and inexperienced service - things like refilling water glass, noticing that drinks glasses were empty and failing to offer another beverage, assuming both diners were finished when one diner’s plate was empty...but the food itself was very good and the sunset views were extraordinary!

                                            37. LH

                                              LisaH

                                              New York Area

                                              1 review

                                              5.0

                                              1 review

                                              Dined on June 16, 2019

                                              overall5food5service5ambience5

                                              The Pridwin is our favorite place and we anxiously await their season every year! Food is always excellent, the staff is efficient and very friendly, and you can’t beat the view!

                                            38. OT

                                              OpenTable Diner

                                              New York Area

                                              2 reviews

                                              5.0

                                              2 reviews

                                              Dined on May 26, 2019

                                              overall5food5service5ambience5

                                              Fabulous view, great service and yummy food.

                                            39. MB

                                              MagdaleneB

                                              1 review

                                              5.0

                                              1 review

                                              Dined on May 25, 2019

                                              overall5food5service5ambience5

                                              Love the Pridwin for its fanstasic view and great food.

                                            40. JL

                                              JasonL

                                              New York Area

                                              9 reviews

                                              vip
                                              3.0

                                              9 reviews

                                              Dined on September 2, 2018

                                              overall3food3service1ambience5

                                              The ambiance, views, and sunset are truly gorgeous. The service was truly terrible. The food was just ok.

                                            FAQs

                                            Pridwin Hotel is rated 4.2 stars by 120 OpenTable diners.

                                            Not available on OpenTable

                                            Unfortunately, this restaurant is not on the OpenTable reservation network.

                                            If you like, we'll notify you by email if this restaurant joins.


                                            Is this your restaurant?
                                            Claim this listing

                                            Additional information

                                            • Neighborhood

                                              Shelter Island

                                            • Hours of operation

                                              Daily 8:00am - 11:00pm

                                            • Cuisines

                                              American, Seafood

                                            • Dining style

                                              Casual Dining

                                            • Dress code

                                              Casual Dress

                                            • Parking details

                                              Hotel Parking

                                            • Payment options

                                              AMEX, Discover, MasterCard, Visa

                                            • Executive chef

                                              Swainson Brown

                                            • Additional

                                              Banquet, Bar Dining, Bar/Lounge, Beer, Farm to Table, Full Bar, Non-Smoking, Patio/Outdoor Dining, Private Room, View, Wheelchair Access, Wine

                                            Copyright © 2022 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 700, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved.
                                            OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
                                            Booking LogoPriceline LogoKAYAK LogoAgoda LogoRentalcars LogoOpenTable Logo