- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Loved the queso dip and veggie enchiladas. Friends had margs and said they were very good as well. Would def go back.
Far exceeded my expectations! If you are looking for ambiance, good service, great food, then it’s a must. There times you go to a restaurant and maybe the apps were good; or just the meal. But when you have apps, a meal and dessert and all are delicious..what more can be said but to go again and again!
This was our first time here after a great recommendation. We were pleasantly greeted upon our arrival and we’re seated right on time. Spoke to the gentleman who I originally thought was a employee but ended up the owner. Told him it was our first time here and after being seated he came over to speak to us about our experience. Gave us a few suggestions that turned out great. Well worth the money and will be returning with my family in the future. Two thumbs up for this restaurant. 👍👍
Amazing, everything was delicious!
We are so happy to hear it! Thanks for coming by!
Great experience. Food was delicious with a great presentation. Drinks were outstanding, although a bit pricey. Highly recommend the Prickly Pear frozen margarita! Our waitress was lovely. We will definitely be back.
We are so glad to hear that you had a great experience with us! Can't wait for your next visit!
This was the second time here ,Excellent service and food was amazing !!
We're so glad to hear it! Thank you so much for the review!
Upon arrival Hostess stared at her Phone and seemed distracted And confused about our reservation. The Restaurant was fairly empty and eventually we was seated next to the Only other 2 people.The waiter Joe was very good, The food was upscaled chili's at best. Not a good value for the price seemed pretentious. The icing on the cake was $3 for a tablespoon of able spoon of sour cream which would be free in any other Southwestern establishment in the Bay Shore area. Will not be back and do not recommend. The hostess should be Trained on how to greet people.
The food is bland/ charred and overpriced. Waitstaff is nice but I was disappointed with my meal.
It’s our goal to make sure that every customer has a pleasant experience, which is why our servers are so accommodating. It may not be fair to say that our food is bland after only trying a quesadilla & yuca frites. As many other reviews have shown, our food is anything but bland. As for your statement the food being unauthentic, our menu uses ingredients and is inspired by traditional dishes that are served throughout Mexico. We thank you for coming by & giving us a try and providing feedback.
Been here several times and never been disappointed . I tried something new the steak taco . Wow the best ever. What a flavor and so tender . Will keep that as a favorite ,The shrimp &fish taco were delicious . We can’t wait to go back and the owner is wonderful makes you feel like family . So happy this place finally opened up & it’s in a great part of bayshore
We are thrilled to hear about your past experience with us! We are excited for your next visit!
Delicious food and drinks. We had a great time. def would recommend!
Thank you so much for the kind words! Hope to see you again soon!
Prices were high- a small bowl of delicious Guacamole for $15!
Also- no staff or patrons wore masks or asked for vaccine status as is required in NYC. That was offset by the open doors and well spaced tables
Good food, good service, but too noisy for us ! Tables rather close considering Covid is still active, it’s not a large room. We’d never seen guacamole listed as “market price”, it’s not lobster! Way overpriced at $16.
May try it on a weeknight.
Thank you so much for providing us feedback about your experience here! We take the cleanliness of the restaurant very seriously, and our cleaning procedures are 100% effective! The reason that our guacamole is listed at market price is due to the constant change in the cost of supplies, which unfortunately is out of our control. We hope that you understand! We are happy to hear that you enjoyed the food and service, so we hope we see you back here for a better experience!
I took my friend Lisa out for her birthday this evening.
It was both our first time going to this particular new Mexican restaurant in Bayshore, and we were very pleased. The ambience, the Decour the courteous welcome from the hostess to the from the experience with our waitress, Mallory was very nice.
The quality of everything we ordered was very fresh and very well executed with very nice flavor.
We would definitely go back again and I highly encourage anyone who enjoys Mexican cuisine to give it a try.
I met and the owner I was very impressed. He’s a young man who owns a couple other restaurants which I’ve never been to as of yet, but he was proactive and engaging with his guests on this beautiful Friday evening.
We are so thrilled to hear this! We are excited to have you back here again!
First time eating at Pecado and was not disappointed. Food, cocktails, and service were great! A little pricey but worth it for a fun date night!
Thank you so much for visiting us! We hope to see you here again!
We loved it! Food was fresh and delicious.
The food is delicious and desert perfect especially the coconut tres leche.
So happy to hear it!! We hope to see you again Jessica!
Fantastic Cocktails and great food! Our server Eduardo was so great. Such a nice personable guy!
We are thrilled to hear about your experience here at Pecado! We hope to see you here again soon!
Solid choice for late night tasty, healthy, eating option. No wait for reserved table. Two of us shared all...comp Tortilla Chips (bit spicy but not too) and Red Salsa (mild), Guacamole (good, but advertised as "table side" and just brought out of kitchen...didn't want the "show" but not sure worth $16, ordered "medium" but tasted mild...will try spicy next time), Tortilla Salad with added Salmon (yum), Enchiladas Vegetarianas (yum...Black Beans and Rice done right) and Coconut Tres Leches (yum...don't like Coconut and liked it). Was alcohol-free meal - next time will check out Cocktails/drink options. Staff was friendly. Food came out in timely manner. Bottom line...will go again. Want to check out other dishes/drinks.
Thank you so much for visiting us at Pecado! We would like to apologize about the Table-side guacamole! Unfortunately, due to COVID there are manufacturing delays that are preventing us from preparing the guacamole table-side. However, can assure you that each order of guacamole is made fresh to order! We hope to have the Table-Side Guacamole up & running very soon! We hope you understand! We are glad to hear that you still had a wonderful time here, and we look forward to your next visit!
This place is amazing 😉,the owner makes you feel like family ,super nice guy .drinks are amazing . The food is very delicious 😋.service was great , the steak my husband and family loved they didn’t think they would of finished it was huge but they kept eating and eating it couldn’t stop it was the best steak they had .will return soon can’t wait 😊
That is what we love to hear! Thank you so much for visiting us- cannot wait to see you again!
We enjoyed the interesting variety of items on the menu along with original favorites. The food was delicious and portions were just enough. Save room for dessert. The coconut tres Leche cake was amazing. Drinks also very good
Thank you so much for the great review and for coming by!
Another wonderful meal at Pecado. Service was very attentive and makes you feel like you are a guest at their home. Owner stops by every table to make sure everything thing. Love the tequila selection. Flan was great.
Thanks for coming back to hang out with us Steven! It was great seeing you again and thank you for the kind words!
Really delicious food the tres leches was my favorite.
PECADO IS A WELCOME NEW HOME FOR SOME LIVELY DRINKS AND TASTY TAKES ON MEXICAN CUISINE. THE SERVER WAS FRIENDLY AND EFFICIENT, THE MANAGER WAS AVAILABLE AND INVOLVED AND THE OVERALL VIBE IS RELAXED AND FUN. THE BEERS WERE COLD AND THE DRINKS WERE DELICIOUS. THE TWO DISHES WE TRIED WERE HOT AND FLAVORFUL AND THE TRES LECHES CAKE IS WORTH EVERY SWEET CALORIE. TAKE TIME TO VISIT AND ENJOY YOURSELF.
We love to hear this! Thanks so much for the great review- cannot wait to have you back here again!
Excellent menu, everything was delicious. By far the freshest, and tastiest fish tacos I’ve ever had. Ambience was beautiful, and service was very efficient. Will definitely be going here again soon
We could not be happier to hear this Amanda! We appreciate you coming by and cannot wait to see you here again!
Great new addition to Bay Shore! Place is beautiful, food was delicious and service was great! Definitely will go back!
My wife and wanted to try a New restaurant and found this one while walking through Bayshore. I’ve been a professional chef for over 20 years and am usually very critical of dining out. I was very impressed by the food, I had Cochinita Pabil, and my wife had the enchiladas, both were very flavorful, and the portions were just right, we also had guacamole which was also excellent. We will definitely be going back for more in the near future!!!!
Thank you so much for the review! We appreciate you coming by!
Thank you for coming in! Hope to see you again soon!
Loved the avocado fries, skirt steak, enchiladas and creative cocktails! Chic atmosphere and vibe ❤️
That's what we love to hear! Glad you had a great time with us, come back again soon!
The food and drinks were fantastic. The ambience and decor were top notch. Definitely the nicest restaurant in the area. Try the guac. If you can handle it, get the spicy!
Thank you so much!! We appreciate you stopping by!
Food was good and tequila was better !!! Service was attentive and owner took the time to talk with us several times. Tequila selection was outstanding. We will be back.
Steven, thank you so much for the kind words! We look forward to having you back here with us!
Quality of food exceptional. Our waitress, Danielle, was delightful.
We appreciate you coming by! Come back again soon!
Great food and service! Atmosphere was a little loud, but we enjoyed ourselves!
Thank you so much for stopping by Suzie! We hope to see you again in the future!
i had the fish tacos which were tasty with the pickled onions. My only recommendation is to tell chef not to overdo the salt sprinkled over it . It takes away from the fresh flavors.Similarly the chips i found to be over-salted. It is a bit pricey $19 for 3 tacos esp. if taco was so tiny that everything was falling out. My rec is to use two tacos to hold it more firmly which a lot of places do if u use the tiny tacos in stead of normal size ones.
Thank you so much for providing us feedback on your experience! We hope that you come back soon for an even better experience with us!
Amazing restaurant, highly recommend! Love the yucca fries.
Thank you so much for coming by Melissa! We appreciate the review!
If you have not tried this new restaurant you must! The food, ambience, and service are all AMAZING. This has to be the best Mexican cuisine in all of NY!
Beautiful place, fantastic, personable service and absolutely delicious food! Will definitely be back!
That's what we like to hear! So glad that enjoyed your experience here! Hope to see you again soon!
Such great food and atmosphere! You can tell the chef puts love into her food.
We appreciate the kind words! Thank you so much for coming by!
Food and service was outstanding! Staff was friendly and professional. Every bite was delicious. We had table side guac, mahi-mahi, strip steak and dessert and coffee.
Can not wait to go back with friends.
Great new restaurant! Drinks were outstanding but pricey to add $2 if you want a flavored margarita. Decor was simple & clean. Chips & salsa brought to table upon arrival & excellent. Wait staff unbelievably friendly & helpful. Mahi Mahi dinner was delicious, chicken enchiladas were standard. Tres Leche cake pretty good but not the best I’ve had. Prices on dinners a bit high. Expect to pay about $150 with 3 drinks, 2 dinners & 1 dessert w/tip. I hope they make it as I didn’t see all the tables full on a Friday night.
Food was delicious and the service was outstanding. Will definitely be coming back!
Thank you so much for coming by! We cannot wait to have you back here again!
Pecado Mexican offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (631) 992-7717.
Pecado Mexican is rated 4.7 stars by 45 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.