Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. Key West / Florida Keys
  4. Florida Keys - Monroe County
  5. Islamorada

Oltremare - Amara Cay Resort

4.1
4.1
49 Reviews
$31 to $50
Italian
Oltremare Ristorante is setting the standard for Italian cuisine in the Florida Keys. The menu features house made pastas, locally-inspired main plates, and delectable starters, sides and sweets. With upscale, but laid back service that perfectly complements the sublime menu offerings, Oltremare offers a dining experience unlike any other. Explore our highly curated wine list and find a new favorite, or start or finish your meal with a craft cocktail prepared by our expert bartenders, or hand rolled cigars from Key West. Each night is special at Oltremare and our team can't wait to amaze you. Reservations strongly suggested.

Not available on OpenTable

Unfortunately, this restaurant is not on the OpenTable reservation network.

If you like, we'll notify you by email if this restaurant joins.


Is this your restaurant?
Claim this listing

There’s more to explore

Discover countless more restaurants like this one with our app.

Scan the QR code to discover countless more restaurants like this one with our app.

Open app

Additional information

  • Dining style
    Casual Elegant
  • Price
    $31 to $50
  • Cuisines
    Italian, Contemporary Italian, Seafood
  • Hours of operation
    Breakfast Daily: 6:30am - 10:30 am; Dinner Nightly: 5:30pm - 10:00pm; Sunday Brunch: 11:30a-3:00p.
  • Phone number
    (305) 664-0073
  • Payment options
    AMEX, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
  • Dress code
    Smart Casual
  • Executive chef
    Rafael Rodriguez
  • Catering
    For information about private dining, catering and banquets, or special events, please contact the Amara Cay Resort Sales Department at 305-664-0073 or sales@amaracayresort.com.<br />
  • Private party facilities
    Exceptional private dining for groups of ten, sixteen, and thirty two at our onsite indoor restaurant, Oltremare Ristorante, featuring a coastal Italian cuisine unlike any other in the Florida Keys.
  • Private party contact
    Anna Walston: (305) 664-2321
  • Neighborhood
    Islamorada
  • Cross street
    Overseas Highway
  • Parking details
    Hotel Parking
  • Additional
    Banquet, Bar Dining, Bar/Lounge, Beer, Cigar Room, Full Bar, Gluten-free Options, Non-Smoking, Outdoor Smoking Area, Private Room, View, Weekend Brunch, Wine

What 49 people are saying

Overall ratings and reviews

4.1
4.1 based on all time ratings
  • 4.1Food
  • 4.3Service
  • 3.9Ambience
  • 3.7Value

NoiseModerate

49 Reviews
  1. munchingmag

    Richmond

    10 reviews

    4.0

    10 reviews

    Dined on January 1, 2017

    1. Overall 4
    2. Food 5
    3. Service 1
    4. Ambience 3
    I had the best food at the restaurant than I had in a whole week in Islamorado BUT our waiter was rude (tall blonde man with a pony tail) and they sat us in an area that was the lobby of the hotel not a table in the restaurant section. I would go back for the food if I could be sure not to get the same waiter and that I had a reservation in the dining area. Fab food. Amazing meatball appetiser and terrific pasta dishes.

    Is this helpful?

  2. OpenTable Diner

    New York City

    3 reviews

    vip
    1.0

    3 reviews

    Dined on January 1, 2017

    1. Overall 1
    2. Food 1
    3. Service 2
    4. Ambience 2
    The food was a complete and total disappointment. I do not recommend this restaurant at all.

    Is this helpful?

  3. Lovemyfood

    Washington DC

    80 reviews

    5.0

    80 reviews

    Dined on January 1, 2017

    1. Overall 5
    2. Food 5
    3. Service 5
    4. Ambience 5
    Wow what a fabulous restaurant to find on The Keys (Islamorada). The setting, decor, ambience, service and food was great. For New Year's Eve they offered both a la carte and three choices of 'set menu'. I chose the Extravaganza which for $58 including a glass of Prosecco, was fantastic value. If you're looking for a smart/casual restaurant where you can dress up and not feel out of place then this is a perfect find. Loved it.

    Is this helpful?

  4. OpenTable Diner

    Denver

    5 reviews

    2.0

    5 reviews

    Dined on December 31, 2016

    1. Overall 2
    2. Food 1
    3. Service 4
    4. Ambience 4
    The menu was misleading. Ordered the pasta with Parmesan tomato broth and when our dish came out there was no tomato. When asking the server they said "there was tomato when it cooks it turns white." Would never go back again

    Is this helpful?

  5. OpenTable Diner

    New York City

    15 reviews

    vip
    2.0

    15 reviews

    Dined on December 28, 2016

    1. Overall 2
    2. Food 3
    3. Service 2
    4. Ambience 2
    You're basically eating in a glorified lobby. Service was slow and inattentive. No music. They forgot the kids' food and it wasn't served until the adults were served. Food was pretty unremarkable and overpriced. We never mind paying for good food (we are from NYC). But we had a better meal for a third of the price at a local fish shack last night. We ventured up from Marathon because of great reviews but it was not at all worth it. We will not be returning and do not recommend eating here.

    Is this helpful?

  6. UlIBUS

    Berlin

    3 reviews

    1.0

    3 reviews

    Dined on December 26, 2016

    1. Overall 1
    2. Food 2
    3. Service 1
    4. Ambience 1
    Totaler Reinfall. Sollte ein festliches, weihnachtliches Abendessen mit meinem Mann werden. Doch die Atmosphäre im "Restaurant" war unzumutbar. Ein Kinderspielplatz, ungewöhnlich laut, schreckliche Beleuchtung etc. etc.! Im Prinzip ist es der Essbereich der Resortgäste. Familien mit vielen kleinen Kindern. Aber auch der Öffentlichkeit zugänglich....ich bin durch die Webseite hereingefallen. Doch ich denke, man kann diesen Ort nicht ein Restaurant nennen. Service VÖLLIG Überfordert. Auch nicht wirklich freundlich und sehr langsam und vergesslich. Der Caprese Salad war sehr gut. Der Hauptgang nicht erwähnenswert. Einige Vorspeisen schon um 19:00 Uhr nicht mehr verfügbar. Speisekarte dürftig. Ersparen Sie sich diese Erfahrung. Wirklich!

    Is this helpful?

  7. YesItsBruce

    Greater Boston

    50 reviews

    4.0

    50 reviews

    Dined on December 12, 2016

    1. Overall 4
    2. Food 5
    3. Service 3
    4. Ambience 3
    The food was spectacular. The restaurant is basically located in the lobby of the Amara Cay Hotel, so it is not unlikely that people walking to and from the pool (which is a beautiful pool!) will walk by your table. The service was lacking, which I think is a lack of management at the restaurant. For example, the woman who seated us failed to leave the wine and cocktail menus, the server never took away the preset wine glasses, the entrees arrived just a few minutes after our salads, bread was delivered 10 minutes after the entrees arrived, and the server was slow in clearing the table. All of this with only three tables occupied. The food was very good, I'm sure in time the service will catch up to make this a great dining experience.

    Is this helpful?

  8. RobM

    Baltimore

    48 reviews

    vip
    2.0

    48 reviews

    Dined on November 28, 2016

    1. Overall 2
    2. Food 4
    3. Service 4
    4. Ambience 1
    Tasty meal and good service but the place was dead. We were one of only 2 tables. Made it kind of boring. Maybe the word will get out.

    Is this helpful?

  9. Patrick

    Key West

    1 review

    4.0

    1 review

    Dined on November 19, 2016

    1. Overall 4
    2. Food 4
    3. Service 4
    4. Ambience 4
    Was somewhat disappointed. Prices were a bit much for amount and quality of food. When booking, was made to feel like this was a difficult place to get a reservation and few tables remained. We were only 2 in there and no one came in during our meal. 100 dollars no beverages, alcohol, appetizers or desserts. No soup or salad included. No veggie with one meal.

    Is this helpful?

  10. SpencerE

    Miami

    26 reviews

    vip
    5.0

    26 reviews

    Dined on September 23, 2016

    1. Overall 5
    2. Food 5
    3. Service 4
    4. Ambience 5
    Great fresh seafood in Islamorado in an upscale atmosphere.

    Is this helpful?

FAQs

Oltremare - Amara Cay Resort is rated 4.1 stars by 49 OpenTable diners.

Not available on OpenTable

Unfortunately, this restaurant is not on the OpenTable reservation network.

If you like, we'll notify you by email if this restaurant joins.


Is this your restaurant?
Claim this listing
Google Map for Oltremare - Amara Cay Resort

80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036

Additional information

  • Cross street
    Overseas Highway
  • Neighborhood
    Islamorada
  • Hours of operation
    Breakfast Daily: 6:30am - 10:30 am; Dinner Nightly: 5:30pm - 10:00pm; Sunday Brunch: 11:30a-3:00p.
  • Price
    $31 to $50
  • Cuisines
    Italian, Contemporary Italian, Seafood
  • Dining style
    Casual Elegant
  • Dress code
    Smart Casual
  • Parking details
    Hotel Parking
  • Payment options
    AMEX, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
  • Executive chef
    Rafael Rodriguez
  • Additional
    Banquet, Bar Dining, Bar/Lounge, Beer, Cigar Room, Full Bar, Gluten-free Options, Non-Smoking, Outdoor Smoking Area, Private Room, View, Weekend Brunch, Wine
  • Phone number
    (305) 664-0073
  • Catering
    For information about private dining, catering and banquets, or special events, please contact the Amara Cay Resort Sales Department at 305-664-0073 or sales@amaracayresort.com.<br />
  • Private party facilities
    Exceptional private dining for groups of ten, sixteen, and thirty two at our onsite indoor restaurant, Oltremare Ristorante, featuring a coastal Italian cuisine unlike any other in the Florida Keys.
  • Private party contact
    Anna Walston: (305) 664-2321
OpenTable
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Press
More
Businesses
  • Restaurant reservation software
  • Industry insights
  • Hospitality resources
  • Marketing resources
  • Operation resources
  • How to open a restaurant
  • For restaurants
  • For restaurant groups
Join us on
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2024 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 500, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
KAYAK Logo
Agoda Logo
OpenTable Logo