- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Coconut Tres Leches
White cake soaked in three milks, toasted meringue, toasted coconut flakes
Excellent service and delicious food!
We are thrilled to hear this! Come back again soon!
Everything was great! From the music, to the wall decorations and everything in between, it was great. Food and the cocktails are beautifully prepared and served in generous portions. The staff attention was immediate and very accommodating. We will def return.
Thank you for visiting us! We are thrilled to hear about your experience! We hope to see you again soon!
As a mexican/American and having lived in Mexico for a few years, this is truly delicious, authentic food! The owner is also a very genuinely nice guy. The wait staff is so sweet and attentive. What a place!
We love to hear it! Thank you so much for coming by, we hope to have you back here again very soon!
Service was very good. Drinks were tasty and food was enjoyable. I would return
We appreciate the review! We hope to have you back here again soon!
Food is super fresh and delicious. Guacamole, prickly pear Mojito and warm stuffed Churro will blow your mind! Would highly recommend.
Thrilled to hear it! Come back again soon!
Our food came out 5 seconds after we ordered it, then was told my manager to leave because other people had to be seated. The server was nice and attentive though. I would not return. Felt very rushed.
Second time dining here! And the food never disappoints! Can’t wait to go back and try more things on there menu. Drinks are also fabulous
Always a pleasure having you here! Thanks so much for your continued support! We cannot wait for your next visit!
Great meal. Wonderful service by Eduardo and really good drinks. Will definitely come back!
We could not be happier to hear this! We hope to have you back here again soon!
Excellent food and service. Would recommend and we will return to try brunch.
Thank you so much for coming by! Cannot wait for your next visit!
Our waitress was really sweet and helpful with the suggestions ☺️
Margaritas were not good
Celebrated a friend’s birthday. I was seated immediately. The server Eduardo was very knowledgeable and provided excellent service . The ambience was very chic with “day of the dead” themed decor. I had the grilled salmon and it was very good. I’ve also had the skirt steak and yucca fries in the past which are my favorites on the menu. The clarified margarita and the sage burning margaritas are the best! We will return to Pecado over and over again.
Food and service great
Loved this place! From the ambiance to the food to the service! Very satisfied and will definitely be back!
Thank you so much! We're glad you had a great time with us and we cannot wait to see you again!
Food was fantastic and the drinks were sooo good. We will definitely be back.
Great addition to the Bay Shore restaurants. Wide variety of Mexican food and drinks.
First time there! Went with a group of 6 to celebrate a friend’s birthday - it was an awesome experience and would absolutely go again. No pictures of the food or drinks since we were too busy stuffing our faces 😅 but everyone loved their food (wings, elote, chicken fajitas, steak fajitas, chicken tacos, enchiladas we were stuffed by the end of the night. Drinks were delicious! Ended a great night by sharing the most delicious tres leches and churros. 10/10 would recommend, 100/10 going back!
We are so happy you enjoyed your time here with us! Can't wait to have you back here with us!
We are so happy this gem of a restaurant came into bayshore . Been here plenty of times and the food is always delicious and drinks as well . The staff is very friendly and the owner makes you feel like family . We will be back soon can’t wait 😊
Ummm 🤔 what can I say!
This was our first time here. We were very happy with the whole experience. Our waiter Joe was excellent and always right there when we needed something. The food was good, all 4 of us were pleased with our dishes: shrimp burrito, cochinita pibil, pescado adobado and pollo en mole. Can’t wait to go back to try their other dishes. The prices are reasonable and on par with other restaurants in the area. A welcome addition to the Bay Shore restaurant scene.
Thank you so much for dining with us! We cannot wait to have you here with us again!
Amazing! The best Mexican food I’ve had in awhile. Great atmosphere. Frozen margaritas were fantastic. Night recommend going!
Thank you so much for the kind words! We hope to have you back again soon!
The food was delicious. Atmosphere and place were great. The staff friendly and happy to serve you. I will definitely be back again.
Thank you so much for visiting us! Can't wait to see you again!
Food was great, drinks were well done and interesting. Great service, as well
Thank you so much for the review! Hope to see you at Pecado again soon!
Nice place, great atmosphere and service. Food was overly salty and as a result really couldn't enjoy the quality
Thank you for taking the time to provide us with feedback on your visit, it means a lot to us. We are surprised to hear about the food being over salty, as most of our customers and reviews have stated that they are nothing but pleased with the food. We just wish that you had notified us while you were here that you had mentioned you were unhappy with the food you received, that way we could have helped you right then and there. We do hope that you give us a second chance, if not we understand.
Food was very good. Service was terrible. Main courses were delivered to the table while our appetizer plates sat empty for at least 10 minutes in front of us. The runner that brought the food over waited for us to clean up our plates so he could put the food down, if I wanted to clean up after myself I would’ve stayed home. Waiter brought the wrong drink to my husband, waiter’s mistake, we waited more than 20 minutes for a replacement drink. When he brought it over he apologized that the bar was backed up although the table next to us received their drinks that were ordered after ours. I could go on and on about the poor service, but I won’t, I understand everyone is a little short handed due to Covid but the manager should have checked on all the tables not just the one with the pretty girls.
We take pride in providing top-notch service, so this is upsetting to hear. We wish you would've notified the manager while you were here & we would have rectified things. We were down a server that night & had a large party, which our manager helped with. Larger parties tend to need more attention, making it hard for the manager to go around to everyone. We would never pick the tables we check on based on gender or anything else. We value all our customers & hope you give us another chance.
Always a good time at Pecado! One of our favorite Mexican restaurants and it’s such a great addition to Bay Shore!
We are so thrilled to hear this! Thank you so much for coming by!
Food and service was amazing!!! The menu had so many good looking items couldn’t decide what to eat.
It's so amazing to hear about your experience with us! We appreciate you dining with us and we hope to see you again soon!
This was the third time we have dined here and every time the food has been delicious! I would definitely recommend this to anyone looking for a great night out!
Thank you so much! We appreciate you for coming by!
The meals were outstanding! I would definitely recommend this establishment and will be returning.
We are so happy to hear it! We are so excited for your next visit!
Good drinks, apps and dinner. Can’t wait to come back.
Thank you so much for the 5-star review! We can't wait to have you back here again with us!
Thanks so much for the review! We appreciate you coming by!
Loved the queso dip and veggie enchiladas. Friends had margs and said they were very good as well. Would def go back.
So glad to hear it! Thanks for coming by- hope to see you again soon!
Far exceeded my expectations! If you are looking for ambiance, good service, great food, then it’s a must. There times you go to a restaurant and maybe the apps were good; or just the meal. But when you have apps, a meal and dessert and all are delicious..what more can be said but to go again and again!
We are so happy to hear about your experience with us! We hope to see you walk through our doors again soon!
This was our first time here after a great recommendation. We were pleasantly greeted upon our arrival and we’re seated right on time. Spoke to the gentleman who I originally thought was a employee but ended up the owner. Told him it was our first time here and after being seated he came over to speak to us about our experience. Gave us a few suggestions that turned out great. Well worth the money and will be returning with my family in the future. Two thumbs up for this restaurant. 👍👍
Thank you so much for the review! We appreciate you coming by and cannot wait for your next visit!
Amazing, everything was delicious!
We are so happy to hear it! Thanks for coming by!
Would definitely recommend. Service was terrific and food was fresh and delicious
We are so happy to hear it! Thank you so much for visiting us at Pecado!
Great experience. Food was delicious with a great presentation. Drinks were outstanding, although a bit pricey. Highly recommend the Prickly Pear frozen margarita! Our waitress was lovely. We will definitely be back.
We are so glad to hear that you had a great experience with us! Can't wait for your next visit!
This was the second time here ,Excellent service and food was amazing !!
We're so glad to hear it! Thank you so much for the review!
Upon arrival Hostess stared at her Phone and seemed distracted And confused about our reservation. The Restaurant was fairly empty and eventually we was seated next to the Only other 2 people.The waiter Joe was very good, The food was upscaled chili's at best. Not a good value for the price seemed pretentious. The icing on the cake was $3 for a tablespoon of able spoon of sour cream which would be free in any other Southwestern establishment in the Bay Shore area. Will not be back and do not recommend. The hostess should be Trained on how to greet people.
The food is bland/ charred and overpriced. Waitstaff is nice but I was disappointed with my meal.
It’s our goal to make sure that every customer has a pleasant experience, which is why our servers are so accommodating. It may not be fair to say that our food is bland after only trying a quesadilla & yuca frites. As many other reviews have shown, our food is anything but bland. As for your statement the food being unauthentic, our menu uses ingredients and is inspired by traditional dishes that are served throughout Mexico. We thank you for coming by & giving us a try and providing feedback.
Pecado Mexican offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (631) 992-7717.
Pecado Mexican is rated 4.7 stars by 77 OpenTable diners.
Pecado Mexican does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://pecadomexican.cardfoundry.com/giftcards.php.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.